Gardens of Old Porites, Without Sharks

Reposted from Jennifer Marohasy’s Blog

December 9, 2020 By jennifer 

It is often reported that the Great Barrier Reef is half dead, specifically that the corals are bleached, and the water quality is degraded with pesticides and plastics. If I didn’t know better, I might never want to visit a coral reef, lest I be forced to confront this reality – apparently all our fault. Except the coral reefs that I dived last week each made me feel so alive, and in awe of their extraordinary beauty – especially Myrmidon reef which is an ancient and detached coral reef that juts out into the Pacific Ocean on the eastern edge of the Great Barrier Reef. But we didn’t see many sharks.

The sparse reef crest at Myrmidon with Stuart measuring out 10 metres for the first transect, while also holding his camera.

The coral reef called Myrmidon is perhaps as old as the city of Troy. In mythology, that city existed about 5,000 years ago and it was attacked by Achilles and 50 ships each carrying 50 Myrmidons. Paleo-climatologists will argue that that geological period, known as the middle Holocene (7,000 to 4,500 years ago), was much warmer than the present with sea levels at least 1.5 metres higher than they are today along the east coast of Australia including at the Great Barrier Reef.

Perhaps everything seemed unusually magical last Wednesday at Myrmidon because I dived into such crystal-clear water, and it was so sunny. Looking back over the video footage, Myrmidon reef did not have particularly luxurious corals, but there was an iridescence and a beauty that I’ve not seen before. It was so evident that the live corals were growing on-top of dead corals, not one or two generations dead, but representing thousands of years of growth and destruction from cyclones and bleaching events. The reef was unashamedly beautiful yet with so much exposed that represented layers and layers of dead coral. The regrowth was so clearly on eroded antecedent surfaces.

Where we first jumped in at Myrmidon, the coral was sparse and stunted and there were piles of coral rubble some newly dead and covered in green algae. My dive-buddy Shaun, and underwater videographer Stuart, swam with me around a ledge that led us down into an underwater canyon. Green parrot fish swam metres above a giant clam with an ink black body speckled with florescent blue zooxanthellae. I knelt beside it, I was 17 metres under-the-water and feeling part of another world. Stuart was not too far away, deciding which of the massive Porites along the walls of the canyon we would measure, and Shaun would photograph – then we ran the photographic transect.

Porites are the old boulder corals, which like the oldest trees in temperate forests, can be cored to reveal a climate history. I was not at Myrmidon to core the Porites, but just to find out if any still existed and to measure and photograph them – as well as running the photographic transects. But really, I just wanted to sit next to the black clam speckled blue, which had thick olive-green shiny lips and watch it breathe and feed through its two siphons.

We cruised a total of 263 nautical miles (nearly 500 kilometres) last week in search of the old corals, the Porites.

We left Cairns on Saturday 28th November, and spent the first night moored behind Russell Island, which is part of the Franklin Island Group just to the east of the town of Babinda. On the first day we dived the fringing reef of High Island, the next day Normanby, and after that Britomart. There were so many massive Porites at the reef fringing High Island and also at Normanby. We didn’t find any Porites at Britomart. That was perhaps because we only had an afternoon to search, and I made the wrong calls in terms of where we should jump-in, which is perhaps why we didn’t find any Porites at Britomart.

At the first dive site at Britomart, which had been my call, there were huge plate corals under-the-water that I had mistaken as Porites from above the water. These corals were mostly dead, probably from a severe bleaching back in 2016 and then 2017.

But it wasn’t all death and destruction at Britomart. At the second site, where only Stuart jumped-in to the strong current with just his snorkel, he found and filmed large plate corals – so alive. There was some extraordinary biodiversity at Britomart including a school of black Dory – there was also evidence of severe bleaching. We only saw a single white tipped reef shark at that reef.

Every reef that we dived was so variable and each of the different habitats at Pixie, Britomart and Myrmidon had a different ensemble of coral species and forms. But at each reef we only found a single shark. Each of these reefs had a distinct reef crest that might have been more luxurious, and with better coral cover, some 5,000 years ago at the time of the mythical Myrmidons – simply because back then these reefs would have been younger and growing up with the sea level that was higher back then, the corals having grown-up 120 metres since the depth of the last ice age which was just 16,000 years ago. Since at least 2,500 years ago these coral reefs have had to adapt to an overall trend of falling sea levels, not with-standing the modest increase of perhaps 36 cm over the last 100 years – as reported by the United Nation’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

The reef crests at Britomart and Myrmidon today are flat topped and mostly dead, as they are eroded peaks now just below mean low tide growing back after bleaching events, to be smashed again by the huge waves that come with the cyclones.

Coral cover at the crests, which is the most exposed part of the reef, is generally sparser and the corals stumpy, while only a few metres further down under the water it is sometimes possible to find delicate plate corals, at Myrmidon perhaps regrowing since the last cyclone. It is so difficult to generalize about a coral reef, when there is such diversity within and between habitats even at the same reef.

Small plate corals, at Myrmidon.

It was on the second dive at Myrmidon, that we found the garden of Porites. That was a highlight of the week at sea for me. I had gone in search of Porites. I had no idea whether I would find them or not. At Myrmidon we found a whole garden of Porites – massive corals in different colours and each so healthy. In the same coral garden were blue and also a heavenly-white Acropora – so tall, and each branch had a florescent blue tip. Little Chromis fish (Damsel fish) trimmed in yellow, swam in and out.

The skipper, Rob, had warned me in the weeks leading up to the expedition that there was no guarantee we would get all the way to Myrmidon in our 14-metre boat. It all depended on the weather, he said.

Last Wednesday, a week ago, Rob not only got us to Myrmidon, but we found so many Porites and in crystal clear waters.

Stuart and Rob made the decision about where to anchor for the second dive, they found me the garden of Porites. There were perhaps 50 of these massive boulder-shaped corals many more than 2 metres in diameter not far from the boat and at just 8 metres below the water. Perhaps there are another 50 gardens of Porites at Myrmidon reef? That can be my hypothesis!

If only we had the resources to stay, search and survey we could perhaps find as many massive Porites as there were Myrmidons (50) on each of the ships (50) that sailed with Achilles to defeated Hector in the ancient Greek tale – that would make 2,500 massive Porites just at Myrmidon reef! And Myrmidon is just one of nearly 3,000 coral reefs that make up the Great Barrier Reef.

Shaun swimming over some of the massive Porites in the coral garden at Myrmidon.

There are certainly enough massive Porites still alive for scientists at the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS), to calculate an average coral growth rate for the Great Barrier Reef over the last 100 to 300 years – as they used to do by coring Porites from inner, middle and outer reefs including Myrmidon. They stopped coring the Porites at Myrmidon more than 15 years ago.

We only found the one shark at Myrmidon – a small and curious white tipped reef shark that tasted Stuart’s flipper on the second dive, and almost head-butted Shaun at the beginning of their night dive. These sharks (Triaenodon obesus) are more curious than aggressive, which may explain why numbers have apparently declined over the last few decades – apparently as a minor bycatch of the Coral Reef Fin Fish Fishery. The last attempt to properly quantify their numbers is documented in a PhD thesis by William Robins published back in 2006. He claims fishing is the problem.

I’ve heard so many stories about shark finning, even in Great Barrier Reef waters as far south as Lady Elliot Island. Finning involves removing the dorsal, pelvic, pectoral and caudal fins and then throwing the live shark back into the water – where it can only sink to the bottom and die. Best estimates suggest 73 million (!) sharks are finned each year across the world to make soup for rich Asians.

There is so much money from the long-suffering Australian tax payer, via the Australian government, for activist scientists claiming the reef is at risk of climate change, but very little political will to address any of the many threats to sharks in Great Barrier Reef waters. Yet the evidence suggests shark numbers are in decline, not only from finning but also drumlines set by the Queensland government, ostensibly to protect those who swim at north Queensland beaches.

I’m hoping to go back to Pixie Reef, just to the north east of Cairns, in early February to finishing filming for the documentary about our week at sea – last week. In the new year, I want to film some more at Pixie Reef, including Shaun swimming with the resident white-tipped reef shark that Stuart often sees there.

The reefs at Myrmidon, Normanby, High Island and Pixie have so many old Porites, but so few reef sharks.

Working from evidence – including the photographic evidence amassed by us last week, from the photographs taken by Shaun along the underwater transects set by Stuart, and from Stuart’s drone photography in the air above, for at least two different habitat types at each of the reef we visited – I hope there can one day be more agreement about the current state of the corals at the Great Barrier Reef. It would certainly be helpful if some of the many scientists at AIMS returned in one of their big ships to Myrmidon and cored at least a few of the many massive old Porites. They could recommence the program of coring, beginning at Myrmidon, to test the hypothesis that as water temperatures increase coral growth rates will increase too. This could be determined from the annual growth rings once the cores were in the laboratory and under X-ray.

I would also sleep better knowing that there was funding to monitor white-tipped reef sharks. At the moment, about 600 sharks are killed each year on drumlines including reef sharks, then there is the by-catch from the legal fisheries, and then there are those who fin sharks because there is a market.

I surmise that the corals are not threatened by global warming, certainly not by sea level rise, but that the few remaining sharks at Myrmidon, and many other reefs, are at risk from those intent on defeating them, or eating their fins. Indeed, I’m hoping that as Achilles slayed Hector with the help of the Myrmidons, we can begin to acknowledge the hubris of trying to tame Zeus/the weather, while mercilessly denying everything good that sharks represent, including being curious and keeping mid-level predators in check, so that the algae-eating fish can thrive.

Jen measuring a massive Porites at Myrmidon.

**************
The feature image, at the very top of this blog post, is of our boat Kiama as we arrived at Myrmidon reef. The skipper, Rob McCulloch, has put some unedited aerial drone footage taken by Stuart of our boat, Kiama, sailing into Myrmidon, at his YouTube page, here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLtN4deEi10

I am so grateful to the B. Macfie Family Foundation and the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA) for funding the expedition.

Shaun and Jen/me about to jump in at Normanby reef.
Stuart and Jen, top-side at Myrmidon after the first dive.
Wizz and Dennis on the back deck. So much thanks for looking out for us, and looking after us.
The team: Stuart, Jen, Walt (joined us at Maggie Island), Shaun, Rob, Peter Ridd and Dennis … thanks Wizz for capturing the moment.
0 0 vote
Article Rating
36 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John Garrett
December 14, 2020 6:29 am

Thank you for this well-written, thoughtful and informative report.

There are a lot of people who should read it (and won’t).

ThinkingScientist
December 14, 2020 6:35 am

slightly O/T and don’t want to hijack the thread:

Here in the UK I ordered Climate change: The Facts 2020 edited by Jennifer from Amazon UK.

I placed the order 9 October 2020. It is still on my account. It has not been dispatched and no indication whether it will be. At the time it said it expected to ship around 14 November as I recall.

Now Amazon UK simply lists 3rd party sellers for this book. What happened?

PC_Bob
Reply to  ThinkingScientist
December 14, 2020 9:20 am

You should contact Amazon and request a refund. They are always very responsive to customers/buyers. (I ‘was’ a seller’).

ThinkingScientist
Reply to  PC_Bob
December 15, 2020 6:41 am

PC_Bob – I want the book, not the refund.

Call me paranoid, but why did Amazon take orders back in October, not fulfil orders and now not offer the book for sale?

robin townsend
Reply to  ThinkingScientist
December 14, 2020 10:59 am

agreed, I bought it for 15 quid and now it is not despeatched but only available for £47 quid.
Looks fishy.

Chris Wright
Reply to  ThinkingScientist
December 15, 2020 2:49 am

Same problem here. I ordered it from WH Smith. They said it would be available in early November. I’m still waiting.
Chris

Steven Curtis Lohr
December 14, 2020 6:54 am

Very interesting. Thanks.

commieBob
December 14, 2020 7:06 am

Do sharks and their prey go through boom-bust cycles?

DMacKenzie
December 14, 2020 7:19 am

Sounds like the process of coral deeper-water-growth/shallow-water-death is resulting in island and coastline formation as it has for millions of years.

Gras Albert
December 14, 2020 7:27 am

Same for crocodiles & alligators, top skin is sliced off and the animal put back in the water, to survive and grow another skin… Or not…

All to make belts, shoes & handbags…

Why don’t activists get upset about real evil instead of propaganda?

john adams
December 14, 2020 7:46 am

My experience in diving several different areas around Hamilton Island is that millions of starfish have destroyed the coral around the area since they eat live coral. There were acres and acres of dead coral with the sea floor alive with layers of starfish.

Mr.
Reply to  john adams
December 14, 2020 10:14 am

Then the starfish move on to other reef areas to graze on fresh coral food, and corals again take seed on the dead reefs areas?
Rinse & repeat over the eons . . .

December 14, 2020 8:32 am

Thank you Jennifer for a lovely story.
The GBR is magic!

Joe Kadzban
December 14, 2020 8:57 am

well, this kind of report will definitely NOT get you any grant money.. just sayin’…

Loydo
Reply to  Mr.
December 14, 2020 11:47 am

When your trip is funded by the IPA who is owned by one of the world’s wealthiest climate change denying mining magnates, you don’t need to compete for grants.

Patrick MJD
Reply to  Loydo
December 14, 2020 1:10 pm

“Loydo December 14, 2020 at 11:47 am

“I am so grateful to the B. Macfie Family Foundation and the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA) for funding the expedition.”

So you hate the fact the IPA funded actual observational research as apposed to desk based computer modeling? An inconvenient truth eh?

Michael Jankowski
Reply to  Patrick MJD
December 14, 2020 2:44 pm

Loydo is just mad there wasn’t lots of bleaching.

fred250
Reply to  Patrick MJD
December 15, 2020 12:47 pm

Loydo is just “mad”. !

Mr.
Reply to  Loydo
December 14, 2020 1:15 pm

You really think Dr. Marohasy & team are getting these kinds of $$$$s from the subscirption-funded Institute of Public Affairs (IPA)? –

$446,291 – “Standardising halal: Interpreting the tension between global and local”
$271,936 – “Diversifying music in Australia: Gender equity in jazz and improvisation”
$1,011,852 – “A sonic approach to anti-colonialism in interwar India”
$428,865 – “Skulls for the Tsar: Indigenous human remains in Russian collections”
$282,726 – “Metaphors and identities in the Australian vernacular”
$467,536 – “The coming of the dingo and its interaction with Indigenous Australians”
$1,014,155 – “Saving lives: Mapping the influence of Indigenous LGBTIQ+ creative artists”
$922,400 – “Cultural values, birth and parenting: Reproductive health and Lao socialism”
$271,936 – “Diversifying music in Australia: Gender equity in jazz and improvisation”
$441,173 – “Seeing the black child”
$584,000 – “Testing a new model for addressing covert racism faced by Indigenous youth”
$1,025,000 – “The social credit system and everyday life in China”

I think I can safely say that Dr Jen and her volunteers would give their eye teeth for a any one of these sacks of taxpayer’s dough.

RickWill
Reply to  Mr.
December 14, 2020 1:58 pm

That list is simply depressing.

fred250
Reply to  Loydo
December 14, 2020 1:48 pm

Again….. What do we DENY that you have solid scientific proof for?

You are the DENIER, loy..

You are nothing but an empty mindless sock-puppet

fred250
Reply to  fred250
December 15, 2020 12:38 pm

Noted that Loy-dumb can post more rancid AGW hatred and BS

But can’t answer a simple question.

PATHETIC is the first and only word that comes to mind in regards to the Loydo twerp.

Mike
Reply to  Loydo
December 14, 2020 4:26 pm

”climate change denying mining magnates”

You’d think that after visiting this site for so long you would have tempered your reactionary garbage but no. Climate change denying? That the best you can muster? I mean really, WTF are you on? You are surely intelligent enough to recognize at least a little graduation between the various claims but then you come back with this UTTER VERBAL VOMIT, which is the perspective of the simplistic, the infantile, the ignorant and ill-informed. Proof that you are governed by your political bias and your wet little dream-like state of emotion rather than what remains of any objectivity. It’s really rather pathetic.

Loydo
Reply to  Mike
December 14, 2020 10:24 pm

““I have never met a geologist or leading scientist who believes adding more carbon dioxide to the atmosphere will have any significant effect on climate change, especially not from a relatively small country like Australia…
Furthermore, there will always be geothermal activity that spew out heat and ash and this activity does affect the climate.”

Mmm, so much “graduation”, but please, do go on and explain how it is purely coincidence Rinehart, the IPA and Marohasy just happen to be in the same grade?

fred250
Reply to  Mike
December 15, 2020 12:36 pm

See, geologists understand actual SCIENCE

They want actual EVIDENCE

something you are still TOTALLY LACKING

When are you going to make at least a MOST FEEBLE EFFORT to provide some actual real scientific evidence, Loy-dumb???

1… Do you have any empirical scientific evidence for warming by atmospheric CO2?

2… In what ways has the global climate changed in the last 50 years , that can be scientifically proven to be of human causation?

fred250
Reply to  Mike
December 15, 2020 12:45 pm

“explain how it is purely coincidence Rinehart, the IPA and Marohasy just happen to be in the same grade?”

Because they seek TRUTH , FACTS, and EVIDENCE.

Loy-dumb is a complete and utter failure on every point. !

YallaYPoora Kid
Reply to  Loydo
December 14, 2020 10:59 pm

Dodo’s comments should be extinct since none of them have any truth or make any sense.

chickenhawk
Reply to  Mr.
December 14, 2020 12:30 pm

how about studying the gender confusion of great corals due to the global barely warming phenom?

Greytide
December 14, 2020 9:32 am

Thank you for telling of your experience. It is a pity that countries don’t follow the example of the Maldives where Sharks and Mantas are protected. Since I first dived there in the 1990s, sharks had declined to a pitiful level but, since the protection has come in, there are now loads around. We need more countries to protect Sharks and Mantas.

John F Hultquist
Reply to  Greytide
December 14, 2020 4:58 pm

since the protection

Just as with Polar Bears.

RickWill
December 14, 2020 1:56 pm

But we didn’t see many sharks.

It is the one you don’t see that is the problem. They have a habit of working out how to approach people without the person seeing them.

shortie of greenbank
December 14, 2020 2:10 pm

Having snorkeled off Cairns, Port Douglas and Lady Elliot I can say all these have lovely reefs full of colour and varieties of fish. We stayed at Lady Elliot last year and would recommend it if you do like the stay on the island and then a short walk to swim in the reef.

Streetcred
December 14, 2020 8:26 pm

The sharks are there … maybe a bit further south, ask any deepsea fisherman or any surfer … there’s no shortage along the near coast.

ozspeaksup
December 15, 2020 4:11 am

is it just my pc? the pics look drab and boring
nothing id jump in the water to look at, and sure as hell wouldnt pay to see
if thats how they look in reality stuffed if I see any attraction at all or reason to give a damn if they die or go white or any other colour( rayciss ya know)

Reply to  ozspeaksup
December 15, 2020 5:48 am

During our week on the Great Barrier Reef we dove 6 or 7 different locations. In each case, as soon as we broke the surface we were surrounded by millions of beautiful, colorful small fish – it was like diving into a crowded tropical aquarium. The corals were beautiful as well. The GBR was magic!
Strongly recommended – it was one of the best weeks of my life!

https://wattsupwiththat.com/2018/11/26/dozens-of-dead-turtles-wash-ashore-on-cape/#comment-2532704

I spent a week on a dive boat at the Great Barrier Reef in NE Australia in 2005. On one of my first dives, a large sea turtle swam by, right in front of me – Magic!

On my very first dive, I came face-to-face with a 5ft reef shark – that was rather alarming, although they rarely attack. This one looked me over, decided I was too big and tough to bother with, and headed for the appetizers – the thousands of colourful small fish that were visible everywhere.

Blue-bottle jellyfish were common, and we all got stung. One guy took a break at the swim platform with his mouthpiece out, and a jellyfish wrapped around his mouthpiece and he put it back in his mouth – now that hurt – and he got huge Mick Jagger lips.

This was one of the best weeks of my life – I strongly recommend it, and suggest snorkeling over scuba – the colours disappear below about 20 feet, and most everyone can free-dive to 15-20 ft depth.

%d bloggers like this: