Low temperature records overwhelm highs in the USA this past week – where's the media to tell us how this should be viewed?

If this had been summer, and the numbers reversed, you’d see Seth Borenstein writing articles for AP telling us this is ‘what global warming cooling looks like’.

Maybe Bill McKibben will chime in about “melted frozen street lamps“.

Here’s the lows plotted on the US map:

Many of the records in the Dakotas were in the teens. Here’s the total numbers: 

Total Records: 2079
Rainfall: 402
Snowfall: 74
High Temperatures: 138
Low Temperatures: 386
Lowest Max Temperatures: 768
Highest Min Temperatures: 311

Total number of high temperature type records: 138+311= 449

Total number of low temperature type records: 386+768= 1154

Source: NOAA data via HW Records Center here

Here’s all of the temperature records for the past week plotted on the map:

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

60 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nerd
October 8, 2012 4:35 pm

I had to wear winter jacket this morning in central Texas to take my dog out for a walk this morning. I was surprised to see that my old town nearby Dallas hitting in the mid 30s this morning!

David L
October 8, 2012 4:45 pm

Let me see: 1) this was predicted by warming models 2) this is weather not climate 3) this is regional not global 4) look over there; polar bears are dying and Greenland is melting

pat
October 8, 2012 5:02 pm

they’re shocked in texas. watch the 3-min+ weather report video:
8 Oct: CBS Local: North Texas Shocked By Early Cold Spell
Overnight temperatures, Sunday night into Monday morning, dropped to the 40s and even 30s in some northern cities. Readings throughout Dallas were around 45 degrees. Even those who managed to tough out the cooler weather this past weekend started turning on their car heaters for the first time this season, once they stepped outside on Monday morning.
A Frost Advisory was put into effect, with temperatures sitting anywhere between 33 degrees and 42 degrees, depending on where in DFW you want to look. The average first frost for the Metroplex should be around November 22, so any October day this cold certainly comes as a shock…
Chilly weather is gripping most of the country…
http://dfw.cbslocal.com/2012/10/08/north-texas-shocked-by-early-cold-spell/

clipe
October 8, 2012 5:03 pm

The stupidity of Peter Gorrie on full display.
Prentice is apparently an Investigator buff, and reviewed a book about its unsuccessful voyage last winter. Had the ocean remained frozen, the ship would continue to rest unseen, 11 metres below the surface.
Climate change will unseal many other Arctic treasures over the next few years. Most important — less romantic but incomparably more lucrative than an old boat — are oil and gas deposits.

http://www.thestar.com/news/insight/article/843898–gorrie-arctic-discovery-confirms-impact-of-global-warming
I emailed Peter asking how “an old boat” got to where it did before “global warming”.
No reply.

Louis
October 8, 2012 5:11 pm

The media simply follow the talking points given to them. When temperatures are low, it is weather that can safely be ignored. When temperatures are high, it is climate and time to shout gloom and doom from the headlines.

John F. Hultquist
October 8, 2012 5:16 pm

Lot of hot air on the left coasts!

LazyTeenager
October 8, 2012 5:17 pm

David L on October 8, 2012 at 4:45 pm
Let me see: 1) this was predicted by warming models 2) this is weather not climate 3) this is regional not global 4) look over there; polar bears are dying and Greenland is melting
——–
Well your learning and your marks are getting better.
1. Correct. Climate models predict short term variability that is larger than the long term trend.
2. Correct. 1 week of temperature extremes proves neither long term cooling or warming.
3. Correct. Regional trends are only weakly affected by global trends.
4. Wrong. Polar bears is a future prediction not a current situation.
4. Correct . Greenland is melting.
4. Wrong. Look over there are the drought in the USA and hope its going to end soon.

October 8, 2012 5:21 pm

Warmer summers and colder winters is a world-wide pattern that started around 2000 and appears to be strengthening. As I have just commented in the Bob Tisdale thread, it shows up in the SSTs and troposphere temperatures, and arguably the Arctic and Antarctic sea ice summer versus winter extents, and NH winter versus spring snowfall as well.
Historical records show a similar pattern in the Little Ice Age.

Adam
October 8, 2012 5:29 pm

David, how about you do some actual research re. polar bear populations, particularly in the Canadian North. They sure as hell aren’t in decline.

Merovign
October 8, 2012 5:39 pm

Weather is not climate.
Unless it’s hot.

Eric
October 8, 2012 5:45 pm

Re Adam:
I think David was being sarcastic, though no /sarc

noaaprogrammer
October 8, 2012 5:56 pm

In southeastern Washington State, elevation 800 ft., I planted 100 tomatoe plants in May. I only harvested 3 dozen ripe tomatoes before the frost hit last week. Only the early ripening varieties made it to fruition before the frost struck.

Frank K.
October 8, 2012 6:24 pm

Remember kids – EVERYTHING is predicted by global warming! Too hot? Global warming! Too cold? Global warming! No change? Global warming! See? That wasn’t so hard. Now – PAY your global warming tax so the hard working NASA GISS scientists can get their double digit salary increases! And stop yapping about $6/gallon gas – and skyrocketing energy prices. Join the global warming mania! Save the polar bear cubs! 350ppm CO2 or bust!!
Thank you,
your trusted MSM
/sarc

October 8, 2012 6:35 pm

Baby its getting cold outside!! OH YEAH!!

October 8, 2012 6:43 pm

Welcome relief for me. After enduring weeks of 100+ temperatures, today I finally turned on some heat. Tomorrow it will have to stay on but by next week, the air conditioning will have to be on during the day here. Not unusual for North Carolina. The day I was born, there was a light snow. 3 days later it was unusually warm with a high almost at 70. A few days later it snowed again. This was in 1978. The cold rarely stays entrenched here.

Korwyn
October 8, 2012 6:51 pm

@noaaprogrammer Over here in southwestern Washington State we had our first frost about two weeks ago. Earliest I remember in 20 years. This last week has been frozen every day in the morning. Saturday it was 31 F at 0830, by 1130 it was 65, hit 77 about 1530, and by 1800 it was 48. Been like that for a while. It’s been the coldest and driest October I ever remember. I was in grade school in the 70’s, so I remember the “Coming Ice Age” and the local weather subjectively seems to be trending back. My wife is a few years senior to me, and she says the same thing.

October 8, 2012 7:00 pm

It’s great having the Lazy Teen with us to demonstrate Warmist thought processes and techniques like….
First rule of Warmism.
1. Never ever ever answer the actual question asked, or address the original issue.
The Headline for this post was very straight forward namely; ‘Where is the media coverage of the fact that multiple low temperature RECORDS have been broken across the USA?’
Come on then Lazy, you seem to be so erudite about so much…where IS that media coverage?

Matt
October 8, 2012 7:18 pm

The MSM is telling us how this should be viewed. The are telling us it should be ignored.
They are wrong but that’s a different discussion.

tgmccoy
October 8, 2012 7:38 pm

Warmish days cold nights in my part of NE Oregon still fire season, Hunting season was a disaster. I have seen it like this but not since 70’s . Just as I’m trying to get back into the Aerial
firefighting business… A dry weak El Nino will not help

DR
October 8, 2012 7:39 pm

I posted at Grist the other day, but upon returning it had disappeared.
http://grist.org/climate-energy/does-early-snow-disprove-global-warming/

October 8, 2012 8:11 pm

I’m just waiting for some adventurous reporter to come up with a provocative article entitled, “Global Warming Causing Global Cooling”….
Oh, my… You say the intrepid UK Guardian did that last year?… Really?.. Hmmm…OK…Sorry… Never mind…

J Williams
October 8, 2012 8:20 pm

This website (below) is really useful for seeing how record lows and highs stack up. The site allows you to search for specific dates and states. Though we absolutely are experiencing a cold snap throughout much of the U.S., the year-to-date totals show that highs are outpacing lows by a considerable margin.
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/extremes/records/

October 8, 2012 8:34 pm

I was waiting for someone to say, all extreme or abnormal events are caused by man made global climate change. No matter what happens, it’s caused by man and we must stop it or it will get really hot or really cold.

pat
October 8, 2012 8:50 pm

what on earth is this about?
9 Oct: Climate Spectator: Andrew Freedman: How temp talk could doom climate treaty
At the much-heralded climate summit in Copenhagen in 2009, world leaders agreed to limit manmade global warming to less than two degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels…
According to a new study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, however, this seeming inconsistency is not just unsurprising: it was inevitable. By focusing on the two degree goal, negotiators inadvertently guaranteed their efforts would fail, because there’s no hard evidence that any specific temperature target marks a dangerous threshold, with clear consequences for crossing it (instead, there is plenty of evidence that more and faster warming entails greater risks of major consequences, such as the collapse of the polar ice sheets).
This uncertainty, the study argues, provides an incentive for countries to be free-loaders, jumping on board with the agreement without making potentially costly emissions reductions.
The main message, therefore, is that countries should not rely so much on the notion of a climate change ‘red line’, beyond which catastrophe could occur, as the basis for making emissions reduction commitments…
The study is based on results from a simulation game played by 400 students, who played the role of negotiators at a climate summit. Scott Barrett, a professor at Columbia University’s Earth Institute and the lead author of the study, said that in practically every simulation, despite having a temperature target to shoot for, the players in the game committed to emissions limits that allowed the amount of planet warming greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to soar to what would almost certainly be “catastrophic” levels.
The problem, Barrett said, is that unless uncertainty about the threshold can be reduced to zero, individual countries have an incentive to do less than what would be required to avoid exceeding the threshold. In reality, this uncertainty can never be reduced to zero, Barrett said, because of the inherent scientific unknowns about what causes abrupt and catastrophic climate change.
If uncertainty could be reduced to zero, though, climate negotiations would be transformed from a classic ‘prisoner’s dilemma’, in which countries have a perverse incentive to do less than what is required in order to solve a shared problem, and into a coordination game, in which countries would work with one another to ensure they are making sufficient commitments to meet a collective goal…
“The purpose of all this research is to understand first of all why things have gone wrong,” he said. “You need a proper diagnosis of the illness before you order treatment.”
Barrett said negotiators should seek ways around the ‘prisoner’s dilemma’, perhaps by designing a series of smaller agreements that target individual greenhouse gases, rather than trying to craft an all-encompassing treaty that sets emissions reduction goals for entire economies…
http://www.climatespectator.com.au/commentary/how-temp-talk-could-doom-climate-treaty

October 8, 2012 8:59 pm

Where was the media at the BEGINNING of the week discussing all those record highs? A quick Google search suggests that local media covered both events as it pertained to the local area, but there was little national coverage of either set of weather extremes. Let’s face it, Anthony, a couple days of warm or cool weather in sparsely populated parts of the country just doesn’t make national news.
Now, compare this to last March. In one week, over 3000 record high temperatures were set across the US, and over 7500 record high’s for the month. The article you dramatically link to above discusses 3125 record highs in June. If the record lows in October continue at the same pace for the rest of the month, we STILL would still only set about 1/2 as many record lows as the record highs set in June (and about 1/4 as many as March).
So Anthony, to compare this to last summer or spring, THE RECORDS WOULD HAVE TO CONTINUE AT TWICE THIS PACE FOR THE REST OF THE MONTH! Then the numbers would be reversed. If the records do indeed continue at this pace for the rest of the month, at that point I would expect to see the media cover this as national news. As it is, a couple days of record cold is barely local news.

1 2 3