Climategate: Statement from Norfolk Police

Jan 8, 2010

This morning I contacted Norfolk Constabulary with a view to finding out if they had yet ascertained whether the breach at the Climatic Research Unit was a leak or a hack. I have just received a response which is frankly amazing:

Norfolk Constabulary continues its investigations into criminal offences in relation to a data breach at the University of East Anglia.  During the enquiry officers have been working in liaison with the Office of the Information Commissioner and with officers from the National Domestic Extremism Team. The UEA continues to co-operate with the enquiry however major investigations of this nature are of necessity very detailed and as a consequence can take time to reach a conclusion. It would be inappropriate to comment further at this stage.

The National Domestic Extremism Team? Words fail me.

The climate data they don't want you to find — free, to your inbox.
Join readers who get 5–8 new articles daily — no algorithms, no shadow bans.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
270 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
MattN
January 8, 2010 5:16 pm

D. King (13:53:50) :
MattN (13:23:10) :
NO ONE expects the National Domestic Extremism Team….!!!!!!!
Our chief weapon is fear!
Fear and Surprise….
and ruthless efficiency….

Archonix
January 8, 2010 5:20 pm

JoePapp (16:06:13) :
I admit no crime. How am I responsible for the actions of the grandparents of people I’m not even related to? My grandfathers fought in the deserts of north africa as liberators against the germans.
You might want to look it up yourself, of course. The Katyn massacre took place in 1940, which was near the start of the war, not after it. The fact is, at that time we were in a war for our very existence. It’s easy to sit in comfort from the opposite end of the century and demand apologies and reparations and throw accusations of complicity and bad judgement (to put things lightly) but it’s important to remember that you and I were not there. We weren’t privy to the information they had. Most importantly, we are not fighting for our very lives. So, demand apologies all you like, because you won’t get them from this Brit. I do not ever apologise for things I am not responsible for and I refuse to bear responsibility for something that happened before my parents were even born.

Another Brit
January 8, 2010 5:21 pm

JoePapp (16:06:13),
I believe it was in fact mostly Cossacks. However, that was not Britain, that was politics and politicians. Yes, our politicians were to blame, but that does not include every man woman and child who were unaware of it. Almost every civilisation and country has committed crimes in its past, including the USA, but that does not mean we hold today’s citizens to account. The British people are not responsible for Climategate, just a few scientists, some are our own and but many are from other nationalities. I do not see you condemning those nationalities with the same vitriol. I regret that I find your hatred depressing, as that is what colours this debate, mindless and thoughtless hatreds that have nothing to do with science or climate. And even more sadly, such comments can only give an outside party the feeling that perhaps there are some extremists on the sceptic side of the debate.
I have no wish to enter into a slanging match about this, but as a traveller of the world, I have respect for the majority of citizens of every country. I do not blame the Germany of today for the sins of the Nazis, nor condemn todays Russians for the sins of Stalin. As a British citizen, I abhor today’s politicians, but it is my country and I am proud of it, and proud of the many times it has stood against tyranny in the past. I am sure we shall come through this one, – we tend to be slow to anger, but righteous more often than not.

PaulsNZ
January 8, 2010 5:23 pm

Get ones enemy’s enemy to reveal their fraud!. I suggest asking a different policing agency to investigate as well.! Or use of private detectives to target insiders to collapse this fraud from within!.

K2
January 8, 2010 5:32 pm

Richard Lawson (13:39:52) :
“Animal rights activists have been virtually wiped out over the last three years in the UK through a combination of highly successful infiltration and intelligence gathering by Special Branch and M15.”
.
.
Umm – I think they simply became part of the establishment, such as the head of the WWF now being the head of the MET, and Greenpeace being lined up with the oil companies, and the former head of the CRU is a – ummm – respected — ummm – “researcher”.

u.k.(us)
January 8, 2010 5:34 pm

this blog is being read by the “powers that be”, or by their minions. they know the tide is turning.
censorship doesn’t work here, and they know it.
al gore strikes again!

joe
January 8, 2010 5:40 pm

“National Domestic Extremism Team.”
I hope Anthony is not on homeland security extremists list. Are you allowed to board planes Anthony?

Jim Masterson
January 8, 2010 5:46 pm

>>
Phil M (15:44:14) :
care to revisit any of the names and derogations that have been directed at climate scientist by the denizens of this site?
the mud has been slung in both directions for quite some time. it’s a little late to play the “Holier Than Thou” card.
<<
He who mud slings last mud slings best.
Jim

jerry
January 8, 2010 5:47 pm

The reason the NDET was brought in was to give the local plods more power to investigate – including the ability to extract passwords under threat of imprisonment – and without any possible defense of self-incrimination.
The UK RIPA act, specifically section 49, exists for this purpose.
The Register has a piece on prosecutions in domestic extremism cases
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/08/11/ripa_iii_figures/
Do not for one moment be fooled into thinking the cops are out to do a balanced investigation. They have one object only – to get a prosecution. And to do that they use every possible power available to them.
They will be trying to find a whistle-blower – or less probably a hacker. The password coercion powers will be being used to gain access to encrypted files and emails of suspects.

January 8, 2010 5:54 pm

Wyndham Dix (16:32:58) :
Would that C S Lewis were alive today to write his sequel to “That Hideous Strength” and the story therein about NICE, the National Institute for Co-ordinated Experiments. More than coincidence, methinks, that one of the heroes of the book was Mr Bultitude, a bear no less. Seems to me that Lewis was remarkably prescient about IPCC, NDET, NETCU and their ilk.

You can buy that book on US Amazon here (used paperbacks are cheap):
http://www.amazon.com/That-Hideous-Strength-Space-Trilogy/dp/0743234928/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1263001840&sr=1-1
On UK Amazon here (click on “show more editions” to get very cheap used paperbacks):
http://www.amazon.co.uk/That-Hideous-Strength-C-S-Lewis/dp/0007157177/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1263001984&sr=1-1

Merrick
January 8, 2010 5:57 pm

I’m going to suggest that there’s a subtle reason this group has been brought in to perform the investigation. From Wikipedia:
“The National Extremism Tactical Co-ordination Unit (NETCU) is a British police organization funded by, and reporting to, the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO) that coordinates police action against groups in the United Kingdom it describes as extremist. As of April 2007, it was headed by Superintendent Steve Pearl.[1] ******Because the ACPO is not a public body but rather a private limited company, NETCU is exempt from freedom of information laws and other kinds of public accountability******, even though they are funded by the Home Office and deploy police officers from regional forces.”
So, no one will ever be able to know anything about the investigation that some other body doesn’t decide to “officially” accept from them.
I’m not sure if the Brits in this instance or the Democrats in reconciliation on healthcare legislation are doing a more amazing job of hiding information from the public. But it is all pretty impressive!

Glenn
January 8, 2010 6:07 pm

Jim Masterson (17:46:20) :
>>
Phil M (15:44:14) :
care to revisit any of the names and derogations that have been directed at climate scientist by the denizens of this site?
the mud has been slung in both directions for quite some time. it’s a little late to play the “Holier Than Thou” card.
<<
"He who mud slings last mud slings best."
They drew first mud. – Rambo

Editor
Reply to  Glenn
January 8, 2010 6:16 pm

Glenn
“He who mud slings last mud slings best.”
“They drew first mud. – Rambo”
Mud determines character. – Me.

January 8, 2010 6:11 pm

Another Brit (17:21:46)
Archonix (17:20:16),
JoePapp’s opinion is his own. It’s certainly not mine, and I don’t think it’s the opinion of very many here. Most Americans look upon Great Britain with fondness and respect, and I think most Brits look upon America like proud parents whose offspring has exceeded their expectations.
Personally, I don’t have hatred for the malefactors, but I do have lots of frustration at the complicit media, law enforcement, government and professional organizations that appear to be furiously working behind the scenes at damage mitigation, hoping to gloss over the CRU email scandal by not reporting it, and by appointing tame investigators who will generally whitewash the incident with a wink and a nod, and a minor slap on the wrist.
And I put the deceitful and arrogant little U.S. Napoleon, Michael Mann, at the top of the list, even over the CRU players. He is no doubt a big part of the reason – if not the entire reason – that the East Anglia emails were leaked. Mann is certainly not averse to stepping on toes and throwing his weight around, and the undeserved hero status conferred on him in his early 30’s by the IPCC, realclimate and others surely added to his swagger. I look forward to Mann meeting a new Iron Duke at his own Wellington.

Glenn
January 8, 2010 6:13 pm

joe (17:40:30) :
“National Domestic Extremism Team.”
“I hope Anthony is not on homeland security extremists list. Are you allowed to board planes Anthony?”
This may not be such a joke:
“The top of the document also defines “alternative media” as something sinister — though the term is commonly used to describe blogs and popular publications like New York’s Village Voice.”
“Alternative media” is “a term used to describe various information sources that provide a forum for interpretations of events and issues that differ radically from those presented in mass media products and outlets,” the report says.”
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2009/05/05/maverick-dhs-office-issues-glossary-domestic-extremist-groups/

January 8, 2010 6:19 pm

Jim (16:02:58) :

*****************
Barry Foster (13:34:47) :
Meanwhile, the BBC (in a panic that people may be turning off of warming) put out more BS http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/8437703.stm
****************************
“Despite the high readings, Professor Gustafsson said that so far there was no cause for alarm, and stressed that further studies were still necessary to determine the exact cause of the methane seepage.
“It is important now to understand how fast it is being released and how much is being released,” he said. ”
Translation: “I’m gonna get a boat-load of money to study this!”

The most interesting part of the entire thing is at the end. It is a common and nasty ‘trick’:

Despite the high readings, Professor Gustafsson said that so far there was no cause for alarm, and stressed that further studies were still necessary to determine the exact cause of the methane seepage.
“It is important now to understand how fast it is being released and how much is being released,” he said.
However, there is a real fear that global warming may cause Siberia’s subsea permafrost to thaw.
Some estimates put the amount of carbon trapped in shelf permafrost at 1,600 billion tonnes – roughly twice as much carbon as in the atmosphere now.
The release of this once captive carbon from destabilised ocean sediments and permafrost would have catastrophic effect on our climate and life on Earth, warn the scientists.

(my emphasis)
So he, the accurately reported author or a peer reviewed work on this, states that “so far there was no cause for alarm”. OK, good.
Then the BBC itself helpfully adds: “there is a real fear” and goes on to describe these fearsome reports as coming from “the scientists”. No mention of which scientists. The natural conclusion (and this is not accidental) is that the same scientists just quoted are “the scientists”, but this is obviously not true if you read carefully enough.
This is exactly how the MS get the message of alarmism across. In most cases there is no conspiracy, because the only purpose of most media is to sell advertising. Everything else is just a method of getting you to see the advertising, from bare-chested young ladies to climate alarmism.
Unfortunately the BBC do not have that excuse, so I have to assume it is politically motivated.

edward
January 8, 2010 6:25 pm

The Character Mudd appeared in the orignal Star Tek Series episode #106
His full name was Harcourt Fenton Mudd aka Leo Walsh.

Glenn
January 8, 2010 6:25 pm

Smokey (18:11:35) :
Another Brit (17:21:46)
Archonix (17:20:16),
“JoePapp’s opinion is his own. It’s certainly not mine, and I don’t think it’s the opinion of very many here. Most Americans look upon Great Britain with fondness and respect, and I think most Brits look upon America like proud parents whose offspring has exceeded their expectations.”
Not mine either. Apologies to the British. Papp needs to go away.

Glenn
January 8, 2010 6:28 pm

mikelorrey (18:16:38) :
Glenn
“He who mud slings last mud slings best.”
“They drew first mud. – Rambo”
“Mud determines character. – Me.”
“Here’s to mud in your eye” – Yoda

ROM
January 8, 2010 6:31 pm

Domestic extremism of all persuasions has always been a constant blight upon our civilisation for centuries.
Over the last three quarters of a century our western society has become increasingly specialised and concentrated in most of it’s essential services and as such has become ever more vulnerable to strikes against a particular part of our essential infrastructure or leadership.
Examples such as power stations and electrical sub stations, water supply systems, rail and transport infrastructure such as vital bridges and so many more essential items that the public never give a thought to in keeping our society functioning.
With modern weapons and the ability to communicate and organise very rapidly and over long distances due to the speed and efficiency of the modern communications systems, domestic terrorism even if only organised by a tiny cell of extremists, now has the capability to destroy the essential underpinnings of our society and it’s day to day functioning as well as creating many deaths and great destruction all in the name of promoting their particular brand of a twisted and warped ideology.
For those who know their history, the Black Hand society, a group of slavic extremists are blamed for the starting of world war one when they assassinated the Archduke of Austria.
The extremist anti jewish National Socialists ie; nazi’s, arose out of the ashes of the German Weimar Republic.
The murderous European based Red Brigades of the 1970’s were domestic terrorism at it’s worst.
The animal liberation movement was steadily evolving towards a more and more extremist movement where the end justified the means no matter how extreme.
And there are indications that a similar extremism will eventually emerge in the global warming alarmist camp when we already see extremists trying to shut down power stations.
Recently in the UK, global warming extremists were attempting to chain themselves to a coal elevator feeding the boilers on a major power station and by doing so, shutting down the power station.
An act that fortunately was stopped by the police just before the extremists could carry out their act.
The long term history of domestic terrorism and domestically based extremism where any means, no matter how disruptive to society or how many innocent lives are destroyed, justifies the end has a history which shows that such movements will eventually descend into full scale and possibly murderous violence against both the leadership of our society and against society as a whole.
The reaction of governments is to now create intelligence organisations whose role is to find, watch, infiltrate and neutralise such extremist groups which has led to the creation of organisations like the UK’s National Domestic Extremism Team.
No doubt there are now parallel organisations in a number of other western countries with similar roles to play against domestically based terrorism.
The real problem is not the gathering of information or the role that these organisations play in neutralising domestic terrorism but that history shows that these semi secret governmental type organisations invariably expand their tentacles into other parts of society , something that is never envisaged or foreseen by those who set the organisations up in the first place.
So the question of real significance is not the National Domestic Terrorism Team’s existence and it’s role in watching for and neutralising domestic terrorism but ;
Who and what watches the watchers?

makeluvfukwar
January 8, 2010 6:35 pm

“Understand? He WROTE it. For the infowar clowns” Animal Farm (16:36:03)
Can you say what you mean by the term ‘infowar clowns’ please because I use the website frequently as a resource.
Thanks.

DocWat
January 8, 2010 6:35 pm

US Weather Bureau Report
The Arctic ocean is warming up, icebergs are growing scarcer and in some places the seals are finding the water too hot, according to a report to the Commerce Department yesterday from Consul Ifft, at Bergen, Norway.
Reports from fishermen, seal hunters and explorers, he declared, all point to a radical change in climate conditions and hitherto
unheard-of temperatures in the Arctic zone. Exploration expeditions report that scarcely any ice has been met with as far north as
81 degrees 29 minutes. Soundings to a depth of 3,100 meters showed the gulf stream still very warm.
Great masses of ice have been replaced by moraines of earth and stones, the report continued, while at many points well known glaciers have entirely disappeared. Very few seals and no white fish are found in the eastern Arctic, while vast shoals of herring never before ventured so far north, are being encountered in the old seal fishing grounds.
(Sorry, I neglected to mention that this report was from
November 2, 1922 as reported by the AP and published in The Washington Post.)

Nigel S
January 8, 2010 6:49 pm

JoePapp (16:06:13)
The BAOR base in Bielefeld (and possibly elsewhere in Germany, I only saw them in Bielefeld) was guarded in the 1960’s by elderly Polish men in blue overcoats who had decided to remain in W. Germany after WW2 rather than return home because of the threat of persecution and possibly death. Life is complicated isn’t it. If you drive a Volkswagen thank the British army for that!

Ray
January 8, 2010 6:54 pm

john (16:50:27) :
And you accept that? Of course, there is worse… an unelected Queen!
At least here in Canada our Prime Minister still has to be elected in a riding in order to have a seat in the Chamber.

Jim Masterson
January 8, 2010 6:57 pm

>>
Glenn (18:28:19) :
“He who mud slings last mud slings best.”
“They drew first mud. – Rambo”
“Mud determines character. – Me.”
“Here’s to mud in your eye” – Yoda
<<
“Tell your parents not to muddy the water around us.
Our group had 25% fewer cavities with clean water.”
-Kingston Trio–Coplas Revisited
Jim

January 8, 2010 7:08 pm

By Paul Lewis, Rob Evans and Matthew Taylor~London Guardian
Police are gathering the personal details of thousands of activists who attend political meetings and protests, and storing their data on a network of nationwide intelligence databases.
The hidden apparatus has been constructed to monitor “domestic extremists”, the Guardian can reveal in the first of a three-day series into the policing of protests. Detailed information about the political activities of campaigners is being stored on a number of overlapping IT systems, even if they have not committed a crime.
Senior officers say domestic extremism, a term coined by police that has no legal basis, can include activists suspected of minor public order offences such as peaceful direct action and civil disobedience.
Three national police units responsible for combating domestic extremism are run by the “terrorism and allied matters” committee of the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo). In total, it receives £9m in public funding, from police forces and the Home Office, and employs a staff of 100.
An investigation by the Guardian can reveal:
• The main unit, the National Public Order Intelligence Unit (NPOIU), runs a central database which lists thousands of so-called domestic extremists. It filters intelligence supplied by police forces across England and Wales, which routinely deploy surveillance teams at protests, rallies and public meetings. The NPOIU contains detailed files on individual protesters who are searchable by name.
• Vehicles associated with protesters are being tracked via a nationwide system of automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras. One man, who has no criminal record, was stopped more than 25 times in less than three years after a “protest” marker was placed against his car after he attended a small protest against duck and pheasant shooting. ANPR “interceptor teams” are being deployed on roads leading to protests to monitor attendance.
• Police surveillance units, known as Forward Intelligence Teams (FIT) and Evidence Gatherers, record footage and take photographs of campaigners as they enter and leave openly advertised public meetings. These images are entered on force-wide databases so that police can chronicle the campaigners’ political activities. The information is added to the central NPOIU.
• Surveillance officers are provided with “spotter cards” used to identify the faces of target individuals who police believe are at risk of becoming involved in domestic extremism. Targets include high-profile activists regularly seen taking part in protests. One spotter card, produced by the Met to monitor campaigners against an arms fair, includes a mugshot of the comedian Mark Thomas.
• NPOIU works in tandem with two other little-known Acpo branches, the National Extremism Tactical Coordination Unit (Netcu), which advises thousands of companies on how to manage political campaigns, and the National Domestic Extremism Team, which pools intelligence gathered by investigations into protesters across the country.
Denis O’Connor, the chief inspector of constabulary, will next month release the findings of his national review of policing of protests. He has already signalled he anticipates wide scale change. His inspectors, who were asked to review tactics in the wake of the Metropolitan police’s controversial handling of the G20 protests, are considering a complete overhaul of the three Acpo units, which they have been told lack statutory accountability.
Acpo’s national infrastructure for dealing with domestic extremism was set up with the backing of the Home Office in an attempt to combat animal rights activists who were committing serious crimes. Senior officers concede the criminal activity associated with these groups has receded, but the units dealing with domestic extremism have expanded their remit to incorporate campaign groups across the political spectrum, including anti-war and environmental groups that have only ever engaged in peaceful direct action.
All three units divide their work into four categories of domestic extremism: animal rights campaigns; far-right groups such as the English Defence League; “extreme leftwing” protest groups, including anti-war campaigners; and “environmental extremism” such as Climate Camp and Plane Stupid campaigns.
Anton Setchell, who is in overall command of Acpo’s domestic extremism remit, said people who find themselves on the databases “should not worry at all”. But he refused to disclose how many names were on the NPOIU’s national database, claiming it was “not easy” to count. He estimated they had files on thousands of people. As well as photographs, he said FIT surveillance officers noted down what he claimed was harmless information about people’s attendance at demonstrations and this information was fed into the national database.
He said he could understand that peaceful activists objected to being monitored at open meetings when they had done nothing wrong. “What I would say where the police are doing that there would need to be the proper justifications,” he said.

1 4 5 6 7 8 11