Earth's Magnetic Field Has Massive Breach – scientists baffled

I know. This sounds like a plot of a 1950’s scifi movie. But it is real. From my view, our localized corner of the solar system is now different than it used to be and changes in the magnetic interactions are evident everywhere. First we have the interplanetary magnetic field that took an abrupt dive in October 2005 and has not recovered since and remains at very low level:

ap_dec08-520

click for a larger image

Then we have the recent discovery that the ionosphere has dropped in altitude to unexpected and unexplained low levels.

We have a solar cycle 24 (driven by the solar magnetic dynamo) which can’t seem to get out of the starting gate, being a year late with forecasts for activity from it being revised again and again.

And finally we have this, this discovery that Earth’s magnetic field can be ripped open and our atmosphere laid bare to the solar wind, much like Mars.

Magnetism is underrated in the grand scheme of things, in my opinion. We’d do well to pay more attention to magnetic trends in our corner of the universe and what effects it has on Earthly climate. – Anthony


From NASA News (h/t to Geoff Sharp)

Dec. 16, 2008: NASA’s five THEMIS spacecraft have discovered a breach in Earth’s magnetic field ten times larger than anything previously thought to exist. Solar wind can flow in through the opening to “load up” the magnetosphere for powerful geomagnetic storms. But the breach itself is not the biggest surprise. Researchers are even more amazed at the strange and unexpected way it forms, overturning long-held ideas of space physics.

“At first I didn’t believe it,” says THEMIS project scientist David Sibeck of the Goddard Space Flight Center. “This finding fundamentally alters our understanding of the solar wind-magnetosphere interaction.”

The magnetosphere is a bubble of magnetism that surrounds Earth and protects us from solar wind. Exploring the bubble is a key goal of the THEMIS mission, launched in February 2007. The big discovery came on June 3, 2007, when the five probes serendipitously flew through the breach just as it was opening. Onboard sensors recorded a torrent of solar wind particles streaming into the magnetosphere, signaling an event of unexpected size and importance.

Right: One of the THEMIS probes exploring the space around Earth, an artist’s concept. [more]

“The opening was huge—four times wider than Earth itself,” says Wenhui Li, a space physicist at the University of New Hampshire who has been analyzing the data. Li’s colleague Jimmy Raeder, also of New Hampshire, says “1027 particles per second were flowing into the magnetosphere—that’s a 1 followed by 27 zeros. This kind of influx is an order of magnitude greater than what we thought was possible.”

The event began with little warning when a gentle gust of solar wind delivered a bundle of magnetic fields from the Sun to Earth. Like an octopus wrapping its tentacles around a big clam, solar magnetic fields draped themselves around the magnetosphere and cracked it open. The cracking was accomplished by means of a process called “magnetic reconnection.” High above Earth’s poles, solar and terrestrial magnetic fields linked up (reconnected) to form conduits for solar wind. Conduits over the Arctic and Antarctic quickly expanded; within minutes they overlapped over Earth’s equator to create the biggest magnetic breach ever recorded by Earth-orbiting spacecraft.

Above: A computer model of solar wind flowing around Earth’s magnetic field on June 3, 2007. Background colors represent solar wind density; red is high density, blue is low. Solid black lines trace the outer boundaries of Earth’s magnetic field. Note the layer of relatively dense material beneath the tips of the white arrows; that is solar wind entering Earth’s magnetic field through the breach. Credit: Jimmy Raeder/UNH. [larger image]

The size of the breach took researchers by surprise. “We’ve seen things like this before,” says Raeder, “but never on such a large scale. The entire day-side of the magnetosphere was open to the solar wind.”

The circumstances were even more surprising. Space physicists have long believed that holes in Earth’s magnetosphere open only in response to solar magnetic fields that point south. The great breach of June 2007, however, opened in response to a solar magnetic field that pointed north.

“To the lay person, this may sound like a quibble, but to a space physicist, it is almost seismic,” says Sibeck. “When I tell my colleagues, most react with skepticism, as if I’m trying to convince them that the sun rises in the west.”

Here is why they can’t believe their ears: The solar wind presses against Earth’s magnetosphere almost directly above the equator where our planet’s magnetic field points north. Suppose a bundle of solar magnetism comes along, and it points north, too. The two fields should reinforce one another, strengthening Earth’s magnetic defenses and slamming the door shut on the solar wind. In the language of space physics, a north-pointing solar magnetic field is called a “northern IMF” and it is synonymous with shields up!

“So, you can imagine our surprise when a northern IMF came along and shields went down instead,” says Sibeck. “This completely overturns our understanding of things.”

Northern IMF events don’t actually trigger geomagnetic storms, notes Raeder, but they do set the stage for storms by loading the magnetosphere with plasma. A loaded magnetosphere is primed for auroras, power outages, and other disturbances that can result when, say, a CME (coronal mass ejection) hits.

The years ahead could be especially lively. Raeder explains: “We’re entering Solar Cycle 24. For reasons not fully understood, CMEs in even-numbered solar cycles (like 24) tend to hit Earth with a leading edge that is magnetized north. Such a CME should open a breach and load the magnetosphere with plasma just before the storm gets underway. It’s the perfect sequence for a really big event.”

Sibeck agrees. “This could result in stronger geomagnetic storms than we have seen in many years.”

For more information about the THEMIS mission, visit http://nasa.gov/themis


Sponsored IT training links:

Get up to date NS0-502 questions to practice for 70-270 exam and complete your CISA certification in days.


Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
271 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
December 18, 2008 10:23 am

Samfavata… I like your attitude… It’s a good opportunity for us to evolve… Uh?

December 18, 2008 11:01 am

Nasif Nahle (09:06:56) :
Into the composition of the energy incoming to Earth through that geomagnetic breach,
Isn’t anybody reading the postings? That ‘geomagnetic breach’ happens every few hours. Every time the read curve on this plot http://www.swpc.noaa.gov/ace/MAG_SWEPAM_7d.html goes above the white dashed line, there is a ‘breach’. This thing is overhyped in the extreme: this is not news, this happens all the time, this has no big effect [on the contrary, geomagnetic activity dies away during a ‘breach’].

Steve Keohane
December 18, 2008 11:03 am

Katherine (00:32:09) If one were to slice through the earth at 67 deg. latt., the circle described at that latt.(assuming a perfect sphere) would be the amount of wobble that the axis precesses through, and I was giving an off-hand measurement of that circumference relative to the magnetic pole’s movement. Perhaps poorly worded.

December 18, 2008 11:06 am

crosspatch (09:11:31) :
what you are seeing isn’t unique or uncommon. Chances are it has been there all along.
This happens every few hours. Every time the read curve on this plot http://www.swpc.noaa.gov/ace/MAG_SWEPAM_7d.html goes above the white dashed line, there is a ‘breach’. This thing is overhyped in the extreme: this is not news, this happens all the time, this has no big effect [on the contrary, geomagnetic activity dies away during a ‘breach’]. And the ‘effect’ has been known for more than thirty years, see e.g. page 9 of http://www.leif.org/research/suipr699.pdf
I have now pointed that out some five times, doesn’t anybody read the postings?

December 18, 2008 11:12 am

samfavata (09:44:54) :
“Shifts in our protective magnetic field have most certainly occurred before, as the article stated. What’s interesting to note is that the last MAJOR polar shift occurred about 10,000 years ago ~ coincidentally, about the same time Homo Sapien Sapien emerged. Mutations in genetic data caused by solar radiation are […]”
Many postings in this and most other threads [and blogs] make one doubt the ‘Sapiens’ part of our species name.

December 18, 2008 11:14 am

Every time the read curve on this plot ==> red, of course. I need another cup of coffee…

December 18, 2008 11:41 am

Thanks, Leif… I think you’re right; thing has been overhyped to the extreme.

Jim Arndt
December 18, 2008 11:58 am

Leif, I think samfavata was thinking about Homo Humorous Sapien 😉

BarryW
December 18, 2008 12:14 pm

Leif Svalgaard (11:14:36) :
Dr Michio Kaku was on Fox this morning and stated that the solar max would be in 2012 and that would be larger than anticipated because there had been a measurement that was 20 times larger than originally thought. link
Could you identify what data he’s talking about? I thought the prediction has been for a large peak for a long time now.

December 18, 2008 12:57 pm

BarryW (12:14:23) :
Dr Michio Kaku was on Fox this morning and stated that the solar max would be in 2012 and that would be larger than anticipated because there had been a measurement that was 20 times larger than originally thought
This was total nonsense. He also talks about the ‘shock wave’ that will result from the ‘flipping’ of the Sun’s magnetic field. There is no such shock wave associated with the flipping. And the field doesn’t ‘flip’. The polar fields [one thousandth of the total] slowly erode and then slowly builds up again over the next few years. He said: “we made a mistake in thinking the next cycle would be small”. I don’t know what mistake he is babbling about. NASA’s mistake was in thinking the next cycle would be very large. This is total alarmism and nonsense.

deathsinger
December 18, 2008 1:00 pm

Leif,
Thank you for all of your efforts to educate us.
As to
“Many postings in this and most other threads [and blogs] make one doubt the ‘Sapiens’ part of our species name.”
Some people post comments before reading the entire comment string. As a string gets longer it is harder to read all the comments. Just sayin’…

Steve Higgins
December 18, 2008 1:06 pm

Somewhere there is probably an American to blame for this, another who publically takes responsibility, further still a whole cadre lawyers who want to bring a class action lawsuit against the rest.

A Wod
December 18, 2008 1:14 pm

In 1645 Diane Purkiss in her book on the English Civil War, page 443, writes that :
“above Newmarket [Suffolk], there were strange apparitions in the sky…. that may have been the Northern Lights” and that “they were to haunt the American Civil War battlefields in the cold hard winter of 1863, as far south as Fredericksburg in Virginia”

December 18, 2008 1:24 pm

After seeing the plots of geomagnetic field posted by Leif, I think there are many things I have to correct, especially in my next Radio broadcast, next Saturday; however, what the purpose of NASA scientists was on overstating their observations? I don’t think they were only justifying a bulk of funds. Perhaps they are trying to blow out any evidence on favor of Shaviv’s theory?
On the other hand, I think many from the press releases from NASA have been alarmist in the last eight years.

December 18, 2008 1:41 pm

Crosspatch:
Rule of thumb … if you see something the very first time you look for it or as soon as you are capable of seeing it, chances are very good that what you are seeing isn’t unique or uncommon. Chances are it has been there all along.
— Like, for example, oh, say, the OZONE LAYER? I still know people who have trouble sleeping at night because they worry about R12 (Freon). Sigh. So, can anyone demonstrate a mechanism wherein the O3 layer is continuous, with no holes or gaps or seasonal variations? Is it really possible to respect someone who thinks that switching to R134a in our vehicles’ A/C has “saved the planet”???

December 18, 2008 1:48 pm

does anyone know what the latest count is for spotless days in 2008?

Jim Arndt
December 18, 2008 1:49 pm

I e-mail Fox and hope they will correct that junk. He acted like the sun was going to explode or something. He should stick to parallel universes.

Michael J. Bentley
December 18, 2008 2:16 pm

E. M. Smith
Who the heck are you? Been reading your postings which seem pretty well grounded in a plethora of subjects! Interesting reading, keep it up!
NASA did some good things early on. Then they got cocky. Rather than down and dirty engineering and science, learning from errors and knowing when they “lucked out” they began to think of themselves as invincible. It’s a pity really where they have fallen to. I don’t doubt there are some good people still there, but they are overshadowed by the blowhards.
You, Leif, (yea, I still like ya!) Pamela, Anthony and others keep my faith in humankind going even though the flame flickers from time to time.
Mike

SteveSadlov
December 18, 2008 2:33 pm

Felix’ notion is that the low B and H fields during a pole flip admit huge flux of cosmic particles, leading to heightened high latitude precip, etc. Maybe it really is “Ice Age Now!”

December 18, 2008 2:38 pm

SteveSadlov (14:33:11) :
Felix’ notion is that the low B and H fields during a pole flip admit huge flux of cosmic particles, leading to heightened high latitude precip, etc. Maybe it really is “Ice Age Now!”
Cosmic rays are at a minimum when the poles reverse polarity.

kim
December 18, 2008 2:42 pm

Tea is better than coffee, and chocolate best of all. Theobromine, the food of the Gods.
=============================

BarryW
December 18, 2008 5:58 pm

Leif Svalgaard (12:57:08)
Thanks, I thought it was a load of something, but I wanted to double check with someone in the know. Michio Kaku is a theoretical physicist and you would expect better but maybe he’s breathed in too much chalk dust.

Robert Bateman
December 18, 2008 6:46 pm

E.M.Smith (00:08:26) :
You are overreading things if you think that I am worried. Crop failures from climate change hit Europe in the early 14th century. Such things have happened before, as well as Grand Minima.
I am bothered that Science isn’t doing anything to try to understand or try to predict what will happen to crops worldwide if we enter another Grand Minima.
Science does great things monitoring and predicting volcanic eruptions and tsunami warnings.
I have a Farmers Almanac, I follow along, and it’s getting less reliable.
So, try to have a heart and think about your fellow man for a change.
Is that clear enough?

December 18, 2008 7:21 pm

Dear Robert Batman… We biologists are trying, but I think we’ll die in the trying. There is not cooperation from other disciplines and we don’t know whether the information is true or it’s not. For example this “massive breach in the geomagnetic field” and that one about our ionosphere shrinking as it “has never been observed before…” If the last discovery was true, then we could associate the phenomena with the breakdown of bee’s pollination and other sprouting biological problems which depend on the UV radiation intensity. That’s why we highly appreciate the intercession of Dr. Leif Svalgaard and other scientists who write here on. Best, Nasif Nahle

DR
December 18, 2008 8:32 pm

http://www.physorg.com/news147456732.html
(PhysOrg.com) — The sun’s magnetic field may have a significant impact on weather and climatic parameters in Australia and other countries in the northern and southern hemispheres.
[AD]
According to a study in Geographical Research published by Wiley-Blackwell, the droughts in eastern Australia are related to the solar magnetic phases and not the greenhouse effect.