Awe, shucks …

Guest Post by Willis Eschenbach

Wintertime was magic when I was a kid. When the snow came, it transformed our world. It turned the forest that surrounded our ranch into an infinity of marvels, mysteries and delights. We could track the animals and follow their secret ways. We didn’t get a lot of snow, most years there wasn’t enough to dig tunnels even for kids on their stomachs. Every few years, though, we’d get two or three feet of snow that would stick. Then we would build the tunnels, sliding and pulling ourselves through them on our stomachs like demented penguins.

What I remember most about those snow tunnels was the color. It was an icy blue that only lived one place in my experience, in the snow tunnels. That color had a strange fascination for me, it was a source of some strange wintry warmth that could only be produced by the weather. Nothing else on my planet had that same color, nowhere was there that same icy blue as the snow tunnels. Even today, I get the shivers thinking of it.

ice marbles 1

SOURCE

Over at Judith Curry’s excellent and perennially interesting blog, there’s a discussion about what makes for a good scientist. One thing that has always pushed me to search for scientific explanations has been my never-ending awe at the size and the power and the endless varieties of weather around the world. I always find myself asking, how do they do that? What mechanisms explain that? How is that possible?

One of my first experiences of this kind of awe was at something I’ve never seen described anywhere since. That’s what got me thinking about the winter.

Near where I grew up, there was something called the “German ditch”, which exists to this day. It was dug by hand, maybe around the turn of the last century, by the early German immigrants. It brought water from a noble watercourse yclept “Atkins Creek” to a whole string of ranches along the lower hillsides. It was maintained by the collective labor of those who benefitted from the water, on the eponymously named “Ditch Day” which occurred once a year, or more as necessary. It picked off water from the creek and brought it in the ditch, which up at the head was maybe three feet wide and two feet deep (.9 m x .6 m), for some miles along the ridge.

Along the way, there was another creek that the German ditch had to cross over. It was spanned by a wooden framework holding up a wooden channel of about the same dimensions as the ditch. It was a lovely piece of work, all hand-done back in the day, with notches and mortice-and-tenon joints in the framework. At places, it was maybe twenty feet (6m) down to the creek below.

And of course, it leaked some. Not a lot, it was kept up, but some, as such wooden sluices are wont to do. Now, I used to like to walk the forest when I was a kid. And so on one very, very cold winter morning, somehow I ended some miles from home, up at the wooden aqueduct where the German ditch was dripping water. I had to walk through new snow to get there, and everywhere I looked it was that blinding white. Dark glasses? We’d never heard of them.

When I got there, I looked around. Where the sun was striking at the bottom of the framework holding up the aqueduct, I saw the most astounding, coruscating, vibrant, refulgent, wildly alive rainbow of light and color I had encountered in my young life. It was like the illustrations of the pirates’ chests in the books I loved to read, chests full of real jewels, gems I’d never seen with names like rubies and emeralds and sapphires, with light that comes blazing out in all colors when you lift up the lid of the chest. But this was for real! I was stunned. I remember just standing there, entranced, amazed that nature could be so full of wonders.

When I climbed down to the bottom, to my great surprise I found a conical pile of ice, from the drips from the German ditch. It had grown up to maybe waist height. At the top of the conical pile of ice, there was a hollowed-out ice bowl. And to my amazement, the ice bowl was full to the brim with loose ice marbles. The marbles were of various sizes, most about the size of the marbles we played with in the summer, some as large as the “aggies”, the larger shooter marbles we used. But these marbles were all made of ice. And I could pick up handfuls of them.

I watched, astonished. After a while, I figured out the reason that the ice marbles were loose was that every time a splash of water came down from the aqueduct above, it was strong enough to move the loose marbles around. That constant motion had kept them from freezing solid. At the same time, it had rounded off all of the corners of the marbles and made them into perfect spheres. It was also what was responsible for the shimmering, changing light—as the sun hit the moving ice marbles, it was broken into a thousand colored shards and spun in all directions. And even when the ice marbles weren’t moving the water was dripping down them and refracting the sunlight in changing ways. I saw how the conical pile of ice had been built up out of marbles that had spilled out of the bowl and frozen solid and gradually built up to waist height. I could not have been more gobsmacked. I walked away half in a trance, stunned by what I had seen.

I bring this up and I write about it for a simple reason—to recapture the energy bound up in that sense of childlike awe at the untold mysteries of the weather. I believe that for everyone studying the weather, there must have been some such sense of wonderment that started them on the path of scientific discovery. Sadly, far too many of us, including myself, often lose that sense of merry wonderment and infantile amusement at the antics of the weather. In the tropics, to keep the feeling alive, I’d go out in the pouring rain and laugh and jump at the thunderclaps. My mad mate Mike taught me to do that, to dance and cavort in my lava-lava at midnight with the raging thunderstorm tossing lightning around the sky.

I once walked out into the face of a cyclone (a southern hemisphere hurricane). Can’t remember the cyclone’s name, it was in Fiji. I was living up on a hill, it was blowing 70 knots and gusting above that. First I tried going out with no protection, but I couldn’t look upwind, the rain just bulleted my face and any exposed skin, it was unbearable. Plus when I opened my mouth to breathe, the hurricane wind just filled my lungs up.

So I went back inside and reconsidered, and I got out my dive gear. I put on my dive mask, and I put on my snorkel. I put on my parka and pulled the hood down around my face mask. I got out and put on my long pants that I never wore in the tropics, and I went back outside. Then, at least, I could face into the wind. It was all I could do to walk out on the hill, I had to lean at a steep angle. I’m sure I looked a right lunatic, with my parka and my mask and snorkel, nothing of my face exposed. But I could see, and I could breathe.

When I got up on the hill, I saw an amazing sight, the kind of sight to loosen the bowels of a sailor. The moon was out so there was some light under the clouds. I could see far out across Suva Harbour. The sea had risen up, the waves were coming over the reef that normally protected the Harbour. Only somewhat impeded, they rushed across the harbor and were breaking down at the foot of the hill where I stood. The whole of Suva Harbour, normally a placid blue lake, was nothing but wave after wave after breaking wave. Boats were jerking around on their moorings like crazed horses, rearing and plunging. Around me buildings were losing roofs, and coconut palms were losing heavy fronds that were picked up and tossed about.

The thing I remember feeling most at that time? Other than feeling really, really glad I was on solid ground and not at sea, no matter how big the boat?

Totally insignificant. Nothing that I could say or do, nothing that anyone or any group could say or do, would make the slightest difference to the scene unfolding below me. A ship was drifting ashore, to hit where it would hit. My sailor’s soul wept to see it go, it meant heartbreak for the owners. Telephone wires were keening for the loss on all sides. I went back inside, feeling somewhat like the little bird that picks the crocodile’s teeth …

That’s what I lose too often, and what I don’t want to lose, that feeling of curiosity-filled wonderment and total insignificance in the face of the magical marvels of weather, because I think a sense of awe is a crucial ingredient in what makes a good scientist.

w.

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
149 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
December 28, 2012 4:04 pm

It has been said that wonder is the truly religious attitude.
And of course, wonder is the source of science: it raises questions.
/Mr Lynn

Editor
December 28, 2012 5:21 pm

Read this wonderful post earlier, but only now getting round to saying how much I enjoyed it, Thanks Willis.

Yrreg.
December 28, 2012 6:33 pm

Back in the day I remember reading a sci-if short story wherein weather systems were sentient creatures, and the storms, winds and lightning were the results of battles being fought to avoid being pushed around. Now, many years later I stand on my mountain side deck and watch the weather systems move across the valley, fighting, yelling and spitting as one is pushed out and another moves in. Who says engineers don’t have poetry in their souls?

December 28, 2012 7:32 pm

Willis
I searched for a way to find your WUWT posts easily, as they are too good to miss. I found a URL: http://wattsupwiththat.com/author/weschenbach/
That’s very helpful, and I’m delighted. I was less delighted to find that it is not the first Google hit for your name. The first is the address of a biased and negatively critical blog about you in the warmist desmogblog. I wonder – is that a coincidence, or activist manipulation in the search engine? It seems hard to imagine that the desmogblog article is the most searched reference for you.

D Böehm
December 28, 2012 7:38 pm

Herkinderkin,
Put “Eschenbach” into the WUWT search box. You will find dozens of articles by Willis. Every one of them is worth reading.

taxed
December 28, 2012 7:52 pm

ln my childhood l saw a weather event that l have never seen before or since.
lt was in the early 70’s ( l think l have nailed it down to Jan 72). We were having very cold frosty weather. l was looking out of my bedroom window at the frost, when suddenly ice pellets began to fall out of what looked to be a clear blue sky. The only cloud in the sky was a patch of high Cirrus cloud right above me. When l went outside to take a closer look, a even more amazing sight was there to meet me. For everyone of the ice pellets that had fell was in the shape of a 5 pointed star.

