As I have mentioned previously, I’ve provided space for a response from Peter Hadfield (aka the nom de plume potholer54). I’ve published Peter Hadfield’s response in entirety, submitted Feb 7th, 2012. I’ve made only some slight edits for formatting to fit WUWT’s column style.
You can read it side by side in a point counterpoint style with Monkton’s original commentary here at this link. This allows you to see both sides in one place without having to flip between stories.