Julia Hartley-Brewer clashes with meteorologist Jim Dale over global warming after reports that the world is more likely than not to be 1.5C warmer in the next five years.
Jim Dale said: “It will take time, it will not be a straight line, but you’ve been warned.”
Julia Hartley-Brewer said: “We’ve been warned again and again, pretty much every few years. I think New York and Miami are supposed to be under water. Julia: Can we all just relax on the basis we are all going to hell in a handcart and you lot can stop nagging us to stop turning our heating off?”
Click here for more from TalkTV https://talk.tv
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Jim Dale should stick to comedy….
Jim Dale should Carry On with comedy.
He definitely has the clown nose for it.
The ‘strawberry nose’
Often supposed to be an affliction of drinkers which, yes ~ish holds water because alcohol wrecks tiny blood vessels.
Also a lack of Collagen, low Magnesium, excess Calcium, high sugar and mostly, deficiency of Vitamin C
Most commonly pushed explanation is that it’s a manifestation of Rosacea- in turn reckoned to be an auto-immune disorder.
There’s your low Vitamin C again, allied to low levels of Zinc, Selenium and Vitamins A & E.
Also Vitamin B (complex) = required for Vitamin C to metabolise properly, similarly Copper. That’s it for Vegeraritainarianarians then…..
Thus why drinkers get Strawberry Noses – the body uses immense amounts of Vitamins B and C to try protect itself from the alcohol.
Also, booze being diuretic, it simply flushes B and C right out of you before they can do anything
Thus: Enter yours truly repeating for the trillionth time:
...caused by eating low nutrient mush & rubbish, passed off as ‘food’, grown on rapidly eroding farmland soils. Increasingly laced with Glyphosate to make it even less nutritious.
Minds and bodies are intimately connected – if one part is falling apart, so is the other.
Hence the fluffing, mumbling, name calling, authority appealing, repeat repeat repeating, apppaels to authority/consensus/computers, not least his very own authority.
While bragging how clever he is comapred everyone else (Jim: you just got an F_minus from Charm School) – and – couldn’t resist telling of his recent jolly to the Far Middle Somewhere East.
what a wreck of a man
The erosion being at the root of the observed climate changes.
As if Temperature = Climate. sigh
Wrong: Weather, thus Climate is caused by the movement of Energy down (always down) a thermal gradient
Temperature Difference (between locations – NOT times) causes Climate – not absolute temperature.
edit to add:
Stress within us uses immense (I do mean that) immense amounts of Vitamin C.
(It helps recycle Dopamine and Serotonin)
Hello hello – Now we see why Lockdown for Covid was one of the worst possible courses of action?
Stress over rising prices, fuel shortages and upcoming everythings wont help either.
Well hello again, is this why UK has the worst Excess Death Rate for 50+ years when it should (following Covid) be enjoying a better than ever excess life rate…
Hence, going right back to the very top, we see and hear Julia arguing for people to ‘relax’
Female Intuition is a very powerful thing – just a shame boys are so poor at reading it.
They’d better start learning soon…………
That was a different Jim Dale, but this one is funnier!
Senior meteorologist, more likely senior muttonhead.
Dale should take his prophecy to China and India and demand that they slash carbon emissions. See if he makes it out alive!
This is a very important point in response to the alarmist rant – what are China and India doing about it? They are building huge new fleets of low-pollution, coal-fired power plants for affordable and reliable electricity. (Along with aggressive development of nuclear capacity.)
then they sell products to the west- so the west ought to claim responsibility for those carbon emissions- if it was truly concerned about those emissions- proving that it isn’t- and it shouldn’t be- so there wasn’t any point moving those industries and all this nonsense about cutting emissions- multiple levels of craziness
David Dibbell:
“They are building huge fleets of low-pollution, coal-fired power plants”
Their plants are NOT low-pollution. China is the largest emitter of SO2 aerosol pollution on the planet, and was responsible for the reduced temps. of the 2020-2023 La Nina, which just ended in Feb
You misquoted what I said. The NEW power plants are described as “ultra-low emission”.
For example:
https://www.voanews.com/a/science-health_study-chinas-new-coal-power-plant-capacity-2020-more-3-times-rest-worlds/6201542.html
David Dibbell:
Regardless of what the Chinese claim, the image shows that they are presently the world’s largest emitter of SO2 aerosol pollution, which stretches west-ward over Europe, etc..
It appears that their “huge fleet” of ultra-low emission coal-fired power plants is yet to be built–unless that is the best that they can do.
Exactly!
