People send me stuff. I’m thinking they must be worried about the urban animals. Why else would a wildlife federation be jumping into city public policy? Hmmm.
I’m not against making cities cooler with more greenery and white/green roofs,. In fact I think the FLIR rooftop image they have in the report is pretty cool.
But when trying to convince people for the immediate need of something, timing is everything:
From NOAA: “Ohio, Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, West Virginia, and Pennsylvania experienced their coolest July on record.“
Also note that the record high for Cleveland in August was set on August 27th, 1948 with 102°F. The all-time record high in Cleveland of 104 °F (40 °C) was established on June 25, 1988.
Funny how they mention in the report they released today that “With mostly pleasant temperatures across the Midwest and Northeast in summer 2009, it is easy to lose sight of the long-term warming trend. But, this is not the time to let down our guard. This temporary respite is due largely to natural climate oscillations working in our favor. We are nearing the end of a minimum in the 11-year solar cycle during which the Earth is receiving slightly less heat from the Sun.”
They seem worried, because in this one press release they manage to cover just about every talking point we’ve ever heard. Here’s the nifty press release.
Immediate Release: August 25, 2009
Contacts:Tracy Sabetta, National Wildlife Federation 614-581-2907
tsabetta@initiativeohio.com
Cleveland Will See Increase in Heat Waves Risks
More Extremely Hot Days Projected with Global Warming
Cleveland, Ohio (August 25)–This morning, environmental and community advocates gathered in a cool location to discuss a hot topic. Together on the “green” rooftop of a downtown building, representatives of the National Wildlife Federation and others announced that Cleveland is on a list of the 30 cities believed to be most vulnerable to heat wave effects as the planet warms. According to a new report by the National Wildlife Federation and Physicians for Social Responsibility, Cleveland’s relatively high level of vulnerable populations and low rates of air conditioning were among the reasons cited by the groups for its selection to the top 30 list.
“Many American cities are vulnerable to increased heat waves that will result from global climate change,” said Tracy Sabetta of the National Wildlife Federation in Ohio. “People in poor health and the elderly often suffer the most, but everyone will feel the heat unless measures are taken to adequately prepare cities.”
In a report being released today called, “Heat Waves: Global Warming’s Wake Up Call,” scientists have concluded that heat waves caused by global warming are going to bring significant challenges for American cities. The report’s authors examined four major risk factors associated with heat-related mortality to identify 30 large cities in the United States that are especially vulnerable to heat waves based on current conditions. Factors considered included the average number of oppressively hot days each year, percentage of homes without central air conditioning, percentage of the city population living in poverty, and the quantity of ground-level ozone pollution.
Three Ohio cities appear on this list: Cincinnati, Toledo, and Cleveland. According to the report, 49 percent of the households in Cleveland are currently without central air conditioning and 30 percent of the population is living below the federal poverty level of $16,530 for a family of three. That is more than double the national average.
As the United States warms another 4 to 11°F on average over the next century, we will have more extremely hot summer days. Every part of the country will be affected. Urban areas like Cleveland will feel the heat more acutely because asphalt, concrete, and other structures absorb and reradiate heat, causing temperature to be as much as 10°F higher than nearby rural areas.
“Cooler years like this one can set us up for trouble by making us complacent and less prepared for inevitably hot years to come,” continued Sabetta. “And make no mistake — the trends clearly show more hot years are on the way.”
Cooler-than-average temperatures across the Midwest and Northeast over this past summer make it is easy to lose sight of the indisputable long-term warming trend. According to the most recent science on heat waves, the jet stream took an unusually southern track across the nation this summer, bringing more Arctic air and less tropical air to the Midwest and Northeast.
But while it may be cool in Cleveland, Ohio this summer, the planet as a whole is continuing to warm. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, this July was the 5th warmest on record globally. Temperatures through July put 2009 at the 6th warmest year on record, tying 2004
The increased air pollution that typically accompanies heat waves can especially harm children, who have a higher risk of developing asthma, have lungs that are still developing and growing, and have higher exposure because they breathe at a higher rate than adults and spend more time outdoors engaging in vigorous physical activity. Historically, about 20 to 28 percent of weather-related deaths have been due to heat, more than any other single weather-related cause.
“Through our programs that focus on the environmental health concerns of children and the elderly living in poor neighborhoods, we at Environmental Health Watch are all too aware of the health consequences of more frequent extreme heat events and increased air pollution associated with global warming,” said Stuart Greenburg, Executive Director of Environmental Health Watch. “Our focus in the fight to reduce greenhouse gases is on the housing sector, which accounts for 24 percent of carbon emissions. We need widespread home weatherization to reduce carbon emissions, increase comfort and health, and make housing more affordable.”
Residents of all Ohio cities can begin to prepare for hotter temperatures by reducing climate change pollution that is heating the planet while taking steps to cool our cities and boost public health response systems.
“Our nation’s environmental challenges are inherently tied to the economic needs of our most vulnerable communities,” said Shanelle Smith, Ohio Organizer for the Apollo Alliance. “This report makes it clear that if we want to have a sustainable environment and put people back to work, we must invest in clean energy. Investing in the clean energy economy will reduce the impact of pollution on our climate and create good green jobs in the process.”
“If we are to prevent crossing critical tipping points such as the melting of all arctic permafrost which will cause the release of huge amounts of methane into our atmosphere, we must act now,” said Dr. Eric Schreiber, speaker for the Climate Project. “The task falls to us. Those who came before us did not understand the need to act. Those who come after us will be powerless to prevent the crippling and deadly effects of climate destabilization. Future generations will judge us by our willingness to make the tough decisions.”
We can reduce the severity of heat waves and their impacts on vulnerable populations.
Curbing global climate change pollution as much and as quickly as possible is an essential first step. Legislation recently passed by the US House and currently being considered in the Senate will reduce carbon emissions and move us toward a clean energy economy. Shifting to clean solar energy is an especially promising option because sunlight is plentiful during heat waves, when electricity demand for air conditioning peaks.
At the same time, we must make our cities cooler and greener, for example by introducing more green space—parks, trees, and “green, reflective roofs” —to greatly reduce the urban heat island effect. Furthermore, cities must implement public health measures—such as heat watch and warning systems, public cooling places, and assistance to low-income residents for home improvements that make buildings cooler—to reduce the impact of extreme heat that we cannot avoid.
###
While I certainly support, at least in theory, measures such as more green space and rooftop gardens, heat watches, etc., the continual drumbeat for global warming sullies the message.
And it was awful nice of them to note that this summer has been rather cool around the Midwest.
I also found it amusing of them to note that 49% of the homes in Cleveland do not have central air conditioning. The horrors – oh, the humanity. Fifty years ago, almost no one had central air. My family only got central air in half of my house 6 years ago. Before that we hauled the ol’ window units out every summer. And half the house still doesn’t have any air conditioning. Does that put us at risk? Or does it simply show what a silly statistic that is?
Forgive me but, don’t solar panels get really hot? How will millions of solar panels reduce UHI effects?
“As the United States warms another 4 to 11°F on average over the next century, we will have more extremely hot summer days. Every part of the country will be affected. Urban areas like Cleveland will feel the heat more acutely because asphalt, concrete, and other structures absorb and reradiate heat, causing temperature to be as much as 10°F higher than nearby rural areas.”
If I read that correctly, the U.S. will warm as much as 11°F, and cities an additional 10°F.
San Antonio continues to hit triple digits, so we will see 120°F+ in the future?
I think I’m going to need a bigger a/c.
It’s a non-stop barrage of propaganda. Like you say they have tried to press every single button in the press release.
Last year my climbing magazine had a special feature about how as mountaineers we had a unique role to play in mending the broken climate. It all seemed very plausible.
Then I glanced at my wife’s gardening magazine. It had an almost verbatim story about how as gardeners they had a unique role. I checked elsewhere: my father-in-law’s bird-watching mag had the same theme – “ornithologists have a unique perspective…”
Almost everyone seems to have some kind of unique and special relationship with the broken climate according to these people. Maybe even formula one racing drivers and power station owners and executive jet owners…
Please, NWF: Keep promoting utter rubbish as if people are stupid to eat it up.
“In fact I think the FLIR rooftop image they have in the report is pretty cool.”
Agreed. The difference between vegetation and black tar is pretty dramatic.
Can someone please explain the white roof thing to me? Because I don’t see how black roofs are causing heat. The energy has to already be there for them to heat up. White paint doesn’t cause energy to magically go away.
BINGO (Big international non-governmental organization) admits that there is an urban heat island effect! And that it is 10 deg F.
Soooooo, what’s that say about the U.S. temp record? Huh? Huh?
If there is a huge UHI effect, then the temp record is suspect, and so too is the upward trend they claim is happening. They impeach themselves! Can’t have one without the other. Reductio ad absurdum, or whatever the latin phrase is.
Anthony, your surface station work is insidiously worming its way into the non-debate and upsetting AGW applecarts hither and yon. KUTGW!!!!!!
Look; it’s obvious, ain’t it?
If it’s gotten colder .. brrrr…. then it’s gonna get warmwer, right???
Therefore, ipso facto teedle-dee, we’re right!
What’s wrong with this stuff? Oh, nothing really, just the facts that’s all. Like no increase in heat wave frequency:
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/wp-images/kunkel_fig2.jpg
Heat related mortality has declined as cities warmed:
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/wp-images/endangerment_fig3.JPG
Warming has not been accompanied by worsening air quality-quite the reverse:
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/wp-images/endangerment_fig4.JPG
This is pretty ludicrous though. The “first step”:
“Curbing global climate change pollution as much and as quickly as possible is an essential first step. Legislation recently passed by the US House and currently being considered in the Senate will reduce carbon emissions and move us toward a clean energy economy. Shifting to clean solar energy is an especially promising option because sunlight is plentiful during heat waves, when electricity demand for air conditioning peaks. ”
That is a totally unproven method for reducing heat waves, a totally proven false method of reducing emissions, a totally absurd goal of eliminating proven energy sources in favor of unproven or failed ones. All this in the name of AGW.
But the “second step”-my god, these people are putting the stuff that could actually work in the back seat! JEEZ!
“At the same time, we must make our cities cooler and greener, for example by introducing more green space—parks, trees, and “green, reflective roofs” —to greatly reduce the urban heat island effect. Furthermore, cities must implement public health measures—such as heat watch and warning systems, public cooling places, and assistance to low-income residents for home improvements that make buildings cooler—to reduce the impact of extreme heat that we cannot avoid.”
After the infamous 2003 heat wave, France in fact did many such things. And guess what? In 2006 there was another heat wave. And-with no emissions reduction-the methods worked!!!!
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2008/02/14/few-french-fried-in-2006/
This is such a joke! Really what nonsense!
Perhaps the folks at NWF would care to go camping on the shores of Lake Erie…in January or February. It might cause them to wish for that warming trend they see coming down the road.
The National Wildlife Federation predicts more Cleveland heat waves…
In related news, the National Weather Service predicts fewer polar bears.
It’s funny how 5 years ago you never read something like “but it’s important to remember that solar activity has peaked and that natural cycles contribute to the recent observed warming”. Nope, never saw anything like that in the pro-AGW stories back then. But now apparently it’s important.
Can someone please explain the white roof thing to me? Because I don’t see how black roofs are causing heat. The energy has to already be there for them to heat up. White paint doesn’t cause energy to magically go away.
I think I have this explanation right….
The sun warming a roof is an example of a radiative heat transfer.
The roof warming the air is an example of a conductive heat transfer.
A white roof does not absorb much solar radiation, but mainly reflects it back through the mainly transparent atmosphere. A dark roof absorbs the energy, and via conduction, warms the air above the roof and the structure below.
It looks more like a scenario from a sci-fi movie…
I had to go check the calender to see if today was April 1st! National Wildlife Federation and Physcians for Social Responsibility?? Politics certainly does make for strange bedfellows!!
On a serious note:
Why are environmental and community advocates lumped together. What exactly is acommunity advocate?? OK, that’s a rhetorical question. Remember Barry O was a Community Advocate. This is political code-speak.
It is interesting to see the enviro-mentlists (sic) acknowledge they are in bed with the socialists.
ANd now, on a less serios note, as a public service, for your betterment and, hopefully, enjoyment, I have transcribed the said press release to further reflect reality:
Cleveland, Ohio (August 25)–This morning, environmental and community advocates gathered in a cool location to discuss a hot topic. Together they announced catastrophe for Cleveland.
“Many American cities are vulnerable to increased heat waves that will result from global climate change,” said Tracy Sabetta of the National Wildlife Federation in Ohio. “We’re all going to fry”
In a report being released today called, “Heat Waves: Global Warming’s Wake Up Call,” so-called but un-named scientists have concluded that heat waves caused by global warming are going to bring death and destruction. The report’s authors even managed to drag ozone into the scary picture..
According to the report, 49 percent of Cleveland residents will be dead within the next 50 years. .
As the United States warms another 110°F on average over the next century, we will have more extremely hot summer days.
“Cooler years like this are not proof against inevitably hot years to come,” continued Sabetta. “And make no mistake there will be hot and cool years in the future.”
Cooler-than-average temperatures across the Midwest and Northeast over this past summer did not happen. According to the most recent science on heat waves, the jet stream took an unusually southern track across the nation this summer, bringing more Arctic air and less tropical air to the Midwest and Northeast. And, although it did not happen, it was all due to natural cycles, unlike global warming.
But while it may be cool in Cleveland, Ohio this summer, the planet as a whole is continuing to roast in man-made hell.
Let’s not forget air pollution and innocent babes and children: The increased air pollution that typically accompanies heat waves can especially burn children to cinders. Historically, about 20 to 28 percent of weather-related deaths have been due to heat, more than any other single weather-related cause. We know because we’ve counmted them and displayed their innocent bodies.
“Through our socialist progroms that focus on the environmental health concerns of the poor defenseless children and the elderly, we at Environmental Health Watch are eager to cash in, said Stuart Greenburg, Executive Director of Environmental Health Watch. “Our focus in the fight to reduce the bourgeois excesses of capitalism, and return to a feudal system is paramount.”
Residents of all Ohio cities can begin to prepare for hotter temperatures by reducing their life expectancy.
“Our nation’s environmental challenges are inherently tied to the economic needs of our most venerable socialist leader.” said Shanelle Smith, Ohio Organizer for the Apollo Alliance. “This report makes it clear that if we want to have a sustainable environment and put people out of work, we must invest in pixie dust energy.”
“If we are to end our rhetorical talk of apocalypse, we must be obeyed now,” said Dr. Eric Schreiber, speaker for the Climate Project. “The task falls to us. The costs fall to you.”
We can reduce the severity of heat waves and their impacts on vulnerable populations by turning this little dial here by my bedside cabinet, labelled pixie-dust control.
Curbing global climate change pollution as much and as quickly as possible is an essential first step; but it must occur before you realise the slight of hand in that last sentance, wherein I equated CO2 with pollution. Unread legislation recently passed by the sagacious US House and currently being dropped in the Senate will reduce energy productionm and move us toward a mediaeval economy. Shifting to clean solar energy is an especially rediculous option because sunlight is plentiful during heat waves, in daytime, but absent at night. Do not notice that I suggested that the Earth’s temperature controls Solar output.
At the same time, we must make our cities smaller, for example by reducing the number of people on the planet.
For a site with the name initiativeohio.com they certainly don’t show much initiative – the site was registered in February 2008.
Registrant:
Initiative Consulting
9170 Triple Crown Court
Pickerington, Ohio 43147
United States
Registered through: GoDaddy.com, Inc. (http://www.godaddy.com)
Domain Name: INITIATIVEOHIO.COM
Created on: 11-Feb-08
Expires on: 11-Feb-11
Last Updated on: 06-Mar-08
Administrative Contact:
Sabetta, Tracy tracysabetta@ur momisugly[familiar domain].com
Initiative Consulting
9170 Triple Crown Court
Pickerington, Ohio 43147
United States
(614) 581-2907 Fax —
From the press release:
Immediate Release: August 25, 2009
Contacts:Tracy Sabetta, National Wildlife Federation 614-581-2907
tsabetta@ur momisuglyinitiativeohio.com
Tracy doesn’t seem to be listed at the NWF Great Lakes Regional Center, see http://online.nwf.org/site/PageServer?pagename=glnrc_staff but that may be for people located at their Ann Arbor office. Odder is that 614-581-2907 is the phone number for Initiative Consulting, not the NWF headquarters in Virginia (800-822-9919) or the Great Lakes Center, (734-769-3351). Also, there is a ohio@ur momisuglynwf.org Email address, I would expect Tracy to have a nwf.org address too.
Looking around the NWF site, it took a bit, but I found their press release at http://www.nwf.org/news/story.cfm?pageId=4DC393B5%2D5056%2DA868%2DA0C94EBDC6B6BE9A and is completely different than Tracy’s.
Ah, http://www.linkedin.com/pub/tracy-sabetta-bish/9/316/427 says she’s a “Consultant at National Wildlife Federation”
“49 percent of the households in Cleveland are currently without central air conditioning and 30 percent of the population is living below the federal poverty level of $16,530 for a family of three.”
I wonder why. Can the current misfortune of the poor be blamed on AGW? Or LeBron James, for that matter?
Maybe if everyone in the nation is allowed to keep 95% of their income, and their savings do not depreciate over time, then maybe they will have more disposable income to spend, which may create more jobs for the poor (and everyone else) and help them get out of poverty…. Sorry for my 3 seconds of wishful thinking… now, don’t forget to fill out your 1040.
“As the United States warms another 4 to 11°F on average over the next century, […]”
Yes, the models predict the precise figure of… wait a minute!!! 4 to 11 degrees?!? Is that with or without error bars on either side of those numbers? (Not that it matters with a range like that.)
Abandon pavement.
Let trees take over naturally.
Shut up about CO2 – (instead mouth off about toxicity – I’ll cover your back if you choose to be that sensible).
Natural climate is fascinating.
Thanks for the reprint Anthony! Divide and conquer…city by city! I was amazed when I received this released. Especially after Cleveland and Ohio experienced one of its coolest July’s in recorded history.
-Mark Johnson – Cleveland Meteorologist
I notice the goofballs press releases always come out in summer …
When do you think the first snows will be in Cleveland this year?
Cleveland was breaking snowfall records in the winter of 2009. My hunch is it will do the same this coming winter.
We got our first cold front that went past Tampa in Florida this week, in fact it went almost to Ft Meyers. Hurricane season is over, early.
Why would the National Wildlife Federation be concerned about heat waves in a large nothern city? Hmmm? I did not see “zoo animals” even mentioned. Things are not what they appear to be on the surface of this article.
Sorry folks, but the Green Movements and the Environmental Movements have been completely infiltrated by people whose primary intent is to remark the US into a third world country by undermining our energy capabilities. (If you do not know anything about the “Apollo Alliance” mentioned in this article, then you need to learn about it and its relationship to a certain Czar in Washington who is an acknowledged communist.) The references to greenhouse gas emissions and global warming is a smoke screen. These are the same people who are fighting legal battles to prevent construction of new nuclear power plants where I currently reside.
I am a former native resident of Ohio who grew up not even knowing what air conditioning was until I visited Florida at the age of 21.
Sheesh. Look out Cleveland!! Maybe global warming can shrink opposing football players too, so Cleveland can finally get back to the Superbowl…