By Robert Bradley Jr. — June 3, 2022
“I suspect fossil fuel leaders were surprised and amazed that their frankly evil plan worked beyond their wildest dreams…. This is NOT to let the fossil fuel leaders off the hook. Far from it, they should be in prison (not climate activists!).” (- P. Kalmus, below)
The climate nuts hurt their cause as much or more than they help it. And their own words doom them to ridicule and irrelevance.
Enter Peter Kalmus, a climate scientist making a living at taxpayer expense. He has been a go-to voice regarding the April 6, 2022, “Scientist Rebellion” event where over 1,000 scientists in 26 countries risked arrest to “warn the world.”
Kalmus glued himself to the entrance of Los Angeles’s Chase Bank headquarters and got arrested. The story is told here:
“The scientists of the world are being ignored and it’s got to stop,” said Peter Kalmus, a California-based father of two and NASA climate scientist. “We’re going to lose everything. We’re not joking. We’re not lying and we’re not exaggerating.”
Kalmus delivered an emotional plea at the doorway of the JP Morgan Chase building in downtown Los Angeles. He was arrested with colleagues who chained themselves to the bank’s doors. Kalmus wrote an op-ed about his experience for The Guardian [excerpted below].
“If everyone could see what I see coming,” Kalmus wrote, “society would switch into climate emergency mode and end fossil fuels in just a few years.”
Problem is that Kalmus is an outlier–a politico in science clothing. Rational, sober, open-minded scientists see his dire views as iffy–and at odds with pubic policy in a rational world. He does not understand such fundamentals as energy density and intermittency–and he seems to not want to acknowledge the case for global lukewarming and benefits of CO2 emissions.
Twitter Rants
Peter Kalmus is angry and disillusioned (the world does not believe his spiel) on social media:
“When there is no policy or regulation to speak of but ‘the market’ after a while you end up with a completely fucked up society like the US.” (April 19, 2022)
“I just really wanted everyone to know that scientists around the world are so desperate for society to treat Earth breakdown as the emergency it is that they are increasingly willing to take significant risks.” April 19, 2022
“At some point you will agree with me that Earth breakdown is such an emergency that we can’t have commercial aviation until we can do so without fossil fuels. Would be pretty great if you could agree nowish so we can get on with shifting fossil fuel culture & transforming society.” April 18, 2022
“The IPCC WG3 report was SUCH a clear warning, and because of it UN Secretary General @antonioguterres has been essentially begging for the people of the world to rebel as governments insanely expand fossil fuels – and he’s quite correct. Rebellion now is the most rational choice.” April 19, 2022
“Oh fuck it’s almost Earth day again. let me know when world leaders get their heads out of their asses and do something.” April 18, 2022
“I honestly don’t care if you recycle or not, I want you to engage in or support those who in engage in climate disobedience.” April 16, 2022
“I suspect fossil fuel leaders were surprised and amazed that their frankly evil plan worked beyond their wildest dreams. The key to their unfortunate success was this failure to report the impending climate emergency, the greatest journalistic failure in history.” April 16, 2022
“This is NOT to let the fossil fuel leaders off the hook. Far from it, they should be in prison (not climate activists!).” April 16, 2022
Here are quotations from his Guardian article
I’m a climate scientist and a desperate father. How can I plead any harder? What will it take? What can my colleagues and I do to stop this catastrophe unfolding now all around us with such excruciating clarity?
…. We chose JP Morgan Chase because out of all the investment banks in the world, JP Morgan Chase funds the most new fossil fuel projects….
Even limiting heating to below 2°C, a level of heating that in my opinion could threaten civilization as we know it, would require emissions to peak before 2025….
Earth breakdown is much worse than most people realize…. It’s so surreal that I often find myself reviewing the science to make sure it’s really happening, a sort of scientific nightmare arm-pinch. Yes, it’s really happening.
Of course he is doing his glue jobs for us, not himself ….
I hate being the Cassandra. I’d rather just be with my family and do science. But I feel morally compelled to sound the alarm. By the time I switched from astrophysics into Earth science in 2012, I’d realized that facts alone were not persuading world leaders to take action….
Nothing has worked. It’s now the eleventh hour and I feel terrified for my kids, and terrified for humanity. I feel deep grief over the loss of forests and corals and diminishing biodiversity. But I’ll keep fighting as hard as I can for this Earth, no matter how bad it gets, because it can always get worse. And it will continue to get worse until we end the fossil fuel industry and the exponential quest for ever more profit at the expense of everything else.
What can the rational say to one Peter Kalmus?
- Check your deep ecology premises.
- Study the history of Malthusian/neo-Malthusian scares and ask yourself: why believe me now?
- Understand the downside of climate exaggeration.
- Study plant physiology, not only climate science, to understand the benefits of CO2. Do the math on forced energy transformation to wind, solar, batteries.
And finally, avoid hunger strikes and self-immolation. Don’t pull a David Buckel, please. And if your civil disobedience turns into a felony conviction, please leave the taxpayer dole in the best interest for us taxpayers.
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
This poor soul is suffering from a case of Cluster B personality disorder.
Cluster B personality disorder: “Cluster B personality disorders are characterized by dramatic, overly emotional or unpredictable thinking or behavior. They include antisocial personality disorder, borderline personality disorder, histrionic personality disorder and narcissistic personality disorder.”
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/personality-disorders/symptoms-causes/syc-20354463
The article’s picture of his multiple personalities is so apropos, all nuts.
“If everyone could see what I see coming,” Kalmus wrote, “society would switch into climate emergency mode and end fossil’
This is close to what was said by many climate scientists whose careers were ended by what was popularly termed the “Climate Blues” (CB) back about a dozen yrs ago. It occurred under the stresses of climategate revelations and the realization of the ‘Dreaded Pause’ which had reached 10yrs and continued year by year agonizingly for another 8yrs until interrupted by the 2015 el Niño (NOAAs Tom Karl actually ended it before this by massive T adjustments – a last act before retiring).
Ironically the real psychological term is d*nial!
https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/adult-health/in-depth/denial/art-20047926
Imagine you’ve completed 8yrs of university study for obtaining your PhD in Climate Science and and are 10yrs into your career, believing that Crisis Human Caused Global Warming from CO2 is going to wreck the planet. Suddenly the warming stops and CO2 emissions are accelerating, yet, the earth is rapidly greening (increased habitat for diversity and bumper crops) and all forecasts of climate disaster have failed miserably. Polar bears, tigers, penguins…doing well. Half your science life is over and there is no crisis. You have been totally wrongheaded. Bingo!
Stunts like chaining to the bank’s door are not serious…serious is like setting yourself on fire….now that’s serious.
When looking at the YouTube video of Kalmus glueing himself to the bank door and listening to what he is saying, I too wonder if he as some kind of personality disorder. I suppose that suggesting to him that he might have one is easier said than done even with his gloom-and-doom hysterical rants.
If he is a candidate for the psychologist’s couch, it begs the question of whether he should even be on the federal payroll.
Or even be on the streets
Kalmus is nuttier than a squirrel turd.
I’d like to upvote that statement about 40 times, next time leave him glued to the door and every one walk away.
That is exactly what I was thinking. When did scientists become emotional basket cases, worthy of a one-way trip to the insane asylum?
Have I misunderstood something or is this just a typo? I am not sure….
‘and at odds with pubic policy in a rational world’
Cute!
No, he’s autistic. Like Greta. Same obsessions, same mental processes. He’s higher-functioning (didn’t drop out of school), but then his parents didn’t take the opportunity to make a buck off his illness as Greta’s parents did.
“What can my colleagues and I do…”
Well…
“New toolkit helps tackle climate anxiety
a new resource that health educators can use to help young people cope with climate change.”
https://climateemergency.ubc.ca/2022/05/11/new-toolkit-helps-tackle-climate-anxiety/
Try that
So the real problem is social media – kids especially are exposed to climate bullshit, and are thusly influenced into believing the lies, and they become anxious and obnoxious. Before social media, there were no climate problems, ergo, social media is the problem. Same for several other contemporary, negative social issues. When a smartphone takes up 90% of your waking day, its going to have its negative impacts.
You are most likely correct but the Force has long been with us. I recall, after graduating college in 1970, becoming a Flaming Liberal. Fortunately, I went into social work, in big city projects, and reality, eventually, hit me in the face. I’m embarassed to say how long it took me to recover my sanity. My parents, life-long Blue Dog Democrats had the sense to vote for Reagan. It took me until 1992 and the Clintons to recover mine and see reality. Liberalism is a Mental Disorder.
KeTaz, me too. You and are are about the same age. College aged kids are idealistic and naive, and it was around our time frame, I think, that liberals recognized that, and over the next decade really began to work it. I caught on in the 80s with media claiming this crisis and that crisis twice a week. If something is a crisis, it continues, but the media had two new crises every week. Old crises don’t get attention. Media motto: “If it bleeds, it leads”. And then they hit on Climate; the perfect liberal noble cause for indoctrination.
See their flowchart (laughs): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7JMUUw6KeM0
I’ll bet he drove his car to the J.P. Morgan bank he glued himself to…
Certainly, he used fossil fuels at some point to get there. Then, he used superglue which is carbon based. And chaining yourself requires smelting iron with coal furnaces and adding carbon to make hardened steel.
Hypocrites are great for laughs, aren’t they?
And that is what we need to do to these nutjobs. Laugh at them every time we get a chance. They are all hypocrites, driving to their protests in their ICE vehicles or riding a bus or something which uses fossil fuels. Let ’em walk to everywhere they want to go. Show us they are serious about ending fossil fuel usage.
Yeah, right. Like that’ll happen.
It always amazes me that the temperature changes daily from morning to afternoon by more than 2C every day; It can change that much going between the open sunlight and shade; It changes much more than that with the seasons, Yet these ‘nuts’ are always screaming that the world will burn up if the average temperature goes up by 2C.
Their lack of appreciation of statistics is disturbing, but then they equate carbon and carbon dioxide. Their delusions trump rational cognition.
One of their main delusions is that they actually believe that RCP 8.5 is real.
Because Climate Science!
Yet these ‘nuts’ are always screaming that the world will burn up if the average temperature goes up by 2C.
_______________________________________________________________
“Average world Temperature” Dixie Lee Ray’s quote is appropriate:
“Beware of averages. The average person has one breast and one testicle.”
Are you saying that Peter Kalmus is an average climate alarmist?
HA Ha ha,
No, I’m saying that average world
temperature is a bullshit statistic.
Peter Kalmus is a bullshit scientist so he may be an average climate alarmist, right?
Exactly! Even considering the cows.
Ashley The average person has less than one breast and one testicle.” 🙂
And 1.99 legs.
2C every day?
Sheesh – you must live somewhere with incredibly mild climate.
The temp has changed about that much in the last HOUR here, with a daily change of about 10C to 15C during the summer…
Once again demonstrating the point that all climate fraudsters miss. It’s the sun stupid
And he was an astrophysicist.
Like James Hansen, The Father of Catastrophic Climate and Massive Temperature Data Adjustments.
From Wikipedia: “… received his PhD in physics in 2008.[5] His PhD work involved searching for gravitational waves …Recently, Kalmus has begun to work in the nascent field of ecological forecasting [models].”
And from NASA: “Peter came to JPL Earth Science [in 2012 according to his Linkedin account] from astrophysics, where he spent eight years designing and implementing searches for gravitational waves from supernovae, gamma-ray bursts, and magnetars as a member of the LIGO collaboration. He now [from 2020] uses remote sensing data to study biodiversity, stratocumulus clouds (which cool the Earth), and severe convective environments as a member of JPL’s Science Data Modeling and Computing Group.” [Emphasis added.]
Kalmus’ first reported JPL work concerning clouds came in late 2014. According to Wikipedia, since 2019 all reports by and about him have been exclusively related to his activism.
Nothing in his education or science work qualifies him to pontificate on the Earth’s demise. Its models, models, models all the way down with him.
Here in Alberta we cycle from -40 to +40 every year.
Yet people keep moving here
We can now add “Earth breakdown” to the list of exaggerations.
It used to be 4 degrees C then 3 then 2 then 1.5 when they realized the former threshold would not be reached. The only thing they are good at is moving the goal post. Emerging from the little ice age around 1850, one would expect and hope the world would warm. Thankfully it did. A warmer world is a better world. These people should not have a bully pulpit to spew their agenda from.
Propaganda loses its effect when the reality of energy and food inflation bites. We had better not lose this political battle.
“Earth breakdown”
ROFLMAO
“we’re not exaggerating.“
Oh yes you are!
It’s like the casino commercials that run here in Canada, where they say “we’re fun!!”
If you are fun you don’t have to say it.
Needless to say, casinos are grim places, I have rarely seen anyone having fun there.
Climate Scientology is in trouble specifically because they exaggerate minute by minute.
The fact that most of their entire program is largely nonsense means they hardly have to say anything day by day, they are still in big trouble intellectually and factually.
Pat, you must have never spent any time in a casino where a bunch of drunks have been around the craps table.
By 628 times.
He is representative of a bunch of morons who want to revolutionise the world according to some bizarre worldview of theirs – they are going off the deep end more and more often because nobody will listen to them.
