
Image Credit: Photobucket.com – GISP2 – Alley, 2000
By WUWT regular “Just The Facts”
In building WUWT Paleoclimate Reference Page during these crowdsourcing threads (1, 2) there have been a number disputes raised about various graphs. During this thread I am hoping that we can determine logical classifications for graphs based upon Alley, 2000. In future crowdsourcing threads we will have to address an array of other disputed reconstructions including Briffa et al., 1998, Jones et al., 1998, Mann et al., 1998, Pollack et al., 1998, Jones et al., 1998, Mann et al., 1999, Mann et al., 2000, Briffa et al., 2001, Esper et al., 2002 and Jones and Mann 2004, AR4 section 6.6.1.1 2007 and Marcott et al. 2013.
Thus far three methods have been used for classifying disputed graphs on the WUWT Paleoclimate Reference Page. The first is to add a “Graph Background” link to offer additional pertinent details. The second is to add a Disputed Graph label to the graph, along with a brief description of the nature of the dispute. The third is to place the graph in the section at the bottom of the Paleoclimate page titled Incorrect/Falsified Graphs along with a longer description of the reason the graph is incorrect or has been falsified. Your suggested improvements to our graph classification methodology are most welcome.
I this thread I’d like to solidify the classifications for the graphs based upon Alley, 2000. The dispute around Alley, 2000 has focused on the axis labels, as WUWT commenter Phil states here
Any graph that claims to use Alley’s GISP2 data must either finish at 95 years Before Present (BP=1950) or AD1855 because that is the final date in his database which is on-line and freely available to us all. Lappi’s graph mistakes Present for 2000 as does Easterbrook, they should have a note added pointing out their error or be excluded.
Based on Alley’s own Figure 1 from his 2000 paper;

the x axis label is Age (thousand years before 1950) or Years Before Present (1950AD) and the Alley, 2000 data clearly ends 0.0951409 thousand years Before Present. Taking that into account, the following are the graphs from the WUWT Paleoclimate Reference Page know to be based upon Alley, 2000 and their proposed Classifications:
2,500 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Correct – No Change

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Correct – No Change

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Correct – No Change

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000, Ljungqvist et al and HadCRUT3 Classification: Correct – No Change

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Confusing – Add Label: Disputed Graph – The x axis label should read Years Before Present (1950 AD)

10,000 Years – GISP – Alley, 2000 – Vostok – Petit et al. 1999 – Click for Animation – Classification: Confusing – Add Label: Disputed Graph – The x axis labels should read Years Before Present (1950 AD)

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Incorrect – Move to Incorrect/Falsified Graphs section – Label Incorrect Graph – The x axis label, “Years Before Present (2000 AD)”, should read Years Before Present (1950 AD)

10,000 Years – GISP2 – Alley, 2000 Classification: Incorrect – Move to Incorrect/Falsified Graphs section – Label Incorrect Graph – The x axis label, “Years Before Present (2000 AD)”, should read Years Before Present (1950 AD)

Please provide your thoughts and recommendations on these proposed graph classifications and labels for the Alley graphs, as well as any other improvements, corrections or other additions to the WUWT Paleoclimate Reference Page in comments below.