Climate craziness of the week: climate change likely to induce food violence

Famous scene where John Belushi yells “food fight!” in the movie Animal House

Where climate change is most likely to induce food violence

Study finds capable governments more important than weather

From the OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY via Eurekalert

COLUMBUS, Ohio – While climate change is expected to lead to more violence related to food scarcity, new research suggests that the strength of a country’s government plays a vital role in preventing uprisings.

“A capable government is even more important to keeping the peace than good weather,” said Bear Braumoeller, co-author of the study and associate professor of political science at The Ohio State University.

While previous studies had examined the impact of climate change-induced weather patterns on violence and the increased danger of violence in weak or failing states, this is the first study to demonstrate that the combination of the two risk factors is even more dangerous than they would be separately.

Braumoeller conducted the study with his former doctoral students Benjamin Jones, now at the University of Mississippi, and Eleonora Mattiacci, now at Amherst College.

Their results appear in the Journal of Peace Research.

“We’ve already started to see climate change as an issue that won’t just put the coasts under water, but as something that could cause food riots in some parts of the world,” Braumoeller said.

Extreme weather such as droughts and floods could hurt agricultural production in some countries, leading to violence there or elsewhere by people who are desperate for food.

“Climate-induced food scarcity is going to become an increasingly big issue and we wanted to understand which countries are most threatened by it,” he said.

The researchers estimated the effects of food insecurity and state vulnerability on the occurrence of violent uprisings in Africa for the years 1991 to 2011.

The researchers used a variety of measurements for both food shocks that lead to violence and to gauge the vulnerability of countries.

For the climate-related causes of food shocks, the researchers analyzed rainfall, temperature and – importantly – the international prices of food, including sudden increases in prices.

“We recognized that countries that imported food could be impacted by climate shocks in other parts of the world that suddenly increased prices, even if they weren’t experiencing any significant weather impacts themselves,” Braumoeller said.

When examining countries’ vulnerabilities, the researchers analyzed a host of factors including a country’s dependence on agricultural production, its imports, the strength of its political institutions and its wealth.

“We found that the most vulnerable countries are those that have weak political institutions, are relatively poor and rely more on agriculture,” he said.

“Less vulnerable countries can better handle the problems that droughts or food price fluctuations create.”

These results suggest ways that the United States and the worldwide community can respond to these challenges.

Addressing the vulnerabilities of countries is “crucial to breaking the link between food insecurity and violence,” Braumoeller said.

That means more than providing food aid to offset shortages in the short-term. More broadly, efforts should be focused on strengthening government institutions in vulnerable countries and helping them invest in “green growth” policies aimed at increasing economic growth while fostering resilience to climate shocks, he said.

“Development aid is important now and it is likely to be even more important in the future as we look for ways to increase climate resilience,” Braumoeller said.

###

Contact: Bear Braumoeller, Braumoeller.1@osu.edu

Written by Jeff Grabmeier, 614-292-8457; Grabmeier.1@osu.edu

Disclaimer: AAAS and EurekAlert! are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert! by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system.

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
153 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mohatdebos
June 9, 2017 7:36 am

I am even more depressed now about the state of academic research in the U.S. Did these “scholars” bother to look at data on global crop production in recent year. Production of virtually all edible grains is at or near record high. Countries are running out of storage (rats must be feasting). More important, did these shaman even look at historical weather and crop production records. You would think anyone researching weather and crop yields at Ohio State University would know that agricultural production and prices for agricultural commodities are highly variable. That is why future markets for agricultural commodities are common around the world, and why governments in many countries, including the U.S., maintain strategic reserves for many agricultural commodities. You would think they would have learned some lessons from the failed prophecies of “Population Bomb” Paul Ehrlich.

Gamecock
June 9, 2017 7:38 am

‘“Climate-induced food scarcity is going to become an increasingly big issue and we wanted to understand which countries are most threatened by it,” he said.’
– Governments produce no food.
– This is from the Jimmy Carter School of Economics, where Jimmah said, “Only government can fairly manage scarcity.” To which Ronald Reagan said, “Screw that, we’re America! We’ll make more!”
“crucial to breaking the link between food insecurity and violence”
I guess it must exist somewhere, they wouldn’t have made it up.
‘weak political institutions’
Back to what climate change is really about: establishing strong political institutions. ‘Climate change’ is just a threat to get people to accept it.

Bruce Cobb
June 9, 2017 7:39 am

Was there a contest to see who could fit the most garbage into a single study? I think they might have a winner here.

June 9, 2017 7:41 am

Stopped at “associate professor of political science”.

Winchester
June 9, 2017 7:52 am

Only an imbecile would look at the past 30 years of US food grain production and figure that there will be food riots due to global warming, now ice age I would bet on it.

Rhoda R
Reply to  Winchester
June 9, 2017 9:31 am

Or even the last 30 years of world wide food production. Hunger world wide is the lowest since people have been tracking that piece of data.

MCPR
June 9, 2017 7:53 am

I’ve got a wonderful idea! Assuming against all common sense that “Climate Shock(tm)” is going to harm food production, let’s turn 40% of our corn crop into ethanol and mandate that people burn it in their automobiles. That should really improve the worldwide food situation.

RWturner
Reply to  MCPR
June 9, 2017 8:59 am

Hold on let me see if there is investment opportunity in government mandated ethanol, yep, okay it is a wonderful idea that will save the planet.

Joel Snider
June 9, 2017 8:02 am

Utterly spurious conclusion, based on a total garbage premise.

Tom in Florida
Reply to  Joel Snider
June 9, 2017 8:58 am

Well as they say, one person’s garbage is another person’s treasure.

ScienceABC123
June 9, 2017 8:18 am

More nonsense from the cornucopia of “Climate change causes everything, and everything causes climate change.”

PiperPaul
Reply to  ScienceABC123
June 9, 2017 8:35 am

More nonsense from the cornucopia of “Climate change causes everything bad, and everything we can tax causes climate change.”
Just a couple additions.

Sparky
June 9, 2017 8:21 am

This one is so silly it wasn’t worth posting. ‘..expected to cause…. but government is already preventing…’ is a typical way of dreamy thinking that happens when herbal inhalations are deep and any reflective thinking is not required. But it is the stuff of dreams and fictions both undreamt and unwritten… the silliness of slack minds. Magical thinking requires it… or maybe not,.. it’s just magical.

Jduncan
June 9, 2017 8:24 am

Very poor fiction I say.

Michael Fabing
June 9, 2017 8:26 am

Did this Bear bullshit in the woods?

Curious George
June 9, 2017 8:31 am

Food is scarce under communism. The Pilgrims almost died of famine in their first years when they practiced a naive socialism. The rite of Thanksgiving celebrates their conversion to capitalism.

Resourceguy
June 9, 2017 8:39 am

So climate change caused Woody Hays? That makes sense now.

Tom in Florida
Reply to  Resourceguy
June 9, 2017 9:04 am

Yes, The Punch!

Matthew R. Epp
June 9, 2017 8:43 am

Has there been a single case of “climate change induced” crop failure/ food scarcity? Is there any verified documentation of regions changing their planting times, crops, etc due to climate change? have there been year to year crop reductions/ failures directly related to “climate change”?
Please don’t cite a flood or drought as those events are simply weather.
Unless these studies can eliminate the govt and wealth equations from the study, it’s all meaningless.
Example: Zimbabwe was once called the breadbasket of Africa, it produced enough food to feed most of the continent. Due to mismanagement at the govt level, it now barely feeds its own people.
Ethiopia – the starvation was caused by ineffective government, more than weather.
Point is, the answer to food security is stable govt, regardless of any potential “climate changes” whether natural or erroneously applied the human released CO2.

texasjimbrock
Reply to  Matthew R. Epp
June 9, 2017 8:57 am

The Mayan civilization collapsed after a seven year hard drought. Now, that was before we had “climate change” so maybe it doesn’t count.

RWturner
June 9, 2017 8:49 am

We are in the Nu Dark Age. The luddites outnumber us, but at least we’ve got reality on our side.

Resourceguy
Reply to  RWturner
June 9, 2017 9:06 am

Okay, but the next over reach administration may act to outlaw reality by executive decree in the early days after taking office. Such action will be supported by numerous beltway think tank studies to back it up and a NYT survey.

texasjimbrock
June 9, 2017 8:56 am

Who pays for this kind of useless study? No, don’t tell me. I am afraid I already know the answer.

secryn
June 9, 2017 8:57 am

If food shortages sufficient to cause rioting occurs, it won’t be due to global warming or climate change. It will be due, as history has repeatedly shown, to dictators and other totalitarian governments maipulating their economies to suit political ends, and their continual process of taking from the working people the just fruits of their labor.

Duncan
June 9, 2017 9:14 am

Speaking of Crazies, in case anyone missed it, here’s Chris Wallace interviewing Al Gore (June 4th). Just watch before having your lunch.
https://youtu.be/BJr-jwqRO4Q

Duncan
Reply to  Duncan
June 9, 2017 9:16 am

I should add, Gore admits the Paris agreement is useless:
WALLACE: “You would agree that even if all 195 nations, now 194, met their targets, it still wouldn’t solve the problem.”
GORE: “That is correct. However, it sends a very powerful signal to business and industry and civil society, and countries around the world.”

J Mac
Reply to  Duncan
June 9, 2017 10:44 am

GORE: “That is correct. However, it sends a very powerful signal to business and industry and civil society, and countries around the world.”
Now that is as clear a case of virtue signaling as I have ever witnessed!

JohnKnight
Reply to  Duncan
June 9, 2017 3:33 pm

GORE: “That is correct. However, it sends a very powerful signal to business and industry and civil society, and countries around the world.”
I hear it as mostly reassurance to the corrupt people in positions of power around the world who stand to gain from a massive scam signaling, myself, J Mac. It’s not like he can just say something along those lines (publicly), ya know?
(I really and truly don’t believe Mr. Gore is trying to save me ; )

Butch
June 9, 2017 9:25 am

WOW..This might be a brilliant idea !
“Trump pitches solar-paneled border wall to GOP leaders” .. Fox News …
http://video.foxnews.com/v/5465606372001/?#sp=show-clips

Butch
Reply to  Butch
June 9, 2017 9:27 am

…A border wall that pays for itself….Finally a good use for YUGE Solar Panels !

Bruce Cobb
Reply to  Butch
June 9, 2017 12:39 pm

I believe that’s called pandering.

Roger Knights
Reply to  Butch
June 9, 2017 3:55 pm

Scott Adams has a thread on his blog about this.

Peta from Cumbria, now Newark
June 9, 2017 9:37 am

I find it surprising that in these modern times where cause & effect are so easily interchangeable, no-0ne seems to have, in any way, considered that the growing of food might be changing the climate.
But then, we all learned in school that plants just keep jumping up out of the ground, begging to be cut, burned, eaten, arobically gestated and *all* they need to sustain them and maintain this bounty, is a puff of carbon dioxide.
Especially trees and/or biomass. Cut & burn the trees, new ones grow and because the burned ones make CO2, the new ones grow even faster. So you can cut & burn more of the still standing ones and before you know it, the new ones will have grown before you cut the old ones.
A fool-proof plan – what’s not to like?
On the riot side..
There is in the UK a rather small and select group of people. Government regulation has made them this way because of the important yet very hazardous job they do.
They drive petrol tankers around British roads, delivering to petrol stations around the country.
They are not dumb, have learned about their special status and the union they are all members of has negotiated very lucrative pay & working conditions for them.
But, its like free money. Enough is never enough and their union is rather fractious outfit, *always* looking out to improve pay/conditions for its hard-done-by members.
So, every now and again they threaten to go on strike so as to improve their lot, but first, they organise a ballot of members.
Within hours of news of just the ballot, there are queues miles long at petrol stations, touts selling fuel at 10 times the going rate and, if the weather’s nice, fights will be breaking out.
Just at the mention of the tankers drivers holding a ballot with a view to going on strike.
And where’s our ‘strong’ government? Doing an effin Hillary right now, turning a huge majority into A Fail.
Why has is become so necessary these days for everyone to pi55 on everyone else’s parade?

AndyE
June 9, 2017 9:38 am

This time you are taking the mickey out of us, Anthony, surely. I note there is a disclaimer attached to the report: accuracy not guaranteed. It’s not April 1st!

Butch
June 9, 2017 9:41 am

Oh come on you guys…Power plants, powered by magical Unicorn Farts are the wave of the future, everybody knows that…right ?

BallBounces
June 9, 2017 9:45 am

” climate change… could cause food riots in some parts of the world” As long as In-N-Out trucks can still get their supplies to their stores, we’ll be OK.

James Bull
June 9, 2017 9:46 am

Of course it will have nothing to do with growing food to convert into fuel if people are going to be hungry.
We’ve got to save the planet for the children!
James Bull

June 9, 2017 9:53 am

So this OSU dreck has metastasized to U. Mississippi and Amherst. Not good.