A New Cold Record set at International Falls: Should we be surprised?

Guest post by David Archibald

News has come from the Duluth office of the National Weather Service that both International Falls & Hibbing broke their records for low temperatures on the morning of September 17. The Falls got to 23°, breaking the old record of 24° set in 1959, and Hibbing to 24°. We shouldn’t be surprised because the Canadian prairies have been cooling for decades now. Also, President Trump, while in California on September 14, had predicted cooling, saying “It’ll start getting cooler. You just watch.” Three days later a new cold record is set at the iconic International Falls weather station. Either President Trump actually has some control of the weather or he is getting very good advice.

The paper on the Canadian prairies by Garnett, Khandekar and Kauer notes that “During the grain growing months of May-July, the mean temperature on the Canadian prairies has cooled down by 2ºC in the last 30 years. The cooling appears to be most certainly linked to diminishing solar activity” and “This cooling has led to a reduction in Growing Degree Days (GDDs) and has also impacted the precipitation pattern.” The paper includes this figure showing the multi-decadal decline in GDDs:

Figure 1: May GDDs 1985 – 2019

The Canadian prairies grow about 75 million tonnes per year of grains and pulses so the temperature downtrend evident is concerning with respect to the ability of the world to feed itself. The fact that the reduction of solar activity over that period is likely to have been the cause of the cooling is supported by the following figure, produced from data in Table 4 of the paper:

Figure 2: June – August Sunspot activity correlation with GDDs 1985 – 2019

Over the period 1985 to 2019, the figure above shows the correlation between sunspot activity and GDDs on the Canadian prairies. The blue line is the line of best fit.

While the Canadian prairies have been cooling for decades, the Modern Warm Period only ended 14 years ago as shown by the following graph of the cumulative aa Index against the long term average:

Figure 3: Cumulative aa Index against long term average 1868 – 2020

While sunspots are visual manifestations of solar activity, it has been suggested that the Sun’s magnetic activity is the biggest factor in controlling climate on Earth. The figure above suggests that trends in solar activity are about 70 years long. If so, the Earth has just started into a long term cooling trend.

David Archibald is the author of The Anticancer Garden in Australia

0 0 vote
Article Rating
115 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Eric Vieira
September 19, 2020 2:58 am

My comment on figure 2: “The blue line is the line of best fit”: Looks rather like a sawed-off shotgun blast with a curve drawn through it. Calling such a graph a “best fit” is quite a feat in itself…

Ron Long
Reply to  Eric Vieira
September 19, 2020 3:26 am

Eric, my initial reaction also. Following your comment I enlarged the figure 2 and looked at the distribution more closely and agree with author David Archibald that there is a general tendency to lower sunspot numbers to be associated with less growing days on the Canadian prairie. For sure the general observation that there has been a significant temperature drop there is well known as many farmer/families follow these trends carefully. New record low at International Falls? Algore must has just crossed over?

Andy Pattullo
Reply to  Ron Long
September 19, 2020 9:49 am

Agree. When drawing a line of “best fit” it would be good to take note of how good the fit actually is. In this case it looks pretty loose. There is a trend but not a strong one. Doesn’t invalidate the hypothesis that sunspot activity has an association with growing season but not strong evidence in favour either.

Greg
Reply to  Andy Pattullo
September 19, 2020 10:22 am

Any particular reason you chose to fit an exponential model?
What is the correlation coefficient of those two datasets?
How much of the variability is explained by the model.

“The blue line is the line of best fit”

LOL. If that is the best best fit you can fit you need another hypothesis.

Guest suggestion: stick to geology.

Greg
Reply to  Greg
September 19, 2020 10:29 am

Do you have similarly powerful evidence of the effects of eating plants on curing cancer, that would be most interesting.

ATheoK
Reply to  Greg
September 19, 2020 7:42 pm

Are you confusing David Archibald with David Middleton?

So sad.
Ruined a perfectly decent comment with a cheap shot at the wrong person, giving away the malicious intent.

Greg
Reply to  Greg
September 20, 2020 1:08 am

Yes, I did confuse the names. There is no “malicious intent”, the message is stick to a subject you understand and techniques in which you have some expertise.

Actually, as oil exploration geologists, I would expect that David Middleton would know how to fit a line and when to fit one.

What mislead me is that David Middleton has adopted the habit of calling ALL of his posts for the last couple of years a “guest… something or other”. That’s so much his trade mark that that and forename David fooled me.

I suppose I should apologise to David Archibald for confusing him with someone who knew anything about numbers.

Bill T
Reply to  Eric Vieira
September 19, 2020 3:31 am

You do not understand science. “Best fit” is what the scientist draws on graph to confirm their conclusions.

TRM
Reply to  Bill T
September 19, 2020 10:14 am

13 month running average has always been my preference.

pochas94
Reply to  Eric Vieira
September 19, 2020 6:09 am

It’s deceptive. Now, with lower sunspot numbers we should expect GDDs on the left side of the chart.

Charles Higley
Reply to  Eric Vieira
September 19, 2020 8:44 am

You have to identify the nature of the graph. The problem is that the graph only shows the average from only two months of every year. Sunspot activity has a long cycle and there is no guarantee that the high or low of sunspot activity will be during this two monts period. Thus, this is like a stroboscopic glimpse into sunspot activity. The graph suffers from this effect, which also suggests that the blue line is somewhat reasonable as snapshots of a larger phenomenon

Greg
Reply to  Charles Higley
September 20, 2020 1:13 am

If the data sets had the slightest correlation the cherry pick of 2 months would reduce the significance of that correlation. Luckily they are not in the slightest bit correlated so this is not a problem.

This while post is the most monument pile horse manure that would certainly merit peer view publication in a “highly respected” journal like Nature Climate Change, if it’s conclusions concerned CO2.

Joel O’Bryan
September 19, 2020 3:16 am

Fig 3 and the North American high temps of the 30’s make no sense if solar “magnetic activity” controls climate. And where is the 1970’s Ice Age cometh?

pochas94
Reply to  Joel O’Bryan
September 19, 2020 7:23 am

Joel, you’ve been around these threads long enough to know that it’s 20 year cycles on top of 60 year cycles, on top of 110 year cycles, on and on up to the big kahuna, the 2,400 year cycle. Sometimes they line up, sometimes they don’t. And then you’ve got Milankovich cycles.

observa
Reply to  pochas94
September 19, 2020 8:31 am

Hence the shotgun blast and we’re all doomed. Like picking your best fit blue suede shoes only to go outside and it’s freezing and pouring rain and you should have worn the sloppy galoshes. None of it matters except we’re all doomed and send more grants to study the dooming.

Weylan McAnally
Reply to  observa
September 19, 2020 9:15 am

We are all doomed. Nobody gets out alive. We all leave with a toe tag.

“On a long enough time line, the survival rate for everyone drops to zero.” – Narrator (aka Tyler Durden)

Reply to  Joel O’Bryan
September 19, 2020 7:00 pm

I don’t like to say “I told you so…”

But…

I told you so…

https://agree-to-disagree.com/most-of-canada-is-currently-cooling

Reply to  Sheldon Walker
September 19, 2020 7:50 pm

Please note that “I told you so…”, more than once…

Just saying…

https://agree-to-disagree.com/global-warming-by-country-and-region

Peter W
September 19, 2020 3:37 am

This is why I made the move from New Hampshire to central Florida four years ago. I had been studying this climate change business for ten years.

Nifty
Reply to  Peter W
September 19, 2020 8:48 am

Me too – Started looking for a job as far south as I could in 2014, in Fort Myers which is as far south as I could find for high tech work.

Reply to  Nifty
September 19, 2020 9:32 pm

There are many high tech work places further south.

Haven’t your heard of the Southern Hemisphere?

This article shows to how to find the best location to reverse global warming:

https://agree-to-disagree.com/how-far-to-reverse-global-warming

griff
September 19, 2020 3:40 am
David Kamakaris
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 3:58 am

Griff, how long is your record?

Reply to  David Kamakaris
September 19, 2020 7:09 am

Griffs record is about 3 minutes long, then it just lifts the needle and goes back the the starting groove again

MeanderMinimum
Reply to  Leo Smith
September 19, 2020 7:59 am

Is Griff one of those “true believers”? It is so seldom I get to see one in the wild, so to speak.

Hot under the collar
Reply to  Leo Smith
September 19, 2020 11:28 am

Yep, Griff is like a broken record reporting broken records.

Patrick MJD
Reply to  David Kamakaris
September 20, 2020 12:33 am

The “griff” gets “science” only from “approved” sources, links above and The Guardian are the usual fare. The “griff” 97% of the time does not even bother reading what it links to.

Krishna Gans
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 4:55 am

To your knowledge, in July, even in August and some days in September we had groundfrost in several regions in Germany, in western and in eastern part.

Steven Fraser
Reply to  Krishna Gans
September 19, 2020 12:11 pm

And, earliest snowfall in Boulder since accurate records have been kept…

Sara
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 5:02 am

Griff, you’d better stock your pantry and make sure you have a way to cook food without electricity. If you don’t, you’ll find yourself hip deep in wishing you’d done so. Things are changing rapidly, kiddo, and those fires will add something to the precipitation load.

I had to turn the furnace on this year on September 9. That is the earliest I have ever done so, in the nearly 20 years I’ve been in this house. This morning, the temp at sunrise was low 40s and the furnace is running nicely. April 30 was the last day of snow this year. I expect to see first snow earlier than it was in 2019, on Hallowe’en.

Krishna Gans
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 5:06 am

PS
Proof

Peter W
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 5:06 am

CTV Ottawa
Published Friday, February 27, 2015 4:06PM EST
Last Updated Friday, February 27, 2015 4:21PM EST
It’s official. Environment Canada says data now confirms February 2015 was the coldest in 115 years.
A report summing up the February weather patterns shows the Arctic air mass stuck over eastern Ontario and southwestern Quebec resulted in temperatures 5 to 9 degrees colder than normal.
The monthly report from Environment Canada states:
“As of February 25, the February 2015 temperature anomaly over eastern Ontario and south-western Québec was never observed before since 1900 making it a 115-year return period event (1 case out of 115 years). The second coldest was 1979. Previous to 1900, there is 1889 which had a colder February than 2015, but data are more or less reliable in those years.
The bone chilling unrelenting cold led to hundreds of collisions, hundreds of frozen pipes, and lost business at local restaurants and businesses.
CTV Ottawa weather forecaster J.J. Clarke says relief is on its way.
A milder weekend with sunny skies is promised for Saturday with a high of minus 9.

