
This post has nothing to do with science or climate, but it does go to illustrate how life gets more complex each day thanks to increased bureaucracy, and that you should take nothing for granted in the world of air travel today.
It is also an apology to the chair and attendees, of the Family Forest Landowners and Management Conference where I had been invited to speak today at 2PM. For the first time in my life, due to circumstances outside of my control, I had to bow out of a speaking engagement at the very last minute. My sincerest apologies to all of you there.
Where I live, air travel isn’t always easy, particularly since I have to drive 90 miles to the nearest major airport, Sacramento, and then board from there, which I’ve pretty much gotten down to a science, or so I thought until yesterday.
I think you will all find the following story of the Murphy’s Law domino effect in action quite amusing, and in retrospect, it is really the only way one can look at it now.
It all started out well enough, I even thought I’d be arriving at the airport early.
The first domino was me misreading the flight time before leaving for the airport, though I didn’t know this until a critical moment later. I thought it was 3:25PM, but I read the wrong page, and that was the departure time of my connecting flight. But being a broadcaster, where missing a deadline to be on-air is a fate worse than death, I always make sure I meet deadlines, so I planned to arrive two hours early because I’d known that the Sacramento airport had recently undergone a major renovation, and there might be some changes that affect me. I was right about that, I just didn’t know how much.
Second domino – I arrived at 1:25 PM at the Sacramento airport and discovered that the Southwest airlines terminal had been moved from the familiar and easy to use terminal A to the new glass and stainless steel cathedral known as the NEW terminal “B”, with the old one (also easy to use) having been demolished. So I drove around and reentered the terminal loop to go to the new terminal. I was looking for parking at the new terminal, and I drove around the loop twice looking for daily parking. I could see the daily parking lot for terminal B, remarking to myself there were few cars in it, but couldn’t seem to find the entrance. I decided to drive into the uber expensive hourly lot, and ask the gate attendant…I had plenty of time…or so I thought. The gate attendant explained that there was no daily parking for new terminal B, as it hadn’t been completed yet. My options for parking were the terminal A parking garage (which I’ve used almost every time for 10 years) or the economy lot out in the next county with a half hour shuttle bus ride that stops at every stop even if no people are waiting to get on/off. I opted for the garage, even though I knew it would be a long walk between terminals, but hey, I was two hours early, I had plenty of time. I’d planned for hiccups like this.
![SMF[1]](http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/smf1.jpg?resize=500%2C333&quality=83)
Gone are the days when I could park my vehicle in the parking garage, walk about 1oo yards, check in, walk 50 yards, go through security, then walk another 50 yards and be at the gate. No, that simplicity is gone forever with this new hallowed glass and steel place of bureaucratic worship. It’s a hike.
The third domino came when I walked up to the check in counter to check my bag. And the attendant admonished me to not speak to her, but use the LCD touchscreen because she was “only there to apply the luggage tag”. I thought to myself “and you’ll be a replaced by a robot soon I’ll bet”. Completing the task, the LCD screen flashed up a red angry warning LATE CHECK IN – NO BAG GUARANTEE. Puzzled, since I had “plenty of time” I dared to make conversation again with the attendant and ask why this happened. Looking at me like I’m sort sort of idiot she curtly replied “Well that’s what happens when you check in 10 minutes before the plane leaves”. It was then to my horror that I discovered I’d misread the wrong flight time, and indeed I had only ten minutes to board. So I said, “there’s no way I’ll be able to make this, let’s just look at other options”. Again she replied, “Well you need to try, THEN we’ll figure it out if you miss the flight.”.
So now I was on a mission, thoughts of a leisurely coffee and late lunch turned to panic in an unfamiliar terminal I’d never been to before in my life.
The fourth domino (and a couple of minutes lost) came when I started looking for the security gate…it turns out there isn’t any in this new aviation cathedral, but you now have to board a train to get to security and from there, the gate. Sigh, it used to be so easy at this airport.
![6785723660_f511d8c77e_z[1]](http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/6785723660_f511d8c77e_z1.jpg?resize=640%2C512&quality=83)
So another two-minute wait for the train…and now I’m down to six minutes left. The train takes a minute, thankfully security was not busy and there were only two ahead of me….but you know how it is, you have to walk that back and forth rope maze thingy to get the 25 feet to the checkpoint.
I get through the driver’s license/ID checkpoint and get to the baggage scanners…and proceed to tear off my belt, my shoes, keys, watch, ring, etc and pack it into the tray for the x-ray machine, something else I’ve got down to a speed science. I got that done, shoved in the trays, and then I saw it, yet another metal and glass behemoth – the full body scanner. I’d never used one before, but I figured “OK this will be quick, they are designed for speed, right”?
Wrong – the fifth domino was my wallet, which I’ve never ever had to remove before in any scanner I’ve gone through. along with the usual assortment of credit cards, I keep an ultra-thin plastic USB drive. It seems the new full body scanner decided it didn’t like that, and on the display put a big red dot on my butt while somewhere I was imagining the robot from Lost in Space flailing it’s arms arms and shouting “DANGER DANGER! WILL ROBINSON”.
So I figured “no biggie”, I put my wallet in a bowl and run it through the x-ray right and I’m done right? Well, no. you see it seems my ticket was flagged due to my lateness and checking a bag, which apparently is one of those “signatures” that bad guys like to use because they want to spend as little time in the terminal as possible to minimize the chance that somebody might “finger” them.
So I get the red carpet treatment reserved for those special cases. Full body pat down, full body magnetometer wand, full body sniffer patch rubdown looking for GSR and explosives residue. Then some questioning, inspection of my laptop, and then when it is decided I’m not a threat, I get unceremoniously ejected like the Soup Nazi on Seinfeld where he yells NEXT!
So I look at my watch as I’m putting it back on and it’s a minute past boarding time now. I figured I’m toast, but hustle to the gate anyway. Naturally, gate B-18 is the furthest one away from security. And of course, the plane is gone.
I’m about to see the sixth domino fall.
So I ask (well, blather excitedly) the gate attendant “Wanda” about all this, harping a bit about security delays after she says to me “ I got the call from ticketing we waited as long as we could” I asked about alternate flights. It seems that the next two flights at 5:30PM and 6 something were tours of the western United States, going in the reverse direction I needed, down to Las Vegas, then to Salt Lake City, and then to Portland both arriving at Spokane after 11PM. I could get them on standby too. “Great, how about tomorrow?”. Well I could get there, but then I have an hour to gather bags and rental car, then drive almost another two hours from Spokane to Moscow Idaho where the forest conference was.
Déjà vu is a funny thing, right then I got a flashback about the last time I was flagged as a potential terrorist on a trip to Idaho, way back in 1985. US Marshalls were involved in that one. And this was before today’s heightened security theater.
I’ll share that story.
+++++
I had been demoing weather display equipment in Boise in the winter of 1985. In those days I lugged around an IBM-AT with a 16 color CRT monitor, and a separate broadcast quality Sony NTSC monitor in specially designed cases like musicians use for road trips. I was my own roadie lugging around over 100 pounds of computer equipment at a time when people lugging around such equipment was uncommon.
![2009-08-20-clean-IBM-AT[1]](http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/2009-08-20-clean-ibm-at1.jpg?resize=640%2C480&quality=83)
The next day I lugged the equipment over to the TV station and set it up. Gathered everyone, and started the demo. About 5 minutes in, the IBM-AT (8 mHz) crashed and gave me a BSOD. I rebooted, started over, same thing at the same point in the demo… I apparently still had some bad memory chip(s). So I asked for their indulgence of 30 minutes, tore the machine apart, reseated all the DIP memory on the motherboard and tried again. No dice. At this point, it was a lost cause. I had to abandon the demonstration.
Meanwhile, the Denver TV station I had called on a week earlier wanted a follow-up, so I had to fly back to Denver, lugging my dead equipment along. Another visit to a ComputerLand store first, more troubleshooting and parts replacement and it looked like I had it. So I went over to KUSA-TV and setup for the demo again…and did the demo, I got about 90% through and got another BSOD. I explained the equipment had been damaged in Boise, and what I’d been doing to repair it, but I could see they weren’t too trustful of the equipment. Remember then, computers weren’t widely accepted and broadcast TV equipment was single use discrete component design, all built like tanks. Tektronix and silver-solder and all that was the norm…because on-air failure during live TV was just intolerable. Nobody wanted a BSOD on-air.
I packed up and left, feeling miserable, and drove to the Denver Stapleton airport in my rental car. I was two hours early, I had “plenty of time”.
I dropped off the rental car and then had to wait a few more minutes for the larger of the shuttle buses that the attendant assured me had the room in the rear needed to accommodate my collection of three roadie cases plus luggage. No problem I said, I had “plenty of time”.
![IMG_2942[1]](http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/img_29421.jpg?resize=300%2C300&quality=83)
Great. At least I had “plenty of time”. The shuttle bus driver calls for a tow truck on the radio. So we all sit around waiting, thinking this will just be a few minutes, a few minutes turns into a half hour, another call on the radio – “we’ll be there soon” comes the response. The half hour turns into 45 minutes, and I’m thinking up ways now that I can get my cases out (the biggest one has wheels) and push them the rest of the way to the terminal about 1000 yards away….but, before I can complete those thoughts, the tow truck finally arrives, and moves the car and we are on our way.
By this time I have about 30 minutes left before the flight, and I still have to check my beasts of baggage. The shuttle bus pulls up to the terminal, I flag a skycap, explain my situation and hand him $30. He said he’d handle it, and I had to go to the ticket counter to pay the usual excess baggage fees. So he tells me just leave them here, go to the ticket counter (visible through the glass) and he’d bring in my roadies cases to get it all settled.
So, of course there’s a line. And I wait, keeping an eye on my roadies cases through the big window, waiting for him to move it. My turn comes, but as I glance back, another skycap has the cases loaded on a cart and is headed down the sidewalk, away from the ticket counter. So I take off, flag him down, explain, and he says “well they were unattended”. I look around for the guy I originally tipped well, and he’s nowhere to be seen. I’m down to 20 minutes so I say to this skycap, pressing money into his palm while explaining, look please just bring it to the ticket counter for me?
So we hustle up to the ticket counter, wait again, I pay the fees, get my boarding pass and I’m off. I still have to get through security and to the gate. Security in those days was much simpler, but once again I got hung up at security because I had tools in my carry on bag…the tools I used to tear apart and rebuild the computer, – I had forgotten to put back in the roadie case. It is the scourge of carrying computer equipment and tools and being late. So I explain, I show them my card and my brochures and why I’d be carrying computer tools. They pass me through, tools and all, since I obviously was not a threat, just some nerdy computer guy.
I’m down to ten minutes, and I recreated the famous O.J. Simpson TV commercial for Hertz where I’m dashing through the terminal to make my plane. And of course, as Murphy’s Law would have it, the gate I need is the one furthest away from the security gates. It must be an unwritten corollary to Murphy’s Law that the later you are, the further away the gate is.
I get to the gate, and they are just starting to close the door, but they saw my breathless panting state, unable to say much but “sorry”, took my boarding pass, and let me on.
Walking down the ramp, I’m congratulating myself for pulling this off against the odds, and I can’t wait to get home and get my computer working right again. I board the plane the stewardess directs me to my seat, which of course is the one way in the back next to the restroom (a consequence of being late). As I walk down the aisle, I notice the strangest thing – something I’ve never seen before or since. About a third of the overhead baggage compartment doors are missing. At first I thought they were just “up”, but they had tape across them. “Bizarre” I thought to myself, what next? So settling into my seat, I pushed the attendant call button and inquired with the stewardess about the missing baggage doors. She explained calmly that “the original aircraft for this flight had a mechanical issue and this was the replacement aircraft” I said, “yeah, but wouldn’t you call these missing baggage doors a mechanical issue”? She assured me everything was fine, not to worry, that “the supervisor has approved the aircraft”.
So I sat there, thinking about the run of bad luck I’ve had in the past few days, and visions of some mechanic under pressure to deliver an aircraft gets the call in mid maintenance and hustles this one into service, just running a line down the “approved” boxes on the check-sheet and signing it in the rush because he doesn’t have a choice. I’m thinking to myself, “I’m about to fly on an incomplete aircraft”. Further visions of nuts missing those all important tie down wires to keep them from vibrating loose also went through my mind. I decided right then, I didn’t want to fly on this aircraft.
So I got up, grabbed my carry-on bag and headed for the front door. I explained to the stewardess there that I had no faith in the mechanical integrity of the aircraft, pointed to the doors, and headed up the ramp.
When I got to the gate desk, I explained, said “sorry” again like 25 times, and said to please just have my baggage held at the destination. They said to “wait here please, we are working on this”. “OK “I said and sat down. I watch through the window as the plane gets pushed away from the gate by the ramp tractor, glad I’m not on it. They disconnect the tractor…and the plane just sits there not moving. I’m thinking “A-ha!” they’ve got some other aircraft trouble, and I was sure that thought was confirmed when a few minutes later they hitch up the ramp tractor and pull the plane back to the gate.
I asked the gate agent, “why are they bringing the plane back, does it have mechanical trouble?’. She replied, calmly “no, they are going to get your baggage off the plane”, and then repeated to me again “please wait here” with a bit of urgency in her voice. I said “no that’s not necessary, just have the baggage held at the baggage counter at the destination and I’ll pick it up when I get the next flight.”. And she repeated “please, just wait here and we will get this sorted out”.
So I’m standing there, puzzled, and it hit me. And just about the time I realized why they were getting my baggage off the plane two guys in suits appeared on either side of me and asked “Are you Mr. Watts?”. “Yes” I replied. “Come with us, we need to inspect your baggage”. I asked “who are you ?“…and they showed me badges and stated they were with the US Air Marshalls. Great I thought to myself, “they think I’m a bomber or something”.
So they walk either side of me and escort me downstairs, into some non-descript room, and I get the questions…”Why did you get off the plane?” “What is in those big cases” etc. etc. And I proceed to tell the story much as I’ve told you readers.
They weren’t satisfied. They wanted to inspect the roadie cases. And they were wheeled in and I was asked to produce the key to the padlocks on them. I dutifully handed the key over to the agent, and he unlocked the roadie cases and opened the lids.
“See”, I said, “just like I told you, computers and monitors” and I produced my card and brochure again.
“You need to prove it to us Mr. Watts”, one agent said. “We need to look inside the cases”.
I said “Well you are in luck, I just happen to have tools for that right here in my bag”.
“Sir, open them up.”
So I spent the next 15 minutes taking the cases off the IBM-AT and, pulling out the hard drive (which in those days was a 10 pound beast by itself holding all of 20 megabytes), and opening the cases to the monitors.
Finally satisfied that my story was true and that I was not any sort of threat, an agent said “you are free to go, but think twice before you get off an airplane again after you’ve checked baggage”.
Again after saying “sorry” about 25 times and thanking them for not hauling me off to jail, I reassembled my equipment, repacked it, and headed off with the beasts of baggage stacked and rolling on the 4 casters on the biggest case towards the door.
At this point I’m pretty toasted, and all I wanted to do was just hibernate in a hotel somewhere and have a few stiff drinks.
I headed for the ground transportation area, got another rental car, and rolled the beasts of baggage out to the curb waiting for the shuttle bus. The shuttle pulled up, the driver opened the door, and said “you again?”. So I sheepishly loaded up and explained to him what happened. He was guffawing all the way to the rental lot. I got a new rental vehicle, jammed all the road cases into the trunk and back seat, and took off to find the nearest hotel. I remembered seeing a Holiday Inn on the way into the airport, so I headed there.
One might think this would be the end of the story, but no.
Once I got to the Holiday Inn, I parked in the covered entryway, and went up to the desk, waiting my turn because there were two people ahead of me. I go to the desk, asked if there were any rooms available, and she said “we are nearly full, but you are in luck, we have one left.” . “Great! I’ll take it.”.
As I’m filling out the form, I hear this awful rumble, getting louder and louder, and turn around to see a veritable horde of motorcycles coming into the parking lot. Lots of gnarly looking folks were riding them. Looking back at the desk clerk, she sensed my astonishment at this sight and said “that’s why we are almost booked”.
I said, “Thanks, but after the week I’ve had, I’ve changed my mind.”.
So I drove to the next available hotel, asked if they expected any hordes of motorcyclists (they didn’t) proceeded to order room service (and several stiff drinks) and stayed there for two whole days, doing nothing but not worrying about anything with no plans to go anywhere. The computer remained packed.
++++++
So yesterday, recounting in flashback my previous troubles that originated in Idaho with computer equipment, live presentations, and air travel, and presented with what were ugly and untenable travel options, I decided that there are times one just has to know when to walk away from air travel, and I did.
Again, my apologies to the Family Forest Landowners and Management Conference.
E M smith
Its bad enough when the computer won’t tell you where the book is located-like your library.
