And in an unbelievable gaffe, he’s told a whole group of people exactly where they can go:
It is probably the most ugly statement I’ve ever seen from a politician regarding a group of people with ideas that disagree with the politician’s own view. If it were a race or class issue, he’d be vilified. He apparently has lost touch with what it means to be an American.
From The Hill’s Blog Briefing Room:
“An iceberg four times the size of Manhattan has broken off Greenland, creating plenty of room for global warming deniers to start their own country,” Markey said in a statement.
And I thought we were past things like this.

AP, Boston Globe, and WBZ-TV confirm this story. Here’s the story on the calving I broke before any MSM where I said “watch the media” I should have said “watch the politicians”.
Markey, who chairs the Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming, co-authored the House version of the climate change bill that’s currently stalled in the Senate.
h/t to Luboš Motl
=============================================
I think we, as Americans, with rights to free speech, should all remind Congressman Markey of what that actually means, especially those in Massachusetts who voted this man into office. His email contact form is here.
Below is the contact info from his web page:
Rep. Markey’s Massachusetts and Washington, D.C. Offices:
Rep. Markey encourages residents of Massachusetts’ Seventh Congressional District to contact him via e-mail, by phone, or through a visit to one of his three offices.
His Medford and Framingham District offices can assist individuals on a more personal basis with questions related to federal agencies such as Social Security, IRS, or the Veterans Administration. In addition, they can help with grant applications, service academy nominations, flag requests, scheduling requests for the district and visits to Washington, D.C.
His Washington, D.C. office handles questions related to legislation, agency oversight and general federal policy.
When leaving a message, include your full name, address, city/town, zip code, phone number, and e-mail address. Please understand that Ed receives several hundred letters and e-mails every day.
![]() |
![]() |
| Medford
5 High Street, Suite 101 Medford, MA 02155 781-396-2900 |
Framingham
188 Concord Street Suite 102 Framingham, MA 01702 508-875-2900 |
![]() |
|
| Washington, D.C.
2108 Rayburn House Office Building Washington, DC 20515 202-225-2836 |
|





Smokey,
My point being, it doesn’t matter if the system is “rigged”. It’s only rigged because we have allowed it to be rigged. We can, and we must, un-rig this system. It not only can be done, it can be done quite easily if we just band together, ignore and disregard these feeble attempts to tear us apart (from climate to racism). Resist these distractions, stay focused and remove the rigging. Know your representatives and do your research, then vote. Get your friends, family and neighbors to do the same. We are all in this together.
At the end of the day, there is no rigging but what we allow. This is our country and we shall restore our freedom, for we are the people!
squid2112 says:
August 8, 2010 at 8:19 pm
Smokey says:
August 8, 2010 at 8:24 pm
Without comment.
Maybe Congressman Malarkey should read this!
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/ambroseevans_pritchard/7933235/Commodity-spike-queers-the-pitch-for-Bernankes-QE2.html
With respect to this question yes. I can ask another one – do you want you grandkids to live or do you want your lineage to end there (or before that)?
The “greatest civilization on Earth”? A country of morbidly obese dimwits half of who think the Earth is 6000 years old and a third of which think the Sun rotates around the Earth and who spent their time sitting behind desks, eating junk food and watching TV? I think the “lazy fricken ass” description fits you very well, because you seem to not have bothered yourself with actually looking around you and understanding what’s going on.
Europe
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automobile#History
USA.
Europe
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Typewriters#History
Europe
US
squid’s, right. Well put.
Barry
I very strongly disagree!
Let us wait and see who is right.
Observation is the only final arbiter of a dispute:
After human emissions of CO2 for 60-years, there was no change in the global warming rate in the period from 1970 to 2000 compared to that in the period from 1910 to 2000. As a result, according to the data, according to the science, human emissions of CO2 has NO effect on the global warming rate.
GM: You are out of your league. Back to Poli-Sci class, the SDS or wherever you’re from. And out down the bottle or weed because, frankly, it’s kind of embarrassing.
someone’s probably said this before me. (no time to read the deluge of comments) but…I think it’s Mr Markey and his alarmist friends that are on thin ice…that’s why they sound so shrill!
Keep up the good work.