Hivemind
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 5:17 am

And a few days later it hit record lows. One day does not a warming trend make…

rbabcock
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 6:07 am

Low solar years have “wavy” jet streams. This drives arctic air farther south and warmer air farther north. The areas in Siberia that experienced hot temperatures this summer had snow just a few weeks later. Unfortunately you only seem to see the warm and never the offsetting cold.

Although the TSI only drops slightly during solar minimums, its frequency distribution changes which effects O3 generation in the atmosphere. There are also a lot fewer solar flares and CME’s hitting the Earth during a minimum. Both of these strike the Earth with tremendous energy and when you have fewer, you have less heating of the upper atmosphere. Additionally there are many more cosmic rays hitting the Earth during solar min.

There is a reason the Dalton/Maunder cold spells happened during a quiet Sun. If in fact we are going into a minimum, it’s going to get cold. We also haven’t had a big volcano go off in quite some time. If a Pinatubo event happens it will only exacerbate what we are facing.

fred250
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 7:38 am

Poor griffool

STILL getting WEATHER and climate mixed up.

The Siberian heat wave in May was a very localised WEATHER event…

… and it was NO WARMER than several previous WEATHER events.

brians356
Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 7:49 am

I’m worried that it has been cooling in my hometown of Lewiston, ID since 1961, when the all time high temperature of 115f was recorded there. And that fully half the 50 US states’ high temperature records were set prior to 1941.

Reply to  griff
September 19, 2020 10:23 pm

griff

I hate to “rain on your parade”, but Russia has suffered from extreme heat waves (and cold waves) for many centuries.

You can see heatwaves (and cold waves) in the GISTEMP temperature anomaly data, which goes from 1880 to the present day.

Have a look at this video that I made from the GISTEMP gridded temperature data.

The colours used have the following meanings:
dark pink – warmer by more than 5 standard deviations
medium pink – warmer by between 4 and 5 standard deviations
light pink – warmer by between 3 and 4 standard deviations
dark orange – warmer by between 2 and 3 standard deviations
medium orange – warmer by between 1 and 2 standard deviations
light orange – warmer by between 0 and 1 standard deviations
light green – cooler by between 0 and 1 standard deviations
medium green – cooler by between 1 and 2 standard deviations
dark green – cooler by between 2 and 3 standard deviations
light blue – cooler by between 3 and 4 standard deviations
medium blue – cooler by between 4 and 5 standard deviations
dark blue – cooler by more than 5 standard deviations

Basically, green and orange are normal temperature anomalies, pink are extreme warming, and blue is extreme cooling.

You can make the video “full screen” if you want to. And you can use the left and right arrow keys to go back or forwards in time, to any month.

I suggest that you look at these months
– January 1880 – large heat wave over Canada and America (pink)
– February 1882 – large heat wave over Russia (pink)
– December 1882 – large cold wave over Russia (blue)
– February 1884 – large cold wave over Canada and America (blue)
– March 1884 – large cold wave over Russia (blue)
– December 1886 – very large heat wave over Russia (pink)
– February 1894 – extreme heat wave in Russia (pink)
– I haven’t even reached the 20th century yet
– etc, etc

If you want to see a large modern heat wave in Russia, look at March 2017.

You might like to check out January 1963, the last time that the river Thames in England froze. See the blue colour over England and Western Europe. Notice that at the same time, there was a heat wave over Eastern Russia.

People notice heat waves that happen now, but they don’t remember the heat waves that have happened throughout history (when people didn’t have air conditioning). It is easy to be alarmist when you don’t know what happened before 1970.

https://agree-to-disagree.com/nta-map-video-30-minutes

Reply to  Sheldon Walker
September 19, 2020 11:02 pm

Another interesting thing about my video of GISTEMP gridded temperature anomaly data.

The video shows El Ninos very clearly. The Pacific ocean turns pink to the left of South America.

You can see the 1998 super El Nino develop and disappear, from June 1997 to May 1998.

Please bring your own popcorn.

Reply to  Sheldon Walker
September 19, 2020 11:16 pm

Whatever you do, DON’T look at the heat wave in my video that happened in Russia in February 1903.

It is too scary !!!

Reply to  Sheldon Walker
September 19, 2020 11:25 pm

And there was a continuous extreme heat wave in Russia from December 1913 to February 1914 (3 months of continuous extreme heat wave).

Do you remember the good old days?

Mark Albright
September 19, 2020 3:50 am

International Falls was even colder on 18 Sept 2020 with 20 F. Record cold was observed the morning of 18 Sept 2020 in northern Minnesota. Here are the 5 lowest temperatures ever recorded in the month of Sept at International Falls MN over the past 114 years:

19 F 15 Sept 2011
20 F 18 Sept 2020
20 F 18 Sept 2012
20 F 26 Sept 1965
20 F 20 Sept 1956

Zane
September 19, 2020 4:09 am

The greens will do a 180 degree turn and start blaming CO2 for global cooling. The climate fear and loathing must continue, Trump or no Trump!

DMacKenzie
Reply to  Zane
September 19, 2020 6:16 am

Higher CO2 levels in upper troposphere DO emit more IR to outer space….technically causing more heat loss, a.k.a. cooling, at that altitude.

very old white guy
September 19, 2020 4:18 am

First frost here in eastern ontario tuesday sept 15. A one hour frost delay at our golf course. Today 1 c on our deck. That is cold for this time of year. It is the earliest frost I personally can remember. I don’t have a graph.

a_scientist
Reply to  very old white guy
September 19, 2020 5:00 am

Similar news here in 50 miles west of Chicago. I got frost this morning. The pepper plants are endangered. We will see, but kind of early !

Peta of Newark
September 19, 2020 4:24 am

Thank you Griffles -m for letting us know that you are ‘worried’ about folks taking themselves and their kids to the beach.

I’d be tempted to say that “Prozac may help” but it won’t.
Chronic depression and the resulting Puritanism *and* magical thinking come on after a lifetime of consuming refined sugar *or* cooked starch *or* alcohol *and/or* cannabis. Any one or more of those will suffice.

Add in the lack of Vitamin B from eating Rabbit Food, lack of Vitamin D from sitting inside, lack of Zinc through the alcohol use we are Big Trouble
Add further the lack of Iron & Magnesium (combined with the lack of Vit B bring on the whole myriad of mental health disorders – Asperger’s, Down’s, Autism & full blown dementia.
Plenty folks will now claim they can see/measure Alzheimer’s in folks who are, but don’t even know, they are pre-diabetic.

All very fine and dandy, even in the 1920’s doctors could reverse/cure full blown Type 2 diabetes – caused from eating too much Rabbit Food.

The REAL Big Problem and the Triple Whammy is that….
1) there are now too many people to be able to eat anything other than sugar
2) the production of same (tillage) is causing not only the observed ‘Climate Change’ but also the rise in atmospheric CO2
3) worst of all, the resulting Bent Minds and warped thinking now believe, via their Magical Thinking, that consuming ever more Rabbit Food will fix their imaginary/magical problem.

It’s impossible to more More Wrong – simply too surreal even for Monty Python

Robert W. Turner
September 19, 2020 4:37 am

The trade winds at 140 degrees longitude have once again flipped westardly and more cool pool is forming in the western Pacific undercurrent. That La Nina is almost guaranteed to form now and the cooling is going to kick off, bigly.
We’re also 10 months into SC 25 and continuing a 30 day stretch of zero sunspot activity.

Joel O’Bryan
Reply to  Robert W. Turner
September 19, 2020 7:26 am

The ongoing solar quiet since August has also piqued my my interest. I mentioned in a comment somewhere about 5 days ago if this continues thru 2 more Carrington rotations (53 days ~7 1/2 weeks) then it’s something to be more concerned about.

Steve Case
September 19, 2020 4:47 am

It’s not just May – July. Maximum temperatures during the warm part of the year May-October have been cooling the eastern USA48 for over 80 years:
comment image
Quite a few of those states the cooling is dramatic and goes back to the 19th century
Source: NOAA’s Climate At A Glance

Loydo
Reply to  Steve Case
September 20, 2020 2:15 pm

“Source: NOAA’s Climate At A Glance”

Despite the fact the link only pertains to a small fraction of the global surface – the US – the source shows what appears to be uniform warming.

2hotel9
Reply to  Loydo
September 20, 2020 2:41 pm

And yet humans are not causing it nor can we stop it. Climate changes, constantly, always has and always will. Right now US is cooling, this will continue till it starts to warm in the spring, then it will cool again. Always has and always will. The fact that college educated people are too stupid to understand this is just comical, until you idiots screw up economies, agriculture, energy production and manufacturing and you are all very close to receiving the rewards you all so richly deserve for your asinine meddling in things you are too stupid to understand.

Doug Huffman
September 19, 2020 5:07 am

Best fit ‘best’ is a continuum from great, through best, to useless, and expressed by the correlation coefficient, standard deviation or variations. Without those additional data it is merely ad copy for the Gullahbull.

SteveS
September 19, 2020 5:16 am

Remember the “great Dust Bowl” of the 30’s that affected the US snd Canada….Seems to conflict with the chart above….explain pls

Sara
Reply to  SteveS
September 19, 2020 6:17 am

The Dust Bowl was the result of the loss of the monsoonal flow of air out of the Gulf of Mexico. And it was not hot weather. You don’t have to have heat to have a drought. It went on for eight years, and it was not a hot weather event.

The cold wave in 1936 was the coldest on record then, with no precipitation included in the Dust Bowl area. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1936_North_American_cold_wave

That went on for several years. Summers were hot and dry, winters were cold and dry.

SteveS
Reply to  Sara
September 19, 2020 6:58 am

Selective much….seems like you picked one year out of many. Since your only contribution is to cut and paste wiki…..looks like you missed this little tidbit
According to Wiki, the paragraph before your info…..
“The 1936 North American heat wave was one of the most severe heat waves in the modern history of North America. It took place in the middle of the Great Depression and Dust Bowl of the 1930s and caused catastrophic human suffering and an enormous economic toll. The death toll exceeded 5,000, and huge numbers of crops were destroyed by the heat and lack of moisture. “

Try watching the history of “the great dust Bowl” to educate yourself regarding the severity if the heat.

Still today, the vast majority of all time state high temp records come from the 1930’s

Sara
Reply to  SteveS
September 19, 2020 9:07 am

No, Steve, I did NOT miss it. I was trying to make a point that you missed entirely: LACK OF WATER POURING OUT OF THE SKY.

Read it again: I said COLD WAVE 19936 — NO PRECIPITATION.

You must have missed that part.

SteveS
Reply to  Sara
September 19, 2020 12:06 pm

Maybe you missed the whole point of the article….low solar, cooler temperatures. The chart shows lowest solar 1933, yet the thirties, with the exception of one cold year, were some of the warmest years on record in the US.

The question was, how dies one reconcile the higher temps of the 30’s with the predicted “cooler” temps Shown in the chart.

Again Sarah, remember the point of the OP, low solar, low temps. Although drought played a part in the dust bowl, The subject raised was Temp vs solar.

Perhaps you meant to start a new post, Solar output vs precipitation. That would be nice, but again not the subject of the post.

The question remains….if low solar causes cooling, how at the low end of a solar downturn do you wind up with a decade of the highest Temperatures. Simple question that doesn’t require dragging in precipitation.
For your own info you can easily look up and see the 30’s were the hottest decade before the current debacle of adjusted thermometers.

Again, we’re talking solar activity vs temperature, try to stay on point.

fred250
Reply to  Sara
September 19, 2020 4:05 pm

“we’re talking solar activity vs temperature”

Yes, we are

comment image

EOM
Reply to  Sara
September 19, 2020 7:47 am

With water vapor being the prominent greenhouse gas in the earth atmosphere, one should not be surprised to find both the greatest summer heat and the greatest winter cold during the very dry 1936 dust bowl. There are a small number of examples of stations receiving both their monthly record maximum and monthly record minimum during the same day during certain very dry summer months.

John F Hultquist
Reply to  SteveS
September 19, 2020 12:24 pm

For all that mention the “Dust Bowl”, I suggest going to
this site, https://www.timothyeganbooks.com/
then BOOKS

See: The Worst Hard Time
– – – then: The Big Burn is the story of “The Great Fire of 1910”

Tom Abbott
Reply to  SteveS
September 19, 2020 2:00 pm

“Remember the “great Dust Bowl” of the 30’s that affected the US snd Canada….Seems to conflict with the chart above….explain pls”

Here’s the Hansen 1999 U.S. surface temperature chart. It doesn’t look anything like the chart in figure 3.

comment image

You can see the high temperatures of the 1930’s, the low temperatures of the 1970’s, and the warming that started in the 1980’s.

And yes you can have record cold in the same year you have record warm temperatures. It just all depends on how the high pressure system that is causing the warm temperatures is situated. The high can be situated over the central US during the summer, bringing high temperatures to most of the nation, and then the high can drift off to the west allowing cold Canadian air to come down into the United States on the east side of the high.

I think nearly all States have their record highs taking place during the decade of the 1930’s.

According to Hansen, in the US, 1934 was 0.5C warmer than 1998, which would make 1934, 0.4C warmer than 2016, the warmest year in the 21st century.

Btw, all other unmodified surface temperature charts have essentially the same temperature profile as the US Hansen chart, i.e., they all show it was just as warm in the Early Twentieth Century as it is today.

There was less CO2 in the atmosphere in the 1930’s, than there is today, yet today is no warmer than in the 1930’s. More CO2, and cooler temperatures. Just the opposite of the claims made by alarmists.

Loydo
September 19, 2020 5:19 am

What is a “Cumulative aa Index against long term average 1868 – 2020” graph?

Krishna Gans
Reply to  Loydo
September 19, 2020 8:59 am

As à set out Climate Scientist you don’t know what the aa index is ?

sycomputing
Reply to  Loydo
September 19, 2020 10:13 am
Loydo
Reply to  Loydo
September 20, 2020 4:28 am

Much obliged.

JoHo
September 19, 2020 5:26 am

For the first time in my (long) memory my heating came on, on the 30th and 31st August (60 miles North of London). The gauge to automatically turn the heating on is permanently set to 13 degrees. When I checked my Weather Station at 6.30 a.m. it was showing 50F. This is far from normal for the South of the UK, so is POTUS going to be proved ‘spot-on’ with his prediction and are we entering a period of cooling?

Richard Barraclough
Reply to  JoHo
September 21, 2020 2:42 am

Hardly. The last 3 days of August were indeed unusually cool – well-timed for the long weekend. But September has been about 1.5 degrees above the long term average (according to the Central England Temperature), and most enjoyable too.

Bruce Cobb
September 19, 2020 6:14 am

Frost here in central NH, about 2 weeks early. We are also dealing with a fairly serious drought here, with no end in sight either. If only one of those bazillion tropical storms would make it up this way. Mother Nature must be “angry” with us for some reason. Maybe we used too much Chiffon margarine?

alankwelch
September 19, 2020 6:17 am

Don’t let Nerem close to these figures. Fitting a quadratic results in an acceleration of 0.54 growing degree days/year2. Also extrapolating, like all good climate scientists do, results in there being 2759 growing degree days by 2100. The dramatic effect this will have on crop levels and pest development is unknown but has been blamed on man made climate change!!

Yooper
September 19, 2020 6:28 am

And then down south we have more fun:
Synopsis for the Gulf of Mexico
454 AM EDT Sat Sep 19 2020

.SYNOPSIS…Tropical Storm Beta near 26.0N 92.5W 996 mb at 5 AM
EDT moving N at 7 kt. Maximum sustained winds 50 kt gusts 60 kt.
Beta will move to 26.6N 92.6W this afternoon, 26.9N 93.4W Sun
morning, then strengthen to a hurricane near 27.1N 94.3W Sun
afternoon, Hurricane Beta will be near 27.4N 95.2W Mon morning,
27.7N 95.9W Mon afternoon, and 28.1N 96.3W Tue morning. Beta will
weaken to a tropical storm offshore the Texas coast early Wed A
cold front will move through the northeast Gulf through the
weekend, bringing fresh to strong NE winds into early next week.

jtom
Reply to  Yooper
September 19, 2020 9:31 am

Another 24 hour hurricane that diminishes to a TS before hitting land. It’s amazing the number of storms this year that make it to TS or hurricane strength only for a few hours. Either NOAA’s models are ‘optimistic’ about their strengths (most storm declarations are based on inference rather than direct measurements), or conditions are not right for sustainable storms like the past.

Enginer01
September 19, 2020 6:34 am

I guess the bigger question is “Has this resulted in a significant drop in bushels/acre on these plains?” Climate extremists to to focus on the cost to agriculture, ignoring it is positive for warmer, and (usually) negative for cooler.
Ignored is the fact that CO2 will continue to rise until significant ocean surface cooling is noted, and possibly for many years thereafter. Some agronomists credit today’s increased crop yield more to CO2 level (800-900 is ideal for most agriculture) than to hybridization and Roundup.
As a “fertilizer plant” engineer, I tend to think that timed-release MAP and other features of modern (ammonia is ammonia) non-synthetic fertilizer will help us thru at least the first 15 years of Solar-minimum induced cooling.

Hubert
September 19, 2020 6:57 am

«  Canadian prairies have been cooling for decades now ! «  What a lie !
Total contradiction with réal data !
Just fake News

Pat from kerbob
Reply to  Hubert
September 19, 2020 7:37 am

Been cooling here in calgary, and wetter
Not for “decades” but steady trend for 15 years

fred250
Reply to  Hubert
September 19, 2020 7:43 am

The data is given as Figure 1…..

NOT fake news.

Get over it!

billtoo
September 19, 2020 6:59 am

http://coolwx.com/record/usamovie.day.php

not limited to northern MN

Pat from kerbob
September 19, 2020 7:34 am

Posted comments before but

I garden in calgary, it has been cooler and wetter as the years proceed. My rain barrels used to go dry end of June through use and no replenishment
Still full sept 18
Used to start picking tomatoes mid August
Beginning sept now
Went to -5c at the lake in southern sask on Labor Day, killer freeze
But has been decent August and most of September, makes up for earlier

Also noted my observation of cooling and warming
Was cool and wet right thru end of July, highs max 20c regularly, lake temp increased to 73F
Very hot dry August, consistent 30’s C, lake still cooled to 62F.
Sun heats water
Hot air after end of July, but lower and less sun, lake cools

My observation of alarmist claim that CO2 heats atmosphere that in turns heats ocean
I call BS based on my little experiment

Pat from kerbob
September 19, 2020 7:35 am

Posted comments before but

I garden in calgary, it has been cooler and wetter as the years proceed. My rain barrels used to go dry end of June through use and no replenishment
Still full sept 18
Used to start picking tomatoes mid August
Beginning sept now
Went to -5c at the lake in southern sask on Labor Day, ki!!er freeze
But has been decent August and most of September, makes up for earlier

Also noted my observation of cooling and warming
Was cool and wet right thru end of July, highs max 20c regularly, lake temp increased to 73F
Very hot dry August, consistent 30’s C, lake still cooled to 62F.
Sun heats water
Hot air after end of July, but lower and less sun, lake cools

My observation of alarmist claim that CO2 heats atmosphere that in turns heats ocean
I call BS based on my little experiment

2hotel9
September 19, 2020 7:47 am

31 here in Butler county PA this morning, during the last two weeks we have had lows of 38 and 40. During September.

Yooper
September 19, 2020 7:50 am

Here’s an interesting take from Adapt 2030:

Reply to  Yooper
September 19, 2020 8:25 am

The cold will remain after the smoke clears. The exceptional cold is from long duration TSI catching up to us while the seasonal insolation falls.

David Dubyne thinks cosmic rays control the climate. Cosmic rays peaked months ago and the temperature was still high and there were in fact fewer clouds during the solar minimum, so the big Svensmark cosmic ray theory failed miserably. The joke’s on everyone.

fred250
Reply to  Bob Weber
September 19, 2020 4:03 pm

Fuunny isn’t it.

All that CO2 emitted into the atmosphere…….. and it gets colder. 😉

Enginer01
Reply to  Bob Weber
September 19, 2020 5:07 pm

I think it’s too soon to cast this theory aside. Svensmark’s first go at this was shot down because the nuclei were smaller than needed to grow cloud-sized particles. The clouds (albedo) are likely the trigger for cooling or warming and, as we all say, climate science is not “settled” yet.

Patrick MJD
Reply to  Yooper
September 20, 2020 12:26 am

Particulates will cool.

Pat from kerbob
September 19, 2020 7:52 am

Mods
I had several comments on here that just disappeared

Which gods did I offend?

Pat from kerbob
Reply to  Pat from kerbob
September 19, 2020 7:53 am

And then reappeared

Mysteries of the internet

Bill Rocks
September 19, 2020 8:00 am

Fuzzy data. Sometimes fuzzy data have meaning.

Mark me down as interested but not yet convinced of a long-term trend Nonetheless, IMHO, the observations of the farmers are credible.

I do appreciate the effort to prepare the information and discuss same because I am unfamiliar with this hypothesis. Am I a bad person?

September 19, 2020 8:17 am

David why did you use the AA index in lieu of sunspots?

The modern maximum is 1935-2004 using annual v2 sunspot numbers.

It’s recently cooling in the north from the TSI having dropped back near solar minimum levels after the flux dissapated from small sunspots.

My empirically derived decadal ocean warming threshold is 95 v2 SN and 120 sfu F10.7 cm flux. The running average of F10.7 since my model training period started (May 1960) is now about 117.1 sfu after falling below 120 in early 2017. The high latitude cooling I expect will happen as this average falls further over the next few years, before sunspots and TSI get high enough for more warming, as the tropics cool too under low TSI.

From my Dec 2018 AGU poster, the assumed solar minimum in Fig 12 was July 2019, whereas the actual was Dec 2019, so the whole thing gets time-shifted forward by 5 months. We are now in the ‘cold winters, hot dry US SW’ part of the cycle, and my conclusion then was for early hard winters until sunspots/TSI rebound to decadal warming levels again.

comment image

comment image

I ran the numbers again for Fig 12 using the latest SWPC SC25 forecast, and it looks like even their highest range will result in a cumulative F10.7cm running average curve that doesn’t return back above 120 sfu in SC25:

comment image

David Archibald
Reply to  Bob Weber
September 19, 2020 5:54 pm

Warmer scientists have plenty of time on their hands and some of them would have looked at what actually causes changes in climate out of idle curiosity. About 10 years ago on WUWT, one such person make a comment along the lines of “You fools. It is solar magnetic activity that changes climate.” Everything has its place. It could be that solar magnetic activity is the largest component, not necessarily the largest component. The best long term record is the aa Index. So I plot it up and, lo and behold, it works like a charm. The changes in trend stand out like the proverbial. So they define the Modern Warm Period.

Calculate the average for the period 1868 – 2020, which is 19.2. Then for each year add the difference between the annual result and 19.2. The Modern Warm Period is a plateau of consistently higher activity. The result is nice and clean, the interpretation unequivocal.

Actually Anthony Watts picked the end of the Modern Warm Period in 2006 when the Ap Index and the aa Index suddenly fell out of bed. At the time, Anthony said “That means something” and so it did.

Reply to  David Archibald
September 20, 2020 5:49 pm

Thanx David you were definitely on to something. It looks like the AA index lags sunspots by about a year; sunspot numbers go back farther than the AA index which is why I use them. See inset (d) here:

comment image

The breakpoints for the detrended integrated sunspot number are in 1935 and 2004. The Modern Maximum in annual numbers averaged 108.5, 65% higher than the previous 70-year period average of 65.8 v2 SN.

ICU
September 19, 2020 9:01 am

Changes in Canada’s Climate: Trends in Indices Based on Daily Temperature and Precipitation Data (2018)
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/07055900.2018.1514579
A Third Generation of Homogenized Temperature for Trend Analysis and Monitoring Changes in Canada’s Climate (2020)
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/07055900.2020.1765728
See also …
ftp://ccrp.tor.ec.gc.ca/pub/EC_data/AHCCD_daily/
V3 are the min/mean/max daily temperatures that are not “_Gen2”

Long story short? GDD have increased throughout CA (one needs to include September to determine total growing season, see the 2018 reference above).

September 19, 2020 9:07 am

Oceanic cooling is being detected in various places in the Southern Hemisphere.

For instance, there’s been a lot of attention to flow of warmer water toward Antarctica. Apparently a warming phenomenon. But recent research has show this warm inflow to be in reaction to a deep downwelling outflow of cold dense water away from Antarctica along the ocean floor. So it’s more like a cooling phenomenon.

https://ptolemy2.wordpress.com/2020/09/12/widespread-signals-of-southern-hemisphere-ocean-cooling-as-well-as-the-amoc/

September 19, 2020 9:12 am

Is WUWT going to post something saying we’re getting warmer next time two places in the same state set record highs for one of the dates of the year?

Bruce Cobb
Reply to  Donald L. Klipstein
September 19, 2020 9:56 am

Oh look, a yellow-bellied warmunist troll. Nice. I thought they had gone extinct.

Aksurveyor
Reply to  Donald L. Klipstein
September 19, 2020 10:36 am

No the msm will blow it out of proportion with the we are are all gonna die mantra. No need to post it here, and the local coolaid drinkers will slobber all over it like it is the hottest evah.