Imagine if you had then gone to the bookstore, picked up the book and taken it to the check out…then the power went down.
You wouldnt be allowed to pay for it yet you had the book in your hand! Utter frustration.
I don’t know if anything can be done to reduce this over dependence on over complex technology which of coiurse makes our lives easier in many ways but complicates it in many others.And when a hacker or another Carrington event strikes….
tonyb
Thanks Anthony! It helps to hear of other stories from the Twilight Zone.
I once had the priviledge of missing three flights in a row at SFO – trying to get to BOS. Missed the first due to a traffic accident with no alt routes, the next two because the Reps wouldn’t tell me anything other than the “next flight out” – one to LA, one to MCA all departing within 15 min. I ran from one gate to another – “no they won’t hold the flight, you’ll just have to run.”
Next to Saint Louis’ Lambert Field, SFO is my least favorite airport. One can clearly see that the Major and other political personages have never had to hike to the tram to get to a rentacar. Just more of the “We love the proletariat, it’s people we can’t stand,” mentality. Get the cattle through the airport as efficiently as possible, while they take Gov jets, or private jets.
Smokey says:
Those were the good old days, pre-9/11/2001. Muslim bastids! They screwed it up for everyone.
Just an excuse. The Gov’t would have found a way to do it regardless…
How about an airport for only departures, arrivals and plane handling not the current combo of shopping mall and airline sales lounge- that could be very secure and simple if approaching the airport was limited for the public to trains.
I myself just did a round trip over the weekend that brought me onto route I80 for about half of PA.
The striking thing is the long line of fossil fueled semi’s that transport the bulk of our daily purchases. The idea back in the 50’s(Eisenhower?) included the strategy of diversifying the transportation network for national commerce over roadways to reduce the effectiveness of nuclear attacks on cities that would cut off railway service because they all generally connect through cities. Logically, we saw how effective it was to disable German or German controlled rail lines back in WW2 and realized our rail service in the 40’s was just as vulnerable to Soviet attack via nukes on an even larger scale. (And perhaps seeing the effectiveness of our Red Ball Express helped with the realization as well.)
Our interstate road system put a serious kink in USSR nuke targeting strategy back then. But now here are the commies back with a new strategy to impede greedy capitalist commerce via cutting off the fuel that powers our roadways.
Wake up! They are throttling us NOW! Stop them.
The difficulties of ensuring we are all safe when going by air are understood. However, there still have to be logical reasons for all security procedures. e.g. An airline Captain described how he had to queue with everyone else to go through security (not an issue in itself). He had a bottle of water which was confiscated. He explained he would be working in a dry environement etc etc. and asked a supervisor why the water had been taken away. The super replied “you might take over the flight”. The Captain replied “That is my intention”.
A friend once flew himself from Biggin Hill near London to Norwich, in a single engined plane, had a cup of tea in the terminal and went to return to the plane. He was stopped and made to go through the body scanner!
Stephen Skinner says:
e.g. An airline Captain described how he had to queue with everyone else to go through security (not an issue in itself). He had a bottle of water which was confiscated. He explained he would be working in a dry environement etc etc. and asked a supervisor why the water had been taken away. The super replied “you might take over the flight”. The Captain replied “That is my intention”.
Do you have a link for that? I searched, but couldn’t find anything about it.
I just signed up for DSL service (yes, I’m behind the times in this regard, but dialup was becoming intolerably slow) just days before reading this post, and I am literally shocked by the amount of regulatory meddling involved compared to just a few yrs ago. Reading their Terms of Service, it’s like signing your life away — we have the right to remotely inspect your computer for viruses, bots, and to track your internet activities, etc, etc.
1984 may have only been off by several decades. Well, I’ll just have to find some programs out there to stifle their tracking & meddling. The game is afoot….
Best flights? Five “Nylon’ trips (New York – London) on Concorde before she was unfortunately retired. Ah well, my carbon footprint must be reasonable, though nothing compared to the artists who jet around the world to lecture us constantly.
One of the worst was a flight home to Caracas from Lima in 1997. A Friday night, but I had made sure that the colombian national airline flight was straight through, even though we were scheduled to make a stop in Bogota.
Got to Bogota an hour late after an unscheduled stop in Medellin to refuel. WTF? But still, same flight through to Caracas, right? Wrong. When we got to Bogota we all had to disembark. Apparently it was going to be a plane change with the same flight number! That was the first and last time that has happened to me and the first indication that my carefully laid plans were going pear-shaped. Only real problem was that the other plane had left, 45 minutes earlier. No more flights until the morning. We were all lined up to get vouchers to go to a hotel. This was delayed by an italian guy who insisted on repeatedly going back to the front of the line to argue with the young lady who was handing out the vouchers. What got my shorts in a bunch was the smile on his face every time he returned. He was getting his jollies at our expense.
When we finally got on the bus, he got off again to discuss with the ground crew. I made a comment that it would be better for all of us if he would shut his piehole: let us get to the hotel and not make a bad situation worse. His wife overheard and communicated this to him. He came and stood over me, but I stood up very quickly and looked down on him (in so many ways). He sat down again fortunately, or I might be writing this from a cell in a South American country.
At the checkin the staff were putting passengers two to a room. I politely refused to share with anyone. To the back of the queue I was sent. Finally when everyone else except a bolivian gentleman with a long ponytail and I were the only ones left there was a standoff. I said I would pay for my room and take it up after with the airline. I got my own room.
Next morning at checkout I was informed that the airline accepted the charge. A bit of an anticlimax in some sense.
At the airport, the only morning flight to Caracas was full. Another voucher received and back to the hotel to wait for the afternoon one. A phone call at 1:00pm; not to bother going to the airport as the afternoon flight had been cancelled. Down to reception to collect more vouchers for lunch and dinner. That evening I contemplated the odds of ever leaving or whether it would be necessary to apply for citizenship. Finally got home in the wee hours of Monday.
I still have the gift from the airline, a set of cutlery from the first class section.
It looks more like a rabbit than a chicken.
REPLY: it always helps to read the caption and look at images on a decent sized monitor – Anthony
My suggestion for a European wishing to visit America. Fly to Canada and drive across the border. You still will get the immigration process at the border, but Canadian airport security is at least more polite. Of course that kind of leaves southern locations off the itinerary unless you have a great deal of holiday time.
When I lived in England, one of my British coworkers asked me what I thought of his holiday plans to the States. He was going to fly into Orlando, do the Disney thing, drive to the grand canyon, then end at Anaheim to do the Disney thing there. I told him it sounded like a wonderful month’s holiday. That’s when he told me he only planned for 10 days. He didn’t seem to realize that it was 2500 miles to drive, and would take most of the 10 days. This was in the days before TSA, so I convinced him to fly from Orlando to Vegas and rent a car there for the rest of the trip. He and his family had a wonderful time. Now I’d have to advise him to extend his holiday and drive or make a less ambitious itinerary.
Back in 1981, my uncle, who was a physician, was driving me to LA International to catch an afternoon flight to Boise when we came upon a two-car collision accident that had happened at an intersection just a few minutes before.
As a physician, he was obligated to stop and render assistance. We were already running twenty minutes late at that point.
It took fifteen minutes to check everybody out — five people — plus a little more time to converse with the EMT’s who had arrived shortly afterward. After his initial examinations were done and the hand-off of responsibility to the EMT’s had taken place, we resumed our drive to LAX.
So we are now about forty minutes behind schedule. We arrive at the airport, we park at the closest garage, and then we boogey on over to the curbside luggage check in. We go through security and he goes with me to the gate. (Non-passengers could do that in 1981.) We arrive at the gate just as they are getting ready to close the door.
The last thing my uncle says to me before I go through the gate is this: “Just remember, if you are more than a minute early for any appointment, you are not making effective use of your time.”
In middle Asia ther is a saying; “Travel is a foretaste of the Hell to come”
Just imagine if TSA was the lowest bidder to manage Hell….
TonyG says:
March 21, 2012 at 7:49 am
Stephen Skinner says:
………The super replied “you might take over the flight”. The Captain replied “That is my intention”.
“Do you have a link for that? I searched, but couldn’t find anything about it.”
Sadly no. It was a radio phone-in discussing whether more regulation was needed to protect air passengers. As the title was slightly ‘leading the witness’ most people who rang in were in favour of the same or more regulation. Then this pilot rang in with his story. His main point was there is enough restrictions already but they should be applied intelligently, or words to that effect.
