WUWT milestone – 10 years

Foreword by Anthony, decade in review by Janice Moore.

Ten years ago today, I started Watts Up With That with one simple blog entry.

wuwt-10years1

Since then, I’ve had 15,559 Posts and 1,902,684 Comments and 291,103,411 Views as of this writing. (updated at publish time)

Running this website, changed my life, and helped to change the world, if only in a small way. The reach is worldwide, where at my former TV station I only reached northern California. Now I have people who love me and hate me on all seven continents. Best of all, I don’t have to wear makeup to broadcast and sometimes I write in my skivvies. That’s freedom, yet just like running a newspaper, there’s always another story. You can’t go a day without publishing, so it’s freedom with a ball and chain attached. I have not taken a real vacation from blogging during that entire time. Still, I wouldn’t trade it. I’ve written entries from all over the world, in China, Belgium, The UK, Australia, Canada, and hundreds of places in the USA. Thanks to WiFi, I’ve written from planes, trains, and automobiles. In the field, and in the city, from Skyscrapers to a Motel 6.

I’m made some enemies in the process, but I’ve also made many, many, friends. Some of the people I’ve met have helped me though difficult times, others have inspired, some have kept me focused when entropy threatened to wreak havoc. Some have provided content when I was too tired to go on. I thank you all. I thank these people who have helped me behind the scenes, but I also thank you; the regular, general readers, the lurkers, and even the detractors.

A few people I’d like to thank personally are listed below in no particular order. I’m sure I’ve forgotten somebody, it isn’t intentional.

Steven McIntyre, Dr. Roger Pielke Senior, Dr. William Gray (deceased), Dr. Roy Spencer, Dr. John Christy, Dr. John Neilsen-Gammon, Dr. Leif Svalgaard, Dr. Judith Curry, Dr. William Happer, Dr. Richard Lindzen, Dr. Pat Michaels, Dr. Chip Knappenberger, Willis Eschenbach, Evan Jones, Bob Tisdale, Christopher Monckton, Dr. Tim Ball, Dr. S. Fred Singer, Kenneth Haapala, Tom Nelson, John Goetz, Jim Steele, Gary Boden,  Frank Lansner, Larry Hamlin, William Briggs, Dennis Ambler, Bill Illis. Jeff Id, Indur Goklany, Alec Rawls, Verity Jones, Joe D’Aleo, John Coleman, David Middleton, Eric Worrall. Dave Stealey, Mike Lorrey, Mike Jonas, Robert E. Phelan (deceased) Charles Rotter, Steven Mosher, David Little, Dr. Ira Glickstein, Dr. Susan Crockford, Marc Morano, Matt Dempsey, Chris Horner, Myron Ebell, David Schnare, E. Calvin Beisner, Caroline Kettle, Viv Forbes, Bob Fernley-Jones, Pat Frank, Larry Kummer, Kip Hansen, Rud Istvan, Kest Green, Andrew Montford, Barry Woods, Dr. Benny Peiser, Scott Gates, David Hoffer, Dr. David Demming, Wim Rost, David Burton, Ronald Voisin, Mr. James Waters, Richard Drake, David Archibald, Andy May, Jo Nova, Simon from Sydney, Andi Cockroft, Poptech, Dr. David Evans, Alan Moran, Dr. Jennifer Marohasy, Chris Field, John A., Mike Bastasch, Matt Drudge, Mark Steyn, Melissa Howes, Nic Lewis, Jos de Laat, Dr. Roger Pielke Jr., James Delingpole, Paul Driessen, Russell Cook, Joseph Bast, Jim Lakely, James Taylor, Charlie Martin, Leo Goldstein, Roger L. Simon, Lucia Liljegren,  Janice Moore, Marisa Mark, Ed Berardi, Dr. Robert Brown, Marcel Crok, Dr. Richard Tol, Stephen and Dr. Mary Graves, Juan Slayton, Ric Werme, Paul Homewood, and Josh (cartoonist extraordinaire).

Here are some people that haven’t been all that nice to me, but deserve thanks nonetheless, because they’ve given me something to write about, debate, and criticize. While normally you don’t thank detractors, I think WUWT would not have been as successful without them. Credit where credit is due.

Dr. James Hansen (who started this whole mess), Dr. Gavin Schmidt (who continues the mess Hansen started, er, well maybe, Trump might fire his egotistical ass), Al Gore (who turned it into a business), Joe Romm (who turned it into a hateful political mess), Dr. Peter Gleick (who showed us that crime doesn’t pay), David Appell (who showed us that condescending people can have a nice side too), William Connolley (whose acidic condescending behavior ruined hundreds of Wikipedia pages, and shows none of the occasional kindness David Appell shows), David Suzuki (who proved that you can scare children with Santa Claus climate stories), Nick Stokes (who has shown us that unrelenting pig-headedness can be a virtue, but has displayed occasional kindness), Ken Rice (and then there’s Physics, who has proven that one can have a degree in Astronomy, and still be dumber than a box of rocks when it comes to climate), Eli Rabbett (aka Dr. Joshua Halpern, who demonstrated a 10+ year fascination with snark and an invisible rabbit), disgraced former IPPC Chairman and apparent sex fiend Rajenda Pacahuri (who showed us that even Nobel prize winners can be scumbags while telling us we are practicing “voodoo science” for pointing out flaws in AR5)  and last, and most certainly least, Dr. Michael Mann (who led the way downward in science with small-minded thinking, pettiness, statistical murder, Nature tricks, and obfuscation). As Dr. Roger Pielke Jr. once quipped, “if Michael Mann didn’t exist, skeptics would have to invent him“.

I thank everyone who has made WUWT a success. This will be my last entry today. Later, I think I’ll take a nap and then go out for a nice dinner and maybe a beer. I think I’ve earned it.

Anybody that wants to contribute to the beer fund can do so with the “Donate” button on the right sidebar.

I now turn it over to Janice Moore, who worked for weeks on this decade-long anthology of highlights, I am in her debt. She writes:


This document was a joy to research and compile, but, at times, it was quite a challenge; it is hard to type with tears in your eyes. This is quite a story… To create a rough sketch of WUWT’s first decade, I tried to select a fairly representative sample, but, the sketch is colored by my own conscious and unconscious preferences. For instance, after the first couple of years, I skipped most of the solar threads (a worthwhile subject, but, well, we had had, by then, rather enough solar discussion for an anthology). (Note: the solar articles are easily found by using the WUWT Search Box (upper right margin).) Originally, I had a separate “HUMOR” section. I changed my mind and the humorous entries appear chronologically, mingled in with the straight education and current events, with the appalling and the dry, the technically eye-crossing (for us non-scientists) and the heart-rending, providing much-needed comedy relief in the midst of the grim battle for truth. I also started out with a “WISDOM” section, but have also incorporated those comments chronologically, sometimes separated from the rest of the thread (mostly to make my cutting and pasting revising easier!).

My goal in writing this anthology was to capture the heart of WUWT without distorting the original (i.e., keeping within the error bars of a reasonably accurate representation of the data, lol), complete, composition of WUWT. Please do not assume that because a given thread was not included I did not think it worthy. Some highly useful and or intriguing threads were left out due to their especially difficult technical nature or highly esoteric subject matter. Most likely, a given thread was not included simply for brevity’s sake. As to the included selections, most are merely summarized in this anthology, thus, I hope you will go to the original document.

Re: reader comment selection — Again, brevity controlled. I tended to include comments that were: helpful to understanding the subject or especially witty or humorous or touching or “typical WUWT.” If you want to see troll comments, while I included a few for amusement, for most of them, you’ll have to go to WUWT and see the thread. I refuse to give them one MORE stage upon which to parade their gobblinish song and dance.

Omitted text is usually indicated by “…” or “[ ]”, however, sometimes these punctuation marks were the original writer’s own. Please know that much of the omitted text was delightfully entertaining and or highly informative. Brevity dictated most of the omissions. Also, sometimes I ghost edited to keep down edit mark clutter. Re: my edits for style or grammar or ease of reading or for dramatic effect: 1) while leaving typos and the like in would have preserved for this anthology the flavor of WUWT (where no editing is possible), I chose to idealize, to a point, the writing (if you want the humor of reading some fun typos, the link is right there to check it out); 2) please do not feel embarrassed at my corrections – we all understand the frustration that is typing on a “smart” phone or into a WordPress edit-not-possible reply box or the understandable difficulty of writing in English when it is not one’s first language, and like issues; and 3) I sometimes left in an English-not-first-language writer’s very charming mistakes, their “accent” being such a delight to “hear.”

If a link does not work, try pasting it into your browser. (There were some broken links as of this writing, but I left them in for reference.)

There is likely a way (not going to attempt to give IT advice) for you to take notes and to annotate this anthology to include favorite articles I left out. Turn it into your own creation! See also “Ric Werme’s Guide to WUWT” (blue square in right margin) for WUWT Classics – a fine list of some of the best WUWT articles (several not included in this anthology).

Finally, a candle in the window for one who cannot speak, but who I know is there: Love is eternal, life immortal. “Death” is only a horizon and a horizon is only the limit of our vision.

Final word: Looking back over these ten years of smiles and frowns, of elation and agony, and of long, lonely, hours of hard work, this fact shines out above all the rest: one person can make a difference.

You see, [Anthony Watts,] you’ve really had a wonderful life.

Clarence Oddbody, Angel Second Class (before his promotion) in film “It’s a Wonderful Life”

Always. Janice


NOTE: This is a very large PDF file, 2436 pages!  Some may not be able to view it within your browser. Suggested reading is to do a “save as..” and download it.

wuwt-the-battle-for-science-the-first-ten-years (PDF 18.1 MB)

 

The climate data they don't want you to find — free, to your inbox.
Join readers who get 5–8 new articles daily — no algorithms, no shadow bans.
5 1 vote
Article Rating
469 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
November 17, 2016 8:50 pm

Congratulations Anthony!!
You have done the world a wonderful service!
Well Done to Janice! Whose poor mind will be filled with fun facts and data for years to come!
as an aside – (Can we just connect Janice to the computer?)

Janice Moore
Reply to  ATheoK
November 18, 2016 12:49 am

Thanks, ATheoK! Oh, brother…. you would THINK I would remember…..

Reply to  Janice Moore
November 18, 2016 5:40 pm

As the light exits and dark descends,
while most sane folks are drifting in sleep,
hark! A comment emerges,
sneaking into your thoughts,
rebuttals should’ve been said,
until wee hours flee,
goldurn, ATheoK and his empty head.

Janice Moore
Reply to  Janice Moore
November 18, 2016 6:25 pm

Man, ATheoK — that is good! DURN good! Do share more of your creative writing with us in the future, okay?

November 17, 2016 8:51 pm

Love the site – thanks for all the time and effort creating the content here as well as all the great links to the range of sites that cover climate. Just having all those links is something the alarmists’ would never do. You can do it because science is about being skeptical and testing ‘facts’. Truth and true science does not have to worry about detractors.
I particularly love how you’ll often pop up an article with little comment from the alarmist position and let the silliness speak for itself. Often, new peeps to this site don’t get what’s going on.
I also love the comment sections as you’ve got the most informed and diverse set of science readers on the planet!
It’s my daily obsession coming here (along with the daily flow game).

jorgekafkazar
November 17, 2016 8:53 pm

Congratulations on an important milestone. I came here about November 2 of 2008, following links from Solarcycle24. One link led to “Real” Climate, where the tude quickly drove me away. The other link led here, and I’ve been back almost daily since.

November 17, 2016 8:55 pm

Thank you Anthony! Your website has been quite the educational source for me. Again, thank you! Keep up the great work.

DeNihilist
November 17, 2016 8:56 pm

Anthony, you are a special person and are loved by me and many!!
After this last week of pure joy and merriment from The Donald’s big win, THIS, yes THIS is the cherry on top Anthony!!!
Live Long and Prosper Anthony, you are a true American Hero!

BallBounces
November 17, 2016 8:59 pm

Congratulations! You have made a positive difference in the world.

November 17, 2016 9:04 pm

Well, I made it through the whole file. Okay, just a subset. Okay, okay, it was the subset that mentioned me. I have my priorities!
One reference convinces me that Janice did a great job. On page 892, she summarizes a post I wrote for the 35th anniversary of the sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald. I concentrated on the class of storm involved, and included several examples. It’s one of my favorite pieces, especially because WUWT readers greatly enhanced post by their comments, and Janice included the best of those comments. Well done!
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/11/10/35-years-ago-the-witch-of-november-come-stealin/

Reply to  Ric Werme
November 17, 2016 10:24 pm

I liked that post too RIc – thanks. Wayne Delbeke

Janice Moore
Reply to  Ric Werme
November 18, 2016 12:50 am

Thank you, SO MUCH, for telling me that, Ric! Cool!!!

Eugene WR Gallun
November 17, 2016 9:18 pm

Anthony —
Right from the beginning I recognized CAGW was a crock of shiit. That was “correct opinion”. I found your site and you offered me “knowledge”. Thankyou. Thankyou.
Eugene WR Gallun
PS — Have a few beers on me.

frank wood
November 17, 2016 10:14 pm

Thanks for your remarkable work Anthony! Double thanks for introducing me to the great Willis!

Christopher Hanley
November 17, 2016 10:14 pm

It’s also ten years (plus a few months) since the cinema release of Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth [sic]” and ‘mann’, hasn’t the opinion climate changed since then due in no small way to Anthony’s blog.
Thank’s Anthony.

sciguy54
November 17, 2016 10:35 pm

Anthony
Thanks for all of your important work, and for all of the inspiration and entertainment you have brought to the world. It is a better place because of you.
And thanks Janice for bringing together such a fantastic sampler from the past 10 years. A monumental task.
Sciguy54

Janice Moore
Reply to  sciguy54
November 18, 2016 12:51 am

You are very welcome, sciguy. I’m glad you are pleased.

AJB
November 17, 2016 10:52 pm

Thank you Leif and others from the bottom of my heart. AJB is henceforth Alan Joseph Bond (an irrelevance), come into the light by what might be described as prophetic revelation to the subconcious mind along the way.
You too can catch a glimpse of Dirac’s spinor on the foreshore of Dali’s Temptation of Saint Anthony: A hobbled angel with a chicken foot on the foreshore in this extremely detailed, lucid and fine work depicting the progress of evolution, our present geopolitical and enviromental condition here on Earth. If religious I might be moved to recite the Lord’s Prayer at this point:
PATER noster, qui es in cœlis;
sanctificatur nomen tuum:
Adveniat regnum tuum;
fiat voluntas tua,
sicut in cœlo, et in terra.
Panem nostrum cotidianum da nobis hodie:
Et dimitte nobis debita nostra,
sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris:
et ne nos inducas in tentationem:
sed libera nos a malo.
Quia tuum est regnum, et potestas, et Gloria,
in saecula. Amen.

If Latin is not your thing, try any of these instead.

Eugene WR Gallun
Reply to  AJB
November 18, 2016 3:23 am

AJB — Huh? What you wrote is gibberish. Get off the drugs, man. — Eugene WR Gallun

Alan Joesph Bond
November 17, 2016 10:54 pm

Fuelled by neuroticism, far too much coffee and bananas.

November 17, 2016 10:56 pm

Congratulations Anthony. You were essential for giving skeptics a voice. And thanks for allowing me to post my essays.

Reply to  jim steele
November 17, 2016 11:13 pm

And a big thanks to Janice for her efforts. She has always been a delightful contributor and cheerleader for the truth.

Janice Moore
Reply to  jim steele
November 18, 2016 12:53 am

Thanks, Jim! Yay!!! #(:)) AND WHAT A FINE AUTHOR YOU ARE — we have been very blessed by your so generously giving us so much first class information, lucidly presented, FOR FREE. Thank YOU.

November 17, 2016 11:01 pm

Thank you Anthony for this site. I have over 1500 emails with references that I have filed on this computer for my children and grand children to read after I am gone, many of them with references to WUWT. We have agreed to disagree about climate some find it hard to believe Al Gore and the school system would deceive them even though I have been trying get them to look at the “real” science and geologic history for 40 years. I have been bookmarking articles for them to read since the late 1990’s across four different computer platforms. I referenced where they are how to read them in my will. I gave up having face to face discussions with them as they have been highly indoctrinated by the education and political system. Well, not quite. I have convinced one son to consider the history of the earth as he has a bent that way. Perhaps they will be more open minded about science once their biased father is no longer presenting arguments that don’t fit the leftist agenda some of them have bought into.
Thank you Janice for your “anthology”. I will be adding it into the list of things I leave to my children and grand children as part of their reading for when I am gone. It will be specifically referenced in my will, and hopefully when they read it, they will get an idea of some balance between natural and human caused effects, positive and negative. I have always tried to explain to them just how little we know as the more we know, the more we know that we don’t know. I have been following climate for 60 years, and while something new may pop up in the future that is worrying, I have been downhill skiing every winter for over 60 years and am currently skiing at Banff, Alberta where the Sunshine ski hill opened a week early this year and Lake Louise opened a week late – weather – not climate. The fear of lack of snow for resorts seems to have been over rated. I have seen good snow years and poor snow years for 70 plus years.
I hope someday WUWT might be suggested/required reading for kids studying climate so they are exposed to multiple facets of the climate discussion.
As an old retired engineer, I know there are all sorts of impacts from human activities. I spend a lot of time in the back country hiking, skiing and horseback from Northern Alberta to southern Arizona. And I have spent time working overseas. I see the impact we humans have although my impression is that it is small in spite of the large amount of annoying detritus we leave behind. We can do better. I teach my offspring to do better. I try to get them to look at sites like WUWT so they can work to do better without fearing that the world is coming to an end. I suspect that in spite of ourselves and our huge human egos, the net effect is likely small, and most certainly beneficial overall. Try running a modern city without modern conveniences. In fact, I found it interesting to pass a huge VESTAS diesel service truck when I was driving to the ski hill today. Seems even the wind is diesel dependent.
Thanks to so many of the contributors who continue to teach an old dog.
I wish WUWT a second great decade along with all the other contributors.
Wayne Delbeke
From 45 km north of Rocky Mountain House, Alberta, Canada, in the boreal forest.

Janice Moore
Reply to  Wayne Delbeke
November 18, 2016 12:57 am

What an honor, Wayne. Thank you for paying me such a high compliment. Your family was blessed with a fine legacy just in knowing you, someone so very concerned about their intellectual purity. I’m mentioned in your will…. that is really moving. Wow.

DeNihilist
Reply to  Wayne Delbeke
November 18, 2016 7:32 am

Wayne, I too have used WUWT and (Jo Nova’s) site to help my boys learn to use their reason. My oldest, when he was in grade 11, had to write an essay on global warming. I advised him to write the opposite side, and gave these sites for him to reference. His teacher, though being a lefty, was impressed enough with his methodology that he gave my boy an A!
I wonder from time to time if this teacher is now a regular reader of these sites – 🙂

Alan Joesph Bond
November 17, 2016 11:04 pm

Those of a mathematical bent may therefore like to acquire the best quality print available, light well and inspect with a magnifying glass. Have at this, it needs to be refined!
Should anyone need to borrow a different pair of eyes, you know how to reach me. For now I need to sleep and recover. Over and out.

