'Paleotempestology' – the new Mann science

I missed this announcement yesterday, but when I saw the word “paleotempestology” today, I immediately thought of Dr. Michael Mann, mainly because he throws tempests and everybody else studies them as examples of scientific silliness aka Tabloid Climatology™. Sure enough, after reading the breathless press release, he’s involved. – Anthony

What Paleotempestology Tells Scientists about Today’s Tempests

GSA Annual Meeting & Exposition: Technical Session, Wednesday, 7 November

Boulder, CO, USA – Understanding Earth’s paleo-hurricane record cannot be more timely and important in a light of Hurricane Sandy, which shocked the U.S. East Coast last week. Talks in this Wednesday afternoon session at the GSA Annual Meeting in Charlotte, North Carolina, integrate field, lab, and model analysis of past hurricanes and future scenarios, covering a wide range of temporal and spatial scales.

Session co-organizer Daria Nikitina of West Chester University says that “gaining understanding of past events provides the context for future coastal vulnerability. Given predicted global warming, the frequency and magnitude of severe weather events will probably increase and with it the likelihood of more coastal devastation” like that witnessed in New Jersey, New York, and Connecticut last week, as well as associated weather events further inland.

Presenter Scott P. Hippensteel of the University of North Carolina at Charlotte will talk on “The effectiveness of traditional paleotempestology proxies in backbarrier marshes from the Southeastern Atlantic Coast” at 2:55 p.m. Writing for the Geological Society of America’s science and news magazine, GSA Today, in 2010, he notes, “Growing populations and recent hurricane activity along the Atlantic and Gulf coastlines have made clear the need for a more accurate and extensive record of storm activity” (GSA Today, v. 20, no. 4, p. 52). He also writes that “the field of paleotempestology has never been of more importance,” especially “in the current period of climate change” (GSA Today, p. 53).

As early as 2001, presenter Jeffrey P. Donnelly of Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution addressed “Sedimentary evidence of intense hurricane strikes from New Jersey” (Geology, v. 29, no. 7, p. 615). In the article, he warns, “Intense storms present a significant threat to lives and resources and can result in significant alteration of coastal environments.” He discusses, “The most famous storm affecting the New Jersey shore in the twentieth century was the Ash Wednesday northeaster of March 5–8, 1962… Storm surge associated with this storm overtopped many of the barrier islands of the New Jersey coast and deposited overwash fans across backbarrier marshes there.” In Wednesday’s session, Donnelly will speak about “Late Holocene North Atlantic hurricane activity” at 1:35 p.m.

Michael E. Mann of The Pennsylvania State University, who spoke earlier this week in a late-breaking panel on Hurricane Sandy, will deliver a talk on “Relationships between basin-wide and landfalling Atlantic tropical cyclones: Comparing long-term simulations with paleoevidence” at 3:40 p.m. on Wednesday.

Heading the session with Nikitina are Andrea D. Hawkes of the University of North Carolina Wilmington and Jon Woodruff of the University of Massachusetts Amherst. Hawkes is a co-author on the Donnelly talk; Woodruff is a co-author on a talk presented by Christine M. Brandon, also at U-Mass-Amherst, “Constraining hurricane wind speed at landfall using storm surge overwash deposits from a sinkhole in St. Marks, FL.”

GSA’s Quaternary Geology and Geomorphology Division and International Section cosponsor this session, along with the International Geoscience Programme (IGCP) 588: Preparing for Coastal Change.

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
5 1 vote
Article Rating
63 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ben Darren Hillicoss
November 8, 2012 4:32 pm

Michael Mann
Had a plan
to add a Paleo
to his yamaleo
Bring his “Ring”
To a tempest sting
And put some ol-o-gy
To his temp-ra-tree
oh yeah he did

markx
November 8, 2012 7:06 pm

oldseadog says: November 8, 2012 at 10:33 am
“….Since there have not been any storms like this before (according to The Team, anyway), should the term not be NEOtempestology?…”
Ha ha … oldseadog nails it.
All of these things seem to be unprecedented! (strangely enough, usually they use the phrase “…unprecedented since (date or year)…”)

November 8, 2012 7:48 pm

Money quote:

Given predicted global warming, the frequency and magnitude of severe weather events will probably increase and with it the likelihood of more coastal devastation

But, but ..
— the predicted warming is unaccountably not happening
and
— a flattened temperature gradient tropics→poles reduces air and ocean flows.
I.e., unproven and irrational. NOT to be used as the Null Hypothesis, under any circumstances!

sophocles
November 8, 2012 10:59 pm

… when they start talking about fossilised paleohailstones we will know the
paleocricket-bats have returned.
(For those not in the know, the paleocricket-bats were connected
with Piltdown Man … )

BB
November 9, 2012 1:47 am

What a Mustela nivalis!!

Rich
November 9, 2012 2:11 am

Brian H said:
“Money quote:
Given predicted global warming, the frequency and magnitude of severe weather events will probably increase and with it the likelihood of more coastal devastation
But, but ..
– the predicted warming is unaccountably not happening”
This exhibits a common error. Actually, it’s the prediction of global warming that causes severe weather events to increase. And in fact the reporting of severe weather events has increased.
Glad I could clear that up.

Tim B
November 9, 2012 2:28 am

the problem with Sandy is that we have more than a generation of people unaccustomed to hurricanes in the northeast. Lucky it took a direct right turn or the northward movement would have produced Cat 2 southeast quadrant winds and the “megastorm” people would be going nuts. Sandy was devasting because it’s been many decades since they dealt with a tropical cyclone and they were not prepared.

Louis Hooffstetter
November 9, 2012 5:11 am

Mann, Kozar, and Emanuel’s abstract (edited for clarity) says:
…we examine(d) the relationships between various measures of Atlantic TC (tropical cyclone = tropical storm / hurricane) activity using… a climate model simulation… over the past millennium (AD 850-1999). …we (then) use(d) the… climate model simulation to force a model of tropical cyclone genesis… This process yields synthetic (artificial) long-term basin-wide (North Atlantic Ocean) seasonal TC histories with realistic statistical attributes. Using the simulated.. histories, we examine relationships between basin-wide (North Atlantic Ocean) TC activity… and major U.S. landfalling hurricanes on timescales ranging from the interannual through centennial. We also use these synthetic TC histories to assess the… geological records of past landfalling hurricane activity.
In clear English, they used output from one model (a climate model projection for the past 1000 years) as the input for another model (a tropical cyclone model), and projected Atlantic hurricane activity on timescales from one to a hundred years. Their projections have scientific validity because they have ‘realistic statistical attributes’. Then they used the output of the double model to interpret the geologic record.
This is a modern day equivalent of reading goat entrails.

Pamela Gray
November 9, 2012 6:07 am

I think I can provide these folks with a valuable forward thinking vocabulary list to add to paleotempestology:
paleoasscoldology
paleofryeggshotology
paleosnowmageddonology
paleorainraingoawayology
paleodryasburnttoastology
paleoglobalweirdingcatastrology
And for sometime in the future when the rest of the world wakes up:
paleosciencenumbnutsdiscreditology

Larry Ledwick (hotrod)
November 9, 2012 7:41 am

Pamela — would that make Anthony a sciencenumbnutsdiscreditologist?
Larry

Mycroft
November 9, 2012 1:18 pm

Larry
go back to counting your toes..far less taxing for that bra…pile of mush in your head.

Larry Ledwick (hotrod)
November 9, 2012 1:55 pm

Mycroft says:
November 9, 2012 at 1:18 pm

???? and just what was that supposed to signify other than you like to insult people for no good reason (and apparently have absolutely no sense of humor or sense of history of WUWT.)
Or are you just one of those folks that feel compelled to be rude when you have nothing useful to say.
Anthony is probably the most influential discreditor of numbnuts scientists in the world at this time.
If anyone deserves credit for trying to bring fools like Mann down to earth it is Anthony.
Larry

jks
November 11, 2012 1:12 am

So at which pet store can I buy a pigmy hurricane that will sit in my lap?