Steve Tabor
December 28, 2012 9:04 pm

Willis’ description of his magical find of the ice cone reminds me of a similar find of my own many years ago. It was in February in the plateau country of Utah near the Arizona border, above the rim of the San Juan River near Monument Valley. I think it was in Mike’s Canyon. I was wandering up the canyon, a shallow trench encased in solid rock, on a cold but dry morning, when I came to a low rim about twelve feet high spanning the drainage. A minuscule stream went drip-drip-drip over the rim rock, falling on the bare stone wash bottom below. Below the drip was an amazing ice structure about four feet wide and six feet high. It was in the shape of a vertical head of romaine lettuce. Water had dripped continuously on the point in the center, probably for many months, just enough to maintain the structure, but not enough to wash it away or damage it with any force. Various cycles of partial thaw (to slush?) and refreeze had cause ice “leaves” to sag outward from the center toward the perimeter, then refreeze solid before sluffing off. Each night’s temperature of 10-15 degrees F. would set the structure in place for the next day’s partial melting and sagging outward. It never got warm enough to do any serious melting, and the structure, in the bottom of a gulch, probably got 1-2 hours of sunshine at the most. This huge ice structure must have been there for months, slowly modified by ever so gentle forces of heating and freezing, never enough to cause it to collapse outright.
It was remarkable sight, a huge ever-changing ice stalagmite kept at a temperature just right to maintain its shape. I will never forget it. I saw it before I ever had enough money to afford a camera, so all I have is the memory.

johanna
December 28, 2012 9:09 pm

Willis, great to hear that you are a fan of Gerard (I mis-spelled it the first time) Manley Hopkins. He must have been an awkward priest. I can just imagine the priestocracy, humming and ha-ing – what the h*** are we going to do with this guy?
Anyway, further to your comment about him ‘worshipping nature’ – I suspect that you have committed a heresy. There are countless poems and poets, some very good, who worship nature. What I like about “Pied Beauty” is that it also says:
“Landscape plotted and pieced—fold, fallow, and plough; 5
And áll trádes, their gear and tackle and trim.
All things counter, original, spare, strange;
Whatever is fickle, freckled (who knows how?)
With swift, slow; sweet, sour; adazzle, dim;”
GMH regarded humans’ toil as part of the Lord’s work. Like you (and me) he wondered at the tools and output of tradesmen and craftsmen. He seems also to have been interested in science and inventions. As a great intellect, he was not bounded by conventional views about Man and Nature.
Thanks to those who have shared their experiences here. They have brightened my day considerably. I’ve had a few similar ones, but am clearly outclassed.
Oh, and further to my mention of watching my cycad sprout a new round of fronds (which happens once a year in this climate) – despite snailbait to the wazoo, I found one contentedly munching on the precious new fronds this morning. Bastard. I flung it to oblivion.
It had overcome distance, snailbait, and a rough, spiky surface to feast on the new fronds. They must be like catnip to cats, or bacon to dogs, or something. The snail passed by several juicy, leafy plants to munch on my once-in-a-year fronds.
Anyone who imagines that nature is kind and benevolent has been watching too many Disney films.

Bob in Castlemaine
December 28, 2012 9:53 pm

Great piece Willis. It’s good sometimes to recall the wonder of the world that surrounds us, it’s too easy to become entrapped in our own bubble.
“Your” German ditch wooden channel reminded me of a bit of “old timer” ingenuity that I came across a few years back (I hasten to add not as a youngster) where the old time prospector miners of central Victoria had encountered a steep narrow gully with one of their many aqueducts dug to bring water to their mining works. Rather than dig another half mile or so in the hard shale ground along the contour of the gully they constructed a siphon, using tinsmith techniques to fashion the pipe, and a wire rope catenary to support it. That it still remains after around 120 years is testament to the ability of these pioneers.
I did photograph the construction on an old mobile, but couldn’t find the picture today, when next I’m in the area I’ll photograph it again.

markx
December 28, 2012 10:26 pm

Marvelous writing Willis … a very wonderful read.
Jae just seeks to remind us that everyone in fact does have a voice.
And Jae’s apparently happens to be a whiney, snarky one with that slight echoing tone caused by speaking whilst using a finger to excavate debri from one’s nostril.