MarkW
Reply to  Donald L. Klipstein
September 19, 2020 10:50 am

Don’t need to, you warminists will do it for us.

Bindidon
Reply to  Donald L. Klipstein
September 20, 2020 4:10 am

Donald L. Klipstein

Oh, how funny! Three Cooling alarmistas in a row, barking unisono like little ankle biters!
Wow! I love that.

The best is that upon a very first analysis, you can see a typical flaw: the time series for 1980-2019 has near its beginning the second highest JJA temperature average since 1900 (after 1936), followed by the four least temperatures since then.

Exactly what should be avoided. The linear estimate for that period therefore hardly could be positive: -0,37 °C / decade.

But… if available data had not been available before 1992, the trend would ave been +0.27 instead, and the article probably wouldn’t have been written that way.

I’ll try to obtain some more data for a deeper analysis, and compare the time series with Silso’s Sun Spot Number data.

J.-P. D.

David Blenkinsop
September 19, 2020 10:58 am

Frostbite Falls! I assume the 23 degrees is Fahrenheit, frost bite indeed?

beng135
Reply to  David Blenkinsop
September 20, 2020 10:00 am

Frostbite Falls — that’s the hometown of Rocky the Flying Squirrel and Bullwinkle Moose. 😉

David Blenkinsop
Reply to  beng135
September 20, 2020 8:40 pm

Yes, someone remind them to watch out for Pottsylvanian spies and tech thieves ..

ren
September 19, 2020 11:37 am

The Nino 3.4 index will soon drop to -0.8 degrees C, which is full La Nina conditions.

EJ
September 19, 2020 3:19 pm

And yet no mention of the elephant in the sky–geoengineering aka weather warfare. Mother Nature had nothing to do with the freak lightening storms that sparked the California fires or the double whammy hurricanes in the gulf or the extreme temp changes. Educate yourself at: geoengineeringwatch dot org

Bellman
September 19, 2020 7:45 pm

During the grain growing months of May-July, the mean temperature on the Canadian prairies has cooled down by 2ºC in the last 30 years.

Am I misunderstanding something in the paper? They claim in the abstract that there’s been a 2°C drop during May-July period, but in the body they say there’s been “a 2°C cooling in April, a 1°C cooling in May, a slight cooling in June and a nearly flat to slightly upward trend in July and August.”

So only one of the 3 months showed any significant cooling, and that only half what is claimed for the entire period.

ren
Reply to  Bellman
September 20, 2020 1:08 am

Cooling down in April in Canada means a delay in vegetation.

Bellman
Reply to  ren
September 20, 2020 1:03 pm

My question was about why this paper claims something in the abstract that isn’t backed up in the actual paper. Maybe it’s just a typo and they meant to say April, rather than May-July, but that’s a huge error, and doesn’t give me much confidence in the rest of the paper.

And then David Archibald quotes it without checking the details, and that gives me even less confidence in this article. Though there are many other reasons I don’t give much credit to it.

beng135
September 20, 2020 9:58 am

Joe Bastardi says shortest period between last spring frost and first fall frost in his PA area. Click on video:

http://www.weatherbell.com/premium

I’m not far from him. Killing May frost here and this morning first fall frost (30F) — earliest fall frost I can remember in west MD, tho I think there were earlier freezing Sept temps in the early 1900s.

2hotel9
Reply to  beng135
September 20, 2020 10:15 am

Here in Butler county PA we have had frost 3 mornings in a row, looks like tomorrow will make it 4.

Bellman
September 20, 2020 3:58 pm

The fact that the reduction of solar activity over that period is likely to have been the cause of the cooling is supported by the following figure, produced from data in Table 4 of the paper

I looked at the same data, and cannot see how you arrived at that conclusion. Here are a few observations:

1) Solar activity has been declining during the period. We can agree on that.

2) The GDD values supplied in the table actually show no overall cooling, in fact they show a slight but statistically insignificant warming. (This despite the table deliberately excluding two cold years near the beginning.)

3) A linear fit of Solar Activity to GDD shows a positive but statistically insignificant correlation between the two.

4) However, given that the trend of Solar is decreasing over time, but GDD is flat, suggests to me that what you are seeing is a correlation with the phases of the solar cycle, not the size of the peaks. As a test of this I looked at only years where Solar was above 50 – result no positive correlation.

Loydo
September 20, 2020 10:16 pm

Which begs the question: why post Archibald’s delusions at all? I suspect the reasons are banally idealogical.

Patrick MJD
Reply to  Loydo
September 21, 2020 1:40 am

Yours get posted, so what’s your point?

Richard Barraclough
September 21, 2020 2:45 am

Hardly. The last 3 days of August were indeed unusually cool – well-timed for the long weekend. But September has been about 1.5 degrees above the long term average (according to the Central England Temperature), and most enjoyable too.

September 21, 2020 10:44 am

Dylan from Hibbing, Minnesota – Bob Dylan predicted this:

Lyrics
… Somebody could freeze right to the bone
I froze right to the bone
New York Times said it was the coldest winter in seventeen years
I didn’t feel so cold then… More

From song talkin New York

– JPP

Reply to  Jon P Peterson
September 21, 2020 5:49 pm

Hmmmm, I haven’t heard this in a long time:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tS_mZfpRe9c

– JPP

%d bloggers like this: