The new Hollywood blacklist

It’s like reverse McCarthyism. If you don’t believe in the AGW party line espoused by other “enlightened” actors, you don’t get to work. From the article:

A deal was allegedly worked out to pay him $300,000 for the commercials and to appear at a company event. “The only points still under discussion–but not in dispute–were what kind of tea and other snacks Ben Stein would have on the set,” the complaint states. “There were no outstanding deal points.”

Stein alleges he informed the ad agency and Kyocera that he was deeply concerned about the environment but he was not certain that global warming is a man-made phenomenon. “He also told [his agent] to inform defendants that as a matter of religious belief, he believed that God, and not man, controlled the weather,” the complaint states.

Days later, Kyocera allegedly withdrew its offer and hired an economics professor at the University of Maryland to appear in the commercials and, “in an astonishingly brazen misappropriation of Ben Stein’s persona, dressed him up as Stein often appeared in commercials (bow tie, glasses, sports jacket).”

==============================================================

Taken further, I can just imagine Ed Begley Jr. and Henry Waxman on the dais asking people like Ben Stein a rephrase of the famous McCarthy question: “Are you now or have you ever been a denier?”

I know this, I’ll never buy another Kyocera product ever again.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

84 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
The Ghost Of Big Jim Cooley
January 13, 2012 4:39 am

Being as he thinks a god controls the weather, couldn’t it just be that the company were terrified he’d come out with something equally as stupid from time to time, and therefore make the company’s image look bad? Imagine you own a business and decide to use some celeb to promote your product. Then imagine that the celeb blurts out that little fairies live at the bottom of his garden. Would you want to proceed and use the celeb? No, thought not.

January 13, 2012 4:42 am

Joules Verne,
Your comparison between contract law and Anthony’s right to buy the products he likes does not apply here. The free market is based in large part on contracts. IANAL [lawyer], but if an agreement was reached and Kyocera then welched, that appears to be a tort. I’m not into predicting outcomes, but if you personally had bypassed other opportunities in order to negotiate an employment contract, and the employer that originally approached you with an offer then reneged, you might see this case differently.

TANSTAAFL
January 13, 2012 7:54 am

At least in McCarthy’s case, there actually WERE communists in the government.

Gary
January 13, 2012 8:14 am

Unless the contract was actually signed and there was no enforceable escape clause, Ben Stein shouldn’t have much of a case. Could be something binding in the verbal agreements, but that would be tough to prove. Maybe Buehler can help. If Ben can find him.

Bill Parsons
January 13, 2012 8:16 am

Hello, Hollywood! Anybody home upstairs?
Anybody… anybody…?

January 13, 2012 10:14 am

Talking about suing for past wrongs, here’s someone else who’s suing after years and years of being blackened – a far greater wrong, on a personal level, than was done to Ben Stein or even – God bless them – to Willie Soon and Sallie Baliunas.
Dr Andrew Wakefield is finally suing the British Medical Journal and a nasty piece of work called Brian Deer, a journalist who lied about Dr Wakefield wrt the MMR vaccine / autism link.
I’ve followed some of this because I myself am (just) on the autistic spectrum, so I did a lot of research to find the truth there, just as with Climate Science. There appears to be a strong link between autism and vaccination but the evidence I sifted suggests the culprit is the mercury preservative they used to use in vaccines. In fact that’s quite possibly what triggered my own Asperger Syndrome many years ago.

Andrew
Reply to  Lucy Skywalker
January 13, 2012 11:52 am

Lucy Skywalker
All great points!
“Causation always equals correlation, ‘cept when it don’t”
I think your personal anecdote shows jst how deeply you look into…personal situations…think about that for a moment….ok,
What I am getting at is this; if “the situation” directly impact your life…you are much less likely to get “snookered” by some ‘Silly Goose’ like Algore or get tricked by some quirk in ‘Nature’…if you catch my drift, lol…
I have dealt with a few “personal anecdotes” my selfs…but no…not multiple personality disorder…actual one is ADHD…and my phone just rang…(ty Ms. Smythe…grrr)…
What I am getting at…’weather’ it is the ‘whether’ or the elks, the bulls,its and ‘harem of cows…running from the wolves, or its my add or your issues. We notice things that impact our lives…like the Dino knew what killed him off right? A big impact…it took Mann millions of years to figure it out…I think…
I hope someone enjoyed reading this…as much fun as I had trying to rite it…its an AdHd thing…It takes intense focus to wright weird…its either this or scream…sometime…ok,
If you are still reading…let me ‘splain. Ms Smythe, was panicing cause the STORM of the YEAR !! is coming two Seattle…Whoops…caplock issues…2012…Snomeggedon…is about hit our region ….
http://www.king5.com/news/local/Puget-Sound-braces-for-snow-this-weekend-137274828.html
I began bracing for winter last summer…so I aint worried…I reminded her…because of being without power for two week last winter…WE are better prepared this year…One generator is in the garage…we need to get fresh gas however…but I know exactly where 2 empty red clean gas cans are…
My dad taught me to be prepared…but we never did boy scout stuff…but he showed me a really cool meteor shower in August of 1980 from 10,000 up at Camp Muir…way more stars when the air is thin…
You learn to observe tiny details all around…like the fact that right now…30 miles away from Seattle…I look outside…see sun, calm…bearly a wisp of air…I have time…before ‘Danger Jim Forman’…in his little Yellow (city)Slicker…oops snow…Yellow ‘Flaming’ Down Parka…atop Queen Anne Hill in Seattle and does play by play of all the SUV’s playing bumper cars with all the Hybrids!…I am sure you can find coverage via that link above. Oh…and just to be clear…the ‘flaming’ parka …I assume a Bad Karma might fly bye…on the Hood of some pimped out Government Motors Escalade…or something.
Accuweather says…right now…….AIR STAGNATION ADVISORY IN EFFECT UNTIL MIDNIGHT PST TONIGHT …
http://m.accuweather.com/en/us/seattle-wa/98104/weather-forecast/351409
Sure am glad I have me an Interweb so I can ask the government Watt’s happening outside…Thanks Al Gore…time to run, lunch break over…
Andrew
(have fun with this one mods, lol)

Scott Covert
January 13, 2012 11:00 am

Lucy, I think the causes of Autism are as varied as the cause of runny noses.
I have read about the mercury preservative link and it doesn’t seem “strong”.
I have three autistic children, one had the vaccines with the preservative, the other two did not. I don’t offer that as proof but it does point to a genetic link.

January 13, 2012 11:03 am

Brian H says:
January 12, 2012 at 9:39 pm
Smokey says:
January 12, 2012 at 6:44 pm
Dr. John M. Ware says:
“A phrase from the Kyocera creed: ‘the natural goodness of man.’ ”
A phrase from Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince: “Men are bad unless compelled to be good.”
Who’s right?
I think it varies.

No, it doesn’t. The discussion of man in a state of nature is as old as speech. The basis of all governments and all civilizations throughout time springs from the answer to this question. By far the most successful governments and civilizations have answered this question the same way Machiavelli did. The answer to this question explains why the Utopian ideal is unattainable.
Anyway, glad to have this brought to my attention. I have a Kyocera phone. I won’t have one on Monday.

gnomish
January 13, 2012 11:42 am

if it were a ‘dog eat dog’ world, there’d be nothing but skinny cannibal dogs.
man evolved a brain for reasoning, not big claws or teeth.
what you have is tribes.
even chimps kill other tribes of chimps.
from this evolved specialized soldiers and a monopoly on force (government) and the glorification of sacrifice (altruism)
they look just like h. sapiens and can interbreed with them but their nature is to consume only – they never produce- which means their survival depends on taking from others. but a parasite that kills its host also dies, hence laws and regulations.
if one were to get all dawkiesque, one could define various subspecies of h. sapiens according to their beliefs – enculturation (sometimes also called philosophy) can effective prevent actual interbreeding (intellectual separation can be as effective as geography).
the prosperity of one of the subspecies allowed it to host a load that has increased in population to the extent that the host is in decline.
the parasitic species had evolved a method to consume its prey without violence – a form of animal husbandry where they raise a population of their consumable suspecies which have been specially memetically modified for the purpose. the cliche used in training a novitiate is ‘all they can do is say no’ (but the fact is that the breed does not know how to say no. they do whine when they suffer, though, and that behavior will simply be bred out of the philosophy.)
heh- it’s impossible for a logical case to be made that anybody is a victim when that ‘victim’ subspecies negotiates the terms with the parasite, ain’t it? if nobody refuses and none of them actually have a real gun in their faces or some thugs on the doorstep – if they can’t show a clear and present danger – how can they call it predation? they would have to actually refuse to even find out if their fears were valid – but they don’t breed their own offspring (teach – keeping with the dawkinsy stuff). they turn over their progeny to the parasite subspecies for training and memetic modification. that’s how domesticated this subspecies is.
and so – it is very easy to make a perfectly logical case that it ain’t rape if it’s negotiated and that the whingy ‘victim’ asked for it, paid for it, got it – and that is exactly as it is and ever shall be.
data proves that both agree on this.