If you’re facing an existential problem, you don’t nibble around the edges of it for solutions.
You dive in with everything you’ve got and take huge bites at it everyway you can.
“Concentration of force” is one of the fundamental principles of battle.
(or maybe the “climate crisis” is not really such a big problem when it’s all boiled down?)
Of course it isn’t. Earth is in an Ice Age right now. That is the real climate crisis. Having Ice at the Poles in summer is what is not normal if we look at the last 200 Million years
Take a moronic CAGW idiot and toss him in with a rude interrupting interviewer and you have an entertaining moment, for me, at least. But not the least informative or instructional for the green warmers. We have solid facts and calm educated individuals that can better try to educate the misguided. If they are educatable in the first place…..
I have a good friend who recently mentioned that she is “very worried” about climate change. Mentioning some real facts made no impression and this person is not dumb, just easily brainwashed. She lives in Portland,OR so that should give you an idea of the kind of “facts” she has been exposed to.
So I had Amazon send her a copy of Climate At A Glance. Waiting for her response which I’m sure will start with ad-hom attacks on Anthony, WUWT and the Heartland Institute. Then at least I can tell her that the data shown in the book comes from everywhere but there. I don’t think she’s been exposed to cherry picking at that level before.
that’s why I like Stephen Koonin, author of Unsettled- he has the facts and a calm personallity- having just read his book, it’s clear to me that he’s one of the most knowledgeable people on the subject of climate
Stephen got cancelled almost the moment his book left the publisher’s warehouse.
That’s the first line of response for the Climate Crisis Cultists.
Mr.,
Might I suggest that Stephen Koonin entered the cancellation process soon after the public became aware of his part in a key conference of the Americal Physical Society, January 8th, 2014. . Dr Curry was one of the debaters
I have read the 573 pages of proceedings several times.
I further suggest that anyone who has not studied this document is not completely educated about the climate change topic.
Geoff S
https://www.aps.org/policy/statements/upload/climate-seminar-transcript.pdf
Julia’s Izzy goes to Figi short interview was a classic.
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2022/09/27/tuesday-titter-twitter/
a rude “well informed” interrupting interviewer. Mr Dale needs to go back to school and learn a few things before he takes on someone with the intelligence and knowledge of the interviewer.
Is a Senior ‘Risk Meteorologist’ more knowledgeable than a regular old literature-degree risk analyst coder?
They’re the “sky is falling” specialists.
Could we ask the Senior Risk Meteorologist what is the “risk” of the next pleasant day?
Just observe this clown with the bound loo paper in his background shot. Note the anxiousness and his body language. Note the tonal quality of his voice and the stutter to his comments. Observe as he (representing the Global Elite “They”) gets the slightest pushback from someone with real evidence. Evidence that they have been continuously wrong with their predictions since they began to dummy up the data.
The data manipulation coincides with the first IPCC doomsday report that was released after their inception in 1988 and has been exposed by the hacked emails from the University of East Anglia.
When life fails to end because of climate change and generations hence become exhausted by these moving doomsday targets, this will be written up in history as the greatest political grift ever played upon the world population. Of course by the time it is exposed the Faceless Global Elite will have successfully reduced world population by 20 to 40 percent, which along with lockdown control of fossil fuel energy, is their ultimate goal.
“this will be written up in history as the greatest political grift ever played upon the world population” Not sure. There’s a political guy in Rome whose organization has influenced half the world for 1000+ years. If you inflation-adjust income and account for discoveries in certain ways…
Bigot. That “political guy in Rome whose organization has influenced half the world for 1000+ years” is the reason the previous Roman organization converted from worshipping and following the whims of egomaniac Emperors to worshipping the “Truth, the Light and the Way”, and the reason you aren’t speaking Arabic or Mongolian or Turkish, and why we have Science, (even if Science today is mostly an atheistic alarmist cult).
Happy Ascension Day (observed tomorrow in most of N. America for convenience, but the proper day was last Thursday).
Not to be critical Kevin but the “guy” that influenced Rome goes back 2000+ years. His pronoun was Lord, He understood that God controlled the climate not a trace atmospheric element described by science as CO2, his father instilled man with critical thinking skills (something 21st Century western schools have abandoned) which allowed man to discover an amazing use for fossil fuel that helped save the whales (ancillary benefit) and force candle makers to scent their wax. This amazing substance in its various forms drove the the Industrial Revolution, without which there would be no income to speak of, inflation adjusted or otherwise. He also instilled man with a free will so that he could choose either to deny him or see the evidence of his existence through science as intelligent design.