GM wrote:
“Let’s step back for a second from the global warming issue and look at the way our society works in general. Say we have the following situation:
– there is a real and very serious crisis that requires taking action well in advance before its effect become apparent;
– it is of such nature that once those effect are there to see by all, it is too late to do anything to prevent it; the only way to prevent is significant sacrifices by the general population, which makes preventive action highly unpopular;
– not only that, the majority of people so not understand why we should be worried about it, because they are too scientifically (and generally) illiterate, and it is only a small group of scientists who understand it well
– those scientists are seen by the masses as belonging to the self-appointed intellectually arrogant “elites”
…snip…
So can someone explain to me what mechanism is currently present in our society that will make sure that action is taken on time in such a situation?”
Assuming you’re not just trolling and this is an honest question, you rigged it by saying the majority of people are too illiterate to understand the issue. That’s not true, if the science is done correctly, carefully, and transparently. The people may not understand the science exactly, but, in general, they understand when they are being told the truth. And then, action will be taken. Of course, the scientists must act like scientists, and not like activists.
GM says:
August 8, 2010 at 8:48 pm
“With respect to this question yes. I can ask another one – do you want you grandkids to live or do you want your lineage to end there (or before that)?”
Why are you so worried by a purported 0.6 deg C rise in temperatures?
Girma says:
“After human emissions of CO2 for 60-years, there was no change in the global warming rate in the period from 1970 to 2000 compared to that in the period from 1910 to 2000. As a result, according to the data, according to the science, human emissions of CO2 has NO effect on the global warming rate.”
Girma is exactly right.
What I find interesting is how ice has become the poster boy of AGW.
To put the volume of ice in perspective from the original article –
Converting the standard US areal unit of a “Manhattan” into SI units is 59km2 * 4 = 236 km2
= 236 000 000 m2
assume it is half an “Empire State Building” thick (another unit of measure I was unfamiliar with) which is 220m, we get
= 51 900 000 000 m3 of ice
= 47 300 000 000 m3 of water
= 45.3 hours discharge of the Amazon river at 209 000 m3 / sec
It is hard to work out, but this calving appears to occur every 10 years to so.
Therefore the glacier is flowing at the rate of 0.0005 Amazons.
Of course a river of ice must be different than a normal river, as it seems to AGWists they don’t ebb and flow.
PS When I did my engineering degree we were told if you wish to hide inconvenient data always express it in the most inconvenient unit. For example express the speed of light in furlongs per fortnight.
[snip – funny indeed. but trolls will misconstrue this simple humor and make an issue of it, since they have no humor themselves ~mod]
In the 1960’s, the Vietnam War became a political wedge issue. It divided brothers, generations, even parents from parents.
It ended when the politics could no longer drive a wedge with it. Reality had set in.
So too will Global Warming as a wedge issue end.
Right now, that is what the Congressman and his followers are trying to do, drive a wedge with a label.
And I understand he is quite sore over the failure of his bill.
This too shall pass…. the wedge issue…just as soon as America wises up to what is going on.
We got more important things to do, like rebuild the place.
I didn’t rig the question, this was part of the initial conditions. And it is very much true in real life – 1/5 of people in the world are completely illiterate and even in a developed country like the US, the level of scientific and math literacy is abysmal (and it’s not just those areas that are affected).
You can not claim that “the people will understand if they are told the truth” because we have many examples in which they were have been told the truth, it has been explained to them with great patience many times again and again, and they still refused to accept it, the best example being evolution. The majority of people in this country are creationists, and this is not because the scientists haven’t done their part in educating the public, it is because they are running against people’s religion.
And it is much worse if we define scientific literacy the way it should be defined, i.e. as a working understanding of the methodology of science, rather than just the ability to recite a laundry list of facts learned in school.
So yes, the people are ignorant and illiterate. And there is no mechanism to fix that in the system either
Using blanket dismissal of your opponents position without actually providing any arguments against is often a sign of mere inability to provide them. You don’t win any points for that post
Perhaps useful as a mobile research station alla “Fletchers Island” from the 1950s…
Around Pole on Iceberg
http://newspapers.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/27133618
phillychuck says:
August 8, 2010 at 9:18 pm
GM wrote:
“[…]”- those scientists are seen by the masses as belonging to the self-appointed intellectually arrogant “elites””
“[…]So can someone explain to me what mechanism is currently present in our society that will make sure that action is taken on time in such a situation?”
Assuming you’re not just trolling and this is an honest question, you rigged it by saying the majority of people are too illiterate to understand the issue. […]”
Yeah, very good, GM has set up his strawman in such a way that the answer must be “A strong and righteous leader; and a temporary suspension of democracy Lovelock-style”. Very good, GM; would you keep yourself available for this position as a strong antidemocratic leader in case we need one? TIA.
Markey is a typical product of his time, an ignorant politician with lots of power that has gone to his head. The truth doesnt matter and reality matters even less, all that matters is the excersise of power and influence combined with his own socio political ideology.
Markey has made his mind up, he knows in his own tiny mind that he knows everything, he exhibits the certainty of the idiot and as usual with that kind of politician he has allowed his base instincts to rule what is left of his rational mind.
Arrogance combined with a sense of self importance is a poisonous mixture and in a politician it is dangerous, the fact is that Markey is losing the argument to his hated enemies and he feels his efforts are being destroyed by his enemies. Such is his sense of self importance he is getting angry at those he perceives to be to blame, they become his enemies.
We in the western world have allowed our political classes too much power for too long, they have been allowed to remove themselves from the lives and wishes of ordinary people and they now exist in a kind of bubble sealed off from the reality we ordinary people face, these political classes now feel superior and born to rule, it is the usual result of a degenerating democratic life and it is happening right now.
The gap between ordinary people and the political classes widens, the political classes believe in their own self inflated importance and they are starting to feel that only they should be allowed to rule, only they have the keys to the future. We in the west have allowed our political representatives too much power for too long, we have allowed them to build their power bases and inflate their egos, they are simply following a well known psychological path.
Democracy is like a garden, it must be tended with the utmost care, plants must be trimmed constantly and weeds dug up, the work must never end. The political classes have become the out of control weeds and its time they were evicted or at least trimmed down to size, it always happens when a small group of people are left to their own devices in charge, they have formed a society that looks after their own interests first and they now look down on those they see as inferior beings.
GM says:
August 8, 2010 at 9:38 pm
“[…]And it is much worse if we define scientific literacy the way it should be defined, i.e. as a working understanding of the methodology of science, rather than just the ability to recite a laundry list of facts learned in school.
So yes, the people are ignorant and illiterate. And there is no mechanism to fix that in the system either”
You are heaping abuse on abuse. Maybe you are rather well suited for the role of a benign, righteous strongman. Keep working on your attitude and we’ll get back to you.
Dear moderator, your point is well-taken. I thought the well-known “how many politicians would it take to screw in the light bulb” joke was not only humorous, but a fine exemplar of Congressman Markey’s baleful comedic stylings. Certainly, there was no harm intended on my part. As with Congressman Markey, I’m sure, I was only kidding.
REPLY: I agree with his decision, but no worries on your part. There are crazy people hanging on every word printed here, looking for some “gotcha” to exploit. -Anthony
wow, I can’t believe that politicians would make this sort of statement anymore. This can be taken as an attack on our liberty and free speech, since if we don’t believe in global warming, he wants us to leave instead of debate. How Un-American can you be. Denying free speech to people by telling them to leave in a nation that is know for their free speech policies
What a typical ‘it’s a hot year up here this year in Mass, so the whole world is hot too!’
Go look at: http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/cag3/cag3.html
to see the US picture. If you select ‘Year to date’ you will see the SE of the US is cooler this year, the NE is warmer, the rest is middling.
Mr Congressman, stop playing God and stick to the USA. The data for you is: ‘situation normal’.
Buster.
I would creat an imaginary bird for my birdfeeder called the Markeybird, but I already have one. It’s called the Cookoo?
leftymartin: August 8, 2010 at 3:47 pm
Markey told high school students, from the World Wildlife Fund’s Allianz Southeast Climate Witness Program, gathered at Capitol Hill on July 10, 2008, that “in Somalia back in 1993, climate change, according to 11 three- and four-star generals, resulted in a drought which led to famine…
Name them Congressman.
Oooooh, you can’t.
Because it didn’t happen.