One of the claims about “global climate change” is that it will affect the normal ranges of flora and fauna of our planet. Well, with a very cold northern hemisphere this winter, that seems to happening. A bird not seen (as a mature adult) in Massachusetts since the 1800’s , an Ivory Gull, normally an inhabitant of arctic areas, has been spotted. Here are the details from the Plymouth, MA Patriot-Ledger. – Anthony

GULL-LOVER’S TRAVELS: Birdwatchers flock to Plymouth to spot rare specimen
PLYMOUTH — Jan 28th, 2009
The temperatures were in the single digits, but not low enough to keep the gawkers away. A celebrity was in town, behind the East Bay Grille, a visitor not seen in these parts in decades, if not longer.
But these weren’t paparazzi, and this wasn’t a Hollywood star. Rather, they were avid birdwatchers – about 20 in all – braving the frigid air as they scanned the bay and the edges of the breakwater with binoculars and spotting scopes.
And they would be rewarded, catching a glimpse of a glimpse of a rare, fully mature ivory gull. A birdwatcher reported seeing one in Plymouth last week, and another was spotted at Eastern Point Lighthouse in Gloucester. From Sunday through Tuesday, the avian visitor was a regular in Plymouth, much to the delight of birdwatchers, who came from near and far in hopes of adding the extremely rare bird to their life list.
Ivory gulls normally stay well above Newfoundland, living on Arctic ice where they follow whales and polar bears to feed on the scraps and carcasses they leave behind after making a kill.

Until this year, the last report of a fully mature ivory gull in Massachusetts was in the 1800s. Three immature birds were seen in the 1940s. In 1976, another immature bird had been spotted in Rockport.
Russell Graham of Dallas is flying in Friday for a three-day visit. He’s hoping the gull will still be in town when he arrives.
“The ivory gull is one of a handful of birds that every birder dreams of seeing but almost no one has.,” he said. “This isn’t a dream that’s confined to North America. There is also an immature bird in France that is causing the same reaction there. There are a couple of places where you can go in the summer and expect to see one but they are distant and expensive – Svalbard on Spitsbergen, Norway and Pond Inlet on Baffin Island, Canada.
“I never thought I would have the chance to see one and I can’t pass up this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.”
If the gull is gone, Graham will consider a side trip to Nova Scotia, where two adult ivory gulls have been seen recently. “I’ll be keeping my fingers crossed,” he said.
John Fox of Arlington, Va., and his friend Adam D’Onofrio of Petersburg drove more than eight hours on Sunday to see the gull.
“No bird this morning,” Fox said a day later, shaking his head. “We left Virginia at three in the morning yesterday and arrived here 20 minutes too late.”
On Sunday morning, hundreds of people got to observe and photograph the gull as it fed on a chicken carcass someone put out on one of the docks in the parking lot. The bird stayed until 11 a.m., then flew across the harbor. It was not seen again for the rest of the day.
“We arrived at 11:20 and spent the rest of the afternoon in the parking lot, hoping it would return,” Fox said.
They stayed at Pilgrim Sands Motel and arrived at the parking lot early Monday morning for one more chance to see the ivory gull before returning to Virginia. Fox said it was his first time in Massachusetts. If he didn’t see the bird, he said, at least he could see Plymouth Rock before they left for home.
“That’s how it goes sometimes,” he said. “We don’t always see what we come for, but it’s nice to see some of the sights when you travel to a new area in hopes of seeing a rare bird.”
As Fox was planning his exit, a commotion caught his attention. One of the birders pointed toward the sky and said with a shout, “There it is.”
The pure white gull was flying toward the parking lot, silhouetted against a bright blue sky. Someone in the crowd announced for the record the gull had arrived at 7:45 a.m.
The bird flew in circles overhead, then landed on a snow bank in the middle of the parking lot. Cameras clicked and the birders “oohed and ahhhed” each time the ivory gull switched positions.
“Look how white it is,” someone said. “It’s got black feet, black eyes and a grayish-black beak,” said another.
The gull eyeballed the chicken carcass, still there from the day before, but it didn’t eat. Instead, it flew to the railing along the edge of the boat ramp and perched with a group of sea gulls. The photographers followed, changing positions to get the best lighting.
Fox stood with the group, talking with other birdwatchers, as the gull sat peacefully on the railing, observing all the people gathered around it. Was it worth the long drive up from Virginia?
“It sure was,” Fox said with a smile.

More anecdotal evidence of cooling:
http://blogs.woodtv.com/2009/01/29/thursday-am/
Only the 5th time in 116 years that January won’t get above 35dF in Grand Rapids, MI.
Just as my confidence is growing that AWG is complete hogwash and that our Penn-Livingston virility-starved sun spots are going to turn our planet into an ever growing Ice cube, Drudge goes and tells me that “Melbourne, Australia’s second-largest city recorded its third consecutive day of temperatures above 43 degrees Celsius (109 F) for the first time since 1855”
When I give mother nature a script, I expect her to stick with it !!!
(Woman, they’re always making you wait.)
When guesstimating effects of a volcano in the Arctic, remember that dark ash on snow/ice may add melting effects. There has been interest in what China’s dust/soot plume does on the Arctic surface. I think it’s yet another uncertainty in weather science, where some researchers have looked at the topic but not enough is yet known about the subject.
I should point out that both in the year on year and in the monthly records it is not unheard of for heat or cold (and wet or dry, but that’s a different story) to immediately follow or precede its opposite. Sometimes in extremis. Since records began. In both and opposing hemispheres 😉
(I couldn’t work out where to put the commas, so left them out. Sorry)
Birds migrate to find food. While cold and snow and ice cover may have an impact on the ability to forage for food, to show a reason for migration, you would have to correct for the cyclical nature of the prey populations vs those ot the predators.
While I agree that a cold summer would reduce forage for prey populations thus reducing their number, such as a summer seen in Alaska this year, its not clear that it was too cold to reduce prey numbers. You may just be seeing the net result of predators being too numerous for the prey.
Jim Thomas
The records still stands that 1855 was warmer and in other cities it has peaked below the temperatures recorded in 1901. Up till now I understand it has been a cool summer
tonyB
Was that Melbourne record corrected for UHI? 🙂
OT, but may be of interest – Sky & Telescope’s March edition is running this story:
Oops! Lost the link:
http://www.skyandtelescope.com/skytel/beyondthepage/38004069.html
Re: Ross’s response to Kaboom’s lament about disappearing whales and polar bears: Kaboom was being facetious.
Gull this bird may be, but when it comes to warming, he’s just not gullible.
Pierre Gosselin (06:52:07) :
“One trend I’ve noticed: MORE SCEPTICS
Reader comments at newspaper websites with stories on AGW are overwelmingly sceptical, with many scoffing at the notion of AGW.
And once the fuel bills come due, look for the AGW fantasy to be ridiculed even more.”
I’m not sure that’s true. What I DO believe is that sceptics are becoming more vocal. The true believers are unobservable. I have never actually MET a believer, so maybe we northern Englanders are naturally sceptical.
DaveE.
Oops.
That should have been unswervable. A new word I just invented lol.
DaveE.
Everybody else is having all the fun except us on the west coast. Snowstorms and freezing temperatures all across the US (east of the sierras), canada and Europe. Snowy Owls and Arctic Gulls visiting at low latitudes. People bracing up for more arctic blasts everywhere.
Everywhere except here that is. Right now in Santa Cruz it feels about 70 degrees farenheit, brilliant blue sky, with more of the same predicted straight through until the middle of next week.
Is that what I should expect through these solar minima periods? While rest of the NH gets the exciting snowstorms and neat frozen lakes, Californians gets- yawn – arm temperatures and sunny, dry weather?! Aaargh!!
Sorry for the OT. I got blocked again from Real Climate today. These guys won’t tell me the color of the sky after my Mann hockey stick posts. You won’t believe what’s unacceptable for me now.
http://noconsensus.wordpress.com/2009/01/31/blocked-again-real-climate/
Maybe. Hard to tell sometimes.
Had no idea the bird was in town…went out on my standup paddleboard today and saw the crowds looking for it. I saw it at the end of the breakwater…far from where all the watchers and their cameras were. Unfortunately I didn’t notice him until I had gotten fairly close….then he flew off…headed southwest towards Plymouth Beach.
http://www.standupzone.com/forum/index.php?topic=3070.0
Well, it’s bound to happen. The first sign of global warming is extreme temperatures, so some places will be very cold and the other very very hot.
Animal and bird movements are an interesting way of tracking temperature patterns. Often during the onset of an earthquake or a tsunami the first signs can be felt by birds and animals. You’ll also observe this during an eclipse
@John (11:59:15) :
Any thoughts on the bloomberg article below discussing the continued shrinking of the glaciers? I had hoped the process would be slowing down. Can anyone point me to any other, perhaps contradictory studies?
I wonder what those numbers are going to look like for 2008. Arctic sea ice seems to have been building strongly this winter: http://www.cbc.ca/technology/story/2008/02/15/arctic-ice.html
This NSIDC report, which is not very current, does document a flattening of ice growth for December 12-19 but curiously has not been updated to reflect changes since then. It will be interesting to see if changes for the entire winter reflect the earlier 8% average increase over 2007 lows:
http://www.nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/
The report shows that you can draw favored interpretations to any set of data. 2008 is claimed to be the second lowest arctic sea ice level on record. But if it is 8-10% above 2007, that also suggests that the pendulum may be swinging back in the other direction.
Just a hunch — but I wonder if the 2008 glacier data won’t turn out to show the same trend.
I appreciate your posting “contrarian” perspective here. We all need that.
Polar Bear Population on the Rise
A Canadian Broadcasting Corp (CBC) Jan 30, 2009 news blog reports that polar bear experts, wild life biologists, etc met in the Yukon to discuss the plight of the Polar Bear and what can be done to save them. Innuit delegates informed all that they are seeing more polar bears around than ever! Here is the link (I wish I knew how to shorten it):
http://technology.sympatico.msn.cbc.ca/News/ContentPosting?newsitemid=yukon-pbear&feedname=CBC-TECH-SCIENCE-V3&show=False&number=0&showbyline=True&subtitle=&detect=&abc=abc&date=True&paginationenabled=false
We have here a snow owl, too.
Not from up north, instead did successfully escape a private zoo in the northern part
of the State of Hesse, Germany. There was a price set on the whereabouts of that bird.
Nobody did care about that price. We all like our freedom. Owls too.
Too, I do know of Snow Owls in Belgium, Netherlands and the State of Schleswig-Holstein, Germany. Looks alike the big birdies do like that climate here, now.
Not me. It’s now the third winter in a row, where I did wear long undertrousers, sometimes. Where is Global Warming when I do need it?
That seems to be the Global Gore Effect. The energy for all his phrases/talks seem
to be extracted from the atmosphere. Hummm, shall we tell him to shut up?
Interesting Gary, here is a quote:
“CBC News
“About two dozen delegates, including field workers, biologists, wildlife management officials and Inuit representatives, have gathered at Yukon College from Friday until Sunday for a pan-northern workshop on polar bear conservation.
The workshop comes two weeks after federal Environment Minister Jim Prentice hosted 70 delegates for a national roundtable on the same subject, in the hopes of bridging a divide between scientific opinion that says polar bears are threatened and Inuit beliefs that bear populations are rising.”
The scientific opinion is at odds with the people actually on the ground. That sounds familiar.
Mike
Psi (08:02:14)
I love that first article. The headline says:
“Recent Cold Snap Helping Arctic Sea Ice, Scientists Find”
Man those scientists are really smart! I guess that’s why we pay them the big bucks. I wish I was smart enough to figure out stuff like that!!!
Mike
Isn’t that why you live in Santa Cruz? 😉 That’s what my sister tells me, anyway, and my Grandmother has loved it there for over 60 years (Capitola).
I wonder what they taste like?
Don’t look very big…..probably have to have quite a few to make a decent meal.