“Julia Hartley-Brewer clashes with meteorologist Jim Dale over global warming after reports that the world is more likely than not to be 1.5C warmer in the next five years.”
********
Oh Lord, here we go again with this 1.5 deg. C threshold temperature claim. I still can’t seem to recall anyone who is pushing this claim producing or stating that there was any sound science (if any science at all) behind it.
Was the world never 1.5 deg. C warmer than today? Medieval Warm Period? Roman or Minoan Warm Period? 2 deg. C warmer? 3 degrees?
I am still waiting for someone in the top echelon of government somewhere in the world to expose this whole fraud. Thirty-five years of it (beginning with James Hanson’s testimony before Congress in 1988) is long enough.
Kudos to JHB for continuing to challenge the alarmist narrative on her program.
can someone please explain how 1.5 C is supposed to be dangerous? For example, if the UK was to become 1.5 C warmer for every year, from now to forever, give an example of current high/low temps for the months of the year.
thank you
The 1.5 deg C is measured from the pre-industrial period. The temperature has already gone up 1.499 deg C since then. It’s like walking towards a cliff – there is no sign of danger for the first 1499 steps, it’s the 1500th step that puts you over the precipice. The last 0.001 deg C of warming, bringing the total to 1.5 deg C of warming, is predicted to occur at 09:17 GMT on 23 July 2023. Everything ends then.
but…but.. July of this year doesn’t give me nearly enough time to improve my golf game!
Wait! I thought we had 5 years before we reached the cliff, so wouldn’t that be 09:17 GMT on 23 July 2028?
Of course they keep moving the precipice so standby for future doomsday forecasts. My money is on a 2025 report pinning the exact date we step off the cliff to 2030. This time almost certainly for sure, until the next time.
IOW the 1 millionth “tipping point”.
Half the world’s population will be grateful to wake up to a 1.5C morning rather than a 0.0C morning.
Especially if they still have plentiful electricity to warm the bathroom.
It’s not. In particular when you consider that it is from a baseline called the Little Ice Age, which was a period of misery and suffering for humanity, not some “paradise” that any departure from which is some “catastrophe.”
Far from it. Today’s climate is FAR BETTER than what they refer to as “pre-industrial” climate, when enough food couldn’t consistently be grown to feed about 1/8th today’s human population.
Biggest lie they’re selling is that a warmer climate is worse. The 1.5 degree “threshold” for their imaginary “irreversible climate harm” (read:improvement) was pulled out of their nether region.
It’s times like these that I really miss Griff.
The resulting thread would have been comedy gold.
We need more people like Julia not afraid to say the king has no clothes on.
She was great, though I do wish she let him talk more.
No anything but that unless you’re studying the Dunning-Kruger Effect. He’s awfal, argues from supposed authority and seems totally unaware of actual facts. Whenever he comes on a programme as a climate expert I just cringe. Julia did us a favour interrupting.
Short history of the infamous 1.5C threshold.
Schellnhuber originally made up 2C with NO scientific underpinning. As evidence of his nonsense, during the Eemian interglacial marine proxies suggest the world was 2C warmer than today, so about 3C warmer that 1880. And Greenland ice cores show it was as much as 8C higher there, yet Greenland did not lose its icecap—since there was lots of Eemian dated ice to core. And the world obviously did not end.
Then the observational EBM ECS came in about 1.7C—meaning Schellnhuber’s fictional catastrophe threshold 2C would never be reached. So the climate alarm could be called off.
That won’t do. So the alarmists moved the disastrous tipping point threshold to 1.5C and the alarm was back on as evidenced by this video. But they have zero actual evidence that 1.5C means anything alarming thereafter at all.
Diurnal land temperature variation is much greater than 1.5C everywhere. And life thrives. Oceans have much more thermal mass than the atmosphere, but geographically its zonal temperature variations are also much greater than 1.5C—ranging from 0C to about 30C at the sea surface depending on latitude and season. And life thrives.
I think the 1.5 degrees C is based on tweaks to Nordhaus’s DICE model.
Whoever downvoted me – where do you think it comes from?
To the extent that Wikipedia can be trusted on contentious issues, the Potsdam Institute ran a tweaked version in 2020 to give a lower Nordhaus Optimum than Nordhaus had – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DICE_model
Downvotes twice in a row. I feel truly honoured 🙂
I was gonna negate the down vote, but then your following comment would show a little less context. So, in the interest of a clean clear trail, you get to keep it. 🙂
That’s very kind of you, but somebody must have felt sympathy for my hurt feelings and negated them anyway 🙂
It really was just pulled out of the air or some orifice, same as the original 2°C limit. There was never a proper cost-benefit analysis done on the warming bad effects vs good effects, and the politically driven and misanthropic suicide-cultish scientist-alarmists will never do one because: a) currently, throughout most of the world, even in India, ~7-8 times more people die during extreme cold periods than heatwaves, b) the northern regions warming up and the tree line moving north would be a huge bonus to the biosphere not Armageddon, c) Equatorial regions will hardly be affected, and it is not certain which direction it would go – desert or jungle. However, the Sahel region has improved and reduced the Sahara in the past few decades, which leads to d) alarmist NASA has determined that the whole world has greened up about 15-20% over the past 5 decades, in spite of all the deforestation that makes the headlines. If that trend continues because of fossil fuel use, then how can any eco-alarmist try to stop that?
This following video starting at 18:55 helps explain where the prediction that New York would be underwater by now came from.
https://youtu.be/WTRlSGKddJE?t=1134
Wasn’t this the Al Gore’s prediction?
I get so many of these prophecies of the end of world confused one would think Christians were running the climate scam.
Jim Hansen in 1990. And one of his last papers before he retired still modeled up to 5 meters SLR by 2050. Even tho that is physically impossible. Greenland is bowl shaped. It’s ice would have to melt over many millennia. And we know know both Ronne and Ross in WAIS are grounded so cannot slide off.
No. It turns out the prediction that New York would be underwater by now came from Suzan Hansen (no relation to James Hansen) and then was promulgated by WUWT and Tony Heller.
You are flat out wrong. I traced his prediction to its magazine reporter 1990 interview (then publication) roots in my ebook Blowing Smoke (with footnotes to enlighten folks like you). It was made by Jim Hansen of NASA GISS, in his office in New York. And when it did not come to pass by 2000, he then claimed the reporter had misquoted him and he had actually said by 2020. Well, it’s 2023 and Manhattan’s West Side Parkway is still high and dry. Alarmist Hansen is still wrong.
The Magazine was The Salon in an article written by Suzy Hansen in 2001. Suzy didn’t even interview James Hansen. She interviewed Rob Reiss who interviewed James Hansen many years prior to the release of his book regarding the matter. No quotes in her article are from James Hansen who has no relation to Suzy and who has made it clear what his position is.
He didn’t say 2000 or 2020. He said 40 years after 2xCO2. The actual prediction is in Bob Reiss’ book.
He didn’t say that either.
As Sam Clemens is reputed to have said – “If you don’t read the newspaper you are uninformed, if you do read the newspaper you are misinformed.”
Don’t confuse Jehovah’s Witnesses or street corner con-men with Christians. It’s a basic tenet of Christian, especially Catholic belief that we can’t know when Jesus is coming back, and that there will be ” wars and rumors of wars” and still that would be just noise – and that Jesus coming back is not “the end of the world” – the world doesn’t blow up nor does everyone just die.
Pope Benedict didn’t think highly of the alarmists, and Pope Francis, unfortunately, is easily swaded by the leftist propaganda that promises utopia for the poor if total political control is given over to atheistic misanthropic egoists – what could go wrong with that?
You mean someone was actually dumb enough to make this prediction?
I always had this down as a skit from some comedy gig.
Careful who you are calling dumb here. Anthony Watts himself played a role in that prediction.
Yeah.
He took the p1ss out of it.
…after playing a role in making it. Anthony deserves props here though. At least he tried to make it right by updating his post saying it wasn’t Hansen’s prediction. Though he did conveniently leave out Hansen’s actual prediction which was for 40 years after 2xCO2, but at least it was a start
What will the alarmists do when/if the 1.5C “line in the sand” is crossed and nothing special happens?
They will continue on with the nonsense, just as they have with every other failed prediction. They won’t stop until there are some serious negative personal consequences.
“We never said it was a certain tipping point”
“It was always a question of reaching a point that COULD be a tipping point and now we have even less safety factor”
“Look around you! The past two days we have endured a heat wave of nearly 20c! “
“Arrrrrrrggggggggghhhhhh!”
Notice that they have redefined “heatwave” to become a period of 3 days. That’s not a heatwave, that’s just some hot weather for a few days.
Mostly say that such predictions were never made.
What predictions? Those were projections. Totally different word.
Correct me if I am wrong. The planet is in an ice age. The is something called the last glacial maximum (LGM) where we are now.
But what about the NGM? Nobody is talking about the next glacial maximum. Looking at the history of the last few millions, I do not think it is possible to predict what the temperature is going to be between the LGM and the NGM.