Philip Bradley
December 29, 2012 12:01 am

There was a puzzle from my childhood that I only solved 30 years later outside an office highrise in the Singapore central business district of all places.
One of my favourite pastimes as a child was fishing in the small ponds that dotted the woods and fields where I lived. The ponds good for fishing were old claypits dug by hand hundreds of years ago. These ponds were small, not much more than 10 meters across and usually sheltered by trees. The water surface was generally as flat and calm as the proverbial mill pond. While the water in the ponds was turbid from the fish constantly stirring up the clay bottom.
When you are fishing you spent a lot of time watching the surface of the water, and I observed a phenomena that you don’t see on larger bodies of water, thin lines of disturbance that develop across the surface. These thin lines were invariable straight, although some times they shifted in direction, but were rarely curved or irregular. They were typically 2 to 4 meters in length, propagated at perhaps 1 or 2 meters per second, and perhaps a centimeter or two wide.
The puzzle was were these disturbances caused by fish swimming just below the surface, invisible in the turbid water, or was the breeze blowing over the surface the cause. As a child I never satisfactorily answered the question.
Fast forward 30 years, and I am standing outside the Singapore highrise waiting for a friend. At the side of the entrance there is a water feature comprising a granite pool about 5 meters across and not much more than a centimeter deep. Across the surface I see identical lines forming in the light breeze as the ponds of my childhood. Puzzle solved, it was the breeze.

Don Monfort
December 29, 2012 12:30 am

Willis,
Self-importance is best kept to one’s self.

markx
December 29, 2012 2:42 am

Don Monfort says: December 29, 2012 at 12:30 am
“..Willis,…..Self-importance is best kept to one’s self….”
More so are some people’s opinions.

Roger Carr
December 29, 2012 4:14 am

This guy had the Willis in him:
     Norman Joseph Woodland, co-inventor of the barcode that labels nearly every product in stores worldwide, has died aged 91.
     One day he drew Morse dots and dashes as he sat on the beach and absent-mindedly left his fingers in the sand where they traced a series of parallel lines.
     “It was a moment of inspiration. Instead of dots and dashes I can have thick and thin bars’,” (his daughter) Susan Woodland said.

Keith G
December 29, 2012 4:41 am

“It was through the feeling of wonder that men now and at first began to philosophise.” – Aristotle.

December 29, 2012 4:41 am

Beautiful!
I share this sense of awe and fascination, but for me it always was and still is the fascination of being able to watch animals go about their business. Once I got severely scolded for being late coming back from school. Well, there was this tree, and there were ants crawling up and down the trunk. I was riveted. I was seven years at that time, and all my life this fascination never left me. Didn’t matter if it was sheep playing (yes, they do), or watching a wasp going in and out of her burrow, or barnacles waving their tentacles under water, feeding, scallops swimming, whatever: if it moves, I’m riveted!
As for ice marbles: I still got a smooth stone I picked up on Chesil Beach, which has a hollow on one side,in which rests a tiny, round and smooth pebble of that same material. Who knows how long it took to arrive at that form, who knows how long it sat on the beach where I found it …
Losing one’s childhood feeling of awe and wonder is the worst thing to happen to anybody.

Lady in Red
December 29, 2012 5:29 am

Willis…. I’m sorry. I did not know the “jae backstory.”
However, I stand by my comment:
There is a flow, beauty to your essay. jae’s comment was irrelevant noise, easily passed over, ignored — which I did… ….until *you* elevated it. Then, suddenly, out of the blue *your* tone changed: yelling, screaming, whining, complaining as it were…. breaking *my* mood.
In future, I’d suggest ignoring him. Or, if you must, something simple and dismissive, implying your backstory history.
Without that backstory history, the comment did not reflect well upon you. ….Lady in Red

Don Monfort
December 29, 2012 7:48 am

markx,
Let me guess. The people you are talking about are those whose opinions differ from your own.
I am sorry that my less than complete fawning adoration for everything Willis says upsets you. I humbly suggest that you avert thine eyes, whenever you see my name preceeding a comment.

Curious Canuck
December 29, 2012 8:16 am

We have a colloquial honourific here in eastern Canada that can be applied so well to Willis.
With all compliment sir, you are a gentleman and a scholar and an ol’ trawl hauler.
Thank you for yet another wonderful read and tight lines to you.