Is this an example of Jim Hansen's endorsed "civil disobedience"?

cca-dc-protest-cap17

Dr. Jim Hansen gets ready to deliver his message at the Washington DC power plant protest on March 2nd 2009. On February 22nd, WUWT covered Hansen’s announcement that he was endorsing civil disobedience. Now one has to wonder; what hath Jim wrought? (h/t to timbrom)

From the Telegraph UK: More than 100 campaigners arrested over ‘power station plot’

More than 100 people are in custody after police smashed a major plot to sabotage one of Britain’s biggest power-stations.

Ratcliffe-on-Soar power-station, Nottinghamshire: More than 100 protestors arrested over Power Station Plot

Demonstrators gathered at night in readiness to move on Ratcliffe-on-Soar power-station, Nottinghamshire. Photo: PA

Officers swooped on environmental protesters as they prepared a mass raid that could have disrupted supplies to tens of thousands of homes.

The demonstrators are thought to have gathered at night in readiness to move on Ratcliffe-on-Soar power-station, Nottinghamshire.

They were rounded up shortly after midnight on Sunday at the Bakersfield Community Centre in Sneinton, Notts, by scores of officers.

Detectives later revealed they recovered specialist equipment that suggested the group represented a “serious threat” to the station’s safety.

Supt Mike Manley, of the Nottinghamshire force, said 114 men and women from across the UK were detained during the dramatic swoop.

They were being questioned on suspicion of conspiracy to commit aggravated trespass and criminal damage at Ratcliffe-on-Soar.

Supt Manley said: “In view of specialist equipment recovered by police, those arrested posed a serious threat to the safe running of the site.

“This was a significant operation, with large-scale arrests. There were no injuries during the arrests, and the police investigation is ongoing.”

Witnesses told how officers in more than 20 police vans descended on the plotters’ apparent rendezvous point in the early hours.

Tess Rearden, who lives near the scene, said: “We were woken up by the sound of doors slamming and saw all these police vans and riot vans.

“My son came out of his bedroom and said: ‘Have you seen what’s going on?’ They were all up and down the roads. It was bedlam – real bedlam.”

Another resident added: “I was leaving my house when I saw a line of traffic approaching me, which seemed strange for the time of night.

“It was only when the vehicles got closer and started to pass me that I noticed every single one was either a police car or a police van.

“I counted 20-plus vans, all one after the other, with police cars at the rear. Then they blocked off all the roads around the community centre.”

One resident told how the protesters did not fight with officers during the swoop but signalled their defiance as they were being led away.

She said: “The police jumped out of their vans and ran behind the community centre. The people they brought out were singing: ‘We’ll be back again.'”

It is thought detectives had prior knowledge of the plot but chose to wait till the demonstrators were together in one place before moving in.

Local city councillor David Mellen added: “I understand there was some kind of gathering of people here in connection with the power-station.

“If the police had information that there was a danger to the power supply in the East Midlands then obviously they had to take action.”

The Derbyshire and Leicestershire forces helped in the operation and later provided additional custody facilities for some of those arrested.

Ratcliffe-on-Soar has been the target of a number of protests in the past, including one two years ago in which protesters tried to shut down the plant.

Environmentalists who stormed the site on that occasion later failed in a landmark legal bid to prove they were acting in the interests of humanity.

Climate-change campaigners admitted they attempted to force the site’s closure by chaining themselves to conveyor belts and filtration systems.

But they argued that, because they were saving the planet from global warming, their actions were legal under the so-called “defence of necessity”.

Had they won their case they would have paved the way for campaigners around the country to stage similar protests without fear of prosecution.

At the time Eastside Climate Action, the group involved, said the break-in reflected “the threat climate change poses to the human population”.

A spokesman said: “We argue that the threat to human life is so serious that it is a proportionate and reasonable response to take direct action.”

Giving evidence at the court hearing, station manager Raymond Smith told how production at the site was threatened during the incident.

He said: “People chained themselves to the conveyor system and the filtration system. They were non-violent, but none had permission to be on the site.

“If the protest had continued to the extent that the power station ran out of coal we would have had to shut it down. But we called the police.”

Eastside denied any involvement in yesterday’s events – thought to be linked to plans for a new coal-fired power-station in Kingsthorpe, Kent.

E.on, the power giant behind Kingsthorpe, owns Ratcliffe-on-Soar – allegedly Britain’s second-largest producer of carbon-dioxide emissions.

An E.on spokesman said: “While we understand everyone has a right to protest peacefully and lawfully, this was clearly neither of those things.

“We will be assisting police in their investigations into what could have been a very dangerous attempt to disrupt an operational power-plant.”

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
116 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Rhys Jaggar
April 13, 2009 8:21 am

This kind of activity is the 21st century equivalent of the medieval church describing sex as dirty and immoral.
Stupid idiotic rubbish in other words………

John Galt
April 13, 2009 8:24 am

Climate change is like the sunrise, it’s natural and you can’t stop it.
The very term “climate change”, as used by the Global Warming Alarmists and Profiteers is idiotic. The term implies the climate would be stable without human factors. This ignorance knows no bounds.
The climate changes all the time. The climate is supposed to change. The climate is always going to change. Get over it.

DD More
April 13, 2009 8:29 am

Would be nice if they shut off all electricty in their jail cells.

Mike Bryant
April 13, 2009 8:34 am

A stylized black and white image of James Hansen will no doubt soon be replacing posters and t-shirts of Che Guevara in leftist haunts worldwide.
Mike Bryant
PS… any artists in the crowd?

James P
April 13, 2009 8:39 am

One wonders what the protesters have in their own homes. What do they run their kettles on, or use to make toast? I imagine the average candle produces a lot more CO2 than the generation of power to produce a similar amount of electric light!

Tim
April 13, 2009 8:41 am

Hansen should be fired.

Hank
April 13, 2009 8:43 am

Civil disobedience presupposes your going to do something serious enough to get arrested for. For Hansen to endorse civil disobedience implies he is encouraging people to break the law.

pdm
April 13, 2009 8:45 am

AGW == Agenda Gone Wild

Phillip Bratby
April 13, 2009 8:48 am

These environmental activists have been brain-washed by governments, by the education system, by environmental organisations and the media. It’s a sorry state that we have got into. Thoughtless idiots.

Roger Clague
April 13, 2009 8:51 am

A few nights in a cell with no heating or light might teach them something useful.

Rick, michigan
April 13, 2009 8:53 am

[snip – a bit off color]
Keep it in Britain, please.

Sam the Skeptic
April 13, 2009 8:55 am

Occasionally I am almost ashamed to be British. This is one of those occasions.
Somebody with some clout has really got to call these people out before the old and the poor (who are as always the ones who get it in the neck) can no longer afford to heat and light their homes. Which I suppose is a fairly irrelevant argument since if these brainless Luddites have their way we’ll all be sitting in the dark and the cold and pretty soon I fear.

H.R.
April 13, 2009 8:57 am

With friends like these, who needs enemies?
Pirates cause global warming. Everybody knows.

Bill Jamison
April 13, 2009 9:09 am

How great would it be if the British could prove that Hansen was a co-conspirator in this plot and charge him? Yeah that would definitely be sweet!

Hans Kelp
April 13, 2009 9:14 am

Worst of all is that a few people self-righteously think they can claim the right to ignore and break whatever democratic rules and processes they want to for the purposes of forcing their own will upon others.
What a mess.

hereticfringe
April 13, 2009 9:14 am

“Hansen should be fired.”
Tim, you made a spelling error. It is spelled “fried”. I think you transposed the “r” and the “i”.

Gary
April 13, 2009 9:24 am

There’s a difference between protest of governmental policy and inciting to riot — a distinction not always made when emotions take control. Laws rightly protect the former and condemn the latter. One has to admire Henry David Thoreau who many years ago went to jail after refusing to pay a tax as a protest against the Mexican-American War. He took personal responsibility for his actions and didn’t just advocate a position.

D. King
April 13, 2009 9:24 am

I love that picture of Panama Jim;
or is it Spy vs. Spy?
http://image20.webshots.com/20/2/35/62/216123562Bbsywj_ph.jpg

voodoo
April 13, 2009 9:24 am

Rogers sasy: ‘A few nights in a cell with no heating or light might teach them something useful.’
When George Bush tried this with a couple murderous monsters it was called torture by the same people pushing AGW. Of course the AGW crowd wants to ‘torture’ all of us.

Wilson Flood
April 13, 2009 9:24 am

The UK Government has done nothing to quell climate change hysteria. There are constant press releases stating that we must reduce carbon emissions by 80% by 2050 if we are to avoid climate catastrophe. Unless you have a reasonable science education and have spent a lot of time looking at data of various sorts (like this website) then you are likely to believe the Government line ie that we have a problem caused by burning fossil fuels. Many people now genuinely believe this, because they have been fed a constant diet of warming propaganda. Therefore it is totally logical to them that we should shut down coal burning power stations and it is totally illogical for the Government to arrest people who are trying to save the planet as they see it. THe Government is seen as hypocritical and only has itself to blame. It could have encouraged a more balanced line on climate change and could have encouraged debate from both sides. It has sown the wind (turbines) so now it can reap the whirlwind.

Shawn F.
April 13, 2009 9:26 am

I believe you are referring to settled debate that it is copyright piracy that causes global warming H.R.?

Power Engineer
April 13, 2009 9:28 am

The plant I am currently working on to start-up in July ’09 in Texas is a coal fired power plant capable of supplying 580 MW of power to central texas. Just the other day an email went around telling us to beware of protestors that might be staged at the gates. I really hope it doesnt come to that but It would also not surprise me. I guess thats what happens when the most influential outlets get taken over by extremists.
H.R.
I agree…pirates do cause global warming,it is an Inverse relationship
http://www.venganza.org/about/open-letter/
🙂

CodeTech
April 13, 2009 9:30 am

because they were saving the planet from global warming, their actions were legal under the so-called “defence of necessity”.

Also known as the Zeroth Law (see Asimov)
Rhys Jaggar (08:21:55) :

equivalent of the medieval church describing sex as dirty and immoral

Um… isn’t it? Maybe you’re just not doing it right… 😉
There’s no way to comment on this seriously… we are watching the beginning of a trend that will increase. Heinlein had a lot of Future History right, but the REAL crazy years are just beginning.

Timo van Druten
April 13, 2009 9:32 am

To a certain extent it is a pity they didn’t succeeded. If they would have disrupted power supply to many people with grave effects to individuals, the public would eventually get furious on this kind of civil disobedience and might give an important signal to governments. Organisations like Greenpeace, WWF and other vocal organisations would have a lot to explain to the general public and might loose their credibility. Of course I don’t underestimated the individual consequences; if you are being effected by disrupted power supply you have a severe problem and probably you will not be happy.
Secondly, I might give the public the possibility to initiate litigation against these individuals and give another signal; civil disobedience does have a price tag.

Mrs Whatsit
April 13, 2009 9:38 am

Actually, H.R., I believe it is the lack of pirates which causes global warming. Conclusive proof is seen in the recent falling-off of global temperatures, which has occurred AT THE VERY SAME TIME AS pirates have been getting back to work off the coast of Somalia.
See? Climatology is easy!

1 2 3 5