Guest geological observation by David Middleton
From the American Association for the Advancement of SCIENCE! of America…
Ship spies largest underwater eruption ever
By Roland PeaseMay. 21, 2019 , 1:20 PM
Last week, Marc Chaussidon, director of the Institute of Geophysics in Paris (IPGP), looked at seafloor maps from a recently concluded mission and saw a new mountain. Rising from the Indian Ocean floor between Africa and Madagascar was a giant edifice 800 meters high and 5 kilometers across. In previous maps, there had been nothing. “This thing was built from zero in 6 months!” Chaussidon says.His team, along with scientists from the French national research agency CNRS and other institutes, had witnessed the birth of a mysterious submarine volcano, the largest such underwater event ever witnessed. “We have never seen anything like this,” says IPGP’s Nathalie Feuillet, leader of an expedition to the site by the research vessel Marion Dufresne, which released its initial results last week.
The quarter-million people living on the French island of Mayotte in the Comoros archipelago knew for months that something was happening. From the middle of last year they felt small earthquakes almost daily, says Laure Fallou, a sociologist with the European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre in Bruyères-le-Châtel, France. People “needed information,” she says. “They were getting very stressed, and were losing sleep.”
[…]
Science! As in “She blinded me with…”
Did I read this correctly?
A sociologist with the European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre…
WTF?
The European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre employs sociologists? They don’t even employ spellcheck.
Spies? Largest? Ever?
Ship spies largest underwater eruption ever
- If the FBI doesn’t “spy”… How can a ship “spy”?
- I seriously doubt that it’s the “largest underwater eruption ever”.
I’m fairly certain that these were a whole lot larger:

(University of Leicester)
Yes… I know those aren’t individual volcanoes… However, all of the Hawaiian islands would have been larger underwater volcanoes before they became islands. Maybe they just mean that it’s the largest underwater volcano that has ever been surreptitiously observed by a ship.
Now that I’ve gotten the easy bits of ridicule out of the way… This is kind of a cool story.
Data from the seismometers, retrieved by the expedition this month, show a tightly clustered region of earthquake activity, ranging from 20 to 50 kilometers deep in Earth’s crust. The team suspects a deep magma chamber fed molten rock to the sea floor and then contracted, driving the cracking and creaking of surrounding crust. GPS measurements on Mayotte also suggest a shrinking magma chamber: They show the island has sunk by 13 centimeters and moved 10 centimeters east in the past year.The map of the sea floor, made by the ship’s multibeam sonar, indicates that as much as 5 cubic kilometers of magma erupted onto the sea floor. The sonar also detected plumes of bubble-rich water rising from the center and flanks of the volcano. Feuillet says her team didn’t see the shoals of dead fish that fisherman reported, but they did collect water samples from the plumes. The chemistry of the water will give clues about the composition of the magma, the depth from which it came, and the risk of an explosive eruption.
Science! As in “She blinded me with…”

MAYOBS TEAM (CNRS/IPGP-UNIVERSITÉ DE PARIS/IFREMER/BRGM)”
Cassidy says the new volcano is probably too deep to cause a dangerous tsunami onshore. But he is worried by the westward migration of the small earthquakes toward Mayotte, which could potentially trigger a collapse of the submarine flank of Mayotte itself. “This scenario could certainly create a tsunami,” he says.Feuillet wants to extend her team’s mission by several months to monitor this geological mystery as it develops.
Science! As in “She blinded me with…”


Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Laure Fallou is a seismosociologist. There are some mentions on Google, so I guess it is real, some kind of new field. Only time will tell if it’s fruitful.
“Several Theoratical Problems in – Gated.
http://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL-ZGZD199104009.
“In this paper we systematically discussed some important theoretical problems about the new-developed subject-seismosociology. First,the macro-environment in which seismosociology emerged and developed is specified, Second, we explored the meaning nature, object, task and method of it. Finally, we pointed out the importance of the cooperation between seismologists and sociologists in studying and developing this new subject.”
“SEISMOSOCIOLOGY AND EARTHQUAKE PREDICTION” – in Chinese.
http://www.nceqsci.com/EN/abstract/abstract1736.shtml
“Three factors of people’ sense from earthquake danger are as follows: possible destructive degree of predicted earthquake, accuracy of prediction and urgency degree of possible forthcoming earthquake. These factors are not only relayed to earthquake prediction, but also are closerly related to seismosoci-ological problems. In the future, we need to study the seismosociological problem under the superposition of earthquake problem with other various serious unfavourable events.“
Drop the seismo.
She is simply a sociologist addressing human behavior and fear responses (human emotions). She is not addressing any physical system behavior or characteristics. If she were studying people’s fears of tornados, would we call her a tornadosociologist? Of course not.
Compare this to an astrobiologist. An astrobiologist addresses possible alternatives to Earth biology in alien environments. They apply physical rules of free energy equations, known physical properties of water and energy transport, and construction of molecules in alien environments that could perform enzymatic reactions and self replication of patterns of molecules.
The harsh fact is just that social sciences really aren’t science.
Larry,
I respect your reasonable nature… but there is no such thing as a seismo-sociologist or a socio-seismologist. The Earth doesn’t give a rat’s @ur momisugly$$ about society… it doesn’t even notice society… fake sciences and fake words notwithstanding.
Don’t be so open minded that your brains fall out.
My interest is in short and long term climate modification ny variable volcanic activity, from 100Ka global ice age cause to short term localised extreme and also seasonal effects. I alrady asked if there was an warm ocean blob associated with theextreme and unusual weather in Madagascar and East Africa, et voila!
So this is easy to assess for me.
And now it seems a bloody great new volcano 5Km^3 popped up on the sea floor in the designated area.
Is there a warm ocean blob as I suggested? Can’t see how there won’t be if that much magma has hit the ocean in a few months….. numbers…..
5Km^3 is 5×10^9 m^3 so 14×10^9 tonnes at 1.4×10^9 Joules per tonne for crystalised magma = 20×10^18 Joules.
That’s enough to warm 5×10^15Kg of ocean by one degree, hence roughly 5×10^15 Cubic metres.
So that’s a volume of water of 5 Million cubic Kilometres raised by 1 degree K, or a smaller amount by more, all in 6 months. The heat will rise so SST must have risen, hence more extreme evaporation in the localised area, et voila….… I suggest the climate event cause was a volcano, under the ocean, with magma. CO2 is innocent!
“The quarter-million people living on the French island of Mayotte in the Comoros archipelago knew for months that something was happening. …“They were getting very stressed, and were losing sleep.””
I blame Trump. Or maybe global warming. Or maybe both.
Don’t forget Brexit…when ever an event is looking for a cause Brexit is always there, just ask the BBC.
Yukcevic: Some time ago you posted about the Earth’s north magnetic pole splitting between Siberia and Northern Canada and about how the magnetosphere has been modified and it may be affecting the Polar Jet and Vortex. Did I get that right? Anyway, it’s an interesting hypothesis since things are being very strange now and the normal models can’t explain it. This is an interesting sitrep:
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-05-23/floods-drought-devastate-crops-all-over-planet-global-food-crisis-be-coming
In case you were serious about where the image for the earthquake map came from. I plotted a similar one on the USGS earthquake map. I would post the whole link but since the filters are included in the link it is very long so I used a URL shortner.
https://on.doi.gov/2HAR5C0
Different bathymetry display… but still a cool map. USGS has a lot of cool mapping tools.
The specific image I included in the post must have an original scientific source… But doing a Google search of the image, just yielded new age syfy schist.
Could this happen anywhere ihe world? Do we have a volcano emergency?