@CNN beclowns itself over Siberian craters supposedly caused by ‘climate change’

From the “There was a network who had a dog of a story, and Pingo was it’s name-o” department.

The phrase “never let a potential climate crisis story go to waste” must be in CNN’s news handbook because this headline has absolutely nothing to to with global warming aka climate change.

The story at CNN titled Massive mystery holes appear in Siberian tundra — and could be linked to climate change is a red herring of the smelliest kind, because if the writer Katie Hunt had bothered to do even the simplest of web searches, she would have learned that this crater, peculiar to that part of Siberia, is called a Pingo. It has been known to western academics since 1825, ruling out the paranoia of “climate change” in recent decades as the cause.

In fact, all Katie had to do was look on Wikipedia for the answer:

Pingos are intrapermafrost ice-cored hills, ranging in height from 3 to 70 m (10 to 230 ft) and 30 to 1,000 m (98 to 3,281 ft) in diameter. They are typically conical in shape and grow and persist only in permafrost environments, such as the Arctic and subarctic. A pingo is a periglacial landform, which is defined as a non-glacial landform or process linked to colder climates. It is estimated that there are more than 11,000 pingos on Earth. The Tuktoyaktuk peninsula area has the greatest concentration of pingos in the world with a total of 1,350 pingos.

In 1825, John Franklin made the earliest description of a pingo when he climbed a small pingo on Ellice Island in the Mackenzie Delta. However, it was in 1938 that the term pingo was first borrowed from the Inuvialuit by the Arctic botanist Alf Erling Porsild in his paper on Earth mounds of the western Arctic coast of Canada and Alaska. Porsild Pingo in Tuktoyaktuk is named in his honour. The term pingos, which in Inuvialuktun means conical hill, has now been accepted as a scientific term in English-language literature.

1825? That’s well before the the Industrial Revolution, said to really begin to affect the planet in 1850, which is blamed as the primary cause of “global warming”, according to NASA:

Global warming is the long-term heating of Earth’s climate system observed since the pre-industrial period (between 1850 and 1900) due to human activities, primarily fossil fuel burning, which increases heat-trapping greenhouse gas levels in Earth’s atmosphere. 

Basically, a Pingo is a plug of ice that can form due to poor drainage, pushing up a small hill as the ice expands, and when the condition of the soil changes, the ice melts, and the soil around it collapses, leaving a crater.

Diagram showing how closed system (hydrostatic) pingos are formed. Figure Is adapted from E. Farrell. https://www.britannica.com/science/open-system-pingo Creative Commons free license from Wikipedia

This isn’t rocket science; it definitely isn’t climate science.

As I have previously reported on Climate Realism, this part of Siberia above the Arctic Circle is a place of extremes due to it’s location where it gets 24 hour a day summer sunlight, and temperatures as high as 100°F a result, and 24 hour a day darkness during winter, resulting in weeks of sub-zero temperatures.  I reported that 100°F plus temperatures have been observed in Siberia over 100 years ago, because it is normal for that location.

Climate alarmist media like CNN would like you to believe this crater is caused by the fossil fuels putting more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. But, history tells us these Pingos go back centuries, long before the left started to blame your SUV for wrecking the planet. I told you about it on WUWT back in 2014.

One of the researchers says so himself deep in the article, but most people only read the headline, and the CNN headline fingers climate change:

He spoke to a reindeer herder who witnessed a massive explosion of a mound on a river channel in the Yamal Peninsula in 2017.“Every morning she was going to this small frost mound in the river because it was the highest place and she was looking where her reindeer were, and this morning when the explosion happened she came again and she started to feel something in her legs and she was afraid of it and she ran.”

“When she was in the distance — 200 or 300 meters there was an explosion. She could have been killed,” he said. Other craters have formed less than 3 kilometers from railways and an oil pipeline, he added.

Bogoyavlensky isn’t convinced that the primary cause of these craters is warming temperatures linked to climate change. Villages and herding communities he has spoken to have told him that older generations have shared stories of explosions creating craters in the tundra. 

Gosh, older generations knew about it, and history records the phenomenon way back in 1825, well before “global warming” aka “climate change” was ever an issue.

If only CNN could learn to use a search engine like Google, and maybe visit Wikipedia or WUWT, they could actually call themselves journalists.

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
5 2 votes
Article Rating
95 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
griff
September 6, 2020 1:35 pm

But the point surely is they now see pingos where no pingos were before… because the permafrost didn’t melt.

(and where’s the story about record Siberian fires?)

John F Hultquist
Reply to  griff
September 6, 2020 2:27 pm

A fellow using a back-hoe — about 1/2 mile from us — hit power lines this morning and started a fire, so there was a lot of local action for a few hours.
30 minutes ago, a sheriff’s deputy assured me it was under control.
The Siberian fires have been ongoing, see
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Siberia_wildfires

. . . That’s 2019, so on to older stuff.
Now back to 2018: Smoke from Siberian Fires Reaches Canada

Then there is this one — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinchaga_fire
. . . the single largest recorded fire in North American history
I remember this one. It made day into night in Western Pennsylvania, although the fire was in Northern Alberta.

fred250
Reply to  griff
September 6, 2020 3:00 pm

After the COLDEST period in 10,000 years… ie the Little Ice Age

Be GLAD of the slight warming.

Stop DENYING climate changes, griff.

