Foreword by Anthony, decade in review by Janice Moore.
Ten years ago today, I started Watts Up With That with one simple blog entry.

Since then, I’ve had 15,559 Posts and 1,902,684 Comments and 291,103,411 Views as of this writing. (updated at publish time)
Running this website, changed my life, and helped to change the world, if only in a small way. The reach is worldwide, where at my former TV station I only reached northern California. Now I have people who love me and hate me on all seven continents. Best of all, I don’t have to wear makeup to broadcast and sometimes I write in my skivvies. That’s freedom, yet just like running a newspaper, there’s always another story. You can’t go a day without publishing, so it’s freedom with a ball and chain attached. I have not taken a real vacation from blogging during that entire time. Still, I wouldn’t trade it. I’ve written entries from all over the world, in China, Belgium, The UK, Australia, Canada, and hundreds of places in the USA. Thanks to WiFi, I’ve written from planes, trains, and automobiles. In the field, and in the city, from Skyscrapers to a Motel 6.
I’m made some enemies in the process, but I’ve also made many, many, friends. Some of the people I’ve met have helped me though difficult times, others have inspired, some have kept me focused when entropy threatened to wreak havoc. Some have provided content when I was too tired to go on. I thank you all. I thank these people who have helped me behind the scenes, but I also thank you; the regular, general readers, the lurkers, and even the detractors.
A few people I’d like to thank personally are listed below in no particular order. I’m sure I’ve forgotten somebody, it isn’t intentional.
Steven McIntyre, Dr. Roger Pielke Senior, Dr. William Gray (deceased), Dr. Roy Spencer, Dr. John Christy, Dr. John Neilsen-Gammon, Dr. Leif Svalgaard, Dr. Judith Curry, Dr. William Happer, Dr. Richard Lindzen, Dr. Pat Michaels, Dr. Chip Knappenberger, Willis Eschenbach, Evan Jones, Bob Tisdale, Christopher Monckton, Dr. Tim Ball, Dr. S. Fred Singer, Kenneth Haapala, Tom Nelson, John Goetz, Jim Steele, Gary Boden, Frank Lansner, Larry Hamlin, William Briggs, Dennis Ambler, Bill Illis. Jeff Id, Indur Goklany, Alec Rawls, Verity Jones, Joe D’Aleo, John Coleman, David Middleton, Eric Worrall. Dave Stealey, Mike Lorrey, Mike Jonas, Robert E. Phelan (deceased) Charles Rotter, Steven Mosher, David Little, Dr. Ira Glickstein, Dr. Susan Crockford, Marc Morano, Matt Dempsey, Chris Horner, Myron Ebell, David Schnare, E. Calvin Beisner, Caroline Kettle, Viv Forbes, Bob Fernley-Jones, Pat Frank, Larry Kummer, Kip Hansen, Rud Istvan, Kest Green, Andrew Montford, Barry Woods, Dr. Benny Peiser, Scott Gates, David Hoffer, Dr. David Demming, Wim Rost, David Burton, Ronald Voisin, Mr. James Waters, Richard Drake, David Archibald, Andy May, Jo Nova, Simon from Sydney, Andi Cockroft, Poptech, Dr. David Evans, Alan Moran, Dr. Jennifer Marohasy, Chris Field, John A., Mike Bastasch, Matt Drudge, Mark Steyn, Melissa Howes, Nic Lewis, Jos de Laat, Dr. Roger Pielke Jr., James Delingpole, Paul Driessen, Russell Cook, Joseph Bast, Jim Lakely, James Taylor, Charlie Martin, Leo Goldstein, Roger L. Simon, Lucia Liljegren, Janice Moore, Marisa Mark, Ed Berardi, Dr. Robert Brown, Marcel Crok, Dr. Richard Tol, Stephen and Dr. Mary Graves, Juan Slayton, Ric Werme, Paul Homewood, and Josh (cartoonist extraordinaire).
Here are some people that haven’t been all that nice to me, but deserve thanks nonetheless, because they’ve given me something to write about, debate, and criticize. While normally you don’t thank detractors, I think WUWT would not have been as successful without them. Credit where credit is due.
Dr. James Hansen (who started this whole mess), Dr. Gavin Schmidt (who continues the mess Hansen started, er, well maybe, Trump might fire his egotistical ass), Al Gore (who turned it into a business), Joe Romm (who turned it into a hateful political mess), Dr. Peter Gleick (who showed us that crime doesn’t pay), David Appell (who showed us that condescending people can have a nice side too), William Connolley (whose acidic condescending behavior ruined hundreds of Wikipedia pages, and shows none of the occasional kindness David Appell shows), David Suzuki (who proved that you can scare children with Santa Claus climate stories), Nick Stokes (who has shown us that unrelenting pig-headedness can be a virtue, but has displayed occasional kindness), Ken Rice (and then there’s Physics, who has proven that one can have a degree in Astronomy, and still be dumber than a box of rocks when it comes to climate), Eli Rabbett (aka Dr. Joshua Halpern, who demonstrated a 10+ year fascination with snark and an invisible rabbit), disgraced former IPPC Chairman and apparent sex fiend Rajenda Pacahuri (who showed us that even Nobel prize winners can be scumbags while telling us we are practicing “voodoo science” for pointing out flaws in AR5) and last, and most certainly least, Dr. Michael Mann (who led the way downward in science with small-minded thinking, pettiness, statistical murder, Nature tricks, and obfuscation). As Dr. Roger Pielke Jr. once quipped, “if Michael Mann didn’t exist, skeptics would have to invent him“.
I thank everyone who has made WUWT a success. This will be my last entry today. Later, I think I’ll take a nap and then go out for a nice dinner and maybe a beer. I think I’ve earned it.
Anybody that wants to contribute to the beer fund can do so with the “Donate” button on the right sidebar.
I now turn it over to Janice Moore, who worked for weeks on this decade-long anthology of highlights, I am in her debt. She writes:
This document was a joy to research and compile, but, at times, it was quite a challenge; it is hard to type with tears in your eyes. This is quite a story… To create a rough sketch of WUWT’s first decade, I tried to select a fairly representative sample, but, the sketch is colored by my own conscious and unconscious preferences. For instance, after the first couple of years, I skipped most of the solar threads (a worthwhile subject, but, well, we had had, by then, rather enough solar discussion for an anthology). (Note: the solar articles are easily found by using the WUWT Search Box (upper right margin).) Originally, I had a separate “HUMOR” section. I changed my mind and the humorous entries appear chronologically, mingled in with the straight education and current events, with the appalling and the dry, the technically eye-crossing (for us non-scientists) and the heart-rending, providing much-needed comedy relief in the midst of the grim battle for truth. I also started out with a “WISDOM” section, but have also incorporated those comments chronologically, sometimes separated from the rest of the thread (mostly to make my cutting and pasting revising easier!).
My goal in writing this anthology was to capture the heart of WUWT without distorting the original (i.e., keeping within the error bars of a reasonably accurate representation of the data, lol), complete, composition of WUWT. Please do not assume that because a given thread was not included I did not think it worthy. Some highly useful and or intriguing threads were left out due to their especially difficult technical nature or highly esoteric subject matter. Most likely, a given thread was not included simply for brevity’s sake. As to the included selections, most are merely summarized in this anthology, thus, I hope you will go to the original document.
Re: reader comment selection — Again, brevity controlled. I tended to include comments that were: helpful to understanding the subject or especially witty or humorous or touching or “typical WUWT.” If you want to see troll comments, while I included a few for amusement, for most of them, you’ll have to go to WUWT and see the thread. I refuse to give them one MORE stage upon which to parade their gobblinish song and dance.
Omitted text is usually indicated by “…” or “[ ]”, however, sometimes these punctuation marks were the original writer’s own. Please know that much of the omitted text was delightfully entertaining and or highly informative. Brevity dictated most of the omissions. Also, sometimes I ghost edited to keep down edit mark clutter. Re: my edits for style or grammar or ease of reading or for dramatic effect: 1) while leaving typos and the like in would have preserved for this anthology the flavor of WUWT (where no editing is possible), I chose to idealize, to a point, the writing (if you want the humor of reading some fun typos, the link is right there to check it out); 2) please do not feel embarrassed at my corrections – we all understand the frustration that is typing on a “smart” phone or into a WordPress edit-not-possible reply box or the understandable difficulty of writing in English when it is not one’s first language, and like issues; and 3) I sometimes left in an English-not-first-language writer’s very charming mistakes, their “accent” being such a delight to “hear.”
If a link does not work, try pasting it into your browser. (There were some broken links as of this writing, but I left them in for reference.)
There is likely a way (not going to attempt to give IT advice) for you to take notes and to annotate this anthology to include favorite articles I left out. Turn it into your own creation! See also “Ric Werme’s Guide to WUWT” (blue square in right margin) for WUWT Classics – a fine list of some of the best WUWT articles (several not included in this anthology).
Finally, a candle in the window for one who cannot speak, but who I know is there: Love is eternal, life immortal. “Death” is only a horizon and a horizon is only the limit of our vision.
Final word: Looking back over these ten years of smiles and frowns, of elation and agony, and of long, lonely, hours of hard work, this fact shines out above all the rest: one person can make a difference.
You see, [Anthony Watts,] you’ve really had a wonderful life.
Clarence Oddbody, Angel Second Class (before his promotion) in film “It’s a Wonderful Life”
Always. Janice
NOTE: This is a very large PDF file, 2436 pages! Some may not be able to view it within your browser. Suggested reading is to do a “save as..” and download it.
wuwt-the-battle-for-science-the-first-ten-years (PDF 18.1 MB)
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
As a critic and critic of the critics, I find this an extremely valuable site. Congratulations, Anthony.
Congratulations Anthony,
You and your volunteers have provided an one of a kind site that brings great minds, lets them open up, and allows the less informed see what is inside!
Thanks
Anthony! Anthony!! AN-THO-NY!!!! Oh, boy, am I happy you DID use it! Yay!!!!
#(:))
Janice, a personal thanks to you for this anthology. Much appreciated.
You are so very welcome, Rud. It was my pleasure.
Janice you’ve been moonlighting; or maybe lighting the moon.
I’m going to have to find some quiet time to download your missing scrolls, and peruse the past.
Thanx for the great effort.
G
Thank you, George. I wish I HAD been moonlighting when I worked on that. Not. 🙂
Enjoy the “scrolls.” I found them in a very dry place. 🙂 Isn’t it great they were written in English!
18.1 MB . . I was dissing you, you’re a megaweight ; )
Why John, are you on a dial-up modem?
Nah, Pop . . but I was kinda reminded of those olden days as I waited for the PDF to finish downloading. That is a whole lot of work she did . . and I recently “warned” a commenter who was being somewhat dismissive/haughty toward Janice, that she is a heavyweight I would not take take lightly . .
Aw, thanks, JohnKnight. Yes, I remember. That was generous and kind of you to say that.
(Well, just by coincidence, I had new internet service installed yesterday (the 18th), and got to see the increased speed by downloading the same file again ; )
I am looking through it now. It is quite the walk down Memory Lane.
A Blast From The Past
Thank you so much, it is an outstanding work.
Thanks, professor Tony! 🙂 You are very welcome!
Congrats to Anthony and all his helpers for a sane view of an insane world, WUWT is my favorite website by far. A few minor glitches with Janice’s “history” doc, though. For example, the pictures at https://wattsupwiththat.com/2007/11/20/how-not-to-measure-temperature-part-35/ don’t show up and the links are broken. I have found several like this.
Worked for me……..
That must have been a huge task. Thanks for putting one of my lame one-liners in.
Congratulations to WUWT and Anthony. 300 million coming up!
10 Gold Stars to you Janice, for such hard work and dedication, and 10 for Anthony, for probably helping to make Trump’s election possible by keeping many of us “little people” well informed with all the great posts and comments attracted to this great site !! Surely, America and the world would be a different place if this blog did not exist..Thank you….
Janice…as usual…YOU’RE AMAZING!!!!
Thank you!
(oh crud…I missed a chance to use “your”) 😉
You’re welcome….
Thanks, Marcus! Ten! Cool…
Your, your, your WELCOME, Latitude dude! 🙂 And, thank you!
As a newbie I appreciate all the work that has gone into shedding light onto the truth.
Thanks Anthony and thanks Janice.
Hans
You’re welcome, Hans. 🙂
Oh, boy, am I happy you DID use it! So am I, Janice. I enjoyed it second only to Anthony’s exposition. I am supremely grateful for the existence of Anthony, and I always enjoy your contributions, too.
Thank you for the kind words, Mary Catherine. I’m glad you are pleased with the anthology! 🙂
Thank you, Janice, for the compilation. Google Search is invaluable for finding good stuff on the internet, but I think I will find your anthology will be a good fast index of high grade articles in WUWT.
You are so welcome, Stephen. I hope you DO find it a good basic reference tool!
Janice wrote:
Seems a Prince Spaghetti ad reference. Very sweet in present context. Various versions, take your pick:
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=anthony+prince+spaghetti+commercial
lol — I LOVED watching that ad (just picked the one from the 1970’s). Thanks for sharing that, Ben. Well, I do not sound at ALL like that woman “Anthony!…… Anthony!…. Anthony!” I called out Anthony with a voice much more like a little girl on Christmas morning would cry out, “A puppy! A puppy!! A PUPPY!!!!
#(:))
Janice I personally thank you for keeping us sane with your humor and your needle sharp criticism of negative vibes.
Oh Damn , sorry Anthony I am for ever grateful for your site . It is hard to explain how much I have learned and how many avenues you have ( and your contributors have) given me. Thanks from the bottom of my heart. ( Janice pass it on) And btw the same goes for everybody that spend their time explaining complex things in a understandable way.
THANK YOU, Sybot (a). 🙂 Cool!
I nominate you for “Most Polite Person on the Internet”.
I wouldn’t be surprised if you got one dozen marriage proposals from WUWT readers.
I should mention I’m referring to Janice Moore.
Not Anthony Watts.
Well, Mr. Greene, you are very, VERY, kind (and courteous) to say so. Chuckling, though, as many readers here will, with a smile, I daresay, beg to differ…. I can be pretty feisty and blunt at times, heh. One in particular told me that he will no longer read my comments because I am too acerbic for his taste. Well, the man who married me would have to have a very good sense of humor and be very playful and love to have FUN (and be silly, too, sometimes, or, at least not mind me being “dramatic” and silly). I’ve found him, though, so it is a moot point (can’t be married de facto due to “circumstances”, but, in my heart, I am). Just fun to chat about, here. Smiling and smiling (and *blushing* a bit, too).
Thank You!
I still remember your first posts on measuring surface temperatures and the effect of Stevenson screens, before WUWT started up. Congratulations Anthony! You have indeed contributed positively to the climate debate. My hope is that now, with a President who is not part of the establishment, we will finally get true transparency in climate science and that everyone (including those in the political sphere) will welcome respectful, robust debate.
Here’s to the next 10 years! 🙂
Congratulations to a sterling job all these years.
Congratulations Anthony for your work and your moderators work to create and maintain the best climate blog in the world.
May you live long and prosper.
Best wishes,
William
I wonder; does Chasmod shave yet ??
G
My thanks to all the moderators — those who are currently active, inactive, and those who have passed on. 294 MILLION comments takes tons of patience and civility.