Janice Moore
Reply to  Alan Joesph Bond
November 20, 2016 10:57 am

Hi, Alan Joseph Bond,
I am only a beginner mathematician, but, I wanted to LEARN and that wikipedia entry had a bit that was confusing to me. (I’m going to write the notation out mostly in plain English, for I can’t readily find the math symbols to use)
Q: Why does the wiki author define the term, “p (to the µ power) = {+ – √m2 + … }”? The equation uses p (sub µ), i.e., just above, “px = p (sub µ) times x (to the µ)”
Thanks for the explanation and I hope that AndyG or a real mathematician responds to you!
Better yet, Mr. Bond, how about writing a post about it for WUWT (definitely an intriguing thing!)? Submit it to Anthony using the “Submit Article” tab at the top of this page. If you can, make it understandable to people whose highest math achievement is Calculus.
Note: if you do try to submit an article and it is ignored:
1) try summoning a mod (spell out m0derat0r with all letters) to ask why it was rejected. It may be that it was simply overlooked. MANY good articles (and Tips, too in Tips and Notes) are not used with no explanation…. . Three of us tried to get Dr. Pat Frank’s video lecture/notes on his paper, “No Certain Doom…” featured as a WUWT article this year and were ignored or, hopefully just overlooked. All that because I feel like I’m setting you up for a big disappointment by encouraging you to post an article for WUWT publication.
and
2. Talk about it (the fact that you submitted an article and weeks passed with no response) on a thread or two to alert us all. At least you will get some sympathy…. (shrug) (wry smile).
Thanks again for your super-brainy contributions above — classic Latin AND quantum field theory. Cool!
Your very beginning level student,
Janice

Janice Moore
Reply to  Janice Moore
November 20, 2016 10:59 am

grr — “AndyG or another real mathematician…

Clive Bond
November 17, 2016 11:13 pm

Thank you from Brisbane, Australia Anthony I wish our politicians could read your posts but their predecessors removed phonics from the reading method just before they started school. So now it is the “look and guess” method and most of them don’t bother. Take a break, you have earned it, and we will all be here when you come back. Clive Bond

Admin
November 17, 2016 11:29 pm

Daaaayyyyuuuummmmm!

Vieras
November 17, 2016 11:30 pm

Thank you Anthony. Well done!

MarkV
November 18, 2016 12:13 am

Thank you Anthony. You have done amazing things for creating understanding amid all the hype and remained a gentleman throughout. Thank you also to all the people who help you and who have contributed in so many ways. Congratulations!

November 18, 2016 12:24 am

Just donated $100. I have both supported and criticized this website over the past 10 years.
Please allow me to do both for the next ten years.

Richard G
November 18, 2016 12:34 am

Nearly a decade ago I would visit WU for Meteorology. During Hurricane season I would visit Dr. Masters blog. After a few years it felt like a CAGW religious sect rather than a Meteorology site. The usual appeal to authority and discredit the messenger was the SOP.
I noticed they would disparage WUWT on a daily basis and after a while I began to wonder, what is this WUWT? I put WUWT in the search box and never looked back. Thank you for your time, effort and dedication to this site Anthony along with those who provide content, moderate, comment and support to the operation of the site.

Patrick MJD
November 18, 2016 1:07 am

Well done to everyone involved, a great mile stone and achievement. Can this thread be made a sticky for a few days, going to take a while to read.
Well done Janice!

Patrick MJD
November 18, 2016 1:11 am

Also, I wonder if we can setup a “Donate” button for Janice who has put in significant effort.

Janice Moore
Reply to  Patrick MJD
November 18, 2016 1:39 am

Thank you, Patrick! 🙂
Your donate idea is very kind, but, that would sort of ruin this for me — I want it to be a gift. THAT is a gift to me. It made me happy that you wanted to, though. Thank you.

Patrick MJD
Reply to  Janice Moore
November 18, 2016 2:41 am

Very selfless of you Janice.

Lodger from Oz
November 18, 2016 2:28 am

WUWT is a wonderful site. I first came here many years ago (not even sure how long) after clicking on a link in a newspaper article on Global Warming by Journalist Andrew Bolt. Thank you so much Anthony and all the contributors for all your efforts. I have no doubt that, many years from now, this website and the name of Anthony Watts will be remembered to history as prime factors in the defeat of the global warming fraud. They’ll be lecturing on you in the Universities! The irony will be so sweet! I’ve downloaded the PDF and I’m going to slowly savour it over the next few days. Thanks to you too Janice for compiling it.