Essay by Eric Worrall
h/t fretslider; According to The University of Exeter, having fun in Summer masks concern about “climate breakdown”, and impedes climate action.
‘Fun in the sun’ photos are a dangerous distraction from the reality of climate breakdown
Saffron O’Neill
Sat 14 May 2022 17.00 AESTThink of the images that defined our understanding of war or protest. Similar ones can tell the truth about this disaster
Open a British newspaper as a heatwave looms and you’ll likely see headlines about the unprecedented nature of the upcoming heat, the cost to lives and livelihoods, and even deaths caused by the extreme heat. But accompanying the same story you are also likely to see images of people having fun in the sun – kids splashing in city fountains, crowded beaches, blue seas, azure skies and holiday happiness.
How the media communicates about climate breakdown reflects and shapes how societies engage with the issue. Behind every picture that makes it into the news is a person mirroring and perpetuating how society thinks about climate breakdown. Images are a key part of any media communication: they are often vivid and colourful, drawing readers in and helping them to remember a story.
They also shape news production: compelling visuals help stories rise up the media agenda. Think about the image of the man blocking a line of tanks in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square, a young girl fleeing her village after being burned by napalm in the Vietnam war, smoke billowing from the twin towers. These images become part of our collective psyche – through them we remember the power of protest, the horror of war, and the moments everything changed. Images of the climate crisis can hold the same power, something the Guardian recognised in its sector-leading 2019 editorial decision to rethink the images accompanying climate stories.
Our new research, led by the University of Exeter, highlights a distinct problem with how the European media visually represents news of extreme heat. We examined media coverage from the UK, the Netherlands, France and Germany during the summer of 2019. Importantly, we only included news stories that mentioned both the keywords “heatwave” and “climate change”, reasoning that if we were to see responsible and accurate reporting of heatwave risks, it would be in coverage that at least alluded to the increasing risk of heatwaves becoming longer, more frequent and more intense under climate breakdown.
…
Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/may/14/sun-photos-climate-breakdown
My first thought was someone should check for fungus growing in the University of Exeter water supply.
But seriously, imagine what a locked down medieval dystopia we would all endure if these killjoys were fully in charge. It would be like living in the Middle Ages, sackcloth and ashes, restrictions on dancing and partying, because having fun leads to more travel and elevated respiration, an unnecessary increase in CO2 emissions, a total mockery of our burden of climate sin.
Of course the climate elite would still enjoy all the perks of an industrial civilisation, like their private jets. Their holy climate mission would justify any imaginable carbon extravagance.
I lived in Britain for over a decade. Britain is a lovely place, but every year they get maybe a week, maybe two weeks if they are lucky, when the temperature touches the high 80s (30C+) and they can really enjoy their lakes and beaches. Yet they have one of the most fearful climate worrier populations on the planet.
Imagine the climate breakdown calamity if Brits who worry about climate change had to endure THREE weeks of Summer.
So I guess this means The Beach Boys are out. Got it.
For ‘responsible & accurate reporting’ read ‘alarmist’.
They cooperate with Greenpeace. So much for scientific integrity and independance. Universities are increasingly politicized and activistic at the exepnse of scientific content.
Headlines about the unprecedented heat, livelihoods lost, and deaths from extreme heat are Fake News. The images of people having fun in the sun, kids splashing in fountains, crowded beaches, blue seas, clear skies and holiday happiness are People’s Real News.
I think the problem is the beach frivolity shows most people don’t really think there is a problem
“How the media communicates about climate breakdown” is totally irrelevant.
Why the media communicates about climate breakdown is the real issue.
What in hell is climate breakdown? Did the climate blow a tire? Has it gone off its medication? (The authors certainly seem to have done so.) As far as any sane, rational persons can perceive the climate is continuing to do its thing just as it always has. It changes from time to time in ways we still can’t predict and seems totally uninterested and unresponsive to anything humans do with our life-giving CO2 emissions.
Let’s head to the beach and have some fun.
The Britsh weather forecasters are very careful to say that lower than average temperatures are just ‘lower then average’, but higher than average temperatures are always flagged as ‘higher than where they should be this time of year’.
When all you’ve got is a computer programmed to find heat and lots of it the met office are fairly hamstrung for anything like logic and thinking.
I explained British weather to a visiting Finnish girl when she said she felt colder in the UK than she did at home though the temperature was higher.
In Great Britain the weather is either warm and damp or cold and damp making it feel much warmer or colder than it is and if it’s not warm and damp or cold and damp it’s just DAMP.
James Bull