Jimbo
January 13, 2012 12:01 pm

Days later, Kyocera allegedly withdrew its offer and hired an economics professor…

Surprise, surprise (not).
http://www.kyocerasolar.com

KYOCERA Provides Solar Power Generating System for Palau’s Largest Solar Project
http://global.kyocera.com

gnomish
January 13, 2012 12:02 pm

there have been brief periods in human history when the population of the reasoning subspecies dominated the forum. they get the name ‘renaissance’. check the etymology. consider the implications.
these periods are maintained, usually, for but a single generation. the reason for this is because they fail to infect their progeny with the explicit philosophy that permitted their success. they lose the ability to define values objectively. they become so unhinged that the concept of refusal, which requires a minimal level of self confidence in one’s ability to reason that only grows from evidence which is only produced by rehearsal of it, is too much of an absolute to be incorporated into the memenome. the notion of an absolute is an antigen and can even bring about anaphilosophic shock.
when there are too few minds remaining in a culture that are able to explicitly define ‘good’ and ‘evil’ in a single sentence at age 4, the culture faces decline. when the prey can no longer say why he isn’t prey by nature – then he becomes that because the distinguishing characteristic of h. sapiens is that he must, by nature, define his own nature – or, better said, a man’s owner has the sole responsibility and sole ability to define the nature of the owned.
and everybody wants to belong – but not to himself…lol
that’s why i love the westboro gang – they are a lot smarter than most of the population in recognizing that things are what they are and there ain’t no shouldawouldacoulda. they provoke outrage because they cruelly taunt ‘sheep’ for being ‘sheep’ and wailing that they shouldn’t be what they are. they don’t loathe themselves and they are able to explicitly damn the self loathers who believe in and support and pay for and suffer the consequences of their self loathing – then go on to howl that they shouldn’t be what they worked so damn hard to be.
once you lose the ability to judge – you lose what made you a reasoning creature by definition.
when you fear to judge because judgement itself is a shibboleth, nature will judge you and that’s when we leave dawkins and go attend your darwin award ceremony.

Ryan
January 13, 2012 12:16 pm

I have basically no sympathy for a gentleman who thinks God controls the weather. We should also consider taking his PhD away from him.

AlexS
January 13, 2012 1:11 pm

Kyocera has every right to say no to someone that agrees or disagrees with Global Warming. It is or should be the right of every private party or person to hire or deny hire someone based on political colors. The author of this piece forgot the difference between a public institution and a private part.
It is like someone protesting that Wattsupwiththat wouldn’t let them write global warming.

David
January 13, 2012 2:01 pm

Smokey says:
January 12, 2012 at 6:44 pm
Dr. John M. Ware says:
“A phrase from the Kyocera creed: ‘the natural goodness of man.’ ”
A phrase from Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince: “Men are bad unless compelled to be good.”
Who’s right?
—————————————————————————-
The real question is who compells the compeller, or perhaps my favorite scene and quote from “Gentlemen prefer Blondes” Nobody Chaperones the chaperone, thats why I am so right for this job. http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CCkQtwIwAQ&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DdaylV6FVCiE&ei=kqgQT5fkNcakiQKRqYTtDQ&usg=AFQjCNF6kdM2cezb-tAfKhUHANNDG_ApuA&sig2=vIgJOxRV-udQAY6cXha8TA
More seriousely, (although actualy both points are very serious) humans have a good side and a bad side, and free choice, so we are both and a blend of both.

January 13, 2012 2:22 pm

Scott Covert says: January 13, 2012 at 11:00 am
Lucy, I think the causes of Autism are as varied as the cause of runny noses
.
Agreed. Certainly heredity is a big factor. And my, you have a handful. I wish you well.
But there is a factor with the vaccine: strong correlation. One way to see this is that it takes that extra straw to break the camel’s back. But my real beef here is the injustice dealt to Dr Wakefield – as well as the roadblock in the way of research down this line.

