Sea Surface Temperature Approaching the Threshold of El Niño

Guest post by Bob Tisdale

This post will serve as the sea surface temperature update for mid-June.

The post also provides an update on the progress I’m making with my new book The Ignored Driver of Global Climate.  I’ve included the table of contents as it exists now and a sample “ENSO cartoon”. The reason I’ve included the table of contents is to ask you if I’ve missed any topics that you believe need to be covered.

NINO3.4

NINO3.4 Sea Surface Temperature (SST) anomalies (a commonly used El Niño-Southern Oscillation Index) are just below the 0.5 deg C threshold of El Niño conditions. For the week centered on June 13, 2012, NINO3.4 sea surface temperature anomalies are approximately +0.43 deg C.

NINO3.4 SST Anomalies – Short-Term

GLOBAL

The weekly global sea surface temperature anomalies made an upward surge a couple of weeks ago in response to the transition from La Niña to soon-to-be El Niño conditions, then dropped, and last week they made a very slight upturn. They are now at about 0.17 deg C.

Global SST Anomalies – Short-Term

NOTE

This weekly Reynolds OI.v2 SST dataset begins in 1990. I’ve started the graphs in 2004 to make the weekly variations visible.

SOURCE

OI.v2 SST anomaly data is available through the NOAA NOMADS system:

http://nomad3.ncep.noaa.gov/cgi-bin/pdisp_sst.sh?lite

STATUS OF NEW BOOK

I’m making great progress with my new book The Ignored Driver of Global Climate. I’m about 85% done, I believe, based on what I think should be included. The following is the Table of Contents as it exists today. I’m presently at chapter “4.10 ENSO Versus the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)”. So far it’s 240+ pages long and includes 180+ illustrations. As you’ll note in the Table of Contents, there are a number of topics discussed in the book that I’ve not addressed in any blog posts to date.

And now the question that I need to ask: what topics do you want to see discussed that I’ve missed?

PRESENT TABLE OF CONTENTS OF THE IGNORED DRIVER OF GLOBAL CLIMATE

INTRODUCTION

Section 1 – A Description of El Niño and La Niña Events Using Cartoons

1.1 Preliminary Discussion of the ENSO Cartoons

1.2 The ENSO Cartoons

1.3 Recap of Section 1

Section 2 – A Few Preliminary Discussions

2.1 The Types of Graphs Presented

2.2 Linear Trends

2.3 How El Niño and La Niña EventsPresent Themselves in the Sea Surface Temperature Record

2.4 Our Primary ENSO Index is NINO3.4 Sea Surface Temperature Anomalies

2.5 How ENSO Events Are Presented in the Text

2.6 On the Use of Anomalies

2.7 Converting Monthly Absolute Data to Anomalies

2.8 Using the Model Mean of the IPCC’s Climate Models

2.9 Why We’ll Be Using Satellite-Based Sea Surface Temperature Data

2.10 Notes on Data Smoothing

2.11 Recap of Section 2

Section 3 – A More Detailed Discussion of ENSO Processes

3.1 A Quick Look at the Size of the Pacific Ocean

3.2 Pacific Trade Winds and Ocean Currents

3.3 Putting the Equatorial Pacific Cross Sections in Perspective

3.4 The ENSO-Neutral State of the Tropical Pacific

3.5 The Transition from ENSO-Neutral to El Niño

3.6 El Niño Phase

3.7 The Transition from El Niño to ENSO Neutral

3.8 La Niña Phase

3.9 The Recharge of Ocean Heat during the La Niña

3.10 Recap of Section 3

Section 4 – Additional ENSO Discussions

4.1 How El Niño Events Cause Surface Temperatures to Warm Outside of the Tropical Pacific

4.2 Central Pacific versus East Pacific El Niño Events

4.3 ENSO Indices

4.4 ENSO Indices Also Fail to Capture the Relative Strengths of ENSO Events

4.5 The Repeating Sequence of Primary and Secondary El Niño Events

4.6 A Look at How a Few More Tropical Pacific Variables Respond to ENSO

4.7 ENSO Events Run in Synch with the Annual Seasonal Cycle

4.8 Subsurface Temperature and Temperature Anomaly Variations in the Equatorial Pacific

4.9 An Introduction to the Delayed Oscillator Mechanism

4.10 ENSO Versus the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)

4.11 Recap of Section 4

Section 5 – The Long-Term Impacts of Major ENSO Events on Global Sea Surface Temperature Anomalies

Section 6 – The Long-Term Impacts of Major ENSO Events on Global Land-Plus-Sea Surface Temperature Anomalies and Lower Troposphere Temperature Anomalies

Section 7 – The Long-Term Impacts of ENSO on Ocean Heat Content Anomalies

Section 8 – Failed Arguments Against ENSO as the Primary Driver of Global Surface Temperatures

Closing

ENSO CARTOONS?

If, after looking at the Table of Contents, you’re wondering about the “ENSO Cartoons” mentioned in Section 1, the following is a sample. There are 29 in Section 1. Why so many? I was looking at all of the websites that provide introductions to ENSO and noticed that most included only a couple of illustrations of the ENSO process. Readers there have to jockey between the text and the illustrations. Unfortunately, much of what’s discussed in the text at those websites is not illustrated. So I’m trying the cartoons which combine text and the illustrations, with hope that they will help readers understand the basics of the ENSO processes. Later, in Section 3, I go into much more detail, supporting the cartoons with data, to reinforce what was presented in the cartoons.

Sample “ENSO Cartoon”

MY FIRST BOOK

The IPCC claims that only the rise in anthropogenic greenhouse gases can explain the warming over the past 30 years. Satellite-based sea surface temperature disagrees with the IPCC’s claims. Most, if not all, of the rise in global sea surface temperature is shown to be the result of a natural process called the El Niño-Southern Oscillation, or ENSO. This is discussed in detail in my first book, If the IPCC was Selling Manmade Global Warming as a Product, Would the FTC Stop their deceptive Ads?, which is available in pdf and Kindle editions. An overview of my book is provided in the above-linked post. Amazon also provides a Kindle preview that runs from the introduction through a good portion of Section 2. That’s about the first 15% of the book. Refer also to the introduction, table of contents, and closing in pdf form here.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

67 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kurt in Switzerland
June 18, 2012 10:06 am

Good job. Now how to get this message to Mainstream Media?
Proponents of the theory of Anthropogenic Global Warming are telling the general public that the seas are in fact warming (and becoming more acidic, and rising), due primarily to mankind’s CO2.
Time to make a lot of noise about the subject and to ask true scientists to come to some conclusions.
Kurt in Switzerland

June 18, 2012 10:07 am

“what topics do you want to see discussed that I’ve missed?”
The potential for the amount of energy tied up in the ENSO process to be influenced by solar activity and / or global albedo on centennial timescales.

DWR54
June 18, 2012 10:09 am

Bob,
What, in your opinion, is the average ‘lag’ between SSTs in ENSO 3.4 and:
i) global average surface temperatures
ii) temperatures at 14,000ft (AMSU CH5).
Thanks.

June 18, 2012 10:15 am

From your lips to God’s ears, Bob. Unfortunately it’s still feeling very “La Nina-like” here in Denver today. 95 degrees and a vicious high pressure system, and the most destructive wild fire in state history. Please bring on the El Nino.

SAMURAI
June 18, 2012 10:26 am

In your chapter on satellite SST data, will you also include a critique on ARGO data vs satellite SST data?
It would be very interesting to hear your views on this.
Good luck with your book!

Pamela Gray
June 18, 2012 10:42 am

blocking episodes related to the jet stream and how these patterns are influenced by oceanic conditions.
ENSO influence on Jet stream meandering between the equator and the Polar Jet stream.

Werner Brozek
June 18, 2012 11:00 am

Even if El Nino happened next week, I believe it is too late for 2012 to set any warm records. Here are the latest hadsst2 numbers that I have:
With the sea surface anomaly for April at 0.292, the average for the first four months of the year is (0.203 + 0.230 + 0.242 + 0.292)/4 0.242. If the average stayed this way for the rest of the year, its ranking would be 14th. This compares with the anomaly in 2011 at 0.273 to rank it 12th for that year. (1998 was the warmest at 0.451.)

ChE
June 18, 2012 11:10 am

Still cold and wet and grey in the PNW. Is summer really going to happen this year?

jorgekafkazar
June 18, 2012 11:14 am

Why the trade winds slacken and trigger the El Niño. You knew I’d bring that up, didn’t you? The book is a great idea.

tonyb
June 18, 2012 12:22 pm

Bob
Can I echo Pamela Gray. The jet stream is to me the most significant driver of weather. Whether or not it is influenced directly by ocean currents I can’t say, but it is the position of the jet stream that diverts weather systems. For example, here in the UK the jet stream has been a long way south and in consequence we have been getting lots of weather systems coming from an unseasonably wet and cold position.
I noticed that these patterns cropped up regularly when researching 15th and 16th Century weather references for an article and noted it here;
“Due to its geographical location British weather is often quite mobile and periods of hot, cold, dry or wet weather tend to be relatively short lived. If such events are longer lasting than normal, or interrupted and resumed, that can easily shape the character of a month or a season. Reading the numerous references there is clear evidence of ‘blocking patterns,’ perhaps as the jet stream shifts, or a high pressure takes up residence, feeding in winds from a certain direction which generally shape British weather.”
tonyb

Harold Pierce Jr
June 18, 2012 12:22 pm

ATTN: BOB T.
Did you ever get around to checking out “Cyclic Climate Changes and Fish Productivity” by K.B. Klyashtorin and A.A. Lyubushin????? You ref list would not be complete unless you cite this seminal monograph.
Here somthing ellse you should do: Make two copies of Klaus W. MEI graph. Place one on top of the other and move the top plot over the bottom to check for repeating patterns. There are repeating patterns from about 1970 to 2000.

Editor
June 18, 2012 12:30 pm

DWR54: Like lower troposphere temperature anomalies, the average lag between NINO3.4 sea surface temperature anomalies and the response of global mid troposphere temperature anomalies (AMSU channel 5) is in the neighborhood of 5-7 months (so 6 months). Because the surface temperature datasets also include the direct measurement of the sea surface temperature anomalies of the central and eastern tropical Pacific, which includes the NINO3.4 data, their lag is shorter, closer to 2-4 months (so 3 months).

Editor
June 18, 2012 12:35 pm

Pamela Gray: I’ve described why the jet streams shift, but I haven’t shown the before and after of where they shift.

timetochooseagain
June 18, 2012 12:42 pm

What, exactly, makes a .5 degree anomaly or greater so special? Is this just a completely arbitrary threshold or is there some physical reason to think that anomalies of more than .5 degrees from the “normal” would lead to the alleged “effects” of ENSO, but closer to zero than that has no relationship?

Steven M-E
June 18, 2012 12:57 pm

I must have missed the memo that not having hot dry weather in the Pacific Northwest meant we were lacking a Summer, come on it’s June 18th, give Summer a chance to get here already.
I’m looking forward to the book, I’m also glad it has a section on the difference between the now default Central Pacific El Nino versus the traditional Eastern Pacific El Nino, as there as some significant differences.

BILL KURDZIEL
June 18, 2012 12:58 pm

Show an example of how raw temperature data is adjusted for the Heat Island effect, leading to exaggerated trends in temperature projections. Great news about your book, Anthony.
We’re all looking forward to it.

