Guest essay by Eric Worrall
Apparently Anthropogenic CO2 is responsible for Australia’s wild weather swings between drought and flood. But “it’s not too late to forestall a dystopian future that alternates between Mad Max and Waterworld.”.
It’s not too late for Australia to forestall a dystopian future that alternates between Mad Max and Waterworld
Catastrophic fires and devastating floods are part of Australia’s harsh new climate reality. The country must do its part to lower carbon emissions
year ago I lived through the Black Summer. I had arrived in Sydney in mid-December 2019 to collaborate with Australian researchers studying the impacts of climate change on extreme weather events. Instead of studying those events, however, I ended up experiencing them.Even in the confines of my apartment in Coogee, looking out over the Pacific, I could smell the smoke from the massive bushfires blazing across New South Wales. As I flew to Canberra to participate in a special “bushfires” episode of the ABC show Q+A, I witnessed mountains ablaze with fire. One man I metduring my stay lost most of his 180-year-old family farm in the fires that ravaged south-east New South Wales near Milton.
My experiences indelibly coloured the book I was writing on the climate crisis at the time called The New Climate War.
…
Tragically, many of the same towns that were devastated by the massive bushfires a little more than a year ago found themselves under siege from these historic floods. A climate contrarian would cry foul: “You climate scientists can’t make up your mind. Is climate change making it wetter or drier?” But in fact, that’s a false choice: It’s both.
…
Australians can’t seem to catch a break. But it’s not too late to forestall a dystopian future that alternates between Mad Max and Waterworld.
…
Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/mar/24/catastrophic-fires-and-devastating-floods-are-part-of-australias-harsh-new-climate-reality
Our rather violent weather extremes seem to have left an impression on Michael Mann. But are these extreme conditions unusual? History suggests not.
…
What did early explorers have to say about fire? Here are some quotes from early explorer diaries and records.
The natives were about, burning, burning, ever burning; one would think they … lived on fire instead of water.’ Ernest Giles (1889), Australia Twice Traversed.
The natives set fire to the grass which is abundant everywhere, and at that time is quite dry… The conflagration spreads until the whole country as far as the eye can reach, is in a grand and brilliant illumination.’ Report from Port Essington, in Arnhemland.
Captain James Cook wrote that his crew ‘saw upon all the Adjacent Lands and Islands a great number of smokes — a certain sign that they are inhabited … ‘
… the very extraordinary devastation by fire which the vegetable productions had suffered throughout the whole country we had traversed – George Vancouver.
I wish it would rain and cause the grass to become green, so as to stop them burning… – Stuart (1865).
…
Read more: http://learnline.cdu.edu.au/units/env207/introduction/history.html
What about Mann’s assertion climate change is making the extremes worse? From a government website description of the Federation drought, 1895-1903;
…
In 1892 Australia had 106 million sheep, two-thirds of which were in the eastern states. By 1903 the national flock had almost halved to 54 million. The nation lost more than 40 per cent of its cattle over the same period, nearly three million in Queensland alone.
Drovers sought feed for hungry stock along travelling stock routes (known as the ‘long paddock’) or moved stock to pastures on the east coast and southern mountains where conditions were less dire.
Droving took an immense toll on sheep and cattle with losses of up to 70 per cent recorded, particularly in regions where watering points could be 100 kilometres apart. In 1902 local newspapers reported that more than 2000 steers lay dead along the Goondiwindi to Miles route in Queensland.
…
Read more: https://www.nma.gov.au/defining-moments/resources/federation-drought
Michael Mann, What you call a land of Mad Max and Waterworld, we call home. Breathing a bit of bushfire smoke every other year, enduring floods and droughts, is as much a part of Aussie life as beach BBQs and beer, and always has been.
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
It’s the equivalent of ‘ambulance chasing’, people like Mann relish natural disasters to push their agenda for personal benefit.
Tony Heller produced an article with the same conclusion, that being, there is nothing unusual happening with Australia’s climate.
https://realclimatescience.com/2021/03/michael-mann-says-australia-didnt-used-to-have-floods-or-fires/
The UN/IPCC’s credibility is eroded by the day thanks to MM
Mann has to double down on his mendacious propheteering. Either that or admit that he’s been
lyingmistaken for the last quarter-century. Simply retiring and moving out of the limelight is not an option for those with such big egos.Admitting past errors is impossible for one so enamoured of his own importance at the centre of the climate cartel.
The best known poem of Mackellar, My Country, was written by her in 1904 at the age of just 19,
I love a sunburnt country,
A land of sweeping plains,
Of ragged mountain ranges,
Of droughts and flooding rains
I love her far horizons,
I love her jewel-sea,
Her beauty and her terror
The wide brown land for me!
Clear needs to be changed by left mob to “Of droughts and flooding rain cause by man made CO2”
The self-importance is staggering. He and Greta are as full-blown crazy as every other doomsayer in history. The end is nigh (for real this time, it’s ‘science’)! Pseudo-scientism is the new apocalyptic cult.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dates_predicted_for_apocalyptic_events
1983 was the only year the spillway at the Hoover dam came in to play.
https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1995-10-29-tm-62672-story.html?_amp=true
The dam is not as safe as they thought when full. The dam outlet tunnels & spillway are not safe with maximum flows.
So after 1983, fill then spill is to be avoided. It’s much safer to start the water releases much earlier to reduce peak outflow.
You also notice, 1983 also involved a doubling of the predicted inflow from melting snow upstream (snow accumulation during winter).
Remember that bigger computers can’t fix bad models, they just get to the wrong answer quicker.
“Climate Stability” like Mars?
How can you RESTORE stability that never was?
2020 saw the apparent extinction of 2 large species — influenza and weather.
Maybe Dr Mann can explain the Federation Drought and the devastating Gippsland bushfires of 1898, when pCO2 was less than 300 ppmV.
Oh the good old days of the utopian Australian paradise climate..
I’m pretty sure when the British first arrived they wouldn’t have declared it as such.
More like “unfit for human inhabitation” would be closer to the mark.
That’s why the Indonesians stayed away. They left it to the Aborigines. The Aborigines were stuck with nowhere to go. They survived for 40,000+ years hunting and gathering, unable to tap the region’s resources through lack of technology.
it’s a shame that Prof Mann does not realise that you need fuel for a fire. In temperate rain forest sufficient fallen leaves, fruit, seeds etc accumulates in around 2-3 years to produce 20 tonnes of litter per hectare which according to the CSIRO, if ignited cannot be extinguished by usual fire fighting techniques. So if forest litter is allowed to accumulate without burning for 5 years a conflagration is guaranteed if it catches alight.
Also Prof Mann does not seem to realise that it it necessary to raise the temperature of wood or any other cellulosic material to around 150-250C in order to ignite it. So why will a temperature rise of only a few degrees C change the probability of a fire occurring?
Fires become catastrophic when fuel is allowed to accumulate and the temperature has very little to do with it other than facilitating their drying out thus making it easier to ignite them.
Perhaps someone should send Prof Mann a copy of the Bush Fire Fighters Manual where fires are well explained. Alternatively a refresher course from first year high school chemistry would probably be enough!
‘Black Thursday’ bushfire, Victoria Australia – 6th February 1851.
Surely Mann knows that Australia’s contribution to global CO2 levels is de minimis.
Sherley he does know….he’s there to sell books…make money…recruit more believers…he can’t go to China.
Beautiful Autumn day here in Perth, Western Australia, today.
Lying Mike Mann wrote in the the UK’s leading communist-inspired newspaper, “In a scientific study I co-authored a year ago, we demonstrated that climate change is causing the wet season to get wetter and the dry season to get drier in many parts of the world. NSW is one of those regions, and we’ve seen the consequence in the whiplash of fires and floods that have plagued the region over the past 14 months.”
Mann The Snake-oil Seller might as well tell Australia to start tossing virgins into volcanoes and other offerings to appease the climate gods. Mann’s is absolute junk science — made up crap to fit a political narrative that always blames mythical human CO2-climate change. The guy should be laughed out of town.
I love it when Nobel Laureates cite Hollywood movie scripts to make their point.
Nobel Laureate????
Or do you mean the self proclaimed award the fool, claimed at one stage.
He meant Lowrate.
Mann claimed he was awarded a Nobel Prize. That makes him a Nobel Laureate. Whether he deserved it or not is a different issue.
Mann is not a Nobel Laureate. The 2007 Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to the IPCC (and the other fool, Al Gore). Whilst Gore can lay claim to being a Nobel Laureate, Mann cannot as he never received a Nobel.
Like many others here I boggled at the phrase “restore climate stability”. Those of us who have spent more than a weekend in the country know that the Australian climate has been like this for centuries.
It takes someone with an actual belief in magic and mysticism to believe Mann’s garbage claims like that. Science, actual science as a process, is not part of the bilge that spews from Michael Mann.
From 1908:
The love of field and coppice
Of green and shaded lanes,
Of ordered woods and gardens
Is running in your veins.
Strong love of grey-blue distance,
Brown streams and soft, dim skies
I know, but cannot share it,
My love is otherwise.
I love a sunburnt country,
A land of sweeping plains,
Of ragged mountain ranges,
Of droughts and flooding rains.
I love her far horizons,
I love her jewel-sea,
Her beauty and her terror
The wide brown land for me!
The stark white ring-barked forests,
All tragic to the moon,
The sapphire-misted mountains,
The hot gold hush of noon,
Green tangle of the brushes
Where lithe lianas coil,
And orchids deck the tree-tops,
And ferns the warm dark soil.
Core of my heart, my country!
Her pitiless blue sky,
When, sick at heart, around us
We see the cattle die
But then the grey clouds gather,
And we can bless again
The drumming of an army,
The steady soaking rain.
Core of my heart, my country!
Land of the rainbow gold,
For flood and fire and famine
She pays us back threefold.
Over the thirsty paddocks,
Watch, after many days,
The filmy veil of greenness
That thickens as we gaze …
An opal-hearted country,
A wilful, lavish land
All you who have not loved her,
You will not understand
though Earth holds many splendours,
Wherever I may die,
I know to what brown country
My homing thoughts will fly.
”It’s not too late for Australia to forestall a dystopian future that alternates between Mad Max and Waterworld”
Michael Mann will go down in history as a most deplorable, self centered, transparent and generally odious individual.
Why? Because this statement shows without any shadow of doubt, that MM has now completely and utterly forsaken any semblance of scientific reason and has instead chosen political activism, using any and all known tricks to further his propaganda in the most cynical of ways…..by spewing a bald-faced lie which will only be taken seriously by a seemingly growing number of useful idiots who will – and are at this very moment in Melbourne – disrupting the smooth running of society using their delusions as a weapon. Mann is simply facilitating this with untruths which are obvious to anyone who cares to see. The man is a creep.
That quarter wits like this are able to get tenure tells you all you need to know.
We have climate stability in Australia. It is our sunburnt country, our land of droughts and flooding rains, vast horizons and jewelled seas, a wide brown land of beauty and terror, as poetically described by Dorothea MacKellar in 1908, so let us appreciate it without climate guilt being imposed on us.
“As I flew….” typical hypocrit. What a jerk this guy is.
fires ring sysney 1994
I remember that bushfire period when all roads in and out of Sydney were closed because of the bushfires.
The land of droughts and flooding rains, where bushfires have been taking place way back in time and long before white settlement in January 1788.
Watermelon Greens Australia and other Church of Climate Change members, climate hoaxers and warming creative accountants, call climate emergency at every opportunity, as in 2019/20 bushfires and now 2021 heavy rainfall and resulting floods.
By the way, in the Lower Hunter River NSW District the present flood is about the same as 1955 and according to local Aborigines these floods are not the worst, before 1840 there was a massive flood they say and using their reference points three times deeper around the City of Maitland.
Huh?? Who says the present Hunter flood is about the same as 1955? The main street of Maitland didn’t even go under water in this ‘present’ flood – during the ’55 flood the main street was about 2 metres (~6 1/2 foot) under water! The 1955 flood had a peak of 12.5 metres, the peak of this flood is expected to be around 7.3 metres (Friday 26/03) at Maitland.
This ‘present’ flood is nothing like 1955.
Since 1955 a substantial levy bank has been constructed to protect the City of Maitland from flooding, the present flood came close to breaching the levy.
News, local news,
Moderate floods are expected to stop at some of the hunters, and Maitland is expected to reach the highest benchmark on the Hunter River on Friday night. Water levels in Wollonby Brook fell slowly but below the minor flood lines in Burga and the Singleton on Friday. SES said it expects no more floods in the singleton. A small flood in Maitland followed the highest water mark, and SES predicted that the Hunter River would peak at a height of about 7.6 meters. This figure was corrected after previous concerns that a height of 8.5 meters would arrive on Saturday. Detective Chad Gillies, commander of the Port Stephens-Hunter Police District, said the waterways continued to swell despite constant rain in most of the area. “Thankfully, most of our community is now safe, has good communication with SES and is ready, and to this day there have been injuries and deaths in our area. No, “he said. “I can say that some of our residents have quarantine reports, but as I said, they are well prepared and well versed.” He said. He said the property was quarantined around Dungog, Maitland and Port Stephens. SES estimates that approximately 60 properties were blocked in the Hillsboro and Rosebrook areas near Tokal. On Thursday, Maitland Vale branch volunteers began operating flood boats to transport residents from Maitland Vale Road to the Luskintyre Road intersection between 9 am and 11 am or 3 pm and 5 pm. Did. The boat was scheduled to carry groceries and supplies by ferry until Sunday. Detective Gillies said that while the damage to the meteorological system was blamed elsewhere, as the long Easter weekend approaches, attention should be paid to the expansion of roads and waterways in the area. .. “What that means for us is that the risk isn’t over,” he said. “Especially in terms of road closures and road conditions that could be affected by last week’s events, we encourage everyone to really be aware of what is happening around the road and drive into that situation. In Barga, Wollonby Brook fell at 3.59 meters on Friday morning, but the water level on the Singleton River dropped from its peak on Thursday at 12.2 meters to 9.84 meters. “People in the lowlands of the Wollonby Brook region, which may be affected by floods, need to be prepared for quarantine and evacuation potential,” the SES said in a statement. Paramedics expected water to close Patty Road near Burga Public School and many bridges and lowland roads around Jerry’s Planes. I was afraid that Whittingham near the singleton would be isolated. The Meteorological Department predicts a shower in Newcastle on Monday after a cloudy but dry weekend. Forecasts are similar for Cessnock and Singleton, giving the waterways a few days to clear the floods that flooded the area last week. Hunter Water on Friday reported that storage in the region as a whole was 99.6%, up 34.1% in the same period last year and 4.5% last month. Only Anna Bay’s sand floor, estimated to be 94% of its capacity, has the remaining space. News: Our journalists are working hard to bring the latest news in the region to the community. To continue to access trusted content: