What did you do for Earth Hour? The (yawn) reality

The Toronto city skyline at 8:27 pm during Earth Hour, March 26, 2011.
The Toronto city skyline at 8:27 pm during Earth Hour, March 26, 2011. Image: Lucas Oleniuk/TORONTO STAR

Here’s a collection of thoughts, quotes, and of course the result of our WUWT poll on “what did you do for Earth Hour?

First, my own experience: Being keenly aware of it days ahead, even I forgot about it at the appointed time, having been distracted by normal family happenings, so I didn’t remember to turn on all my outdoor lights until 8:50PM. Given other news reports, it seems the novelty has worn off, and many many simply either forgot about it or don’t care.

Pointless symbolism isn’t what it used to be I suppose.

Here’s the newsbytes describing the (non)event worldwide (Thanks to Tom Nelson for many of them):

Toronto only sees 5 per cent power drop for Earth Hour

Is Toronto in the dark when it comes to Earth Hour?

Millions of people from 134 countries — from Delhi, India to Heidelberg, Germany — switched off their lights and televisions for the fifth annual Earth Hour on Saturday night to show their support for action on climate change.

But Toronto only saw a 5 per cent power drop during the event — half of the reduction achieved during Earth Hour in 2010.

The year before that, the city had a 15 per cent drop in megawatts being used.

“Honestly we still think it’s successful, we think it’s a great program,” said Jennifer Link, a spokeswoman for Toronto Hydro, who added that cool temperatures likely had many people using more heat than this time last year.

Earth Hour fans ‘disappointed’ to see so many lights still on

In Toronto, energy use fell by 115 megawatts between 8:30 p.m. and 9:30 p.m., a drop of about 5 per cent, said Jennifer Link, a spokeswoman for Toronto Hydro.

Last year, the city’s Earth Hour efforts saved 296 megawatts; in 2009, it was 454 megawatts.

Meanwhile, Nova Scotia Power reported saving 10 megawatts of power, a significant drop from last year’s 18 megawatts.

Toledo pays little attention to Earth Hour

‎Locally, the Toledo Zoo participated in the event. Facebook responses included “this is so silly”, “there is no way I can close early to participate” “C’mon, on a freezing cold Saturday night?” and “I enjoyed the hour”.

h/t to reader Brad R for this one below:

“Utility provider Enmax reported no noticeable drop in power consumption between 8: 30 p.m. and 9: 30 p.m. Saturday, when residents were asked to participate in Earth Hour by shutting off all nonessential power.”

How Was Your Earth Hour? ~ Philippines

As we drove along Ortigas Avenue, I was freakishly disappointed. Why? Because lights were on and it was Earth Hour.

Inside the car, I thought I wanted to blame the relatively-poor marketing the Earth Hour guys had on this year (You haven’t really noticed the Earth Hour 2011 ads as well right? You know they were there but the campaign wasn’t convincing enough).

My Experience of Earth Hour | My Mind, Thoughts and Feelings

Unfortunately, where I was, it was only us who participated in this event.

My parents slept early and I was left with my two grandchildren, age 6 and 7. I had to explain to them what this was all about.

Being just kids, they were restless. They kept on asking me how long will this last and why was it our neighbors did not do the same thing. I told them that it will only last for one hour and they should be proud to be a part of this worldwide event, to take a stand against climate change.

While we were waiting for the hour to pass, I decided to say the rosary and let them join me.

…Kids have this way of asking questions that any mature person would not dare to ask.

Five minutes after the hour had passed, we turned on the lights. They kids were happy.

The Earth Hour has passed. In retrospect, I questioned myself if I can still go beyond.

Tonight, LAX pylons will go green — and then dark — to mark Earth Hour – chicagotribune.com

Earth Hour will come early to Los Angeles International Airport. The ring of 15 100-foot-tall towers near the airport’s entrance will light up a solid green at 7:30 p.m. — an hour before Earth Hour — and remain illuminated for 60 minutes. Then the lights will go out from 8:30 p.m. to 9:30 p.m., an airport news release says.

[Yeah that’s just what I want from Earth Hour, screwing around with the electricity at one of the worlds busiest airports]

World switches off light as ‘Earth Hour’ begins 

“We did hesitate a bit (about calling for Earth Hour in Japan) because there are many without electricity in disaster-hit areas,” said Naoyuki Yamagishi, climate change programme leader for WWF in Japan.

Leo Burnett Chicago Kicks Off the Next Generation of Earth Hour, Activates Global Social Media Campaign Reaching 128 Countries | NEWS.GNOM.ES

“Our goal for Earth Hour 2011 is to reach new, unprecedented heights of social engagement to fuel the single largest act of global participation the world has ever seen,” said Carey Isom, Senior Vice President of Digital Strategy at Arc Worldwide/Leo Burnett Worldwide. “As a HumanKind communications company dedicated to putting a brand’s purpose at the center of everything we do, we are honored to bring awareness and activation to this very special cause.”

Earth Hour is the largest mass participation event in human history and was organized by WWF—an election between Earth and global warming, organized the largest mass participation event in human history.Created by Leo Burnett Sydney in 2007 and carried on by Leo Burnett Chicago, Earth Hour was the first time people of all nationalities, race, ace, gender and religion were able to vote on the future of our planet as one global democracy. Now, just five years later, more than one billion people turned off their lights in celebration of Earth Hour.

[Hmm, more like a billion people don’t HAVE electricity:

1.6 billion people — a quarter of humanity — live without electricity:

Breaking that down further:

Number of people living without electricity
Region Millions without electricity
South Asia 706
Sub-Saharan Africa 547
East Asia 224
Other 101

Source: globalissues.org Poverty Facts and Stats]

Dubai, Sharjah Earth Hour saves 249000KW

Yeah but, how much more CO2 did they release organizing the celebration, getting people there, and putting that guy up in the helicopter/airplane/hotair balloon/whatever to get the shot?

To celebrate the worthy cause and encourage participation by residents and businesses in Earth Hour, Dewa, in partnership with Emirates Wildlife Society (EWS) in association with the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF), Emaar and other government departments and local schools and universities and NGOs and private sectors and residents, marked the event with a traditional Arabic heritage village at Emaar’s Burj Plaza in the Downtown district adjacent to the world’s tallest building, Burj Khalifa.

Over 20 Arabian tents filled with arts and crafts, traditional cooking stations, El Arish hospitality, educational exhibitions, music and many local gifts and souvenirs were enjoyed by over 6,000 people who took part in the fun festivities and Earth Hour celebrations. A family occasion, children were also catered to with their own arts and crafts tents, face-painting, delightful entertainment and a conservation exhibition to educate and inspire their young minds.

Council’s ‘lights out’ weekend branded tokenism (From Oxford Mail) 

THIS weekend Oxford City Council will turn off all “non-essential” lights in a bid to tackle global warming.

But Green campaigners say it begs the question: why are lights burning in the first place if they are not needed?

Especially as the authority employs a climate change officer at a cost of £44,000 a year.

Celebrate good times, climate realists: THIS is what winning looks like

Two three-minute official Earth Hour videos are below.  The 2010 video is all about the global warming hoax.  The 2011 video fails to even mention global warming. 

Make no mistake: this is what winning looks like.  Of course, most alarmists are never going to come right out and admit that on The Most Important Issue of All Time, they were wrong and we were right.  What they’re going to do is just gradually quit talking about it.

 

YouTube – Earth Hour 2011 Official video 

This Earth Hour 2011: 8.30pm, Saturday 26 March, celebrate your action for the planet with the people of world, and add more to your Earth Hour.

YouTube – Earth Hour 2010 Official video

Earth Hour 2010 is set to be the best yet

What Makes Earth Hour Fun? | Real Science 

They know the lights will be back on in less than an hour. If they tried Earth Month instead, that would be the end of the global warming religion.

Here is the results of the WUWT poll, as of noon PST, March 27th:

It seems wildly popular to turn on lights, or ignore the whole idea, rather than turn them off, doesn’t it?

However, in one country, North Korea, Earth hour was once again a stunning success:

http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2010/05/nvskorea.jpg?w=300Night-time satellite photo of North and South Korea. Note the single light for “Dear Leader”. Image from the Defense Meteorological Satellite Program 

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

170 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Amino Acids in Meteorites
March 27, 2011 2:25 pm

Earth what?

Eric (skeptic)
March 27, 2011 2:28 pm

I was out helping reload/fix a hosed computer and forgot about it. Hopefully we at least used a bit of power rebooting a bunch of times thanks to Bill.

pat
March 27, 2011 2:28 pm

Hawaii failed to even acknowledge the silly non-event this year after Mayor Hanneman urged Honolulu citizens to observe it last year and absolutely no one did, including Hanneman himself.

Amino Acids in Meteorites
March 27, 2011 2:30 pm

God bless Calgarians!
The WWF should have said, “We’re canceling Earth Hour this year because we’re too busy focusing on relief for Japan”.

Dr. Dave
March 27, 2011 2:32 pm

Well, I feel guilty. I completely spaced it off this year. In years past I turned on every light in the house. My girlfriend complains that when all the lights I’ve put up in the garage are on it looks like daylight (she’s right) yet she still wants more light in the kitchen beyond the 650 watts of halogen already installed. Next year I promise I’ll do more to emit more CO2 and consume more electrons.

Daryl M
March 27, 2011 2:33 pm

I turned on my outside lights, but otherwise ignored earth hour completely.

kcom
March 27, 2011 2:34 pm

“I did what I said I would do…….nothing. But I also forgot about it, too. Fortunately, if you plan to do nothing and then forget, you’re still covered:<)"
I followed your plan to a T, Bob Barker. 🙂 My results were the same.
Ian, in answer to your pointed questions, my comment above is instructive. Earth Hour is so meaningless that I forgot all about it. But I think the ongoing bad reaction to it is evidence of the obnoxiousness of AGW proponents in general and of the initial Earth Hour campaign in particular. The first year (or at least the first year it went international) it was a full court press of moral indignation. It went from being a fun idea to an obligation that proved your moral worth as a human being. But it’s so stupid, it’s hard to take the campaigners’ seriousness seriously and their “we’ve got the moral high ground attitude” is off-putting. Especially, as many believe, if it’s much ado about nothing. And don’t get me started on the whole “let’s light a bunch of candles” thing. Candles are dangerous, polluting, inefficient (how much light do you get for each unit of carbon dioxide produced?), need to be transported (which uses energy), and just epically symbolic of the ridiculousness of this whole thing. What is the point of acting completely differently for one hour in a way that has nothing to do with any possible future energy scenario, except one which might follow a complete collapse of our technological society? People here are reacting to the triumph of irrationality – and it’s no surprise if they get a little testy about it. People accuse AGW skeptics of being anti-science, when what they are in reality is anti-fantasists. They don’t buy the malarkey, or even the symbolic malarkey, that the Greens are trying to force on us. And, as we’ve learned in the past in other areas, if you give them an inch you are in danger of giving them a mile, and so we are standing firm.

Mike Jowsey
March 27, 2011 2:34 pm

Ian says: March 27, 2011 at 1:51 pm
We poke fun at it because it is in aid of saving the planet from CAGW. It’s a total joke.
It’s funny. I mean, listen to this:

Jennifer Link, a spokeswoman for Toronto Hydro, who added that cool temperatures likely had many people using more heat than this time last year.

They are too cold to save the planet from warming!

Wucash
March 27, 2011 2:37 pm

It was dark, so I turned on all the lights, it was a bit chilly, so I turned on the electric heaters, I had laundry to do so I had to put on the laundry drier to make room in my washing machine. Then I went to my room and played on my electric guitar with the amp up quite loud.
Times like Earth Hour really brings home (no pun intended, really!) what a wonderful thing electricity is. I hope one day all the world gets to experience it.

March 27, 2011 2:38 pm

Ian says:
March 27, 2011 at 1:51 pm
Few ridicule the cross dangling from the rear view mirror and other religious observances, or efforts to reduce use of energy and resources. You missed the point of the opposition to the hypocrisy of Earth Hour. How can I explain it to you. Hmm… if you were a budhist, would you be against someone else hanging a cross on your rear view?

Stephen Brown
March 27, 2011 2:40 pm

Today, Sunday 27th March, I telephoned my 89 year old Mother who still lives in Luanshya in Zambia. She’d just got back from a trip down to the Kafue River, where our somewhat extended family has what we term a ‘shack’: it is, in fact, a brick-built bungalow. Apart from going fishing for Kafue Yellow-Belly bream, she’d taken paraffin and candles to our caretaker and his family. There’s no hope of ever getting any electricity supply to their location in my life-time.
They didn’t blow out any candles or lamps for this fatuous idea of Earth Hour, they ate their evening meal in the gloaming of the evening, not in the darkness of the night. Their day ends at 2000 hours as they cannot afford to burn their lighting fuel beyond that time. After 2000 hours, they rely on what meagre light they get from their fire, for which wood has to be collected every day.
And yet our caretaker counts himself to be one of the fortunate Zambians; he has a job which pays, his children (and those of his now-deceased brother and sister-in-law, both victims of AIDS) are both fed and educated and he is grateful that his wife now knows how to regulate and moderate the arrival of more children, courtesy of my Mother having had a ‘girlie-talk’ with her and introducing and supplying her with The Pill.
He has four children of his own and now has his late brother’s three children as well. Now he does not want any more children as he does not need them. His present family is guarded against malaria by both prophylactic drugs and DDT-impregnated mosquito-nets (supplied from China and re-sprayed with Chinese aerosols every month) under which he and his family sleep.
Willis Eschenbach was correct in stating that improving the life of a man and his family reduces the size of that family; I know, I have seen it work and every month I still make my own financial contribution to make sure that this state of affairs continues. I’m paying towards the up-keep of a family I haven’t seen in ten years and I’m glad that I can do so.
I celebrated Earth Hour by adding up how much I’d paid over ten or more years towards making life a trifle easier for one man’s family but regretting that I was not able to do more. I just wish that the Greenies would do the same for many more such families. It would make much more of an impact than just switching of some lights for a moment or two.

Adam
March 27, 2011 2:41 pm

Gee, earth hour’s been going on for 5 years? This is the first I’ve heard of it. And I’ve never seen one single advertisement, or any hint of earth hour except on this blog. However, I don’t watch T.V., so maybe that’s it.
Also, if you wanted to have a more effective earth hour you should make it at 3:00 am. I know I’d participate.

DirkH
March 27, 2011 2:46 pm

“As a HumanKind communications company dedicated to putting a brand’s purpose at the center of everything we do, we are honored to bring awareness and activation to this very special cause.”
PR people always bring a smile on my face. They are such lovely, cuddly creatures.

March 27, 2011 2:49 pm

Ian says:
March 27, 2011 at 1:51 pm

Yes, it’s only symbolic, and no, I don’t get upset at seeing people with crosses on their rear-view mirrors. But then I also don’t have those same people condemning me and everyone else for NOT sharing in their meaningless symbolism. There are many symbolic events people take part in during the year — but the language of condemnation that comes from those who partake of Earth HOur against those who don’t is nasty and downright scary.
Take this quote, for instance:

Being just kids, they were restless. They kept on asking me how long will this last and why was it our neighbors did not do the same thing. I told them that it will only last for one hour and they should be proud to be a part of this worldwide event, to take a stand against climate change.

Now imagine the same conversation concerning a Christmas Tree. “Well kids, just be glad you’re taking part in this great movement and not being ignorant heathens like our neighbours.”
No. I don’t like it. And it isn’t harmless.

eddieo
March 27, 2011 2:50 pm

You can just see a tiny wiggle in the UKs energy grid at 2030 this evening if you look closely. http://www.bmreports.com/bsp/bhttp:/

Sean Peake
March 27, 2011 2:50 pm

I tried to add to my moth collection by burning several 400 watt metal halide bulbs outside. After an hour of catching nothing, I realized that moths must not like -8 degree C weather. Maybe next year?

Dave Andrews
March 27, 2011 2:51 pm

Ian,
But organisations like WWF do have an effect and ‘Earth Hour’ is important to them so it cannot be ignored.
Further, consider that WWF-UK ‘s latest annual review for 2010 shows they had an income of £56.71m against an expenditure of £50.51m. Thus this ‘charitable’ organisation made a profit of £6.2m in the UK alone.
Now is this what all those good people who contribute expect of such an organisation?

Adam
March 27, 2011 2:55 pm

Ian,
We are against this because we are sick and tired of the green agenda; one that noticeably impacts our life and is based on bad science (myself I wouldn’t even call it science, as very little of what is accepted as truth is sufficiently proven for scientific standards). You ask would I get mad at seeing the Jesus Fish or a wedding ring- of coarse not. Those beliefs (both of which I don’t share) don’t hurt anyone. Would I get mad at seeing a burning cross and a bunch of men in white hoods talking about supremacy- YES. Even if they don’t hurt anyone directly they are encouraging others to do so, and embolden them to take action. This is especially important to climate change because it is unlikely that most enthusiasts will admit to being wrong. We can only hope they stop being so enthused.

Steve from Rockwood
March 27, 2011 3:01 pm

“Honestly we still think it’s successful, we think it’s a great program,” said Jennifer Link, a spokeswoman for Toronto Hydro, who added that cool temperatures likely had many people using more heat than this time last year.
Was I the only one who saw the irony in that quote?

Martyn
March 27, 2011 3:03 pm

Earth Hour. Whoops! Thanks for the reminder.

Leon Brozyna
March 27, 2011 3:12 pm

Forgot all about it.
Didn’t turn on all my lights.
Then again, I didn’t turn anything off either … while I hopped in the car and ran out to the store and got back home after the whole silly thing was over.
I suppose the limo libs were gushing over each other about how wonderful they were in caring for the planet.

DirkH
March 27, 2011 3:15 pm

Ian says:
March 27, 2011 at 1:51 pm
“There is one thing that puzzles me though. An event which can’t possibly impact anyone but oneself such as Earth Hour is causing such a stir with everyone.”
The longing for power of the greens does affect me. Earth Hour is one of their yearly propaganda events. So it is the obvious target for derision.
It would be ironic if the yearly Switching Off Of The Lights in a city like, say, Shanghai would produce some extra tourist travel… From the marketing video for Earth Hour, it looks like a huge party.

Karen D
March 27, 2011 3:24 pm

Ian, I understand what you’re saying, but let me ask you this. Did you really turn off your breaker during Earth Hour to save energy — or was it to save face with your neighbors so they wouldn’t tut-tut you the next day?
Did you feel any pressure from your neighbors to do as they do or suffer the scorn? If not, that’s wonderful. But in some neighborhoods things are different.
As for being offended if someone has, for example, a religious symbol on their car, I’m not. But I AM offended if someone tells me I should have one, too. Especially if they imply that I must not care about God if I don’t have a religious symbol on my car. That’s the way I see Earth Hour. I happen to conserve energy as a life-long habit. I just don’t feel the need to prove my personal conservation efforts to anyone.
You took Earth Hour as an opportunity to reflect on your own energy use and that’s great. You put the exercise to good use. (In my house we happen to have that discussion pretty much every time the electric bill arrives, as things are a bit tight.) But the way it often goes with people, Earth Hour is just as likely to be a time when people feel pressured to “fit in” with the rest of the neighborhood and cut the lights for one hour, and then they’re done conserving until next year. It’s the potential to be a meaningless gesture that elicits the mockery, in my opinion.

March 27, 2011 3:25 pm

“There are also things that quite frankly don’t matter. Earth Hour is one of those things that doesn’t matter. It is the equivalent of people who pray before going to bed.” (Ian)
Ian, I can’t speak for everone, so I won’t, but in my own case, as someone who’s lived in a communist country and has been subjected to pointless, organized and purely symbolic mass gestures such as this one, I find the dissent, non-cooperation and ridicule expressed by folks here actually quite heartening.
The Earth Hour gesture is in no way analogous to a bed time prayer, which is a private and personal act of faith, rather than an organized, publicly visible and communal gesture of obeisance to a set of political ideas. If you think about it, I’m sure you’ll agree that your hackles would rise if municipalities, schools and organizations promoted a “let’s all say a bed-time prayer together…where everyone can see us…on my count…”

starzmom
March 27, 2011 3:29 pm

I watched it snow in Kansas–and kept the heat on and put a fire in the woodstove. Also lights stayed on. I am not a fan of cold and dark.