Another study in the science genre of: The Bleedin’ Obvious
A real study in frontiers in Conservation Science, determines that gorillas drink more water when it’s hot.
ORIGINAL RESEARCH article
Front. Conserv. Sci., 10 March 2022 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fcosc.2022.738820
Introduction
Water has numerous essential roles for animals, such as being a medium for chemical reactions to occur, a transporter of metabolic and waste products, a lubricant and shock absorber (Robbins, 1983; Jéquier and Constant, 2010). In addition, water plays a vital role in thermoregulation (National Research Council, 2003; Mitchell et al., 2009; Jéquier and Constant, 2010; Withers et al., 2016). Maintaining water balance is a major homeostatic objective and critical for growth, reproduction and survival (Karasov and del Rio, 2020). Water requirements are influenced by several factors, such as climatic conditions, diet and metabolic rates (Robbins, 1983; Jéquier and Constant, 2010; Karasov and del Rio, 2020).
Terrestrial animals gain water from food (preformed water), metabolic water resulting from the oxidation of macronutrients and through drinking water (Robbins, 1983; Jéquier and Constant, 2010). Most animals rely on free-standing water sources, but some are able to obtain most of their water needs from metabolic and preformed water (Withers et al., 2016). Understanding how animals obtain and use water is particularly important in the face of climate change, as increasing global temperatures and more extreme weather events are predicted to influence water availability and can have a negative impact on animals’ ability to maintain homeostasis (Hetem et al., 2014; Fuller et al., 2016; Zhang et al., 2019).
Increasing temperature leads to the increased need for evaporative cooling, particularly in endotherms, which requires water (National Research Council, 2003; Withers et al., 2016; Mitchell et al., 2018; Karasov and del Rio, 2020). To compensate for increased water loss when temperatures are high, animals often increase the amount of water consumption (Adams and Hayes, 2008; Dias et al., 2014; Harris et al., 2015; Mella et al., 2019; Chaves et al., 2021). Animals may also increase water drinking during dry periods, which coincide with the times of highest temperature in some areas (Harris et al., 2015; Mella et al., 2019). In addition, the water content of foods may be lower during times of low rainfall and so animals may need to supplement water intake with drinking (Fuller et al., 2016). Animals may also prioritize water rich foods to supplement preformed water intake during periods of low rainfall (Ciani et al., 2001; Sato et al., 2014).
Decreased water availability has been shown to drive increased mortality rates in several species (Cayton and Haddad, 2018; Riddell et al., 2019; Young et al., 2019; Campos et al., 2020). In contrast, rainforest dwelling species may obtain most or all of their water requirements from their diet (Karasov and del Rio, 2020). However, increasing temperatures may lead to increased water drinking as a means to thermoregulate and avoid dehydration (Dias et al., 2014; Chaves et al., 2021). Monitoring changes in water drinking behavior can serve as an early warning indicator of the impacts of climate change as the duration of dry spells and temperatures increase.
A considerable proportion of primate species (22%; 134 of 604) are predicted to be vulnerable to the impacts of drought (Zhang et al., 2019). Moreover, primate habitats are predicted to experience 10% more warming than the global mean increase in temperature, with 86% of primate species likely to experience increases of over 3°C in maximum temperatures by 2050 (Graham et al., 2016; Carvalho et al., 2019). Higher elevation regions are also experiencing faster increases in temperature than lower elevation ones (Wang et al., 2016). Given the vulnerability of primates to dry spells, it is vital to look for indicators of physiological stress in endangered species, such as changes in the occurrence of water drinking caused by climate change (Chapman et al., 2006; Bernard and Marshall, 2020).
Understanding how endangered mountain gorillas obtain and use water is particularly warranted as they are vulnerable to the risk of extinction for a number of reasons. Only around 1,000 individuals remain in two small isolated mountaintop islands of Uganda, Rwanda, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo over an area of approximately 784 km2 (Eckardt et al., 2019; Granjon et al., 2020). The slow life history of mountain gorillas limits their ability to evolve beneficial adaptions that are better suited to new climatic conditions sufficiently quickly to mitigate the detrimental effects of climate change (Robbins, 2011). Mountain gorillas are also geographically highly restricted due to intense human pressure surrounding their current habitat, such that they cannot disperse to other areas (Robbins, 2011).
