Earth's Magnetic Field Has Massive Breach – scientists baffled

I know. This sounds like a plot of a 1950’s scifi movie. But it is real. From my view, our localized corner of the solar system is now different than it used to be and changes in the magnetic interactions are evident everywhere. First we have the interplanetary magnetic field that took an abrupt dive in October 2005 and has not recovered since and remains at very low level:

ap_dec08-520

click for a larger image

Then we have the recent discovery that the ionosphere has dropped in altitude to unexpected and unexplained low levels.

We have a solar cycle 24 (driven by the solar magnetic dynamo) which can’t seem to get out of the starting gate, being a year late with forecasts for activity from it being revised again and again.

And finally we have this, this discovery that Earth’s magnetic field can be ripped open and our atmosphere laid bare to the solar wind, much like Mars.

Magnetism is underrated in the grand scheme of things, in my opinion. We’d do well to pay more attention to magnetic trends in our corner of the universe and what effects it has on Earthly climate. – Anthony


From NASA News (h/t to Geoff Sharp)

Dec. 16, 2008: NASA’s five THEMIS spacecraft have discovered a breach in Earth’s magnetic field ten times larger than anything previously thought to exist. Solar wind can flow in through the opening to “load up” the magnetosphere for powerful geomagnetic storms. But the breach itself is not the biggest surprise. Researchers are even more amazed at the strange and unexpected way it forms, overturning long-held ideas of space physics.

“At first I didn’t believe it,” says THEMIS project scientist David Sibeck of the Goddard Space Flight Center. “This finding fundamentally alters our understanding of the solar wind-magnetosphere interaction.”

The magnetosphere is a bubble of magnetism that surrounds Earth and protects us from solar wind. Exploring the bubble is a key goal of the THEMIS mission, launched in February 2007. The big discovery came on June 3, 2007, when the five probes serendipitously flew through the breach just as it was opening. Onboard sensors recorded a torrent of solar wind particles streaming into the magnetosphere, signaling an event of unexpected size and importance.

Right: One of the THEMIS probes exploring the space around Earth, an artist’s concept. [more]

“The opening was huge—four times wider than Earth itself,” says Wenhui Li, a space physicist at the University of New Hampshire who has been analyzing the data. Li’s colleague Jimmy Raeder, also of New Hampshire, says “1027 particles per second were flowing into the magnetosphere—that’s a 1 followed by 27 zeros. This kind of influx is an order of magnitude greater than what we thought was possible.”

The event began with little warning when a gentle gust of solar wind delivered a bundle of magnetic fields from the Sun to Earth. Like an octopus wrapping its tentacles around a big clam, solar magnetic fields draped themselves around the magnetosphere and cracked it open. The cracking was accomplished by means of a process called “magnetic reconnection.” High above Earth’s poles, solar and terrestrial magnetic fields linked up (reconnected) to form conduits for solar wind. Conduits over the Arctic and Antarctic quickly expanded; within minutes they overlapped over Earth’s equator to create the biggest magnetic breach ever recorded by Earth-orbiting spacecraft.

Above: A computer model of solar wind flowing around Earth’s magnetic field on June 3, 2007. Background colors represent solar wind density; red is high density, blue is low. Solid black lines trace the outer boundaries of Earth’s magnetic field. Note the layer of relatively dense material beneath the tips of the white arrows; that is solar wind entering Earth’s magnetic field through the breach. Credit: Jimmy Raeder/UNH. [larger image]

The size of the breach took researchers by surprise. “We’ve seen things like this before,” says Raeder, “but never on such a large scale. The entire day-side of the magnetosphere was open to the solar wind.”

The circumstances were even more surprising. Space physicists have long believed that holes in Earth’s magnetosphere open only in response to solar magnetic fields that point south. The great breach of June 2007, however, opened in response to a solar magnetic field that pointed north.

“To the lay person, this may sound like a quibble, but to a space physicist, it is almost seismic,” says Sibeck. “When I tell my colleagues, most react with skepticism, as if I’m trying to convince them that the sun rises in the west.”

Here is why they can’t believe their ears: The solar wind presses against Earth’s magnetosphere almost directly above the equator where our planet’s magnetic field points north. Suppose a bundle of solar magnetism comes along, and it points north, too. The two fields should reinforce one another, strengthening Earth’s magnetic defenses and slamming the door shut on the solar wind. In the language of space physics, a north-pointing solar magnetic field is called a “northern IMF” and it is synonymous with shields up!

“So, you can imagine our surprise when a northern IMF came along and shields went down instead,” says Sibeck. “This completely overturns our understanding of things.”

Northern IMF events don’t actually trigger geomagnetic storms, notes Raeder, but they do set the stage for storms by loading the magnetosphere with plasma. A loaded magnetosphere is primed for auroras, power outages, and other disturbances that can result when, say, a CME (coronal mass ejection) hits.

The years ahead could be especially lively. Raeder explains: “We’re entering Solar Cycle 24. For reasons not fully understood, CMEs in even-numbered solar cycles (like 24) tend to hit Earth with a leading edge that is magnetized north. Such a CME should open a breach and load the magnetosphere with plasma just before the storm gets underway. It’s the perfect sequence for a really big event.”

Sibeck agrees. “This could result in stronger geomagnetic storms than we have seen in many years.”

For more information about the THEMIS mission, visit http://nasa.gov/themis


Sponsored IT training links:

Get up to date NS0-502 questions to practice for 70-270 exam and complete your CISA certification in days.


0 0 votes
Article Rating

Discover more from Watts Up With That?

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

271 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steven Hill
December 16, 2008 6:18 pm

Typical thought from man…
“This finding fundamentally alters our understanding”
God created it!

Jack Wedel
December 16, 2008 6:38 pm

In archeological time frames, the earth’s magnetic field has frequently ‘flipped’ so that North magnetic becomes South magnetic. Any theories how this might happen and what the causes might be, like unprecendented cosmic ray bombardment? Maybe it will break down (ionize) and disperse all the CO2 out of the atmosphere and all plants will die. What ho – a new panic attack!

Gary Hladik
December 16, 2008 6:42 pm

Darn it, just when you think magnetospheric science is settled… 🙂

December 16, 2008 6:43 pm

This could explain the insanity going on in Washington D.C.

tarpon
December 16, 2008 6:51 pm

What we know you could write a book, what we don’t know would fill a library. Who was it that said man’s assumptions, that’s assumptions, get it, were right in the first place. Just because you assume, does not make it so.
And what if cycle 24 is a bummer and does a slumber walk-by instead of roaring.

December 16, 2008 6:52 pm

Now where know where all that nasty man-made heat is hiding, it’s in the magnetic hole.
Anyone for the new AGW – Antimagnetic Global Warming?

Deanster
December 16, 2008 6:53 pm

Wow …
My Neighbor just got back from Cancun .. .came back babbling something about the Miyan Calender ending in 2012, and something about the Earths magnetic pole flipping …….
Hmmmmmm …. could this be the precursor???????????

December 16, 2008 6:55 pm

Anthony says, “Magnetism is underrated in the grand scheme of things, in my opinion.”
Yes it is. It is just as important as electricity, in fact they are two sides of the same coin.
So for those interested in the strongest magnets commercially available: click
Click on “Magnets” on the left side of the page.

DR
December 16, 2008 7:01 pm

Ok Anthony, once again you’re bringing this up. What is it exactly you suspect is or will be the effect of these phenomenon? Off the record of course.

December 16, 2008 7:02 pm

So I should start wearing a tinfoil hat again?

Bobby Lane
December 16, 2008 7:02 pm

“This kind of influx is an order of magnitude greater than what we thought was possible.”
Yes, once again demonstrating that science still has a lot to learn. Perhaps some people, including but not limited to the AGW crowd, will learn some humility. But I wouldn’t bet on it. Not even if I had 10 to the 27th power dollars.

Edward
December 16, 2008 7:02 pm

I don’t think this was predicted by any of the existing GCM’s therefore it cannot exist.
More importantly, what are the implications of this new finding?

Bobby Lane
December 16, 2008 7:06 pm

“This completely overturns our understanding of things.”
Sibeck agrees. “This could result in stronger geomagnetic storms than we have seen in many years.”
Maybe one day we’ll wake up to the fact that it’s not such a small world after all, and that it’s not going to be us who does us in.

David
December 16, 2008 7:10 pm

Wow. And to think that erroneous predictions about the Arctic Ice melting get front-page headlines (back in June, anyway), but this gets nothing. Literally nothing. I would not have heard of this had Anthony not put this up here, but it is happening now, and is probably far more consequential than the Arctic Ice melting, even though it did not actually melt.

Robert Bateman
December 16, 2008 7:12 pm

Forget AGW, we have AGM (Another Grand Minimum).
We are working on Year 13 here, and now it starts to get serious.
Even if this is SC24, it’s about as lifeless as they come.
Ask the guy on the street about the Deep Solar Minimum, and you get a blank stare. When summer comes rolling around and it ain’t, they’ll know something has gone wrong.
Who’s going to break it to them?

A.Syme
December 16, 2008 7:14 pm

It’s those unknown unknowns that will get you every time!
I’m wondering if this type of radiation would be trapped in the Van Allen belts.

December 16, 2008 7:21 pm

we are living history
all we can do is wait and see
since we have so few records what is happening this may or may not be typical

Brooklyn Red Leg
December 16, 2008 7:54 pm

Well, well….another feather in the cap of the Electric/Plasma Universe model appears to be shaping up. I bet Planetary Cosmologists that heard about this are going nuts to try and explain it. At least, that is what it appears like to a layman like me. Once more, and with feeling, to all the AGW dolts ‘Its the Sun, stupid!’.
Seriously though, this does make for an interesting scenario. I truly do wonder how the Electric/Plasma Universe advocates will use this extremely valuable nugget of information.

Syl
December 16, 2008 8:17 pm

“we are living history”
The current global climate/sun relationship and the global financial breakdown are two very interesting and intriguing phenomena that I find both fascinating and frightening. Both of which I’d rather read about in history books than live through. Interesting times indeed.
I think God is giving the finger to the warmers who are using the financial breakdown as an opportunity to implement their agenda. May they notice the insult before it is too late.

crosspatch
December 16, 2008 8:23 pm

Well, first of all we have to consider that if we found this the first time we sent a probe that was actually looking at it, it is probably something that has been happening over and over again throughout time. It probably isn’t a rare thing, we have simply only now noticed it. I would say the probability is good that it is interesting but most likely not harmful in any way.
You have to remember that during field reversals, the Earth can be without any significant magnetic field for quite a long time. Being without a magnetic field for relatively short periods isn’t so bad. We would experience increased erosion of the atmosphere into space and probably serious ozone damage from any major CMEs that might happen during that time if directed right at Earth.
This is probably something that happens quite often. Probably a rather routine event that we just happened to see for the first time.

AnyMouse
December 16, 2008 8:26 pm

Fortunately, it appears the scientists who are wearing baffles are not also those wearing blinders.

MarkB
December 16, 2008 8:28 pm

“This finding fundamentally alters our understanding of the solar wind-magnetosphere interaction.”
So the scientific consensus changed? My, my….

Bernie
December 16, 2008 8:30 pm

So what is the cause this time? We have had CFCs and CO2, maybe it is television now. I am sure it can be modelled.

December 16, 2008 8:41 pm

How long will it be before this new discovery is attributed to naughty people driving cars and burning coal?
Remember, we cause not just global warming but climate change, and not just climate change but climate chaos (the new phrase rapidly being adopted by doomsayers everywhere). What greater evidence can there be of the wickedness we do than a reversal of previously established orthodoxy casting a whole branch of science into chaos?
Mark my words, within a month or two we will find “hole in the earth’s magnetic field” being added to the list of things for which we will have to bear responsibility. It will just be thrown into the mix not analysed, in the same way that hurricanes and melting ice in summer are used wholly inaccurately and out of context to support the AGW bandwagon.

BillR
December 16, 2008 8:50 pm

In response to Syl, hopefully God’s plan is that the financial meltdown will prevent any of our government’s rash and disastrous plans to combat AGW going through…

1 2 3 11