[that’s page views, 1.9 million comments, but still… thx -mod]
Correction: 1.9 MILLION comments. It still takes tons of patients and civility to keep the quality high.
+1!
Congratulations and big thank you to WUWT, Anthony and all contributors.
(I joined in the late 2008, learned a lot and enjoyed every minute of it since)
Yeah. Me too Anthony. As you know I joined back then as well and, based on a few calculations/estimates viewed 50,000 pages since then. I have 30 bookmarked sites now and WUWT is just under Drudge, which is my start page. I love your web site and the way you manage it.
I hope it becomes obsolete. I really do. Then it can become Anthony’s “interesting science” site.
Thank-you Anthony.
Nice job Janice. #(;’)
Thanks, Paul! #(:))
What a long strange trip it’s been.
Well done, Anthony … this comes from a daily visitor to your web site and little did I realize I have visited your site since its beginning. It’s going to get really interesting now, so please stay put!
My friend, as much as you might think you’ve accomplished, when all the returns are in it your contribution will be seen to be ten times as large.
My sincere congratulations to you for bringing the ongoing climate science conversation out into the public arena, for providing a place where new and old ideas can be publicly examined, tested, and investigated, and for keeping the shiny side up and the rubber side down on this most cantankerous bus you are driving.
I’ll close with the Spanish toast “Salud, y pesetas, y tiempo pa’ gozarlas” … I wish you health, and money, and time to enjoy them.
w.
I prefer the more forthright Spanish toast “Salud, y feurte Al Canute!”
I measure my discovery of WUWT with Willis’ post of The Smoking Gun at Darwin Zero. It was an eye-opener on the sausage making in the practice of splicing and adjusting raw temperature records.
So Thanks and Congratulations to Anthony Watts for the 10 years of curating this fine reservoir of excellent information and community. My gratitude to Willis Eschenbach for drawing me to this wonderful world.
what a waste of time,
no. I mean `what ! a waste of time ?`
i was sitting in a cold house one night with most of the lights off and the family all paying their respects to Morpheus when I found an interesting website, one of the articles had just a simple file linked to it.
Almost 3 hours later I stopped reading it and tried to get some sleep just as the dark was slowly being erased from the sky.
hooked from that first `HARRY READ ME FILE` heaven knows how many articles and how midnight hours I`ve spent since then , learned a little too.
thank you.
On the night Climategate broke here I went off and checked some of the data and text files (not very interesting), then Emails which kept me up too late. Just before I was going to go to bed, I figured I should check the HARRY READ ME file in case it had some pointers to other important things. Two hours later I managed to pull myself away and go to bed.
When I heard it was getting hard to find on the Web, I created http://wermenh.com/climate/HARRY_READ_ME.txt to inflict on other unsuspecting (or suspecting) readers.
A word of appreciation for your spin-off surfacestations.org. A great excuse to get in the car and go exploring.
Ah Juan, see right there, one of the people that I forgot to thank. Added to the list, and thank you!
Understatement …another one of your fortes.
Congratulations and thanks Anthony.
…and thanks to Janice Moore for her fine opus magnum.
Download and perusal brought back fond memories.
You’re welcome! Glad to hear that.
I feel like the kid on the old Shake-n-Bake ads: “and I helped!”
It’s simultaneously difficult to believe it’s already been 10 years, and that it’s ONLY been 10 years. I was awakened to the evidence-free nature of climate “science” a few years earlier, and was impressed when WUWT came along and seemed like a home.
I know the first years were filled with people saying what one of my first posts said: something like “I’m glad to see other people realize that this isn’t real”, followed by a description of the awakening process.
Well… today we have an Elected world leader whose eyes are wide open to the CAGW industry and what it’s really all about, so I feel very positive that the whole thing will soon crumble under its own excessive, arrogant, ignorant anti-science weight.
Code Tech — You (and ALL the commenters) HELPED! (and I’m sure Anthony agrees!)
Janice,
Colossal effort. What do you do for a day job? I often have wondered.
Anthony,
An amazing ten years. I will send a contribution for several large beers shortly. Wine, scotch too, if you like.
Hi, Jan,
I have a great education (Communication — Marketing — Management — Computer Science/Business), including a law degree (with an active license), but, I can’t find professional work. Due to life circumstances, mainly, I lack the 5 (sometimes, even TEN) years experience required. Or something. Anyway, I’ve been mostly unemployed. For a very long time. At least, I had a lot of time to do that anthology, lol.
Right now, I am a bit embarrassed to admit, but the only job I could land (so far — things are going to get better!) was a Macy’s temp. seasonal sales associate job. Lol, another newbie saw me arrive at work recently and after we chatted a bit, as I walked away toward the break room to put my things away, she called out, “Have fun today!” I turned to see if she was serious, saying (very dryly), “Oh, yes. I’m going to have FUN.” I could see by her face that she was SERIOUS! She thinks that job is fun. Oh, man. Well, just wrote all that so you can know that such a job is very boring and tedious to me and the only thing I enjoy is talking with customers and helping them make good clothes buying choices.
Thanks for asking — that you cared to know was lovely.
Janice
Janice,
Thanks for your open and detailed response. Perhaps, with your varied educational background and obvious latent talent, there is a position for you in the Trump administration. He could use a sound mind.
Yay Anthony!!!! WUWT has been and continues to be a great well-mannered forum, a place to learn and to share one’s observations and understandings.
Thank you for making WUWT what it is and has been for the past decade…and for allowing me to contribute posts here for 8 of those 10 years. (Wow, my first posts here, about the contribution of strong El Nino events to long-term global warming, were way back in January 2009, almost 8 years ago? Yikes.)
Thank you, Janice, for taking on the monstrous task of compiling the highlights of WUWT.
You are very welcome, Bob (there are several by you, in there). Thank YOU for years, YEARS, of excellent, free, science education.
Cheers to you Anthony! An awesome 10 years down and decades to go bro!
Bravo!
http://rs1028.pbsrc.com/albums/y344/Busola1/Applause.gif~c200
And yet another person that I forgot to thank. You really need a name instead of a handle, oh, wait.
ROTFL!
Well done Anthony. Can it really be ten Years?
Tonyb
As I think of the struggle against the warmists, I am reminded of the struggle of the allied troupes in WWII.
Maybe the comparison not appropriate, but the fight against the warmists is just as difficult.
Do not let up from those who wish to dominate us.
Your battle, like that of the British had little support until the USA became involved in the conflict.
It appears this may be a repeat of history.
Hans
Well done. Unfortunately all that work goes in defending the truth of Climate. Refuting gross rubbish. It had to be done and you, Anthony, courageously picked up the mantle. Thanks Anthony. We are deeply in you debt. Thanks also to those who have contributed to this site. Thanks to Mr Trump who is a headache for the ‘other side.’ Now the boot will be on the other side! Just can’t wait for 2017, hopefully reality will come.
Congratulations Anthony. You and WUWT have made a large difference with the best yet to come.
You changed the world for the better Anthony.
A heart felt THANK YOU to you and all those who post for our benefit. Through thick and thin you have stayed steadfast to a noble cause.
Congratulations. There is so much to thank you for.
Thank you in particular for making a new watchdog where mass media failed so miserably!
I have just put in a new donation, and I encourage everyone to do the same. 🙂 🙂
Congratulations and Thank you! Also thank you to all those who have contributed!!
All the best!
Joe
Congratulations, Anthony. You provide an invaluable service.
Thanks to Janice Moore for all her hard work. An enormous effort.
You are welcome, TA!
Dear Anthony,
Thank you so much for being there. You and your team as well just keeps making the heart of WUWT and the climate sceptic position beat every day and night every year.
You contribute to world history, that’s the truth and we all know it. Your role cannot be exaggerated.
All the best, and I can’t wait for you all to see what im up to next.
Kind Regards, Frank Lansner