Editor
June 18, 2012 12:58 pm

Harold Pierce Jr: Thanks for the suggestion, but Klyashtorin and Lyubushin (2005) is a paleoclimatological study and my book discusses the satellite era of sea surface temperatures.
Regarding the repeating patterns discussed in chapter 4.5 The Repeating Sequence of Primary and Secondary El Niño Events, I presented those in a post a couple of years ago: http://bobtisdale.wordpress.com/2009/07/12/similarities-of-the-multiyear-periods-following-significant-el-nino-events-since-1970/
There were three decadal periods of what appear to be “primary” and “secondary” ENSO events. The primary El Niño events occurred in 1972/73, 1986/87/88, and 1997/98. The two-year El Niño of 1986/87/88 simply skews it a little bit, but the secondary El Niño events “fit” with the other two periods.
It looks like that epoch may have ended though. Has ENSO switched to moderate El Niños followed by two back-to-back La Niñas? We’ll simply have to watch and see what Mother Nature and her two mischievous children have in store for us.
Regards

rogerknights
June 18, 2012 1:07 pm

Bob Tisdale says:
“… my new book The Ignored Driver of Global Climate.”

Oh Nooooo!!!!
Try “{Gaia’s | Climate’s | The} Forgotten Forcing”
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(Nobody uses “forcing” except climate science (others use “drivers”), so “The Forgotten Forcing” will be self-explanatory.)

rogerknights
June 18, 2012 1:09 pm

PS: Here’s another title I donate to anyone who has a book in the pipeline:
The “Green” Bay Tree”

rogerknights
June 18, 2012 1:14 pm

PS: How about “ENSO: The Forgotten Forcing”?
That gets an important “keyword” / search term (ENSO) into the title, which will help it pop up on Amazon when readers do searches.

June 18, 2012 1:20 pm

Hi Bob Tisdale;
Your work is admirable. The new book is about a very important topic. The ToC seem to concentrate on the Pacific. But the ocean space covers the earth over more than 2/3, and although ENSO puts, from time to time, a lot of dynamics into the atmosphere, the potential of other ocean space could be significant as well. Here is the temperature map for winter 1939/40: http://www.seaclimate.com/c/c1/images/buch/big/C1-6-TM4.png , an issue which still needs to be explained, and presumably not with a reference to El Nino (at least not alone) as Brönnimann et al (Nature*) have done it, as discussed, here: http://www.seaclimate.com/f/f.html
All best wishes for successfully finishing you book soon. It is awaited with high interest, with best regards ArndB
*) Brönnimann, S.; Luterbacher, J.; StaehelinJ., Svendby, T.M.; Hansen, H. & Svenøe, T
(2004); ‚”Extreme climate of the global troposphere and stratosphere in 1940–42 related to
El Niño”; Nature, Vol. 431, pp. 971-974.

Latitude
June 18, 2012 2:29 pm

Matt says:
June 18, 2012 at 10:15 am
From your lips to God’s ears, Bob. Unfortunately it’s still feeling very “La Nina-like” here in Denver today. 95 degrees and a vicious high pressure system, and the most destructive wild fire in state history. Please bring on the El Nino.
===============================
This mega-fire is about 2% the size of the 1890 fire, which burned from Santa Fe well up into Colorado along the Sangre de Cristo Mountains.
http://stevengoddard.wordpress.com/2012/06/17/todays-fire-update/

Pat of Charleston
June 18, 2012 2:42 pm

Bob Tisdale,
Please do not call your Illustrations cartoons. Cartoons are humorous and can be dismissed.. Please call them annotated illustrations or some other name such as annotated illustrations (cartoons).

Editor
June 18, 2012 3:27 pm

Pat of Charleston: Thanks for that thought on the word cartoons. I’ve just changed it in the text.

Brian H
June 18, 2012 4:30 pm

Differential impacts of La Nina and El Nino on population and agricultural centers. Basis for projecting “cost cycles” and hyping of regional effects as if they were global.

1 2 3