January 13, 2012 2:34 pm

Scott Covert
Meant to add, I now swear by the gf-cf diet, it pretty well returns me to “normal” plus it did well in closely-monitored tests, so long as it’s followed 100% not 99%. Naturally I want to encourage all on the spectrum with this.
Andrew
Thanks for your stream-of-consciousness input. Don’t know if gf-cf works for ADHD, it might, certainly it’s a spiritual challenge and for many AFAIK, wake-up call. All the best.

Zeke B
January 13, 2012 3:11 pm

Part of Stein’s case involves the claim that the chap Kyocera hired instead “appropriated his image”. Nothing could be further from the truth. Not only has Morici been wearing glasses, bow ties and sports jackets for years (evidence: http://www.rhsmith.umd.edu/news/stories/2008/morici-testimony.aspx) but unlike Stein, he actually IS an economics professor, as portrayed in the commercials.
Stein-0, Truth-1

Steven Kopits
January 13, 2012 3:29 pm

You’re referring to Peter Morici, Prof. of Economics at U. of Maryland. Morici testifies pretty frequently in Congress and mostly says sensible things–as does Ben Stein. Morici regulary wears a bowtie, and cuts a fairly idiosyncratic figure. I doubt his is an AGW proponent, and I would guess he’s cheaper than Stein.

Iren
January 13, 2012 4:25 pm

Kyocera has every right to say no to someone that agrees or disagrees with Global Warming. It is or should be the right of every private party or person to hire or deny hire someone based on political colors.
Do they also then have the right to copy his persona and appearance? Maybe, in the end, it had less to do with his views than the fact that they wanted to save money. Aren’t there any passing off laws in America? If they wanted to drop him for his views they should not then have copied him. Dishonest from every point of view.

Zeke B
January 13, 2012 4:32 pm

Steven Kopits: Although he has opposed measures like Kyoto for merely encouraging the relocation of “dirty” industries to developing countries (where they’d be exempt), from what I’ve read Morici seems to accept that human activity is influencing climate change.
However my point was about the spurious allegation of image appropriation. As you mentioned , does cut an idiosyncratic figure–the elements of which (bow tie, glasses, sports jacket) are identical to those Stein which seems to believe belong to him and him alone.

Zeke B
January 13, 2012 4:43 pm

Please pardon the editing errors in my previous post. I also meant to add that, while Morici has written very little on climate issues (and solely from an economic perspective), his bête noire has long been America’s trade deficit with Japan (and others). Ironic that he will now be shilling for a Japanese multinational..

grandpa boris
January 13, 2012 7:07 pm

If Stein’s image were still based on Ferris Bueller and “Win Ben Stein’s Money”, he’d still be a desirable spokesman.
Stein had discredited himself with “Expelled”, his virulent creationism, and embarrassing pollyannic nonsense he passes off as informed investment and economics commentary (see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-x01rhPtMLQ for example).
Did Kyocera chose someone else as a spokesman because Stein is too expensive or because they didn’t want him tainting their image? I hope it’s the latter.

Erinome
January 13, 2012 7:18 pm

> It’s like reverse McCarthyism.
Actually it’s like the (so-called) free market. Right? Don’t you all espouse that — that owners of capital should be free to hire who they want to, and fire who they want to, for whatever reason?
Isn’t this exactly what you all want?
REPLY: Oh please. Apparently you have a reading comprehension disorder. He WAS hired, contract worked out, deal cut. THEN he was fired when they discovered he didn’t know for sure if AGW was a problem. It isn’t any different than what happened in Hollywood. People were blacklisted from working for their beliefs and associations. – Anthony

January 13, 2012 9:06 pm

Anthony is exactly right. This is a contract dispute, not a free market issue per se. If Stein can prove Kyocera reneged on their agreement, he will win. If there is insufficient evidence, he’ll probably lose. But it seems pretty clear that Ben Stein is being blacklisted because of his views.

Jeff Alberts
January 13, 2012 9:49 pm

Will someone ask god why he kills little babies with tornadoes and hurricanes, but leaves people like Al Gore untouched?