Newsflash: tropical species adapt to temperature changes

From Wiley Sciences, some interesting admissions, though I have to think that insects are far more tolerant than they give them credit for. But, take it all with a grain of salt, because it is just more modeling output.

Some like it hot: Tropical species ‘not as vulnerable’ to climate change

Functional Ecology (journal)
Functional Ecology (journal) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

extinction

In the face of a changing climate many species must adapt or perish. Ecologists studying evolutionary responses to climate change forecast that cold-blooded tropical species are not as vulnerable to extinction as previously thought. The study, published in the British Ecological Society’s Functional Ecology, considers how fast species can evolve and adapt to compensate for a rise in temperature.

The research, carried out at the University of Zurich, was led by Dr Richard Walters, now at Reading University, alongside David Berger now at Uppsala University and Wolf Blanckenhorn, Professor of Evolutionary Ecology at Zurich.

“Forecasting the fate of any species is difficult, but it is essential for conserving biodiversity and managing natural resources,” said lead author Dr Walters.

“It is believed that climate change poses a greater risk to tropical cold-blooded organisms (ectotherms), than temperate or polar species. However, as potential adaptation to climate change has not been considered in previous extinction models we tested this theory with a model forecasting evolutionary responses.”

Ectotherms, such as lizards and insects, have evolved a specialist physiology to flourish in a stable tropical environment. Unlike species which live in varied habitats tropical species operate within a narrow range of temperatures, leading to increased dangers if those temperatures change.

“When its environment changes an organism can respond by moving away, adapting its physiology over time or, over generations, evolving,” said Walters. “The first two responses are easy to identify, but a species’ ability to adapt quick enough to respond to climate change is an important and unresolved question for ecologists.”

The team explored the idea that there are also evolutionary advantages for species adapted to warmer environments. The ‘hotter is better’ theory suggests that species which live in high temperatures will have higher fitness, resulting from a shorter generation time. This may allow them to evolve relatively quicker than species in temperate environments.

The team sought to directly compare the increased risk of extinction associated with lower genetic variance, owing to temperature specialisation, with the lowered risk of extinction associated with a shorter generation time.

“Our model shows that the evolutionary advantage of a shorter generation time should compensate species which are adapted to narrow temperature ranges,” said Walters. “We forecast that the relative risk of extinction is likely to be lower for tropical species than temperate ones.”

“The tropics are home to the greatest biodiversity on earth, so it imperative that the risk of extinction caused by climate change is understood,” concluded Walters. “While many questions remain, our theoretical predictions suggest tropical species may not be as vulnerable to climate warming as previously thought.”

###
Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
32 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rick Bradford
August 16, 2012 9:38 pm

Well, of course, Green/Leftists believe that nothing can prosper without government intervention, so the idea of tropical species being able to adapt to climate change is prima facie absurd
/sarc

Editor
August 16, 2012 10:24 pm

striptubes says:
August 16, 2012 at 5:28 pm

I note with some dismay that the line break html tag (br) doesn’t seem to be working even though WordPress says it should be. Is there any way to get a preview of what my comment will look like so I know if things are going to work?

See the bottom of my Guide to WUWT, note the icon up on the righthand nav bar.
See also the “Test” link on the top nav bar, you can try stuff out there.
Finally, there’s a firefox extension that can help, see the links on the test page to GreaseMonkey and CA assistant. I tried them out, and didn’t like a couple things about them.
Mods – The test page is stuck on bold at http://wattsupwiththat.com/test-2/#comment-994949 – please fix when you have a chance. I wish WP would fix that bug.

H.R.
August 17, 2012 2:39 am

Steve C says:
August 16, 2012 at 11:58 am
“Should the insects appear to be adapting too well, and thinking of those grains of salt, there’s always this.”
I followed your link, Steve C, and I find that the downside is one would be charged immediately with a-salt. OTOH, if the specs are accurate, one could never be charged with battery.

Brian H
August 17, 2012 3:50 am

Arg, the brain-pain.
“…stable … with narrow temperature ranges…” tropics require fast adaptation to climate change? Which will affect the tropics almost not at all? Someone please ‘splain why this isn’t jaw-droppin’ stoopid, pliz?

ferdberple
August 17, 2012 6:44 am

“The tropics are home to the greatest biodiversity on earth, so it imperative that the risk of extinction caused by climate change is understood”
==============
From this “scientists” conclude that warming is bad. If warming is bad, then why is the “greatest biodiversity on earth” in the warmest region of the earth?
Surely if warming is bad, then the greatest biodiversity should occur at the poles.

Mike M
August 17, 2012 9:37 am

The whole issue appears moot because there is no evidence of anything but natural variability in the tropics. I think that so because that is where the greatest amount of negative feedback from water vapor occurs. Simply knowing how much higher tropical thunderstorms reach in altitude and how more frequently they form for every degree increase might be enough of a basis alone to assert that continued spending to examine tropical species vulnerability to global warming is nothing more than a waste of money.
Wow, there’s been a whopping ~0.2 degree warming in the last 30 years, all those critters are gonna die!
http://www.climate4you.com/images/NOAA%20SST-Tropics%20GlobalMonthlyTempSince1979%20With37monthRunningAverage.gif
What if the moon fell to earth? Oh my! Let’s fund a study for that possibility…

Steve C
August 17, 2012 12:10 pm

H.R. – Glad you got a chuckle out of it, as I did from your comment. I dunno how much longer I can hold out without one …