"Thorough, not thoroughly fabricated: The truth about global temperature data"… Well, not *thoroughly* fabricated.

Guest post by David Middleton

Featured image borrowed from here.

ARS Tecn

If you can set aside the smug, snide remarks of the author, this article does a fairly good job in explaining why the surface station temperature data have to be adjusted and homogenized.

There is just one huge problem…

US Adjusted
“In the US, a couple systematic changes to weather stations caused a cooling bias—most notably the time of observation bias corrected in the blue line.
Zeke Hausfather/Berkeley Earth”… I added the the natural variability box and annotation.  All of the anomalous warming ince 1960 is the result of the adjustments.

 

Without the adjustments and homogenization, the post-1960 US temperatures would be indistinguishable from the early 20th century.

I’m not saying that I know the adjustments are wrong; however anytime that an anomaly is entirely due to data adjustments, it raises a red flag with me.  In my line of work, oil & gas exploration, we often have to homogenize seismic surveys which were shot and processed with different parameters.  This was particularly true in the “good old days” before 3d became the norm.  The mistie corrections could often be substantial.  However, if someone came to me with a prospect and the height of the structural closure wasn’t substantially larger than the mistie corrections used to “close the loop,” I would pass on that prospect.

 

Just for grins, I plotted the UAH and RSS satellite time series on top of the Hausfather graph…

 

US Adjusted_wSat
US raw, TOBs-adjusted and homogenized temperatures plotted along with UAH and RSS global satellite temperatures.  Apples and oranges? Sort of… But still very revealing.

 

I think I can see why the so-called consensus has become so obsessed recently with destroying the credibility of the satellite data.

 

Addendum

In light of some of the comments, particularly those from Zeke Hausfather, I downloaded the UAH v5.6 “USA48” temperature anomaly series and plotted it on Zeke’s graph of US raw, TOBs-adjusted and fully homogenized temperatures.  I shifted the UAH series up by about 0.6 °C to account for the different reference periods (datum differences)…

USA48

I used a centered 61-month average for a 5-yr running average.  Since there appears to be a time shift, I also shifted the UAH ahead a few months to match the peaks and troughs…

USA48x.png

The UAH USA48 data do barely exceed the pre-1960 natural variability box and track close to the TOBs-adjusted temperatures, but well below the fully homogenized temperatures.

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
212 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted