Twenty years, over 600 million page views, over 38,000 articles, countless arguments, personal losses, and one stubborn idea: scientific claims should stand or fall on the evidence.
Twenty years ago, on November 17, 2006, I published the first post at Watts Up With That?. I had no grand plan to build one of the world’s most widely read climate-related websites. I certainly didn’t envision spending the next two decades examining temperature records, questioning climate models, debating scientists, dealing with the occasional internet mob, or explaining for the umpteenth time why a thermometer next to an air-conditioning exhaust might not be the ideal instrument for measuring long-term climate change. I thought I might finally have a little spare time. That prediction turned out to be spectacularly wrong, and considering the subject matter that would eventually dominate this website, there’s a certain irony in that.
The original idea behind WUWT was simple enough. I wanted a place to discuss interesting things about science, technology, weather, and the natural world. I described it as somewhat “gee-whiz” in nature. The internet already had plenty of celebrity gossip and political shouting matches, and I was more interested in the kind of useful trivia that makes people stop and think. Why is the sky blue during the day but black at night? Why does urine smell funny after eating asparagus? And, with apologies to Lon, does disc golf cause cancer? Those were the sorts of questions I thought we might explore. The only real ground rules were to avoid crude language and personal attacks. Otherwise, almost anything was fair game.
The blog began under the umbrella of the Chico Enterprise-Record’s NorCalBlogs platform, and my intended audience was largely local: people around Northern California who knew me from my days on television and shared my interest in science, weather, and technology. For the first few months, that’s pretty much what it was. I wrote about PlayStation 3s, internet speed tests, hurricane-strength nails, and household power hogs. Climate-related material appeared almost immediately, but WUWT was still primarily a general science and technology blog. That began to change in the spring of 2007, when a longstanding curiosity about weather instruments led me in an unexpected direction.
Before getting into that history, I should say a word about the feature image created for this anniversary by Charles Rotter. Charles has taken the familiar Stevenson screen, that traditional white wooden shelter used to house weather instruments, and given it a rather unusual architectural upgrade. It now resembles an outhouse, complete with a thermometer mounted on the door, standing alone in a field beneath a beautiful sunrise. The caption simply reads, “TWENTY YEARS — 2006–2026.”
I had to laugh when I first saw it. After two decades of examining the condition and placement of surface temperature stations, the image sums up rather neatly what we’ve thought about the quality of some of the measurements being used to construct the historical temperature record. The thermometer may be housed in something that looks vaguely official, but that doesn’t necessarily make the observations trustworthy. Of course, the cartoon is deliberately exaggerated, and the actual scientific questions are considerably more complicated. Still, Charles has managed to convey twenty years of frustration with poorly sited instruments in a single picture. Sometimes a little humor gets the point across more effectively than another hundred pages of statistical analysis. Thanks, Charles. It’s a fitting image for the occasion.
The Thermometers That Changed Everything
My background in broadcast meteorology had given me a particular interest in how weather observations are made, especially surface temperature measurements. Years earlier, as a student assistant at Purdue University, I had assembled Stevenson Screens, the familiar white, louvered shelters used to protect thermometers from direct sunlight and precipitation while allowing air to circulate. I remembered the care that went into their construction and maintenance, and I had wondered about the traditional use of whitewash and the later transition to modern latex paints. That curiosity led me to conduct experiments involving paint and the thermal behavior of instrument shelters. While looking into nearby NOAA weather stations, I began noticing things that troubled me about the locations and surroundings of some temperature instruments, particularly at Chico and Marysville.
The more I investigated, the more obvious it became that the issue was much larger than the type of paint used on a thermometer shelter. I found examples of instruments near buildings, thermometers influenced by pavement and other heat-retaining surfaces, and locations where the immediate environment had changed considerably over the years. These were legitimate measurement questions, and I wanted to know how widespread the problems might be. After all, if we were going to use historical temperature records to make claims about long-term climate trends, it seemed reasonable to examine the conditions under which those measurements were being made.
That led to SurfaceStations.org, an ambitious volunteer effort to photograph, document, and evaluate weather stations in the United States Historical Climatology Network. One particularly memorable bit of motivation came from a letter to the editor describing me as a “weapon of mass destruction.” Well, if you’re going to be accused of something that dramatic, you might as well make yourself useful. By August 2007, we had 200 volunteer sign-ups. Some documented a single station near their homes, while others traveled extensively, visiting dozens or even hundreds of locations. They photographed instruments, recorded their surroundings, and contributed observations that had previously been difficult for the public to examine.
It was citizen science in a very practical sense, and it taught me something important about the value of independent investigation. You don’t necessarily need an enormous research budget to ask a useful scientific question. Sometimes you need a camera, a map, a willingness to travel, and enough persistence to keep asking questions when the answers aren’t immediately forthcoming. Of course, documenting a station’s surroundings and determining the effect on a temperature record are different tasks. The latter requires analysis, comparisons, and careful treatment of uncertainties. But the photographs and station histories provided evidence that could be examined rather than simply assumed away.
One person who deserves particular recognition here is Evan Jones, whose contributions to SurfaceStations were tremendous. Evan took on the painstaking work of organizing station information, verifying locations, examining photographs, measuring distances from nearby structures and artificial surfaces, and helping classify the exposure quality of individual stations. Much of this was tedious, detail-oriented work that rarely attracts public attention but is essential to producing useful scientific results. He also contributed to our later analyses, including the work presented at the American Geophysical Union in 2015. SurfaceStations required far more than photographing poorly situated thermometers, and Evan understood that. His persistence and attention to detail made him an indispensable part of the effort, and I owe him a considerable debt of gratitude.
The project eventually produced two major reports, separated by thirteen years, and both remain among the accomplishments of which I am most proud. In March 2009, I published Is the U.S. Surface Temperature Record Reliable?, documenting the widespread siting problems uncovered by our volunteer survey. We found instruments surrounded by asphalt, concrete, buildings, air-conditioning equipment, and other artificial influences that had no business being so close to thermometers intended to measure representative outdoor air temperatures. More than 650 volunteers ultimately helped examine over 80 percent of the stations in the historical network. It was an extraordinary undertaking for a project that began with a few photographs of weather stations in Northern California, and the resulting documentation provided a body of evidence that other researchers could examine for themselves.
The work also led directly to a peer-reviewed scientific publication. In 2011, I was a co-author, along with Souleymane Fall, John Nielsen-Gammon, Evan Jones, Dev Niyogi, John Christy, and Roger Pielke Sr., of Analysis of the Impacts of Station Exposure on the U.S. Historical Climatology Network Temperatures and Temperature Trends, published in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres. The paper drew upon the extensive SurfaceStations survey to investigate how station siting affected recorded temperatures and temperature trends. We found measurable differences associated with station exposure, including differences in maximum and minimum temperature trends that partly offset one another in mean temperature trends. The results demonstrated that station siting deserved serious scientific attention, while also showing why its effects on national temperature trends required careful analysis. For me, this was an especially satisfying milestone. What began as a volunteer effort to photograph weather stations had developed into original, peer-reviewed research, with the observations collected by our volunteers contributing directly to the scientific literature.
Then came an unexpected development from Washington. In August 2011, the U.S. Government Accountability Office published Climate Monitoring: NOAA Can Improve Management of the U.S. Historical Climatology Network, a formal examination of the same station network we had been surveying. The GAO reported that approximately 42 percent of active USHCN stations in 2010 failed to meet at least one of NOAA’s own siting standards. It also found that NOAA lacked adequate centralized tracking of station compliance and had no consistent agency-wide policy for deciding what should happen when stations failed to meet those standards. The report made recommendations for improving management of the network. NOAA subsequently improved its station information systems, but the GAO ultimately closed one recommendation concerning noncompliant stations as not implemented.
The GAO investigation also had a personal dimension for me. During the preparation of its report, I was interviewed by GAO investigators about the SurfaceStations project and the problems our volunteers had documented. I appreciated the opportunity to explain our methods and observations directly to federal auditors, rather than have the project characterized solely through the arguments of its critics. When the GAO subsequently identified substantial deficiencies in NOAA’s station management and compliance with siting standards, it was gratifying to see the subject receive that level of independent scrutiny. The report’s findings stood on the GAO’s own investigation, of course, but I was proud that the work begun by a group of volunteers had become part of a serious federal examination of the nation’s temperature-monitoring network.
Another memorable encounter came in September 2012, when veteran PBS NewsHour correspondent Spencer Michels visited my office in Chico to interview me about climate change, the reliability of surface temperature measurements, and the controversy surrounding Richard Muller’s Berkeley Earth project. It was about 105°F outside, which made for a rather appropriate setting in which to discuss thermometers and temperature records. Spencer asked thoughtful questions about my position, and I explained that I accepted the evidence of global warming while questioning how much of the observed change could be attributed to particular causes and how much confidence should be placed in some of the underlying measurements. My recollection is that Spencer seemed genuinely surprised to discover that I was a fairly reasonable fellow. Apparently, some of what he had heard about me beforehand had led him to expect something rather different. I found that both amusing and revealing.
The interview aired on September 17, 2012, and PBS also published a much longer version of our conversation. The reaction was extraordinary. Some viewers objected strongly to the very idea that PBS would give a climate skeptic an opportunity to explain his views. The controversy became sufficiently intense that PBS ombudsman Michael Getler published a lengthy examination of the broadcast, including a response from Spencer explaining why he and his editors had chosen to interview me. PBS defended the editorial decision to include a skeptical perspective, while acknowledging criticism that some of my statements should have received more direct challenge within the broadcast. I appreciated Spencer’s willingness to conduct the interview and let viewers hear what I actually had to say.
The Berkeley Earth project itself became an important chapter in the SurfaceStations story. Richard Muller and his colleagues undertook an ambitious reanalysis of historical temperature records, including questions about station quality, and concluded that the overall warming signal remained robust. I disagreed with aspects of their treatment of station exposure and the way some of their conclusions were presented publicly. In my view, the classification of stations and the distinction between well-sited and poorly sited instruments deserved more careful attention. The controversy illustrated a recurring problem: two analyses can begin with broadly similar observational material yet reach different conclusions about how measurement deficiencies should be treated. The appropriate response is to examine the methods, classifications, assumptions, and uncertainties. That is what we continued trying to do.
In 2015, I presented additional findings at the American Geophysical Union’s Fall Meeting in San Francisco, working with Evan Jones, John Nielsen-Gammon, and John Christy. Our analysis compared temperature trends from better-sited stations with those from stations affected by nearby artificial surfaces and other influences. We reported that the better-sited subset showed a lower warming trend over the period examined than NOAA’s adjusted national series. Those findings generated further debate, particularly concerning station selection, instrumentation changes, and the effectiveness of homogenization. I welcomed the opportunity to present the work in a scientific setting because the questions involved were testable and deserved serious examination.
One of the most gratifying developments came in 2019, when researchers associated with NOAA conducted a field experiment at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, examining precisely the kind of local influences that had motivated my original surveys. Their peer-reviewed paper, Impacts of Small-Scale Urban Encroachment on Air Temperature Observations, described measurements taken at increasing distances from a developed area. The researchers found that instruments closest to the built environment recorded higher average temperatures than those farther away, with differences of approximately 0.31°C for aspirated sensors and 0.24°C for unaspirated sensors. They also found that nearby development could affect daily temperature extremes, depending on environmental conditions and instrument design. In other words, distance from artificial surfaces and heat-retaining structures really did matter. The physical effect that had concerned me since 2007 was demonstrated experimentally. I regarded that as an important vindication of the basic premise behind SurfaceStations: where a thermometer is located, and what surrounds it, can materially influence what it measures.
The Oak Ridge study did not, by itself, establish the size or direction of any bias in the national temperature trend, nor did it settle the separate question of whether NOAA’s adjustment methods adequately compensate for siting problems. Those remain questions requiring broader analysis. But the experiment provided direct physical evidence that the local environment surrounding a weather station can affect the temperature recorded by its instruments. After years of hearing arguments that statistical processing could adequately address such concerns, I found it encouraging to see researchers return to the fundamentals of measurement and demonstrate the effect in the field.
In 2022, I returned to the subject with a second report, Corrupted Climate Stations: The Official U.S. Temperature Record Remains Fatally Flawed. This follow-up survey examined 128 stations and found that approximately 96 percent failed the siting criteria used in the assessment. The report argued that the persistence of nearby artificial heat sources and heat-retaining surfaces raised serious questions about the reliability of temperature observations and the adequacy of subsequent statistical adjustments. Critics challenged the representativeness of the sample and the extent to which those findings could be generalized to the national temperature record. I continue to believe that the underlying measurement problems deserve greater attention, particularly because the quality of the raw observations remains fundamental to any subsequent analysis.
Looking back over the entire project, from the first photographs in 2007 to the reports of 2009 and 2022, the GAO investigation, the peer-reviewed research, and the Oak Ridge experiment, I am struck by how far a relatively simple question traveled. What began as curiosity about thermometer shelters and station surroundings eventually involved hundreds of volunteers, federal auditors, and researchers conducting controlled field experiments. Whatever conclusions one reaches about the magnitude of long-term warming, the quality of the instruments and the environments in which they operate should never be treated as an afterthought. A thermometer can only measure the conditions to which it is exposed, and no amount of statistical sophistication can substitute for understanding what those conditions actually were.
The Surprise I Never Expected
Perhaps the greatest surprise of the entire SurfaceStations experience was the hostility it generated. I had expected scientific disagreement. I had expected arguments about station classifications, measurement uncertainty, statistical adjustments, and the implications for national temperature trends. Those were all legitimate subjects for debate. What I had not expected was the extraordinary level of personal animosity directed at me simply for documenting the physical conditions surrounding weather stations and asking whether those conditions might affect the temperature measurements being used to support major scientific and policy conclusions.
Some people seemed determined to punish me for publishing what I believed the evidence showed. The insults, accusations, attempts to discredit my motives, and attacks on my reputation were sometimes astonishing in their intensity. I had spent years working in meteorology, where checking instruments and examining the quality of observations were ordinary parts of the job. Suddenly, applying those same principles to the historical climate record was being treated by some critics as an act of ideological aggression. I found that genuinely bewildering. The thermometers were sitting out there in plain sight. Their surroundings could be photographed. The distances to buildings, pavement, air-conditioning equipment, and other potential influences could be measured. Yet a number of my harshest critics seemed far more interested in attacking the person asking the questions than in going out and checking the evidence for themselves.
That was the part I found especially difficult to understand. We had volunteers driving hundreds of miles, sometimes at their own expense, to document weather stations that most people had never thought to visit. Meanwhile, some of the loudest voices condemning the project appeared unwilling to make even a modest effort to verify the observations they were so eager to dismiss. It would have been easy enough to visit a nearby station, take photographs, check the distances, and compare the results with our documentation. If we had made mistakes, I wanted to know about them. Instead, too much of the response consisted of ridicule, accusations, and personal abuse. I came to realize that for some participants, the controversy had become less about the accuracy of the measurements than about the perceived consequences of questioning them.
Over time, the underlying measurement concern received the serious attention it deserved. The SurfaceStations observations contributed to peer-reviewed research in which I was a co-author. The Government Accountability Office investigated NOAA’s station network and documented shortcomings in compliance with siting standards. Researchers at Oak Ridge later demonstrated experimentally that proximity to developed surfaces can influence recorded temperatures. Those findings were deeply satisfying because they established that the physical concern motivating the project was real and measurable. They did not resolve every dispute about national temperature trends or statistical adjustments, and I have never claimed that they did. But they vindicated my decision to take station exposure seriously and to insist that the quality of the underlying observations mattered.
Looking back after twenty years, I remain surprised by how much anger could be directed at a man with a camera asking questions about thermometers. I would have preferred that more of my critics had picked up cameras of their own. We might have learned something together, and perhaps saved everyone a great deal of unnecessary hostility. But the experience also taught me the value of persistence. When the evidence is something people can examine for themselves, the sensible course is to keep documenting it, keep asking questions, and let the results speak.
The project also changed WUWT. The blog began attracting readers far beyond Northern California, many of whom wanted to see the photographs, discuss the data, and debate what the findings meant. By late 2007, the traffic and technical demands had outgrown the newspaper’s blogging platform, and WUWT moved to its own hosting arrangement. What began as a little local science blog was developing an international audience, and I was discovering that maintaining a popular website could consume considerably more time than I had ever imagined.
Climategate and the Growing Audience
Then came November 2009. November 17 was WUWT’s third birthday, and it was also the date associated with the beginning of the circulation of the files that would soon become known worldwide as Climategate. I was traveling at the time, and two days later, after clearing customs at Washington Dulles International Airport, I found myself sitting in an airport terminal examining a 61-megabyte collection of emails and documents that appeared to have originated from the Climatic Research Unit at the University of East Anglia. The material appeared genuine, although the circumstances of its release were still unclear, and I wrote the breaking story right there in the airport. I have recounted the experience in greater detail before, so I won’t repeat the whole story, but I remember that morning vividly.
The documents opened a window into how some prominent climate researchers communicated privately about their work, their critics, and the handling of scientific information. The ensuing controversy became one of the defining episodes in the modern climate debate. The emails were subsequently examined by multiple inquiries, which generally did not substantiate allegations that the underlying evidence for human-caused warming had been fabricated. Nevertheless, the controversy raised important questions about openness, access to data, scientific communication, and institutional accountability. For me, the lasting lesson was the importance of transparency. When scientific conclusions are used to justify policies affecting energy supplies, industry, transportation, agriculture, and household finances, the underlying data and methods should be available for independent examination wherever reasonably possible.
WUWT was already growing before Climategate, but afterward the audience expanded dramatically, and the discussions became considerably more spirited. The growth also brought recognition I never anticipated. In January 2009, WUWT was named Best Science Blog in the Weblog Awards. We eventually won that category three times, earning a place in the awards’ Hall of Fame, and WUWT also received Weblog of the Year recognition in 2013. In 2011, the Bloggies named WUWT Best Science Blog, ahead of much larger websites. I remember saying at the time that I would skip the Sally Field acceptance speech and simply say, “Thank you, dear readers.” I think I’ll stick with that approach.
The awards were gratifying, of course, but what mattered more was what they represented. Readers were willing to spend their time at a website that frequently challenged widely accepted claims and invited discussion of the evidence. Some agreed with me, while others disagreed, sometimes vehemently. Both groups helped make the site what it became. Today, the cumulative readership reported exceeds 600 million page views, a number I still find remarkable. For perspective, when I started WUWT, the first iPhone hadn’t yet been released, Twitter was in its infancy, Facebook had only recently opened itself beyond its original college audience, and YouTube was still a relatively new phenomenon.
The internet itself was a different place. Over those two decades, entire social media platforms have risen, dominated public attention, and faded. News organizations have reorganized or disappeared, search engines have changed their rules repeatedly, and the way people discover and consume information has been transformed. Somehow, through all of that, WUWT has kept going because readers continued returning, sharing articles, contributing observations, asking questions, and sometimes telling me when I got something wrong. Especially that last part.
Twenty Years of Asking Inconvenient Questions
If there’s a common thread running through these twenty years, it is my belief that scientific claims deserve careful scrutiny, particularly when those claims become the basis for major public policy decisions. Climate is an enormously complex subject. The atmosphere, oceans, clouds, ice, land surfaces, solar influences, and natural variability interact across timescales ranging from hours to centuries and beyond. We have learned a great deal about those processes, but important uncertainties remain, particularly in regional projections, cloud feedbacks, the behavior of some extreme events, and the translation of global climate changes into specific local consequences. Those uncertainties matter, as do the distinctions between observations, estimates, model simulations, and projections.
A computer model can be a useful scientific tool, but its output depends on its structure, assumptions, inputs, and treatment of processes that cannot be resolved directly. Models must be tested against observations, and their limitations should be explained plainly. Similarly, a temperature record deserves careful examination of instrument changes, station moves, observation practices, urbanization, and statistical adjustments. The existence of such issues doesn’t automatically invalidate a temperature record, but it does mean that methods and uncertainties should remain open to examination. The same standard applies to claims made by skeptics. Over the years, I’ve published material that I agreed with, material that I questioned, and material that generated vigorous debate among our own readers. That is part of the value of having a forum where arguments can be examined in public.
Unfortunately, public discussion of climate has often rewarded confidence supported by repetition more than confidence supported by evidence. We’ve seen sweeping headlines built around preliminary studies, dramatic projections presented without sufficient context, and policy arguments that glide past difficult questions about costs, engineering, reliability, and unintended consequences. Those questions are especially important when discussing energy. A proposal to change how an industrial society produces and uses energy needs to be evaluated against physical and economic realities. Electricity systems have to work when the wind is calm, when the sun isn’t shining, and when demand is at its highest. Energy must remain affordable for families and businesses, and developing countries have their own priorities, including access to dependable power and the benefits that come with it. Good intentions don’t repeal the laws of physics or economics.
I’ve never believed that skepticism should be reserved for one side of a debate. If someone makes an extraordinary claim about the climate, I want to see the evidence. If someone proposes spending trillions of dollars to address a projected problem, I want to know what the expenditure is expected to accomplish, how that benefit is calculated, and what alternatives have been considered. And if a headline announces that some particular weather event proves a sweeping theory, I want to know what the actual observations show. That approach has earned WUWT criticism over the years. Some of it has been fair, some mistaken, and some simply personal. It comes with the territory, and after twenty years I’ve developed a fairly thick skin, although there are days when a nice quiet weather station in the middle of nowhere seems preferable to the internet.
The Critics Came and Went. WUWT Is Still Here.
No retrospective of twenty years at WUWT would be complete without mentioning the many websites and personalities that devoted considerable time and energy to attacking this site, its contributors, and me personally. Some offered legitimate scientific criticism, which is part of any worthwhile debate, but others seemed to make a hobby out of finding something objectionable in nearly everything I published. There were websites that existed primarily to monitor WUWT, dissect our articles, ridicule our contributors, and assure their readers that we were wrong about practically everything. Some of these critics were remarkably dedicated. I sometimes wondered whether they spent more time reading WUWT than I did writing it.
One of the most prominent was Joe Romm, whose Climate Progress website became an influential voice in climate advocacy and frequently took aim at skeptics, including me. Romm was a physicist by training, a former senior official at the Department of Energy, and a formidable political communicator. We certainly had our disagreements over the years, sometimes quite sharply. His criticism of WUWT and other skeptical voices was often relentless, and I returned the favor when I believed his arguments deserved challenging.
Joe died on September 14, 2026, at the age of 66. His passing was reported by The Daily Pennsylvanian, and MIT subsequently noted his obituary in The New York Times. By the time of his death, he was a senior research fellow at the University of Pennsylvania’s Penn Center for Science, Sustainability and the Media. Whatever our differences, his death marks the passing of one of the more recognizable figures from the early years of the climate blogosphere. We occupied opposite sides of many arguments, and I have no intention of rewriting that history. But I recognize the substantial role he played in shaping the public climate debate. My condolences go to his family and friends. Twenty years is a long time, and one of its more sobering lessons is that even the fiercest arguments eventually outlast some of the people who took part in them.
Then there was HotWhopper, operated by Australian blogger Miriam O’Brien, who wrote under the name “Sou.” For years, she was one of WUWT’s most persistent critics, frequently responding to articles I or our contributors had written. Her criticism could be sharply personal. Then, rather abruptly, the activity stopped. Her last identifiable article appears to have been published in January 2023, and the site has remained silent ever since. I’ve made inquiries among people familiar with her and believe she may have passed away, although I have been unable to locate an obituary or obtain independent confirmation. I don’t want to turn an uncertain report into a statement of fact. Whatever the explanation, HotWhopper has become a largely dormant archive.
Another persistent critic was Dr. Victor Venema of the University of Bonn, a climate scientist who specialized in the statistical homogenization of historical temperature records. Victor and I had spirited exchanges over the years, particularly concerning my surface station work and the reliability of adjusted temperature datasets. His criticism could be sharp, and I eventually gave him the nickname “Victor Venomous,” which, as I recall, he did not appreciate. We disagreed fundamentally about the confidence that should be placed in statistical adjustments to historical temperature measurements.
Venema was deeply involved in developing and evaluating homogenization techniques, including a major international benchmarking study published in 2012. The underlying premise of these methods is that temperature records contain artificial changes caused by station moves, instrument replacements, changes in observation practices, and other nonclimatic influences. Statistical algorithms attempt to identify and correct those changes by comparing neighboring stations. In principle, that sounds reasonable enough. The difficulty arises when neighboring stations themselves contain biases, particularly from urbanization, poor siting, or other changes that affect multiple stations in similar ways. Under those circumstances, an algorithm may have difficulty distinguishing a genuine regional temperature signal from a shared measurement bias.
This was one of my longstanding objections. My surface station surveys had documented numerous examples of instruments exposed to artificial heat sources or otherwise questionable surroundings. I was concerned that homogenization could spread the influence of warmer, poorly situated stations into records from better-situated locations. Venema and others argued that homogenization generally improved temperature records, citing benchmarking exercises and statistical tests. But the real-world question is whether the adjustments reliably identify the actual sources of error, especially when station histories are incomplete and biases are shared across a network.
A 2023 paper in the Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, titled Evidence of Urban Blending in Homogenized Temperature Records in Japan and in the United States, examined the possibility that homogenization procedures can spread urban warming influences into surrounding station records. Its authors also questioned whether successful performance on synthetic benchmarking datasets necessarily demonstrates equivalent reliability when applied to historical observations. The paper did not establish that all homogenization produces warming biases, but it provided a concrete example of why statistical adjustment methods deserve continued independent scrutiny.
Venema passed away in December 2022. Whatever our differences, I recognize that he devoted considerable professional effort to his chosen field. I continue to disagree with his confidence in homogenization methods and with the dismissive treatment that critics of those methods sometimes received. Looking back, the important question remains the same one that motivated my weather station surveys nearly twenty years ago: how accurately do our historical temperature records represent the temperatures that actually occurred?
Perhaps the most amusing example of a website devoted to criticizing WUWT was one actually called Wott’s Up With That?, an unmistakable play on our name. Its stated purpose was to respond to what its author regarded as misinformation on WUWT. Imagine starting a website whose identity, title, and editorial purpose were largely defined by another website you disliked. The site’s activity eventually dwindled, with a lengthy gap in publication and a brief return in February 2024. As far as I can determine, it has been quiet since then.
Another name that belongs in this history is John Cook, founder of Skeptical Science. I’ve had my differences with Cook for many years, particularly over his famous 97% consensus claim and the way his website portrays people who question various aspects of climate science. In my view, the site has generally concentrated on rebutting critics of prevailing climate interpretations, and WUWT has frequently been among its targets.
One of the more revealing episodes occurred in 2013, when a collection of images from a directory associated with the private Skeptical Science discussion forum became publicly accessible. Among them were doctored photographs and cartoons mocking climate skeptics, including me. One particularly absurd creation borrowed from the movie 300, portraying me, Christopher Monckton, and James Delingpole as bare-chested Spartan warriors. Other images were considerably less flattering. The discovery offered an unexpected glimpse of the sort of humor circulating behind the scenes among some of the people who publicly presented themselves as defenders of scientific reason. I have no objection to parody; heaven knows we’ve published plenty of cartoons ourselves. But I did find the contrast between the site’s public posture and some of the material circulating in its private forum rather revealing.

The climate wars, Spartan style. Anthony Watts, Christopher Monckton, and James Delingpole portrayed as warriors from the film 300. The photomontage was among the images documented in WUWT’s August 6, 2013 article about material associated with the Skeptical Science forum.
Apparently, our critics imagined us as Spartan warriors, complete with spears, shields, red capes, and physiques that would have required considerably more time in the gym than I was spending at my computer. Of all the attempts to ridicule me over the years, this one may have been the most unintentionally flattering.
The episode also reminded me of another piece of artwork from 2013, when illustrator Steve Brodner created The Mad Men of Climate Denial for The American Prospect. The illustration caricatured climate skeptics, including me.

Apparently, when you spend enough years questioning climate orthodoxy, you eventually become a character in somebody else’s political artwork. I suppose that’s one form of recognition, although I would have preferred a more flattering portrait.
I was sufficiently amused by the whole exercise that I worked with Josh, our longtime cartoonist, on a response called Mad Men: The Prequel. Josh produced a splendid counter-parody, and the exchange became one of the more entertaining episodes in the climate-blogging wars.

There were other websites as well, including sites with variations on the WUWT name, along with the occasional blogger who seemed to regard rebutting my latest article as an essential public service. Some have disappeared, others remain as archives, and still others simply stopped publishing regularly. I don’t pretend to know why each one faded away. People retire, interests change, circumstances intervene, and maintaining a website over many years requires more effort than most people realize.
I don’t take the disappearance or inactivity of a critic’s website as proof that my arguments were correct. Scientific questions are settled by evidence, and the passage of time can be just as unkind to an incorrect claim on WUWT as to one published elsewhere. But there is something satisfying about having built a publication that has survived so many changes in the online world, particularly when some of its most determined detractors were unable or unwilling to maintain their own efforts for the same length of time.
Dr. Roger Pielke Jr. also deserves recognition for the extraordinary abuse he has endured while insisting on careful distinctions between climate change, extreme weather, and the economic costs of natural disasters. Roger’s research on disaster losses made him a target of fierce criticism, particularly after he wrote for Nate Silver’s FiveThirtyEight in 2014. The attacks extended well beyond scientific disagreement. In 2015, Congressman Raúl Grijalva demanded that the University of Colorado investigate Roger’s funding following his congressional testimony, insinuating possible undisclosed fossil-fuel support. Roger has repeatedly stated that he received no such funding, and the university investigation found no basis for the allegation. In his 2025 account, How to Get Rid of a Tenured Professor, Roger described the professional isolation, lost opportunities, and personal toll that followed, culminating in his departure from the university at the end of 2024 after nearly twenty-four years as a tenured professor. I have enormous respect for his willingness to keep asking difficult questions despite the consequences. His experience is a sobering reminder of what can happen when political pressure and personal attacks intrude upon scientific disagreement.
Dr. Michael Mann also deserves mention in any account of the climate debates surrounding WUWT. His famous hockey stick temperature reconstruction made him one of the most recognizable and influential figures in climate science, and we have disagreed sharply over the years about scientific methods, uncertainty, and the public presentation of climate research. Unfortunately, those disagreements frequently became personal. I’ve been called a “denier for dollars” and, by my recollection, just about every other name in the book, including “carnival barker”. Mann’s willingness to use such language has never impressed me, particularly coming from someone with his scientific credentials and public influence. Of course, I’ve occasionally returned the favor. I’ve publicly remarked on more than one occasion that I believed Dr. Mann’s ego was so enormous he must have trouble fitting through most doorways. I still think there’s some humor in that observation, although I doubt he shares my appreciation of it. After twenty years of exchanges, I remain convinced that the climate debate would have been better served by more examination of data, greater acknowledgment of uncertainty, and fewer attempts to discredit the people asking questions.
Josh artfully described Mann’s contribution to “climate science” in one hilarious cartoon.

The story of Michael Mann’s influence on the climate debate would also be incomplete without mentioning my friend Mark Steyn, whose 2015 book, A Disgrace to the Profession, assembled critical assessments of Mann’s famous hockey stick reconstruction from scientists and other commentators. Josh even contributed illustrations to the book. Mark paid an extraordinary personal price for his involvement in this controversy. Mann’s defamation lawsuit against Steyn and fellow defendant Rand Simberg, filed in 2012, dragged on for more than a decade, imposing years of legal expense, uncertainty, and personal strain. I have great respect for Mark’s determination and his refusal to abandon the debate.
The litigation continued long after the February 2024 jury verdict and became an extraordinary burden on those involved. I also remember the late Canadian climatologist Dr. Tim Ball, who faced a separate defamation lawsuit brought by Mann. When Tim died in September 2022, his family was left in deeply difficult financial circumstances after years of legal battles. He had, for all practical purposes, died nearly penniless.
With the family’s permission, we organized a memorial fund through WUWT to help them with funeral and related expenses. Our readers responded with remarkable generosity, raising approximately C$25,000. In a public message of thanks, Tim’s son David described the exhaustion and financial toll of decades of litigation and expressed the family’s gratitude to everyone who contributed. That episode has stayed with me. Whatever one’s position on the scientific disputes, watching a colleague’s family face such hardship after his death is heartbreaking. I remain grateful that the WUWT community was able to offer them some practical help when they needed it most.
When Criticism Turned Into Intimidation
Over twenty years, I’ve learned to expect criticism, and I’ve certainly received plenty of it. Some has been thoughtful and scientifically useful, while much of it has been little more than name-calling, ridicule, and attempts to damage reputations. I’ve been accused of being in the pay of industries that have never funded WUWT and portrayed as someone whose questions about climate measurements and projections somehow constitute a threat to humanity. But there have also been episodes that went well beyond ordinary scientific disagreement, including suggestions that skeptics should be imprisoned, prosecuted for crimes against humanity, or subjected to violence. Looking back, some of the language was astonishing.
One of the ugliest personal attacks I encountered came from a publication called The Buffalo Beast. After it published an article about me containing claims I believed were inaccurate, I wrote to request a correction. Instead of addressing the factual issues I raised, the response, as I recall it, included the grotesque and entirely false allegation that I had “engaged in sexual acts with farm animals.” I remember being stunned by the sheer viciousness of it. Here I was trying to correct the record about something that had been written about me, and the answer was an obscene personal smear having nothing whatsoever to do with weather stations, temperature measurements, or climate science. That incident remains one of the clearest examples in my memory of how far some people were willing to go in attacking someone whose work or conclusions they disliked. I had expected disagreement, even harsh disagreement. I hadn’t expected that a request for factual accuracy would be met with such calculated humiliation.
Another example involved Joe Romm’s Climate Progress website. In June 2009, the site became embroiled in controversy over a warning that a future generation might be ready to strangle climate skeptics in their beds. Romm defended the posting, and the episode was later documented in a chapter by Marc Morano that I published at WUWT in 2018. The language was presented in the context of anger over future climate consequences, but I found it remarkable that such imagery could be treated as an acceptable part of the public discussion.
An especially extraordinary example came in December 2012, when Professor Richard Parncutt of the University of Graz in Austria published an essay discussing whether influential global-warming skeptics should face the death penalty. His argument rested on the proposition that certain individuals could be held responsible for enormous numbers of future deaths by obstructing climate policies. Parncutt subsequently withdrew the article and issued a public apology, acknowledging that some of his claims and comparisons were inappropriate. He later defended the original discussion as a philosophical exercise and maintained that he opposed capital punishment. Nevertheless, the fact that a university professor had publicly entertained such a punishment for people whose views he regarded as dangerously wrong illustrates how extreme the rhetoric had become.
The most disturbing physical incident I recall involved two scientists whose work I have followed and respected for many years, Dr. Roy Spencer and Dr. John Christy of the University of Alabama in Huntsville. During the weekend of April 22–23, 2017, seven shots were fired into the National Space Science and Technology Center, the building where they worked. The bullets struck the area around Christy’s office on the fourth floor. Spencer reported the shooting on his website, expressing concern that the attack might have been motivated by hostility toward their climate research. University police, however, characterized the incident as a random shooting, and no climate-related motive was established. Fortunately, nobody was injured.
Whatever the shooter’s motive, the incident was deeply unsettling. Spencer and Christy had spent decades developing and maintaining a satellite-based atmospheric temperature record, work for which they received NASA’s Medal for Exceptional Scientific Achievement in 1991. Their research and public statements had also made them prominent participants in debates over climate-model projections and the interpretation of temperature trends. Seeing bullet holes in a research building associated with their work was a grim reminder that public controversies can sometimes take an ugly turn. We may never know why those shots were fired, and I would not claim that the shooting was politically motivated without evidence. The event itself was serious enough.
I should add that hostility and threats have occurred on more than one side of the climate debate. Researchers whose conclusions I have criticized have also reported receiving threats and harassment, and I condemn that behavior just as strongly. Nobody should have to worry about personal safety because of a scientific argument, a published paper, or an opinion about public policy. The proper response to a claim you believe is wrong is to examine the evidence and demonstrate the error. Once arguments about measurements, models, and policy become arguments about who deserves punishment, the discussion has wandered a very long way from science.
Through all of this, WUWT has continued publishing. I’ve never expected everyone to agree with me, and after twenty years I certainly don’t expect universal affection. Criticism comes with the territory, particularly when you question claims that have become deeply intertwined with politics, institutional reputations, and substantial financial interests. What I have always wanted is the freedom to examine those claims openly and to have the arguments judged on their merits. If the worst consequence of asking an inconvenient question is another unflattering cartoon or another angry blog post, I can live with that. I’ve already survived twenty years of both, and I suspect the supply is far from exhausted.
Some of the Good Ones Have Moved On, Too
The passage of twenty years has also seen the retirement or gradual winding down of some websites that I have greatly respected. Two particularly important examples are Dr. Judith Curry’s Climate Etc. and Steve McIntyre’s Climate Audit. Both were influential in bringing independent analysis and critical examination to climate science, and both helped establish a level of technical discussion that was often missing from mainstream reporting. Their contributions deserve recognition, especially because the people behind them were willing to devote substantial time and effort to questions that were frequently unpopular within their professional communities.
Judith launched Climate Etc. in September 2010, following Climategate, and developed it into an important forum for examining climate uncertainty, scientific methods, and the intersection of science and public policy. Her willingness to engage with people holding different views, including critics of prevailing climate interpretations, made her a distinctive voice in a field where such openness could carry professional consequences. On June 23, 2026, she published a farewell article titled RIP Climate Etc., explaining that her interests had evolved and that the expense and technical difficulties of maintaining an aging WordPress website had become increasingly burdensome. Having spent twenty years dealing with WordPress myself, I can certainly sympathize. Judith also indicated that she might send future noteworthy articles to WUWT, an offer I would be delighted to accept. Her original site remains available as an archive, and her work continues through other channels.
Steve McIntyre’s Climate Audit deserves equally prominent recognition. Steve began publishing in 2005, before WUWT existed, and his painstaking examination of climate reconstructions, particularly the statistical methods and underlying data associated with Michael Mann’s famous hockey stick, helped establish an important precedent for independent auditing of climate research. His attention to detail, persistence in obtaining data, and willingness to work through complicated statistical questions set an example that influenced many of us. Climate Audit has become much less active in recent years, although Steve has continued to publish occasional analyses. A carefully researched article from Steve can contain more substantive analysis than a month’s worth of ordinary climate commentary, and his archive remains an extraordinary resource.
Seeing these influential websites retire or slow down has given me a greater appreciation for the effort required to keep WUWT operating year after year. Judith and Steve have earned the freedom to pursue other interests, and I respect their decisions. Their contributions to the climate debate will continue to matter long after their posting schedules have changed. Meanwhile, WUWT continues publishing regularly, maintaining its reference pages, welcoming guest contributions, and providing a forum for readers who still have questions.
The People Who Made It Possible
One of the great surprises of this adventure has been the number of people I’ve met along the way. Scientists, engineers, meteorologists, statisticians, programmers, photographers, researchers, writers, and ordinary readers have contributed their knowledge and time. Some have written guest posts, while others have helped with technical problems, checked calculations, tracked down obscure references, or sent me an email pointing out something interesting. A few have provided valuable advice privately because public involvement might have complicated their professional lives. I’ve also made lasting friendships, and yes, a few enemies. That, too, comes with the territory.
I want to remember the late Dr. Leif Svalgaard, our resident solar expert, who died on October 11, 2025, at the age of 83. Leif was an accomplished solar physicist whose career included important work on the interplanetary magnetic field, solar magnetism, geomagnetic indices, and the reconstruction of historical solar activity. He helped improve our understanding of the Sun’s magnetic behavior and contributed to major revisions of the historical sunspot record. Among his achievements was the development of methods using historical geomagnetic observations to estimate solar-wind conditions long before spacecraft measurements became available. His scientific contributions extended well beyond WUWT, but I was fortunate that he chose to share so much of his knowledge with our readers.
Leif had a particular talent for explaining complicated solar physics while showing very little patience for unsupported claims, regardless of who made them. If someone argued that solar variability explained nearly everything about recent climate change, Leif was just as likely to challenge that assertion as he was to correct someone who dismissed the Sun’s influence altogether. He could be blunt, occasionally exasperating, and wonderfully precise. More than a few commenters discovered that bringing a weak argument into a discussion with Leif was rather like bringing a paper umbrella into a thunderstorm. But that was part of what made him so valuable. He insisted on examining the observations, understanding the instruments, and respecting the historical data. His contributions gave WUWT readers access to an exceptional level of expertise and helped make our discussions of solar science more rigorous and informative. I will miss his knowledge, his independence, and his willingness to spend time answering questions from people outside the professional scientific community. Charles Rotter recently published a remembrance of Leif and his remarkable career, which I encourage readers to visit.
Leif’s participation also illustrated something I have always valued about WUWT. Here was a distinguished scientist willing to engage directly with readers, many of whom had no formal training in solar physics, and to explain difficult subjects in detail. He didn’t require them to agree with him, and he certainly didn’t agree with all of them. The discussions were often more valuable because of that. His passing is a loss to solar science and to the community that developed here over the years.
I also want to acknowledge two people whose friendship and scientific work have meant a great deal to me over the years: Dr. Roy Spencer and Dr. John Christy of the University of Alabama in Huntsville. Both are accomplished atmospheric scientists, best known for their pioneering work developing and maintaining the satellite-based atmospheric temperature record. But my appreciation for Roy and John goes well beyond their professional accomplishments. Over the years, we’ve developed a genuine friendship and an easy camaraderie built around shared interests, scientific curiosity, and a willingness to question assumptions. We’ve exchanged ideas, compared observations, discussed research, and enjoyed more than a few laughs along the way. Their friendship has been one of the genuinely rewarding parts of this twenty-year adventure.
John’s involvement with SurfaceStations goes back much further than some readers may realize. He was a co-author, along with Souleymane Fall, Evan Jones, John Nielsen-Gammon, Dev Niyogi, Roger Pielke Sr., and me, of our 2011 peer-reviewed paper examining station exposure and temperature trends. He also worked with Evan, John Nielsen-Gammon, and me on the analysis presented at the American Geophysical Union in 2015. Having someone of John’s experience take these measurement questions seriously, contribute his expertise, and help bring the work into the scientific literature meant a great deal to me. I have always regarded his participation as an important part of the SurfaceStations story.
The collaboration also extended into later research. In 2022, John and Diane Kim published Detecting Impacts of Surface Development Near Weather Stations Since 1895 in the San Joaquin Valley of California. Their paper examined how the growth of Fresno and changes in the surroundings of weather stations influenced the historical temperature record. It specifically referenced our earlier SurfaceStations research and our 2015 AGU work. The authors found that the effects of urban development were especially apparent in nighttime minimum temperatures, illustrating once again how changes in the local environment can complicate the interpretation of long-term measurements.
Roy and John subsequently joined William Braswell in another important investigation, Urban Heat Island Effects in U.S. Summer Surface Temperature Data, 1895–2023, published in the Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology in 2025. Using a different approach from SurfaceStations, they examined relationships between population density and temperature measurements across the contiguous United States. Their analysis estimated that urban heat island effects accounted for approximately 22 percent of the observed warming trend in the raw summer temperature data they studied. That estimate applies to the particular dataset, season, and methodology examined in their paper; the implications for adjusted national temperature records require separate evaluation. Nevertheless, it was another serious, peer-reviewed investigation of a concern that had motivated my own work for many years.
I have long believed that the original SurfaceStations project helped stimulate further investigation into these measurement issues, including some of the work undertaken by Roy and John. That’s my perspective from years of personal interaction and scientific discussion, and I wouldn’t presume to speak for them about the origins of every research idea. What the published record clearly demonstrates is that our work intersected, that John participated directly in the early research, and that later studies continued examining the effects of station exposure and urban development. I find that enormously satisfying. One of my original hopes was that photographing weather stations and documenting their surroundings would encourage researchers to investigate these questions more thoroughly. Seeing accomplished scientists pursue those questions with their own methods and publish the results has been among the most rewarding outcomes of the project.
Beyond the papers and the technical discussions, though, I value Roy and John as friends. Scientific debates can be contentious, and the public controversy surrounding climate research has sometimes been unnecessarily personal. Through it all, their good humor, intellectual independence, and willingness to engage have been a welcome constant. I’m grateful for their friendship, their encouragement, and the many conversations we’ve shared. The scientific work matters enormously, but the friendships that have grown out of it matter just as much.
Another person whose contributions deserve special mention is Josh, (aka Cartoons by Josh) whose cartoons have become such a recognizable part of WUWT. Over the years, Josh has produced hundreds of illustrations capturing the contradictions, controversies, personalities, and occasional absurdities of climate science and policy. His artwork has provided a welcome dose of humor during debates that can otherwise become rather grim. He has a remarkable ability to take a complicated controversy and reduce it to a single image that makes readers smile, think, or occasionally spit coffee onto their keyboards. Some of his cartoons have been pointed, others playful, and a few have rightfully annoyed their subjects considerably. I consider that a respectable achievement for a cartoonist. He liked to parody Dr. Michael Mann, a lot.

Josh’s generosity has been extraordinary. He has contributed his talent to WUWT over many years, frequently without compensation, and his illustrations have become part of the site’s visual identity. The cartoons also remind us that disagreement needn’t always be conducted with solemn declarations and grim predictions. Sometimes a well-placed joke exposes a contradiction more effectively than several pages of argument. I’m grateful for his friendship, his creativity, and the many times he has helped us laugh at a controversy that was taking itself far too seriously.
I also owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to The Heartland Institute, which took me under its wing in 2018, first as a research associate and later as a Senior Fellow for Environment and Climate. Heartland recognized the value of my work at a time when independent climate research and commentary were hardly a reliable path to financial security. The people there gave me encouragement, professional support, and the opportunity to continue pursuing the questions that had occupied so much of my life. Along with two other generous supporters whose help has been equally important, Heartland quite literally helped keep me from ending up on the breadline. I don’t say that lightly. Behind twenty years of WUWT are some very real personal and financial sacrifices, and without people and organizations willing to stand behind me, I doubt I could have kept going. To everyone at Heartland who has supported me over the years, please accept my heartfelt thanks. Your friendship and confidence in my work have meant more than you may realize.
WUWT would never have reached its twentieth anniversary without the people who have helped keep it running. Charles Rotter has carried a substantial share of the editorial workload for years, and his dedication has been invaluable. Willis Eschenbach has contributed his distinctive combination of curiosity, analysis, independent thinking, and an occasional ability to start an argument before breakfast. Eric Worrall and our many other guest contributors have brought perspectives, research, and stories that I could never have provided alone. Joe D’Aleo, John Coleman, Bob Tisdale, and numerous other researchers and commentators have helped expand the range of subjects and technical analysis available to readers. Our moderators deserve particular thanks, too. Anyone who has spent time managing an active comment section knows that maintaining a reasonably civil discussion can be more challenging than analyzing a climate dataset, and unlike a climate model, the comment section can become unpredictable in a matter of seconds.
The comment section itself has been an extraordinary resource. Readers have contributed corrections, original calculations, photographs, historical references, and research ideas. Some have spotted mistakes that escaped the original author, while others have identified interesting observations that deserved a closer look. I have always believed that a knowledgeable and engaged readership can provide a useful form of distributed scrutiny. That doesn’t mean every comment is correct, as our moderators can certainly attest, but it does mean that useful information sometimes comes from unexpected places. A reader with access to an obscure dataset, a retired engineer who remembers how a particular instrument worked, or a volunteer who can visit a weather station in person may have something valuable to contribute. The SurfaceStations project was perhaps the clearest demonstration of what such a community could accomplish.
There are far too many people to name individually without leaving someone out. To everyone who has helped behind the scenes, written an article, contributed data, offered technical assistance, or simply helped keep the discussion going, thank you. You know who you are, and I hope you know how much your efforts have meant. The same goes for the many readers who have never posted a comment but have followed the site faithfully, sometimes for nearly the entire twenty years. Their continued interest has been an important part of what has sustained this effort.
Rebuilding WUWT for the Years Ahead
A twenty-year-old website accumulates history, but unfortunately it also accumulates technical debt. Over the years, WUWT developed a collection of aging plugins, broken links, frozen third-party graphics, outdated notices, and pages designed for a time when most people read websites on desktop computers. Some of the reference material had become difficult to use, particularly on mobile devices. In 2017, I noted that we had 49 reference pages, some of which badly needed attention. That was a rather charitable description of the situation. For a long time, the daily demands of publishing and maintaining the site took precedence over rebuilding its infrastructure, but we are finally making substantial progress.
The WUWT Reference Pages have been a major focus. We’ve replaced dozens of outdated or frozen third-party graphics across more than twenty reference pages with over 85 automatically updating charts covering global temperatures, sea ice, ENSO, atmospheric CO2, solar activity, tornadoes, Great Lakes ice, and numerous other subjects. We’ve added clearer anomaly and baseline-period labeling. The reference graphics now display properly on phones and smaller screens, and we’ve added two new reference sections, Sea Level and Climate and Human Welfare. Both subjects deserve careful attention, particularly because they are frequently discussed in terms of projections and broad claims rather than clearly presented historical observations.
The ClimateTV section has also received a significant upgrade, including improved video metadata to make episodes easier to discover, a cleanup and merging of a disorganized 330 topic and organization entries, with over 1,000 clips now featured online and growing rapidly, and the removal of the outdated plugin and banner elements. Our book reviews now feature a modern card layout with cover images, search, and filtering tools. We’ve also been removing dead links, clearing out obsolete notices, and improving the site’s mobile performance. None of this is especially glamorous work, and nobody is likely to write a breathless headline announcing that an old WordPress plugin has finally been retired, but these improvements matter.
The reference pages have long been one of WUWT’s most useful resources because they allow readers to examine measurements and historical trends directly, often without having to navigate through layers of interpretation. I want those resources to remain accessible, accurate, and useful. After twenty years, the old website has earned more than a little maintenance, and the improvements we’re making are intended to keep it functioning well into the future.
I am indebted to Charles Rotter for employing automated tools that made this happen.
Why Independent Climate Discussion Still Matters
The internet of 2026 is a very different environment from the one in which WUWT began. Information is more abundant than ever, but abundance doesn’t necessarily produce understanding. Search engines increasingly determine which sources people encounter, social media rewards immediacy and emotional reactions, and artificial intelligence can produce convincing explanations in seconds, even when the underlying information is incomplete or wrong. Meanwhile, the boundary between scientific analysis, political advocacy, and institutional messaging can become difficult for ordinary readers to distinguish. All of this makes independent examination of evidence especially valuable.
Despite the ridiculous accusations of being in the employ of “big oil,” WUWT has never had the resources of a university, government agency, major news organization, or large advocacy institution. What we have had is a readership willing to examine claims, challenge assumptions, and contribute expertise. That doesn’t guarantee that every article we publish will be correct; no publication can make that promise. What it does provide is an opportunity for arguments to be tested, disputed, corrected, and improved. I believe that opportunity remains worth preserving, especially when scientific findings are increasingly invoked to justify decisions with enormous economic and social consequences.
Twenty years ago, I was interested in asking questions that made people think, and I still am. The questions have become more complicated, the stakes of public policy debates have grown, and the technology has changed almost beyond recognition, but the basic idea hasn’t changed much. Show the data, explain the methods, identify the uncertainties, and allow questions. It also helps to keep a sense of humor, particularly when dealing with a subject in which some people appear to believe that every unusual weather event is unprecedented, every computer projection is destiny, and every disagreement requires a denunciation. Sometimes the most useful response is simply to look at the numbers.
A Personal Request for the Next Twenty Years
This brings me to a subject I have never particularly enjoyed raising: financial support. WUWT has depended on its readers from the beginning. We don’t receive government grants, we don’t answer to institutional funders, and despite years of accusations to the contrary, we have never received oil-company funding. Those claims have circulated for so long that I suspect some people would be disappointed to discover how ordinary our financial circumstances actually are. The reality is straightforward. Running a website of this size costs money, including hosting expenses, technical maintenance, software, security, publishing operations, and the continuing work needed to keep our reference materials functioning.
We can no longer rely on Google advertising, and changes in search visibility have made it harder for independent websites like ours to reach new readers. The site remains online because readers have decided that it is worth supporting. If WUWT has been useful to you over the years, I hope you’ll consider helping us continue. Our membership page offers two ways to provide recurring support. A Supporter membership is $7 per month or $70 per year, while WUWT Insider is $18 per month or $175 per year. For readers who prefer to make a one-time contribution, our PayPal donation option remains available. I will share donations made with Charles Rotter. Thank you for your consideration.
Any amount helps, and regular contributions are particularly valuable because they allow us to plan ahead, maintain the site, and continue improving the resources readers depend on. I would like WUWT to remain an accessible archive of observations, analysis, debate, and scientific history for many years to come. Twenty years of articles and discussions represent a considerable body of material, and keeping it available and usable requires ongoing effort. I would also rather spend my time publishing interesting science than trying to figure out why another plugin has stopped working. If you can help, you have my sincere thanks. If you can’t, please don’t feel obligated. Your readership, participation, and willingness to share the site with others have always been important contributions in their own right.
Looking Back, and Looking Ahead
When I published that first post on November 17, 2006, I had no idea where it would lead, and I certainly didn’t expect to be writing a twentieth-anniversary article. Along the way, there have been extraordinary moments, frustrating moments, long nights, unexpected discoveries, and more arguments than I could possibly count. There have been successes and mistakes. I’ve learned things I didn’t know, reconsidered positions when new evidence warranted it, and discovered that running a widely read website requires an entirely different set of skills from forecasting the weather. I’ve also learned that curiosity can be remarkably persistent.
A question about the paint on a thermometer shelter eventually led to a nationwide volunteer project. A small local blog became a place where people from around the world gathered to discuss climate science and policy. A casual decision to try blogging became twenty years of work. Along the way, I learned that people can become surprisingly angry when you ask them to examine a thermometer, and that some of those same people can be remarkably reluctant to go look at one themselves. I also learned that persistence matters, that independent observations have value, and that a dedicated group of volunteers can accomplish things that once seemed far beyond their reach.
The hostility was something I never anticipated, and I won’t pretend that it was always easy to endure. But neither did I anticipate the friendships, the generosity, the remarkable expertise of our contributors, or the loyalty of readers who kept coming back year after year. Those have been the more enduring surprises. The arguments may have attracted attention, but the people made the journey worthwhile.
Some of you have been here almost since the beginning, while others discovered WUWT only recently. Some read every day, some stop by occasionally, and some comment frequently while others have never written a word. All of you have helped make this possible. I hope the years ahead bring better measurements, better access to data, more rigorous debate, and greater willingness to distinguish what we know from what we merely project. I also hope WUWT continues to be a place where people can explore those distinctions without being told that asking questions is somehow improper. There’s still plenty to examine, and judging by the headlines, we’re unlikely to run out of material anytime soon.
Climate alarmism today: where every weather event is unprecedented, every forecast is a catastrophe, and every skeptic is a heretic.
Twenty years ago, I started a blog because I thought I might have some spare time. Twenty years later, I still haven’t found it, but I wouldn’t trade the experience. To everyone who has contributed expertise, encouragement, criticism, financial support, or simply a few minutes of their day to read what we’ve published, please accept my deepest thanks. It has been a remarkable journey, and I’m honored that so many of you have shared it with me.
As I sit here writing these words, looking back over twenty years of friendships, struggles, hatred, losses, and unexpected triumphs, I find myself more deeply emotionally moved than I ever imagined I would be.
Here’s to twenty years of Watts Up With That?, and to the questions still waiting to be asked.
With sincerest thanks, and dedicated as ever,
— Anthony Watts
November 17, 2026