John F Hultquist
September 6, 2020 1:58 pm

Any “earth science” text book, say in a geography or geology for the past 75 years, included a few paragraphs and a photo of pingos. The idea is that a frozen chunk of H2O will have free flowing water migrate toward the frozen. A key concept of science is that water is a very strange substance live science link here; and you can search-up many others.
The melting of, I recall, but not the explosions. The “bursting” of pipes is well known.

Bill Rocks
September 6, 2020 2:05 pm

Pingo.
Geology 101 in the year 1968.
Rank amateur CNN.

M__ S__
September 6, 2020 3:01 pm

I don’t think CNN cares if they get the facts wrong.

The objective was to blame a strange image on a favorite “news” narrative, and they did it. The vast majority of people simply accepted what they said and moved on. They won’t bother to check, and CNN editors know that—mission accomplished.

JCalvertN(UK)
September 6, 2020 3:47 pm

An excellent paper about those holes(which CNN clearly didn’t read) is here https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-31858-9 “Cryovolcanism on the Earth: Origin of a Spectacular Crater in the Yamal Peninsula (Russia)”
They present evidence, from shadows on satellite or aerial photos, that prior to its bursting, this pingo-like structure stuck up some considerable height. It then burst like a giant ‘zit’.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-31858-9/figures/1

John F Hultquist
Reply to  JCalvertN(UK)
September 6, 2020 8:40 pm
JCalvertN(UK)
Reply to  John F Hultquist
September 7, 2020 4:38 pm

That article seems to be a completely different take on the matter. If I’m reading it correctly, the Nature paper seems to be suggesting that the gas was largely CO2.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-31858-9/figures/2
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-31858-9/figures/3

Editor
September 6, 2020 3:48 pm

Another way for pingoes to form is hydraulic pressure. Water at a slightly higher elevation, flows downhill, until it is blocked by ice or a change in soil. The water would flow UNDER the permafrost to the blockage.

Pressure would build and cause the hill to form. In some cases, it appears there is an explosion, with soil thrown out in a crater. Here, the pressure has built past the failure point of the soil and the permafrost.

Even modest changes in elevation cause large forces. A water source only 10 feet above the pingo, and forming a hill a little over 100 feet wide, would have nearly 6,000,000 pounds of force under it.

Counter intuitively, the hill can also grow higher than 10 feet. As the water has more exposure to surface temps, it freezes. This newly frozen water then becomes part of the hydraulic “cylinder”, with water pressure pushing upward. The ice can be self supporting, so exerts no hydrostatic pressure against the hydraulic pressure.

This can happen independent of climate change, and thinning or thickening of the permafrost. In fact, thinning permafrost can make formation of pingoes harder to happen. Without thick enough permafrost, the water may simply leak to surface as a spring. The ice needs to be thick enough to not break when subject to hydraulic pressure, and instead simply deforms, instead of breaking. Of course, if the permafrost is too thick, it will resist deformation, too.

Hans Erren
September 6, 2020 9:46 pm

This summer I visited the Uddelermeer pingo in The Netherlands, I never knew that its origin had also an explosive component.

Zane
September 6, 2020 9:48 pm

Pingo? Bingo!

September 7, 2020 1:23 am

This is something new, not pingos. I don’t like CNN either but in popular scientific matters (where this article belongs to) it reports what actual science tells us. Scientists of course know these are not pingos. These are explosive outbursts originating from depth (and clearly throwing matter outside, sometimes far away) not implosions like pingos and they are easily distinguishable from (the anyway well known) pingos. Scientists have a good working hypothesis (gaseous methane buildup due to AGW) and they are actively researching the topic. The matter is hard, this phenomenon is new, and they currently can only research the results of accidentally discovered older outbursts, and there are still a rather low number of that.

http://www.geologyinmotion.com/2014/08/methane-outbursts-due-to-melting.html

Thomho
September 7, 2020 1:34 am

While I agree with the WUWT criticisms of the article-and thanks for the explanation of Pingoes – may I point out what has been overlooked is the writer’s use of “could be linked to Climate change” emphasis on “could”

I dont know how US newspapers write but believe me down here in OZ the MSM could not write an article if the phrase ” this could be ” was banned
Reportage of facts has gone out the window Opinion masked as reporting is all the go with “could ” and “May be” the get out weasel words prefacing most articles these days in the written media

dennisambler
September 7, 2020 4:33 am

They might discover Maars next…

https://news.uaf.edu/volcanoes-permafrost-earthquakes-shape-alaska/

“What’s a maar? It looks a lot like a lake, it’s circular and it exists because of colossal explosions that happened when molten rock met water. Jim Beget has visited the world’s largest set of maars, located on the northern horn of the Seward Peninsula east of Shishmaref.

Landforms shaped in dramatic fashion intrigue Beget, retired from the Alaska Volcano Observatory and University of Alaska Fairbanks Department of Geosciences. He has visited the Devil Mountain Lakes maar, the largest one on Earth.”

Fran
September 7, 2020 1:37 pm

I read pingo as pinga – a great dance

Rich Davis
September 7, 2020 3:09 pm

Minor point, but how does a clown parade beclown itself?

ResourceGuy
September 8, 2020 6:58 am

It’s CNN photo journalism, not real journalism. The journalism profession has been under more severe threat for longer than any tundra or forests.

John Endicott
September 10, 2020 5:52 am

If you had ended the headline with “@CNN beclowns itself” and you’d have pretty much described everything CNN has done the past 4 years. The bigger news would be if CNN could “report” a story without beclowning itself. Sadly that’s news that’s unlikely to happen anytime soon.