I am always disappointed when solutions for problems appear to be unrelated to the problem. I’m not necessarily talking about the restriction on bottled water, but, for example, when it was determined that the success of 9/11 was in part due to a failure of communication between the CIA and FBI, the solution was not to implement communication between the CIA and FBI but instead create a completely new department; Homeland security.
A bit of aluminum-hat thought. The US government would prefer that you not travel at all. Travel is far and away the best means of education. Among other important revelations is that in very few parts of the planet do people operate and think as you do at home. Regardless of how different they may be depicted in you high school geography class or the local media, reality is far, far different. Even within the US, the reality of regional differences can surprise you.
Having been to Europe, Israel, and post-USSR Ukraine, I can say for certain that US air-travel security is needlessly irritating, worse even than a former Iron Curtain country like Ukraine, where you could be stopped at any time and required to show “your papers, please.” I’ve often wished that the Israeli airport security people ran things here. They are trained immensely better than the TSA gang, are not dependent on technology and procedure, and are extremely effective. They are also polite, no nonsense, and will be nice about your falling asleep leaning against the passport-control counter.
Back in the late 60’s into the 80’s I used to fly around the East Coast on repair assignments for various OEM mainframe computer manufacturers, lugging my personal toolcase and a briefcase as carry-ons. I’d show up thirty minutes before flight time, get my pre-paid ticket at the front counter, then walk back 4-500 yards to the gates – before any Security was in place. On one flight the gentleman seated next to me had a Colt .45 1911 semi-automatic handgun in his briefcase. Neither I or the Stewardess had any problem with it. I also carried a four-inch folding knife regularly, but the only blood it’s tasted has been mine!
I believe it was the D.B. Cooper escapade that introduced Carry-On Bag Inspections. All bags (but not handbags!) were opened and looked in, just in case someone else was secreting a parachute. lol Anyway, the observant Security gal pulled out my 1/8th inch blade 14 inch long screwdriver, asking the Cop nearby if this could be considered a weapon and shouldn’t the case be in the hold. Cop looks in and said he doubted I would be doing any disassembly en-route!
Had several other run-ins over the years, but by the early 90’s just kept my knife with me. I refused to fly after 9-11, as the whole scenario has become intolerable, and I could drive to most of my calls in less time than flying, by the time you add in the exorbitant waste of time and treasure these misguided security measures invoke.
I pity that our children will never know the freedom we had, Anthony. Stay strong, and thank you.
C’mon folks. There are over 5,000 flights a day in the U.S. A few crazy stories are fun to read but those are really the exception not the rule. As a huge fan of WUWT and with great respect to Anthony, if you hadn’t caused the problem by misreading your flight info you would have not had a story to write. 🙂
James Ard says:
March 21, 2012 at 7:39 am
It looks more like a rabbit than a chicken.
REPLY: it always helps to read the caption and look at images on a decent sized monitor – Anthony
———————————————————————————————————-
Until I read the caption, it looked to me like a Thanksgiving turkey (and I stared at it for several seconds on my 21″ monitor, trying to figure out why they would hang that in an airport terminal).
Funny stories Anthony, and many commenters (sic?).
Anthony,
I hope you find this post. We were all deeply disappointed on your not making it to the conference, but on behalf of the Steering Committee for the Family Forest Landowners and Managers Conference, let me extend our sincerest sympathy to you and your family for your recent ordeal. Had you got on the plane in Sacramento, you would have had to deal with a winter storm on your return home. I was out all morning clearing 12” of snow from my road.
In retrospect we should have recommended you fly into Lewiston, ID on Delta, if possible, but I admit SWA and Spokane are my preferred airline and route. Your experiences with Idaho travel appear to represent all of my worst trips rolled into two, but mine had snow in St. Louis and rain from Washington DC to Jackson, MS on to the Florida panhandle, DOD classified documents, wrong aircraft and a blizzard in Albuquerque. Fortunately, I did not go to jail either. I would like to assure you that it is not Idaho. Our state is a beautiful place and we hope you will attempt to return soon. I must admit, though, the only place I have lost my luggage, was in Spokane after connecting through Salt Lake.