Someone voted for AOC
Nancy Pelosi once said in AOC’s district you could elect a glass of water. Finally I agree with Pelosi on something. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61LhdXna8q0
A glass of water might have more intelligence…
Ok, where do we get a tow-truck for the planet? Is Magrathea back in business again yet?
““The scientists of the world are being ignored…”
Correction: the thoroughly unhinged are being ignored.
It’s a good thing they are largely being ignored. I work at a government/university institute and my coworkers are thoroughly brainwashed.
Just with regard to covid, going on almost two and a half years now, 90 plus % are pretending to work remotely and administration allows it to happen.
Since Super Glue’s plastic, you’d think they’d react to it like this:
In WWII, during the Battle of the Bulge, General McAullife, of the 101st Screaming Eagles, when receiving a demand to surrender, replied “Nuts”!. Amazing how much ahead of his time he was.
Kalmus literally sees the hand of CAGW in anything he looks at. He twits of his heartbreak due to the dead trees on his hikes on the Pacific Crest Trail 2 years apart, and blames the dry conditions on fossil fuel consumption. Extreme fixation. The medieval equivalent of someone believing they help mankind reach heavenly goals by advocating, organizing, and taking part in witch burnings….
He has too much free time on his hands. He should do something useful, like harvesting vegetables.
Doesn’t know what exponential means. Not a scientist.
I like this Peter Kalmus better as it only takes a second to realize he’s a nut.
https://www.webumenia.sk/en/autor/4684
That photo spoiled my day!
They would be at the racetrack, cleaning up on exactas and the daily doubles.
Wouldn’t it be nice if they were betting their own money and livelihoods?
For Kalmus, what’s coming are the men in white coats with a straitjacket, ready to take him away, ha-ha, to the funny farm.
Naw, Cambridge will probably hire him as the other bookend for that other paranoid nut, Peter Wadhams. BTW it appears that cockroach crawled back into to woodwork since I haven’t heard much from him lately. Could that be because of the ice extent in the Arctic?
As for gluing or attaching oneself to a public place to protest I say leave them there and let the natural course of events take place. Act like they don’t exist, let them figure out how they are going to get loose and suffer all the consequences that come from doing such a thing. If they are injured or even die there then so be it. A dose or two of that medicine and this craze would end quickly.
No, that’s unfair. We must ensure they stay well hydrated while protesting…
“We must ensure they stay well hydrated while protesting…”
Fire hose can do that !
Only after they soil themselves so that they start stinking.
Didn’t see this post prior to making mine…
Throughout time various cultures have revered crazy people as having some kind of spiritual connection or insight. It seems that such an attitude has come to us in this time.
I remember the nut job who tried to glue himself to an automated sliding door.
If he did manage to glue himself to the door, I would have so much fun, spending a few hours walking back and forth in front of the sensor.
I visualize ignoring him and grasping his shirt front as a door handle to get into the bank.
The first time their “bodily functions” act…
No, his antics are too useful. More financial support is more likely coming his way.
Per the above article, Peter Kalmus on April 18, 2022:
“At some point you will agree with me that Earth breakdown is such an emergency that . . .”
Nope, ain’t gonna happen, Pete . . . not now, not ever.
Peter, you should read the nursery story about Chicken Little (aka Henny Penny) and his/her proclamation that “The sky is falling!”. You have much to learn from it.
Nice piece about the use of fear.
https://www.rt.com/news/556146-us-elites-scared-citizens/
Scissor,
Who are you trying to fool? In today’s world, you dare claim that Russian state media (www.rt.com) offers up a “nice piece”?
Methinks you have revealed something significant about yourself for all to see.
Does it really matter who speaks a truth? No, it’s the truth that matters.
Perhaps you’re being sarcastic, Russia and all that.
Gordon get a grip. The article is by an American. Oh, and do you think this inciteful article would ever be found on cable news or WAPO?
Gary, you are absolutely correct in your use of the word “inciteful” in your post, although I am sure you meant to use the word “insightful” instead.
ROTFLMAO!
You see, I do have “a grip” on reality.
As in
There is no question that mental health is a serious issue today with suicides, violence reaching high levels. For the past couple of years, messaging around covid and government response to covid have been at least partly responsible and still people are induced to cower with fear.
As a metaphor, the author’s statement seems accurate, but it is the bulk of her op-ed with which I find agreement.
“America in 2022 more closely resembles a giant mental asylum inside a circus than a country of the brave and the free.”
That’s a description of the Radical Left. They do resemble a giant mental asylum but only repesent about 25 percent of the U.S. population. The rest of us are fairly sane.