How bad will it be? Depend on where on the planet. Really bad for Canada, there will be no Canada not covered by a glacier. Of course, no one has yet been born that will see the NGM.
The video talks about food supply. Currently two of the top 5 wheat and fertilizer exporters are engaging in an artillery dual. That could cause a problem with world food supply.
The largest food, fertilizer, and energy importer is building ships, fighter jets, and missiles to sink US Navy ships that makes world trade possible.
I am not worried about the NGM but it would seem the fear mongers would be.
What keeps me awake at night is forgetting to celebrate whichever World [insert oppressed minority group] Day is scheduled for this week.
Well, Mr., you can stop worrying. Since they got rid of Aunt Jemima, Uncle Ben and the Indian Girl we now have universal racial harmony.
I still have a bottle with Aunt Jemima’s image on the label.
And I savor it.
Hang on to it, Mr. Its a collectable. Too bad you opened the bottle.
Kermit the Frog needed money so he took a ceramic elephant to the bank and asked the loan officer Mr. Paddywhack if he could use it as collateral for a loan. Mr. Paddywhack didn’t think so, but asked his manager if it was sufficient collateral. The manager said: “Its a nick-knack, Paddywhack, give the frog a loan.”
That’s only half the story. It was Kermit Jagger.
“The planet is in an ice age.”
That’s news to me.
Who decides?
We’re currently in an interglacial in an ice age.
The ice caps at both poles says so.
Beat me to it Dave.
By defn., as at least one existing major ice sheet.
Greenland ice sheet exists. Antarctic is covered in ice.
By defn. No decision made.
“The largest food, fertilizer, and energy importer is building ships, fighter jets, and missiles to sink US Navy ships that makes world trade possible.”
The entire implied threat is from an opponent that would starve to death if the threat were executed? Opening scenes from the old comedy-cowboy movie Blazing Saddles.
How about some more beans, Mr Taggart?
I wonder how much of Canada would need to be covered by the Laurentide ice sheet before the government would admit to having been wrong.
“Can We All Just Relax?” Julia Hartley-Brewer Clashes With Meteorologist Over Global Warming👍👍👍 Jim Dale might think twice about coming on with Julia again. Bravo Julio for challenging this absurd climate change alarmism.
Poor old Jim is just another alarmist fool believing his own propaganda…You can see he is very passionate about it, but then zealots always are.
Reminds me of NASA’s Peter Kalmus. A sympathetic video profile of him showed what a raving lunatic he is. He put a composting toilet in one of his home’s bathrooms until his wife and sons rebelled and forced it outside where only he uses it.
If you have a liter of air and a liter of water at say 70F the water has more than 3000 times the heat content than air. How can air with its puny heat content is going to heat up oceans never mind melt glaciers?
The urban trees are all gunna die-
Climate change threatens up to 100% of trees in Australian cities, and most urban species worldwide (theconversation.com)
Depending on how you water them-
Some trees in Kings Park have been in decline for years. Now scientists know why and how to fix it (msn.com)
“… threatens up to 100%” – zero is included in “up to 100%”
Although Julia raises valid points, I sometimes wish she’d interrupt less.
That being said, it’s interesting to note Mr Dale’s constant use of the word “denier” to describe anyone who disagrees with him or has doubt about the reasons for the changes in climate. His “I’m an expert so you should just do what I say” attitude is one of the reasons more of us are questioning the advice.
Disaster after disaster last year, yet we were cooler than we were in 2020. Even cooler than we were in 1998. There is no correlation between world temperature and warming induced disasters. None! This flies in the face of the Scientific Process, where predictions have to come true for the theory to be true. Not one prediction has come true, and yet we still have to put up with this hysteria. Someone give Mr Dale a reality pill and tell him to think like a true scientist.
I lost it at the 9 of 10 deaths were from cold and he said it “didnt matter”
off topic
I tried to watch the following clip where she goes off at adidas met in womens swimwear and got
this site is Blocked
any other aussies have this issue?
She made him look a complete idiot.
Two points she could have made, the record temps recently, were in April, and 10 C at least colder than what they experience in summer
It is not 1.2 1.3 C above pre-industrial, that was during the 2016 el nino, we are back to being 1 C above pre-industrial
Very interesting, when I click on the “YouTube” icon, as in watch on YouTube here is what I get:
http://www.youtube.com is blockedhttp://www.youtube.com refused to connect.ERR_BLOCKED_BY_RESPONSE
But when I go to YouTube and search for the video it comes up and plays.