As it turned out with some quick research on http://www.wattsupwiththat.com and http://www.surfacestations.org, I was able to describe the objectives of the surface station project, quote the statistics on error and present the recent post of NCDC mean temperatures for the last decade for the US. I described the problems with IPCC Global Circulation Model temperature projections, compared these projections for the PNW for 2000-2020 to the downturn in mean temperatures for the last decade in the PNW and the US, and addressed the deep solar minimum we are entering. With this limited view, I was able to link our first talk on landowner perceptions on Climate Change to our third talk on the “Adaptability of Western White Pine to a Changing Climate.” So it turned out to be a three legged stool with a slight tilt as I tried to second guess what you would present and made a weak attempt to describe a coherent argument. We were also able to substitute another presentation to fill in the remaining time. Ironically, a member of the Society of American Foresters presented strategy and polling data associated with a political action in California to convince largely Democratic opponents of the need to address the overstocked condition of California forests through commercial thinning.
I want to extend a personal invitation to you for R&R in Idaho. I live off-grid inside a National Forest on 80 acres of private timberland that my wife and I are in the process of restoring to a sustainable, commercial tree farm. We are Idaho Forest Stewards and members of both the Idaho Forest Owners Association and the American Tree Farm System. No highways, no phone lines, no power poles – just two mountain streams, two horses, two dogs, two cats and three chickens. Thank you very much for agreeing to speak to our group and for your valient attempt to get here.
Sincerely,
Director Idaho Forest Owners Association
Whoops! Meant valiant not valient.
Alan Watt says:
March 20, 2012 at 5:19 pm
During WWII the US military essentially operated an airline to get officers to destinations all aournd the world. It was called The Air Transport Command (wiki here ). My father told me a sign often posted in their facilities was “It takes time and patience to travel by air”.
Some things never change.
Yup. When the Air Force changed the name to Military Airlift Command (MAC), the only thing that changed was the name. We used to say that MAC was the abbreviation for “Maybe Airplane Come”…
^^^
Niiiice
Off-topic, something to cheer you up, Anthony, to know your efforts are counting:
Donna’s book is in the Canadian Senate
http://nofrakkingconsensus.com/2012/03/21/canadas-senate-david-suzuki-the-delinquent-teenager/
correction: “to cheer you on”
!
It’s wonderful what one can learn about a country reading threads such as this. You sound great people; although I am a trifle puzzled by your airoplane stories. I thought you all traveled about in Air Force Ones and had limo connections?
Sorry, I’m a little late to the party.
I’ve certainly not flown as much as some who have commented here, but have probably flown more than most people in the US. My Dad used to work for United Airlines, so we flew quite a bit, on standby, when I was growing up. I don’t really remember any bad experiences through the 60s and 70s.
Didn’t fly much in the 80s (apart from flying to Germany while in the Army) and 90s (apart from a couple of vacations, see below). But in twenty hundred I made a career change, and became an IT consultant. As a result, I was traveling several times a month.
On 9/11, I was on a project in Dallas, and was stuck there for three weeks. Ironically, the smoothest flight experience I ever had was that first flight after 9/11. The security line was empty, the airport was empty, the plane was half empty. Everything went smooth as silk.
My worst experience was after a return flight from the UK in Spring 1994. I was in the international arrivals terminal at Dulles Airport in Virginia, going through customs.
Full disclosure: apart from trying pot in high school, I’ve never done illegal drugs.
So, you can probably see what’s coming.
While waiting in line with probably a hundred other people, with luggage, the customs guys brought a drug-sniffing dog through the lines. For some reason, he liked one of my duffel bags. So, off we go to the “back room”. They questioned me and went through every piece of my luggage. Turns out the dog liked one of my sneakers. They never found anything, there was nothing to find. But I had a fear in the back of my mind that someone unknown to me might have slipped something into my luggage. Fortunately they only did a partial strip search. After a couple hours they let me go. The only reason I can think of for the dog liking my sneaker was that I sometimes kept them in the same closet as the bag of food for my dog. Guess he likes Iams.
The terminal was totally devoid of people at that point. I’m sure the folks in line told a wild tale to their friends of the “drug dealer” caught by customs at the airport.
As others have stated, I drive whenever possible now. Just last week I drove from my house north of Seattle to Spokane for a couple of tech classes. I could have flown, but the time spent flying from Bellingham airport to Seatac, then to Spokane would probably have taken longer than the 5.5 hour drive. Not to mention I could stop and eat whenever I felt like it, do a little sightseeing, take some pics of the wind farms at Ryegrass, etc.