Unfortunately, the Radical Left has the political upper hand at the moment, so it makes it seem like all of us are crazy when the Radical Left spews their venom.
His poor kids.
That was my thought. They should be taken away by the state to protect them from such insanity.
I’m sure they make Greta look balanced and sane
I don’t know; maybe they see him as we do. They live with him after all. How could one miss his insanity?
Then again, there is the Stockholm Syndrome.
C,mon, Man… The State IS the problem.
One step away from a Ted Kosinski .,being smart or a scientist doesn’t guarantee or correlate with mental health . Reminds of the story ( might even have been on This American Life ) of the scientist who destroyed his married age and alienated his kids because of his obsessive over the climate apocalypse
Pubic policy? Another golden spellcheck moment there!
Astrophysics to Climate Science. Wow, he must be a polymath.
Richard Lindzen alluded that “climate science” was the refuge of those who could not make in the hard sciences like physics. Lavish grant money and no requirement for rigour.
Left unsaid was that “climate science ” is mainly a cover cult for watermelons to insist on destroying free markets.
Kalmus: A gravity wave physicist who jumped on the money earning bandwagon of climate scaremongering.
“If everyone could see what I see coming,” Kalmus wrote, “society would switch into climate emergency mode and end fossil fuels in just a few years.”
**************
This guy hasn’t a clue about what he is suggesting here. The U.S. and global economies would collapse in the absence of fossil fuels in a few years. No one would give a damn what the climate was doing once society descends into chaos and anarchy in the face of a failing economy.
It becomes a matter of surviving the chaos.
Kalmus appears to be one of those least able to survive any economic collapse.
When a country’s economy collapses, what also collapses are the various scams that people recognize that fail to put food on tables or roofs over their heads.
wouldn’t take a few years, as soon as the spigots are turned off there is about 72 hours before the stores in cities are devoid of product. within a week there will be riots and the fall of civil society.
I think Willis had one of the best rebuttals of this nuttiness.
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2021/04/25/wheres-the-emergency/
I refer (normally rational) folks that have been duped into this “emergency” claim, to this.
I was driving Friday flicking through XM channels, was listening to another talking head on Fox 115, she read a piece from NASA or NOAA that officially co2 in may hit 421 ppm, a point not seen in 4 million years.
OMG
Then she added that the temps 4million years ago were 7C warmer, saying that we are in trouble.
Do people just not think anymore?
If co2 levels are now the same why is it 7C cooler today?
Shouldn’t it be 7 warmer if co2 controls temps?
Just no capability for logical thought
It’s hard to think logically when you’re a cult member of the first church of the boiling globe.
Let’s see, I look around me and see a large amount of life, including me, so obviously our antecedents all survived this calamitous 7C warmer period. And here they are all worried about 1.5…(of course they are really worried we will all catch on and they won’t be able to subjugate us all to their will!)
““I just really wanted everyone to know that scientists around the world are so desperate for society to treat Earth breakdown as the emergency it is that they are increasingly willing to take significant risks.” “
Real question: Have any ‘scientists’ chained or glued themselves to the private jets or yachts owned by the very wealthy/billionaires?
Or in developing countries such as China and India?
Yeah, not a mention of China or India and their increasing CO2 production, by Mr. Kalmus. Shouldn’t he be over there crying on their doorstep if he wants CO2 reduced?
A. Marxists decide the only way to defeat Capitalism is to declare its’ energy source, fossil fuels, a poison to humanity. B. To promote their plan they enlist politicians, media, and some scientists to be their useful idiots. C. The useful idiots become so involved with their quest to save humanity from extinction the Marxists (A.) leave them on their own to spread mayhem. D. We now have a self generating plan, populated by a minority of useful idiots supported by media, politicians, and scientists that feeds on itself to destroy Capitalism. The Marxists (A.) sit back and enjoy their work which results in destruction of humanity as we know it. Just another Marxist (A.) plan playing itself out like all the others in their past. This too will fail like the rest.
Is anyone surprised that this guy is nuts? He transitioned (lefties are always transitioning) from astrophysics to climate science. He is used to making shit up and believing it. See dark matter, dark energy, cosmic inflation, super symmetry, etc…
Like Michael E. Mann’s movement from physics to paleoclimatology. Lazy liars don’t do well in the physics profession.
I see where astronomers have discovered several galaxies that they think do not incorporate dark matter.
It’s always something. We stumble ahead one footstep at a time down the road to understanding.