Do Greens Mainly Win Support in Urban Jungles?

Maiwar, Brisbane. Source Electoral Commission Queensland (2017).

Guest essay by Eric Worrall

The recent State election in Queensland, Australia has thrown up some interesting voting patterns.

Votes for green leaning left wing candidates seem to have mostly concentrated in high density urban areas. The electorate of Maiwar in Brisbane, the one seat the Green Party seems likely to win, is one of the most heavily urbanised regions in Queensland.

Brisbane has beautiful green spaces, such as a lovely strip of parkland along stretches of the Brisbane River – but these green spaces are mostly carefully manicured and well tended gardens.

Outside these managed gardens, the natural environment in Queensland can be brutal. The lush coastal bushland especially is dripping with threats to human health, ranging from deadly paralysis ticks, to snakes ranging from the relatively harmless green tree snakes to deadly browns and taipans. If you go more than a few hundred miles north of the Capital, there’s a real chance of meeting a crocodile, vicious, highly intelligent ambush apex predators which usually kill by dragging their prey underwater and holding them until they drown. In Australia crocodiles can grow up to 6m (18ft), more than big enough to kill a human.

And of course there are a range of lesser pests like vicious biting horse flies and vast clouds of mosquitoes which occasionally transmit debilitating chronic diseases such as Ross River Fever.

Away from the carefully manicured town gardens, the Queensland bush is not your friend – its a vicious fast growing source of sometimes life threatening pests, which has to be fought on a regular basis to stop it overrunning parts of your yard or farm which you care about.

Support for the climate skeptic One Nation Party was stronger away from manicured urban areas. Though One Nation may not win any seats, they won a substantial share of the vote in many electorates, over 30% in some areas.

Amongst other things, One Nation campaigned on a platform of liberating farmers from onerous restrictions imposed by city based greens. People who have daily contact with the true face of the tropical Queensland bush almost universally rejected green party candidates.

My question – are green supporters mostly people who have an utterly romanticised view of nature? People who rarely come into contact with the real thing?

Does this observation match your experience in your state or country?

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

175 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anto
November 27, 2017 10:37 pm

It’s always amazed how Greens don’t live in the environment, and those who do live in the environment don’t vote Green.

Bruce
November 28, 2017 12:07 am

Who’s ranting? I’m ecstatic! The One Nation nutters have managed to depress the LNP vote so much so that they’re on track to lose 8 to 9 seats. That really is something for an opposition party and really the worst possible outcome for the LNP. At least if One Nation got one seat the public would see what a useless bunch of nutjobs they are. This way their mind boggling incompetence will at least not be on show until the next election. Personally I can’t wait until Labour fulfills their progressive agenda next term with a majority in their own right!

Bob in Castlemaine
Reply to  Bruce
November 28, 2017 12:39 am

“Labour (sic) fulfills (sic) their progressive agenda next term with a majority in their own right!”
I presume Bruce you refer to that progressive, socialist agenda we now see being imposed in Nicaragua?

Bruce
Reply to  Bob in Castlemaine
November 28, 2017 12:58 am

The wonderful thing about Australia is you can spell it labor or labour and fulfil or fulfill and nobody gives a toss.

And yes, I was obviously referring to Nicaragua on a thread about Australian politics.

Resourceguy
November 28, 2017 7:13 am

Concrete jungles to be precise and they are about as well grounded to reality as the fictional characters in the capitol of the Hunger Games story.

Scottish Sceptic
November 28, 2017 9:30 am

It is certainly true in Scotland where the only real support for greens comes from the very middle of Glasgow and Edinburgh. In other words, those most isolated from the appalling affects of the bird-mincers and social isolation caused by rising transport costs imposed on motorists by greens who profit out of subsided city transport.

Sorry … I forgot … there is a significant group of country dwellers who do vote Green … these are the retirees from Universities and other public sector jobs who then travel hundreds of miles into the wilderness, spend a fortune of money gained from preaching to everyone else about conserving energy … to build expensive and therefore highly energy consumptive houses (for the building materials) … from where they bombard the internet with green propaganda telling everyone else to stop consumption.

Joel Snider
November 28, 2017 12:14 pm

Progressive enclaves with little actual exposure to wildlife and nature?
Writes itself from there.