Thanks, Climate Skeptic, For Exposing the BBC’s Falsehoods About Extreme Weather

From ClimateREALISM

By H. Sterling Burnett

Climate Skeptic recently posted an article by Paul Homewood, who operates the website, Not a Lot of People Know That, that exposes the BBC program Panorama’s ongoing misrepresentations about climate change causing worsening extreme weather in the United Kingdom. Homewood’s take down of Panaroma’s false claims is devastating. He shows with hard data that neither floods nor wildfires have become worse or more frequent in the United Kingdom.

The story, “BBC Panorama Serves Up Justin Rowlatt’s Latest Barrel of Climate Hogwash,” examines in detail an episode of the BBC One program, Panorama, called, “Fire and Floods: Our Extreme Weather,” by BBC’s Climate Editor, Justin Rowlatt. As Paul Homewood’s analysis shows, Rowlatt uses anecdotes to claim that wildfires and floods have become worse in recent years due to climate change, in the process, ignoring real world data and historical evidence that shows each of these claims is false.

At the outset, it is interesting that after complaints by viewer’s BBC examined a recent previous post by Rowlatt and found it contained at least two serious errors or misstatements of fact. Ignoring that, BBC allowed Rowlatt to produce a new segment that contains even more easily debunkable claims concerning climate change in the U.K.

Rowlatt repeatedly confuses weather with climate, claiming specific extreme weather events, recent floods and wildfires, for example, are proof of climate change. Yet, as discussed at Climate at a Glance: Weather vs. Climate, the World Meteorological Organization defines climate as “…the average weather conditions for a particular location and over a long period of time.” Typically, 30 years of weather data is averaged to create a “normal” climate expectation for a location or region. Yet none of the recent flood and wildfire occurrences or seasons in the U.K., even those above average, were historically unique, nor were they part of a long-term trend of extreme wildfire or flood conditions.

Concerning wildfires, Rowlatt asserts that global warming is causing more and larger wildfires in England due to increasingly dry summers with little rainfall. Homewood looks at the evidence and points out that multiple lines of evidence, including hard data from NASA, the European Space Agency, and multiple peer reviewed studies show that wildfires are in decline. While wildfires have been historically common in England during dry summers, this year was far from the driest on record and summer rainfall across the U.K. has been above average 12 of the 26 years since 1996 — the relevant 30 year period. (see the graph, below)

There is no long-term trend of declining rainfall that would suggest climate change is having an impact.

Concerning floods, contrary to Rowlatt’s claims that the U.K. was beset by extreme floods, data from the U.K. Environment Agency show just the opposite, in 2025 the numbers of properties affected by flooding was extremely low, reflective of a recent long-term trend of limited flooding, with a few exceptions. (See the figure below)

“According to Rowlatt, global warming is making rainfall more intense and consequently floods worse,” Homewood writes. “Again, however, he provides no data or evidence for this sweeping allegation. Maybe because there is none.

“On the contrary, there has been a marked absence in recent years of the exceptionally heavy monthly rainfall we often used to see in the past,” summarizes Homewood after examining the data.

Nor is there a trend in worsening fall or winter precipitation, as shown in the graph below.

In the end, every specific claim of worsening weather made in the Panorama story is refuted by long-term data recorded by the U.K.’s Environment Agency. Data trumps anecdotes and unreferenced claims every time.

Will the BBC be forced by public pressure to investigate and offer corrections Rowlatt’s most recent climate falsehoods as they had to do for past reports he produced? Who knows. Regardless, with Rowlatt’s track record of putting a compelling, anecdote filled frightening narrative ahead of producing a news story based in facts, it should perhaps send him back to journalism school to learn that reporters are supposed to tell the truth based on careful research, not spin a political tale. Unfortunately for the profession of journalism, journalism schools, in the present age, may be where he learned his bad habits in the first place.

The BBC’s audience deserves better, which in this case is the entirely unalarming truth that there is no evidence at present that climate change is causing more extreme weather in the U.K.

5 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted