
Guest essay by Eric Worrall
Vanity Fair asked academics to name which Game of Thrones characters match the personality and roles of their climate heroes.
Who Is the Jon Snow of Climate Change?
Game of Thrones-loving climate experts explain how every major player has a real-world climate warrior counterpart. (Tyrion Lannister is Leonardo DiCaprio!)
“There’s squabbling among the kingdoms about issues that seem pressing. But meanwhile, far away, there is this looming threat that could eclipse all of it,” says Katharine Davis Reich, associate director at the UCLA IoES Center for Climate Science. She’s talking about Game of Thrones—and also our response to climate change.
Of course, there’s at least one major difference between the two: winter is coming to Westeros, but disappearing on Earth. Still, both worlds’ most pressing problems involve a rejection of information gathered on the front lines, migrations of vulnerable populations that unsettle adjacent communities, and a potential tipping point past which there is no hope of survival.
Peter Griffith, a scientist in Baltimore, MD, who works in the field of carbon cycle and climate, made the connection early while reading the first book in George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series: “Any time there was news from the Wall, and it was ridiculed by King’s Landing—the old stories that nursemaids tell to scare children—there was an immediate sense of, boy, this sounds familiar.”
…
James Salzman, professor of environmental law at the UCLA School of Law and the Bren School of Environmental Science & Management at UC Santa Barbara, admits that there is not an obvious analog for the Khaleesi, mother of dragons and hero to the oppressed. Then again, “maybe she’s Angela Merkel.
…
Wildlings = Pacific Islanders
“The Wildlings are the first to feel the effects [of the threat], not unlike Pacific Islanders and people in the tropics,” Griffith opines. Reich agrees: “If the Wildlings are the ones being terrorized by White Walkers, that’s like people in the tropics, who are already getting hit with climate-change impacts, such as sea-level rise in the Pacific Islands, or the permafrost melt that threatens Alaska villages.”
…
Jon Snow = Michael Mann
First, Salzman considers Al Gore: like the former vice president, Snow “is telling inconvenient truths. The Night’s Watch obviously doesn’t like what Jon has to say.” But after a bit more thought, he says, “Michael Mann would be better. He’s been pilloried.”
Really, the similarities are undeniable. In a phone interview, Mann explains his role as an activist: “I didn’t come to politics, politics came to me. Back in the late 1990s, when I suddenly found myself under assault by climate-change deniers looking to discredit it, and to discredit me, I found myself in a battle I never signed up for. Even though I would probably be happier spending my life the way I had originally intended—in the lab, educating the next generation—I don’t think there’s any more noble pursuit than trying to inform the discourse over what might be the greatest challenge that we face as a civilization.”
…
There you have it – Michael Mann is the pilloried hero who saves the world, by venturing into the darkness and discovering the truth.
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Never watched Game of Thrones. Did I miss anything important?
Apparently not as long a you watched Michael Mann’s trials and tribulations. (No, I didn’t watch GoT either.)
It’s a good show. Lots of twists and turns. A lot of the good guys get killed and the bad guys prosper.
Did you miss anything? Not really. I must say I have liked it, one of only two TV shows I’ve even considered worth buying in the lat 30 years (I dont have TV itself). I actually found I cared what happened, which is unusual for me in TV shows.
Does Canada jail folks for Contempt of court?
Michael Mann is no Jon Snow. Seems to me he resembles Alliser Thorne more closely.
Michael Mann is no Alliser Thorne, Shifty, devious, treacherous, evasive, manipulative. Littlefinger to a tee.
Naw, MM is more of a blunt instrument. He isn’t subtle enough to be Baelish. Thorne is the better fit.
IMHO. all of the above posted commentary about the “Game of Thrones” is proof positive that our Public Education System has morphed into becoming an abject failure at educating the masses in reading, writing, arithmetic and science.
Someone, ….. anyone, …… “QUICK”, …. think up a “Game of Education” for each of the different subject matters …… and get it implemented post haste into the curriculum of the PES.
Will there be betrayal, blood, battles, dragons, magic and heroes in the ‘Game of Education’?… This is starting to sound like history class… Except for the heroes, magic and dragons part… Oh yeah, will it be entertaining? :))
When I was at Grammar School in the UK we certainly did have betrayal, blood, battles, magic, heroes and dragons.
And that was only on the rugby pitch.
I must have gone to sleep as normal and woken up on planet Zog.
Quiet please. I am analyzing.
DiCaprio, Merkel, Mann, Gore. So you want to play Game of Thrones. Let’s play with my samurai
I don’t watch GoT either, but I’m positive that the one on the left in that photo is Naomi Oreskes. (EG)
Naomi Oreskes isn’t that good looking. Even suspension of disbelief has its limits.
Speaking of “good looking” have you looked in a mirror recently?
Why yes, I have. I make Brad Pitt look like an onion. :))
http://visionsource.com/patients/find-a-doctor/
Thanks for the link but, I don’t need glasses. Maybe you should avail yourself of the service. 🙂
Then please try this on your mirror: http://www.windex.com/en-us/pages/default.aspx
Lord Monckton’s twin sister, if the good Lord were Greek:
I prefer http://www.spraywayinc.com/
But thanks for the suggestion.
Shoot the walking dead zombie!! WTF is that you Naomi?
http://bestbachelorpartylasvegas.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Sexy-Girls-and-Guns.jpg
I have not seen the series so I am going to pick up a character from other series. What about Mr. Hankey?
Now, now, we’re talking GOT, not South Park. :))
Yes indeed, more concentration needed otherwise you will be sent to some kind of camp.
Time for a Lewandowski survey: percentage of climate change believers who watch GoT vs. percentage of den1ers, followed by some lengthy fantasy about what it means. Sub-survey: percentage of GoT viewers who dress up in costumes or uniforms while watching the show.
“…percentage of GoT viewers who dress up in costumes or uniforms while watching the show.”
I watch the show in my bathrobe…does that count? 🙂
Alan,
I have never watched GoT, as I am not a fan of the fantasy ‘Social Justice Warrior’ meme that underlies so much of that ilk. I am an avid fan of ‘hard’ science fiction though, as it often gives perspectives on where our developing sciences are leading mankind.
GoT – SJW?
Very funny. What are the odds that there will be a 97% somewhere in there?
Life imitating art or Art imitating life … or fantasy imitating fantasy.
following through with the analogies ….
CAGW = ICE ZOMBIES = BOOGIEMANINTHECLOSET = IRRATIONAL FEAR
Michael Mann is Petyr Baelish — scheming perpetual liar who is singularly focused on self-promotion. All the “deniers” who have lost jobs or grants due to their honesty would qualify as Ned Stark. I’m hoping Scott Pruitt will be Arya Stark and bring justice to the criminals.
Naw, Michael Mann is not smart enough to be Baelish. Peter Gleick is Baelish
No, no … simply no. Ned Stark is clearly Al Gore. Let me break it down for you:
1) Ned was always banging on about climate change (Winter is comin’!”)
2) Ned was always second to the King (Bob).
3) Ancillary evidence – the King to which Ned was SiC was an infamous philanderer.
4) Ned’s attempt to seize power was doomed – clearly he was politically naïve and that, as much as anything, led to his downfall.
I’d say the better analogy for “deniers” is Bronn or Tyrion. Both are pragmatic and worldly wise. Both know where true power lies and seek to work with or around it. They are survivors. Plus they have all the best lines.
I forgot to add:
5) Ned’s whole life story hinges around one big lie (who begat Jon).
Worrall, you should have gotten a screen shoot of Emilia Clarke, season 3, episode 8 at about the 47 minute mark.
A little to risqué for WUWT. Ms. Clark does have a nice body though. 🙂
The Warmists can only find solace in fantasy. SMDH
Leonardo DiCaprio can’t be Tyrion Lannister. Tyrion “knows stuff”.
You’ll notice Leonardo DiCaprio in this scene from season 6 episode 5…playing Tryion Lannister.
I don’t think this is what is meant when we ask kids who quote Harry Potter to “read another book…”.
Seriously, if you follow the book/show, you’ll know that the dominant religion of the Seven Kingdoms is based on fairy tales…which makes it an apt comparison to climate change fanaticism.
Cool! Can we do Tolkien next?
…. Micheal Mann would be the emasculated character called Reek if I had any say it.
MM isn’t, quite, that pathetic.
No, that would be our friend from the UEA, he was the first one to lose his balls.
Coincidently, Mann’s next paper is titled ‘Summer is Coming’
I’m quite comfortable that the article and threads are mostly gibberish to me.
What is a “Game of thrones?…
Or for that matter a Vanity Fair?”
Game of Thrones (GoT) is a fantasy TV series on HBO. It based on a series of books written by George R.R. Martin. The TV series is preparing to start its 7th season.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_of_Thrones
Vanity Fair is a magazine.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanity_Fair_(magazine)
I can see the parallel to G.O.T. …. except, my view, and I do watch the series, the entire Leftist Cabal are pretty much all the various groups vying for power. All the characters, [and climate scientists of the left] are interchangeable. None of them represent Jon Snow .. nor any of the Stark clan.