Mountain gorillas generally obtain sufficient quantities of water from the vegetation they consume and they rarely drink water (Schaller, 1963). The water content of mountain gorilla foods is high, with most foods comprising between 60 and 90% water (Rothman et al., 2006; Grueter et al., 2016), with little seasonal variation (within-species) in the Virunga Volcanoes (Watts, 1998). Mountain gorilla habitat is characterized by bimodal rainfall distribution (heavier rains in March-May and lighter rains in September-November), with temperature mostly being a function of elevation and showing little seasonal variation (Polansky and Robbins, 2013; Seimon and Phillips, 2015; Diem et al., 2019; Eckardt et al., 2019). Both Uganda and Rwanda are already experiencing the impact of climate change with increasing temperatures and frequencies of extreme weather events (Safari, 2012; McGahey et al., 2013; Tenge et al., 2013; Nsubuga et al., 2014; Nsubuga and Rautenbach, 2018). Mean annual temperature increases of approximately 2.1°C have been recorded over the last 5 decades (McGahey et al., 2013; Nsubuga and Rautenbach, 2018). Future projections indicate that this trend is likely to continue, with increases of 1 to 2.5°C between 2000 and 2050 (Tenge et al., 2013; Nsubuga and Rautenbach, 2018). Furthermore, rainfall has become less seasonal, with both an increase in rainfall over time and increases in the duration of dry spells, trends that are likely to continue in the future (Kizza et al., 2009; McGahey et al., 2013; Diem et al., 2019; Salerno et al., 2019; Ojara et al., 2020).
To investigate if changes in climatic conditions could impact water drinking patterns of mountain gorillas, we examined water drinking behavior between 2010 and 2020 in the two remaining populations of mountain gorillas and correlated this to local maximum temperature and rainfall. We tested the prediction that mountain gorillas drink more often during hotter and drier periods. After observing notable differences in the frequency of water drinking between the two populations, we compared the water content of key foods between the two mountain gorilla populations to see if this could explain differences in their behavior.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcosc.2022.738820/full
Of course to get funding this frame was needed.
Undoubtedly, the direct impact of climate change is likely to be a bigger problem for species living in more arid environments that face reduced access to sufficient quantities of either free-standing sources of water or preformed water (Fuller et al., 2016; Cayton and Haddad, 2018; Mitchell et al., 2018; Wessling et al., 2018; Riddell et al., 2019; Young et al., 2019; Campos et al., 2020). Many avenues of future research into this topic remain to better determine how much of a risk increased temperature poses for the mountain gorillas. However, this study emphasizes that climate change may have negative consequences even for rainforest dwelling mammals that routinely obtain nearly all of their water from dietary items. This may be especially true for endangered species in small isolated populations which are vulnerable to drought and the risk of extinction.
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcosc.2022.738820/full
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Duuh!
Je suis gorilla.
Mais oui mon ami. link
Jordan Peterson would also point out that you are lobster as well.
Jordan Peterson following a blind link to Nonsensical American. Tsk tsk tsk.
Falsifiability is the boundary demarcation of science from nonsense.
It’s hot and I’m thirsty….
Is my Nobel in the post?
And you’re landlocked into a limited geographical area by humans, so climate change is reducing your access to water and new foraging areas…
im pretty sure gorillas would be more than capable of finding water provided BY human habitats. in west Aus the greentards took over farmland ripped out water points and troughs to allow nature to restore itself
well it did the reliant on mankind water roos and others died nasty deaths
They can’t be serious, surely. They can’t be that desperate to find alarming “what if” scenarios.
Hey, look, in just the text quoted in the above article they managed to squeeze in the phrase “climate change” a total of seven—yes, seven!—times.
And, I have absolutely no interest in going to the full article to find out how many more times they use that obvious-but-unquantified, red herring phrase.
“they managed to squeeze in the phrase “climate change” a total of seven—yes, seven!—times.” And none of them cut the mustard
“how animals obtain and use water is particularly important in the face of climate change”
That is a complete word salad. How about “climate change forces dogs and cats to adapt by drinking from domestic toilets”?
“Monitoring changes in water drinking behavior can serve as an early warning indicator of the impacts of climate change”
It can also highlight the differences in drinking behaviour between winter and summer months.
Was this garbage peer reviewd?
Green nonsense like this is never peer reviewed and usually just pall reviewed to insure that it hits all the talking points needed to support confirmation bias.
I not sure it was even pee reviewed.
Oh, the horrors!
and they do this because??
A;the water bowl elsewhere is empty
B; the water IN the loo bowl is clean(if you dont use chemical muck in it) and its COOL!
friends dog not only preferred the loo he learnt to lift the lid to get to it she had to change the door handles as well to round not lever, to prevent it
8 Authors
4300 Words
70 references
25 hits [Ctrl-F] “climate change”
Funding: Grand Duchy of Luxembourg
That equates to 8 academic promotions and the opportunities for more travel funding.
Steve ==> Yes
Funding
This project was funded by the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg under the United Nations Environment Programme Vanishing Treasures Programme, Max Planck Society and Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund.
vanishing grant money more like
Look at the sale statistics what breweries sell in summer and what in winter.
And try to find out what the differences are standing for.
It was a fun trip though.
Mountain gorillas in the rainforest. Uganda. Bwindi Impenetrable Forest National Park. Photo caption
A real fun trip but how did they get in to an Impenetrable Forest?
Not mentioned was how these gorillas survived the Medieval Warm Period.
What’s next to study with tax funds? What percent of the time does the Sun rise in the east? If that study goes up for bid I’m in.
The entirety of the above article could be reduced to this single sentence:
“Send us more funding and don’t worry how your money is being spent.”
The majority of government funded university research can be reduced to that sentence.
And, “Send the money quickly! I’m up for consideration of tenure in six months.”
Reading that made me thirsty. The Muenchener Gold is wonderful.
I’ll have to make do with a Stella Artois for now.
Hobgoblin!
Bishop’s Finger!
(Shepherd Neame)
Had not considered this until now, but I am going to seek out Obolon Lager, a Ukrainian beer. I suspect it will go down easier than a Russian vodka (haven’t had any in a long time. I drink Tito’s, made in Texas).
What ever happened to “arctic regions are expected to experience the greatest warming?”
I tried to follow the links to the two references for the “over 3°C increases” claim, but they both just led back to this study.
Who is predicting (sorry, “projecting”) such a large rise and on what evidence?
Alan, answers to your questions: IPCC, none.
But that was meant to be a rhetorical question, wasn’t it? 🙂
First off, primates come from a wide variety of habitats.
Secondly the area where mountain gorillas come from is pretty humid and even the IPCC has been forced to admit that areas with lots of water in the air are not going to see much if any warming from CO2 due to the overlap between CO2 and H2O.
The direct links were indeed to the “References” section of this study.
Following the “CrossRef Full Text” options there, however, led me to the “Abstracts” of the papers in question (in both cases, the full papers are paywalled …) :
URL 1, Graham et al (2016) : https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10764-016-9890-4
URL 2, Carvalho et al (2019) : https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/gcb.14671
NB : The first Abstract includes the “We found that overall, nonhuman primates will experience 10% more warming than the global mean …” claim, it’s the second one we’re after.
From the Carvalho et al Abstract :
Again, the full paper is paywalled, but the “Supporting Information” file would indicate that their “best-case scenario” is actually RCP 4.5 (see Tables S2 and S4).
AR6 (the WG1 report from last September) basically designated their “worst-case scenario” (RCP 8.5, quelle surprise, which is bracketed by the newer SSP3-7.0 and SSP5-8.5 pathways …) as “counterfactual”, while the “future emission trends in the absence of additional climate policies” option was qualified as “approximately in line with the medium RCP4.5, RCP6.0 and SSP2-4.5 scenarios” (see page 1-110).
RCP 4.5 = the “consensus view’s” current worst-case scenario (/ pathway).
RCP 8.5 = science fiction / hysterical scaremongering / …
Therefore, instead of experiencing a year-to-year average increase of about 0.018 deg C, the poor gorillas will have to endure almost 0.020 deg C! Will they be able to find enough water to sate their thirst? Stay tuned for the next chapter of Modern Gorillas.
What is preformed water?
Dihydrogen monoxide – a very nasty chemical
Well, Mark, I was going to post a link to Penn & Teller’s petition to ban the aforementioned, but it’s been disappeared on Youtube etc
“This video isn’t available anymore”
I’ll let you draw your own conclusions on why that should be.
Addendum
Go to 00:30 on….
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RF1nwuRFD3w&t=3s
One they missed.
Dihydrogen monoxide is a deadly poison. link
According to the CDC dihydrogen monoxide kills nearly 4000 people per year in the US alone.
https://www.cdc.gov/drowning/facts/index.html
And, people have been known to suffocate breathing in the liquid phase! In fact, it is so common that there is a special word for it — drowning.
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=penn+and+teller+DHMO&qpvt=penn+and+teller+DHMO&view=detail&mid=9E231EFBEFC38614A4F69E231EFBEFC38614A4F6&&FORM=VRDGAR&ru=%2Fvideos%2Fsearch%3Fq%3Dpenn%2Band%2Bteller%2BDHMO%26qpvt%3Dpenn%2Band%2Bteller%2BDHMO%26FORM%3DVDRE at 40 seconds after fearmongering “Dr Caldicott
Is it anything like packaged dehydrated water?
It comes in a container shaped like a 1-liter bottle. All you have to do is add water, shake, and pour.
“What is preformed water?”
Consecrated water? Perhaps using pixie dust?
Go to a website, click on the link to “Buy a Pond” and have it shipped to you (free shipping with Amazon RainForest Prime).
Once you open the box, lay it out flat, and enjoy your new pond.
Yah, but… whudda ’bout da fish? Do I just toss my fish & chips leftovers in and check back in the morning?
MarkW asked “What is preformed water?”
Most commonly known as “ice cubes”. Up until reading the above article, I had no idea gorillas had those in their diet.
Can gin-and-tonics be far behind?
“ Fluid can enter the body as preformed water, ingested food and drink, and, to a lesser extent, as metabolic water that is produced as a by-product of aerobic respiration and dehydration synthesis. A constant supply is needed to replenish the fluids lost through normal physiological activities, such as respiration, sweating, and urination.
Water generated from the biochemical metabolism of nutrients provides a significant proportion of the daily water requirements for some arthropods and desert animals, but it provides only a small fraction of a human’s necessary intake. In the normal resting state, the input of water through ingested fluids is approximately 2500 ml/day.”
Which, in turn, invites the question, what the heck is “dehydration synthesis”?
How does it differ from normal dehydration and why does it need to be synthesized?
Uh, … ok….
I j ust found a way tro filter wuwt emails..
Any chance you can put that in English?
Are you asking for grant money, too?
OK, but have you come up with a way to do that for comments being posted?
Gorillas will drink when they are thirsty implying that gorillas have more sense than the authors of this self evident tripe who publish when they want attention from their gormless nitwit peers and of course more dosh to study more of the bleeding obvious.
I counted 40 references which seemed to be there to legitimises the most banal of obvious facts and observations. I suppose this childish crap passes as scholarship these days
While the paper shows many indirect claims of necessity of more study, it may be mainly a “wheel rediscovery” as the title suggests. “Under these conditions, drinking water may be an effective way of reducing body temperature and reestablishing homeostasis. This result is similar to findings in several other species (Adams and Hayes, 2008; Dias et al., 2014; Harris et al., 2015; Mella et al., 2019; Chaves et al., 2021).”
I read reasonable papers that often end up with an indirect form of begging. Pressure to publish, measured by numerically based “impact factors” helps make university, and even some governmental labs, research incredibly busy. As noted here before from Sigma Xi, National Honor Research Society, part of the climate crisis pusher crowd. “We are thrilled to invite you to join our monthly virtual mental health workshop, hosted by our wellness partner, Happy. We are dedicated to de-stigmatizing and improving mental health in the research community.” While they don’t understand the cause, it may be a wonder that it is not worse.
It’s not just publication pressure, but also in many other areas leading to producing students as lab assistants and obtaining great titles for their faculty members, departments, institutes, correspondence and advancement. Like some generals in some countries?
Only humans drink water when they aren’t thirsty. These over-educated word-smiths find it difficult to understand that animals show more common sense and only drink when they are thirsty.
Wouldn’t it be a better study to see if the guerillas’ habit is actually getting drier and if the guerillas have plenty of sources of water? A real study with physical measurements?
So many words wasted. Why do Gorilla’s drink water in warm weather? – no access to cold beer. Why do idiots write pseudoscientific papers about it – too much access to Russian vodka and unearned grant money.
But the authors got the got the trip of a lifetime at conservation concerned contributors’ expense.
And lovely photos to put on their Facebook page.
So, gorillas have no problem adapting to slightly higher temperatures. Great news for gorillas everywhere.
Perhaps we need a study to examine whether humans consume more water in hot conditions?
Humans consume more alcohol under lockdown.
How would we know otherwise? I guess we could have polled the gorillas and see what the survey says.
It sounds silly (ok, you got me, this study is silly) but there are plenty of “facts” in science that are really just assumptions. Climate “science” is full of unproven assumptions, too many to list here.
On the other hand, what have we really learned and how can the fact gorillas drink more when it’s hot and dry be applied? I can think of better use of time and money.
No comment. I can’t be more generous.
The commenters don’t credit the authors enough for their ingenious play on
climate changeglobal warming hysteria to fund their dream trip to see charismatic megafauna in the wild; an expensive trip that generally only relatively wealthy Westerners get to make. I’m thinking about getting funding to study the effects of sea level rise on the surf swell in Tahiti.I am more than willing, for only the price of a plane ticket and hotel stay, to vigorously study the effects of climate change at topless beaches in the south of France.
No, you really don’t want to do that. Been there, done that. I’ve seen dozens of beautiful topless females since that trip, but the sight of the obese ninety year old topless person (pretty sure it was a female) I saw there is still seared in my brain.
Be careful what you wish for.
The comments here as sooo negative!
Just imagine if this valuable study had found the opposite and what that would have meant to the dangerous acceleration of sea level rise?
Fortunately the gorillas drink more so we’re safe from the rising seas – for now.
But wait – they now have to study the effect of warming on the drinking habits of chimps.
(Not to mention the effect of warming on my drinking habits)
I just added the thirsty gorilla: https://www.numberwatch.co.uk/warmlist.htm
Next thing you know they will be labeled climate refugees and get an earmark in the budget along with monthly childcare payments.
John Kerry says we’ve already seen millions of climate refugees.
This kind of “research” is what prompted Putin to invade and annex without fear. Look up quotes from him to get the connection.
Putin sees a West that has corroded from within with PC, Wokery and identity politics. Know your pronouns.
How will the West defend what it so abhors – itself? To make it easier on Putin there’s a brainless bimbo and a bumbling, illucid old fool in the White House, a busted UK PM, a weak new German Chancellor and Macron at the end of his term.
What better time could there be?
I’m not sure I would go so far as to elevate her to the status of a “bimbo.”
In a related subject: Water is wet.
Oh No!! Hot weather causes gorillas to drink more water. This never happened before! It’s climate change! We’re all gonna die! … Oh yeah and it’s Trumps fault. /sarc.
Once again they conflate higher maximum temperatures with rising average temperatures.