![706644main_705852main_GEOS5_full_full[1]](http://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/706644main_705852main_geos5_full_full1.jpeg?resize=640%2C320&quality=83)
Rapid upper ocean warming linked to declining aerosols
Australian scientists have identified causes of a rapid warming in the upper subtropical oceans of the Southern Hemisphere.
They partly attribute the observed warming, and preceding cooling trends to ocean circulation changes induced by global greenhouse gas emissions and aerosols predominantly generated in the Northern Hemisphere from human activity.
The research, by scientists from CSIRO and the University of NSW, was published today in Scientific Reports.
Mr Tim Cowan, lead author of the study, says his group was initially interested in the three decade long cooling below the surface of the Southern Hemisphere subtropical oceans from the 1960s and 1990s. “But what really caught our eye was a rapid warming of these subtropical oceans from the mid-1990s, most noticeably in the Indian Ocean between 300 m to 1000 m depth,” said Mr Cowan.
This had the research team asking whether this rapid warming was partly a response to greenhouse gases overcoming the cooling effect of aerosols that peaked globally in the 1980s due to the introduction of clean air legislation across United States and Europe.
To test this, the researchers examined more than 40 state-of-the-art climate simulations that included historical changes to greenhouse gases and aerosols over the twentieth century. “What we found was that the models do a good job at simulating the late twentieth century cooling and rapid warming in the subtropical southern Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, however they show an around 30-year delay in the warming in the Indian Ocean” said Mr Cowan.
“This delay in the modelled Indian Ocean warming is likely due to the presence of atmospheric aerosols, generated through transport emissions, biomass burning, and industrial smog, together with natural emissions of sea salt and dust – these were also the main cause of the late twentieth century subtropical Indian Ocean below-surface cooling” said Mr Cowan.
“What makes this work fascinating is the fact that human-emitted aerosols have such a large impact on remote ocean temperatures.”
Mr Tim Cowan, CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research
The researchers found that models with a delayed peak in Northern Hemisphere aerosol levels after the 1980s had a tendency to simulate a delayed rapid Indian Ocean warming until well after 2020, and that the rate of warming related to how quickly the aerosol levels declined after their peak.
“We know that aerosols in the atmosphere generally cool the Northern Hemisphere by scattering incoming sunlight. This, in turn, increases the movement of heat from the Southern Hemisphere oceans to the Northern Hemisphere oceans via a global oceanic conveyor belt, travelling south from the subtropical Indian Ocean, passing the southern tip of Africa into the south Atlantic and then north along the Gulf Stream” said co-author Dr Wenju Cai.
“Together with a greenhouse gas-induced southward shift the Indian subtropical ocean gyres towards the Antarctic, these processes delay the Indian Ocean warming in the models,” Dr Cai said.
“What makes this work fascinating is the fact that human-emitted aerosols have such a large impact on remote ocean temperatures” says Mr Cowan. “For many years aerosols have masked the direct surface warming induced by greenhouse gases in many Northern Hemisphere regions, however in the Southern subtropical Indian Ocean both aerosols and greenhouse gases have historically conspired to produce a net oceanic cooling, and now the reverse of some of these processes is occurring.”
Mr Cowan said that despite the observed rapid ocean warming, quantifying exactly how much is due to declining aerosols or increasing greenhouse gases remains difficult, but as human-generated air pollution is all-together phased out, this will undoubtedly reveal the full impact of greenhouse gases.
The research has been supported by the CSIRO Wealth from Oceans National Research Flagship, The Australian Climate Change Science Program and the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence in Climate System Science.
Read more media releases in our Media section.
Cowan T, Cai W, Purich A, Rotstayn L, England MH. 2013. Forcing of anthropogenic aerosols on temperature trends of the subthermocline southern Indian Ocean. Scientific Reports.
============================================================
Strangely, when I went to get some background for this essay, I went to NASA’s
Global Aerosol Climatology Project: Glory Science
but got this: Access denied.
Here it is in Google Cache:
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:LUi3pEfq84oJ:gacp.giss.nasa.gov/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
What’s so secret there?
UPDATE: (~ 6hrs later) Either my complaint cleared the way, or it was a technical issue. Either way http://gacp.giss.nasa.gov/ is working now. -Anthony
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
“What makes this work fascinating is the fact that human-emitted aerosols have such a large impact on remote ocean temperatures” says Mr Cowan. “For many years aerosols have masked the direct surface warming induced by greenhouse gases”
###
Post normal thinking, and these guys think they are scientists?
This link seems to return this page from the Goddard Institute:
Global Aerosol Climatology Project (GACP)
http://gacp.giss.nasa.gov/
however they show an around 30-year delay in the warming in the Indian Ocean” said Mr Cowan.
“This delay in the modelled Indian Ocean warming is likely due to the presence of atmospheric aerosols, generated through transport emissions, biomass burning, and industrial smog, together with natural emissions of sea salt and dust – these were also the main cause of the late twentieth century subtropical Indian Ocean below-surface cooling” said Mr Cowan.
================
Upwelling is a seasonal phenomenon in the Indian Ocean because of the monsoon regime. During the southwest monsoon, upwelling occurs off the Somali and Arabian coasts and south of Java. It is most intense between 5° and 11° N, with replacement of warmer surface water by water of about 57 °F (14 °C). During the northeast monsoon, strong upwelling occurs along the western coast of India. Midocean upwelling takes place at that time at 5° S, where the North Equatorial Current and the Equatorial Countercurrent run alongside each other in opposite directions.
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/285876/Indian-Ocean/22775/Upwelling
http://weather.unisys.com/archive/sst/sst_anom-130707.gif
Looks like NASA are on to you, Anthony – the link works fine for everyone else 😉
We see the usual lame claim of aerosols being a major factor in the discrepancy between ‘evil CO2’ vs. reality being recycled. Didn’t we just get a post where Steve Mac showed that a low aerosol effect model did a better job of forecasting the current global temperature anomaly than the high aerosol effect models?
What I find interesting is the map and the large amount of salt aerosols near Antarctica. Since it’s actually chlorine, not CFCs that breaks down ozone, it appears likely from the figure that it’s NaCl that delivers chlorine into the ozone layer above Antarctica.
Amazing how all the models show that so many things can hide the warming. This one is particularly “good” in that it shows it is actually human activity controlling the oceans as well as the old canard about aerosols hiding the warming.
Can they get it narrowed down to red vs. blue state for culpability and ability to pay up? Zip code level modeling and related redistricting processes would also benefit from such fictional modeling engines.
Simulations based on simulations? Does this mean if I simulate $1 million. Then simulate it’s my $1 million that it is my money? I’M RICH!!!
Somewhat OT, but made Drudge, and seems to be the epicycle of the moment these days:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/has-global-warming-stopped-no–its-just-on-pause-insist-scientists-and-its-down-to-the-oceans-8726893.html
I miss a lot of posts these days. Has someone effectively trounced the claim that the deep ocean is sequestering a lot of ‘extra’ heat?
/Mr Lynn
I call today’s climate scientists thermodynamic anthropogenic fundamentalists. The one factor that is constant is their creative imagination on how human release of different gases and particles can explain almost anything that happens to Earth’s climate.
To mention the Sun, tidal effect or oceans cyclicity is strictly verboten.
Yet another paper for the garbage can.
No well confirmed physical hypotheses, just models. When will they get serious about science?
Lemme know when they have something other than manmade data…
The need to invoke more gods for the failure of the current god to do what the prophets claimed they would , is a very old trick. Here we seen the modem version of it , CO2 has failed to increased temperatures in the we claimed it would therefore we need to call into being another ‘god’ called aerosols to cover our rear ends
It makes me wonder what they will blame the next period of glaciation on? In the last million years, mother nature has brought them on all by herself, 11 times. But the next one? Oh no, it must be man who does it.
The article reads, “Mr Tim Cowan, lead author of the study, says his group was initially interested in the three decade long cooling below the surface of the Southern Hemisphere subtropical oceans from the 1960s and 1990s.”
I wonder what subsurface data he’s referring to for the Southern Hemisphere subtropical oceans. There are few to no subsurface temperature measurements south of 30S during that period.
Given that the ocean is hiding heat and responsible for the ~15 year pause in the rise of amospheric temperatures; why wasn’t this not understood mechanism working prior to 15 years ago?
That is, why didn’t ocean heat absorption occur prior to 15 years ago? Why did the atmospheric temperatures rise back then and not now?
Seems like this explanation raises as many questions as it supposedly resolves.
“We know that aerosols in the atmosphere generally cool the Northern Hemisphere by scattering incoming sunlight. …..[…..]…..
……….For many years aerosols have masked the direct surface warming induced by greenhouse gases in many Northern Hemisphere regions….
So, is the sunlight or the greenhouse gases warming the Northern Hemisphere oceans?
I simply don’t get the logic in calling this an explanation. Surely it simply remains an idea.
They have noted an unexpected cooling (or delay in expected warming).
They have noted the changing aerosol levels.
They have theorized the aerosols cause an amount of cooling equal to the observed data.
They apply that ‘cooling parameter’ to their models, set to that assumed level.
Hey presto …. it matches. (How could it not!!??)
At best a plausible concept.
Proof of nothing whatsoever.
Jeez. I hope I live to see 2016 so I can see what new “gods” evolve: (from Mr Lynn)
“Temperatures still expected to reach predicted 2015 levels with only a five-year delay after 12 of the 14 hottest years on record”
I’m backing my wagon up and loading the shovels in response to this report.
A very awesome automobile in the minds of many gearheads is the 427 Cobra. Mention you own one (I don’t) in a grouping of auto enthusiasts and watch the jaws drop. For quite some time it was the fastest accelerating road car that had existed. It was the brainchild of Carroll Shelby during his collaboration with Ford. He took Ford’s 427 side oiler, twin carb, V8 designed for the stock car circuits (not the wimpy 428 Thunderbird V8) and somehow stuffed it in a British roadster designed for a 4 cyl.
Anyway, the first, shall we say, test mule for the 427 Cobra was a 289 cubic inch V8 version, which, in and of itself, was no slouch. Anyway, a number of years ago I bought a kit version of the 289 Cobra from which I built a model. (Now, do you see where I’m going with this?) It’s a 1/43rd scale model which means it’s quite small. Even on a hot day, with thermal expansion, it’s not even 4″ long (a smaller dimension even then sea level rise). I’m quite proud of it. On models that size there’ll be lines scored in the bodywork moldings to indicate the doors and trunk. On mine I painted them in black; it’s called ‘lining.’ It was so convincing I’ve actually had people believe the doors and trunk could open. On the (painted) wood handled gearshift knob you can actually see (painted) white dots indicating the ‘H’ shift pattern. There’s carpets, seat belts, a three spoke wood rim steering wheel.
Too much free time and way too much money.
When it comes to global warming “science,” we are in the era of epicycles.
Correlation is not Causation. That is all.