Climategate

Links to everything about Climategate here. Relevant links posted in comments will be added.

WUWT Stories in chronological order, newest first:


When Results Go Bad …

U-CRU

Telegraph’s Booker on the “climategate” scandal

“Climategate” surpasses “Global Warming” on Google

Mann to be investigated by Penn State University review

Understanding Climategate: Who’s Who – a video

The Curry letter: a word about “deniers”…

How “The Trick” was pulled off

The Australian ETS vote: a political litmus test for cap and trade

An open letter from Dr. Judith Curry on climate science

Zorita calls for barring Phil Jones, Michael Mann, and Stefan Rahmstorf from further IPCC participation

Climategate protester pwn3d CBC on live TV

UEA Climate Scientist: “possible that…I.P.C.C. has run its course”

IPCC reviewer: “don’t cover up the divergence”

McIntyre: The deleted data from the “Hide the Decline” trick

Climategate: Stuart Varney “lives with Ed”

Climategate: Pielke Senior on the NCDC CCSP report – “strong arm tactics”

Warwick Hughes shows how Jones selections put bias in Australian Temperatures

Climategate: CATO’s Pat Michaels and Center for American Progress Dan Weiss on Fox News

Quote of the week #23 – calls for resignation in Climategate

Uh, oh – raw data in New Zealand tells a different story than the “official” one.

Climategate: “Men behaving badly” – a short summary for laymen

Statement on CRU hacking from the American Meteorological Society

Climategate: hide the decline – codified

Must see video – Climategate spoof from Minnesotans for Global Warming

The people -vs- the CRU: Freedom of information, my okole…

Government petition started in UK regarding CRU Climategate

CEI Files Notice of Intent to Sue NASA GISS

The appearance of hypocrisy at the NYT – Note to Andy

Nov 24 Statement from UEA on the CRU files

Nov 23 Statement from UEA on the CRU files

Monbiot issues an unprecedented apology – calls for Jones resignation

The CRUtape Letters™, an Alternative Explanation.

CRU Emails “may” be open to interpretation, but commented code by the programmer tells the real story

Video: Dr. Tim Ball on the CRU emails

Pielke Senior: Comment On The Post “Enemies Caught In Action!” On The Blackboard

Bishop Hill’s compendium of CRU email issues

Spencer on elitism in the IPCC climate machine

CRU Emails – search engine now online

Release of CRU files forges a new hockey stick reconstruction

Mike’s Nature Trick

and the post that started it all…

Breaking News Story: CRU has apparently been hacked – hundreds of files released


Sponsored IT training links:

Join 642-357 online course and improve your 642-691 test score up to 100% using certified 70-685 material.


Other relevant stories:

Get notified when a new post is published.
Subscribe today!
3.8 13 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
419 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Noelene
December 7, 2009 9:01 am

Good article in the WSJ
Global Warming and Mt. Kilimanjaro
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704342404574577892593153408.html?mod=rss_com_mostcommentart
For Mrs. Thomas, arguments over the state of the ice are irrelevant. When she was asked by a Copenhagen Consensus Center researcher what donors and the Tanzanian government should do, she doesn’t think for long. “Education is the first priority,” she says, “and it should provide proper understanding of HIV and reduce the stigma. The next priority is micro-finance so people can have the chance to become self-reliant.”
As she puts it, “There is no need for ice on the mountain if there is no people around because of HIV/AIDS.”

AnonyMoose
December 7, 2009 10:58 am

Today’s top totally-missing-the-point headline is from the Guardian: Met Office to release records that show global temperature rise
And notice the photo is of a scientist torturing an ice core. They’re shining a hot bright light on their delicate ice core just so it can be photographed.

BS is alos Organic
December 7, 2009 11:24 am

http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/2009/pr20091205.html
The Met Office has announced plans to release, early next week, station temperature records for over one thousand of the stations that make up the global land surface temperature record.
“This data is a subset of the full HadCRUT record of global temperatures, which is one of the global temperature records that have underpinned IPCC assessment reports and numerous scientific studies. The data subset will consist of a network of individual stations that has been designated by the World Meteorological Organisation for use in climate monitoring. The subset of stations is evenly distributed across the globe and provides a fair representation of changes in mean temperature on a global scale over land.”

BS is also Organic
December 7, 2009 11:26 am

http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/climatechange/news/latest/tackling-temps.html
“As world leaders gather in Copenhagen for the UN Climate Change Conference, a new map has been launched that highlights the importance of limiting mean global temperature rise to no more than 2 °C above those prior to the industrial revolution.
The Met Office map — The impacts of a global temperature rise of 2 °C — has been produced to complement a similar map, published in October by the UK Government and the Met Office, exploring the impacts on a world if the mean temperature was allowed to climb to 4 °C above the pre-industrial climate average. The two maps together show the range of climate impacts that can be avoided if we act now to reduce global emissions to keep global temperatures below 2 °C.”

BS is also Organic
December 7, 2009 11:28 am

http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/climatechange/science/projects/ensembles.html
“E1 uses methodology from the next IPCC assessment review (AR5) on using concentrations and forcings (the warming influence of GHGs on the atmosphere) as a starting point. Modellers are then able to establish what level of emissions would relate to the stated concentrations, which lets scientists calculate what the likely temperature change might be. Realistic socio-economic scenarios, such as the level of development of renewable energy sources or population growth are then determined to match.”

BS is also Organic
December 7, 2009 11:34 am

With all the probabilistic findings of the Met office I have one question. Are you 100% sure you are right, or are you just getting better at guessing?
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/science/creating/improvements.html

Christine Arnold
December 7, 2009 12:21 pm

Obama cannot make any pledges at Copenhagen that are NOT approved first by Congress. He is NOT a dictator yet and without the approval of congress what he says or does at Copenhagen means NOTHING!
Obama and Congress are employed and work for me and the rest of the US citizens and MUST answer to us. If they don’t do what we the people want they will soon find themselves out of jobs and on the unemployment line like 20% of Americans now are.
Those are the undisputable facts and intelligient Americans, not academians, know that Global warming is and always has been a money making, transfer of power HOAX. We DO NOT buy it and never will.

Dan McCune
December 7, 2009 12:57 pm

Here’s the best article I’ve seen so far on the topic.
December 06, 2009
Understanding Climategate’s Hidden Decline
By Marc Sheppard
http://www.americanthinker.com/2009/12/understanding_climategates_hid.html

photon without a Higgs
December 7, 2009 5:06 pm

Very nice pre-Copenhagen video interview with Monckton.
Includes comments on Lindzen/ERBE, on ClimateGate, and on his intentions in attending Copenhagen. Lays out the ‘skeptics’ case very simply.
I think this video is very nice and would make a good post—IMO. It might give WUWT readers a good feeling knowing that Monckton will be at work in Copenhagen
12 minute video.
http://rt.com/Politics/2009-12-07/climate-change-warming-moncktonthe.html
————————————
h/t commenter PhilW

photon without a Higgs
December 7, 2009 5:23 pm

photon without a Higgs (17:06:12) :
Very nice pre-Copenhagen video interview with Monckton.
Here’s the same interview on YouTube, h/t Ron de Haan

LiamIAm
December 7, 2009 6:57 pm

This is a condensed presentation of the St.Paul address plus a focus on 8 of the ClimateGate players and references Anthony’s SurfaceStations.org work.
—–
Lord Christopher Monckton speaks at the second International Climate Conference [Deutsche land], addressing the so called Climategate scandal and key players involved in what appears to be one of the biggest science scams of our time.
http://www.cfact.tv/2009/12/07/lord-monckton-on-climategate-at-the-2nd-international-climate-conference/
Updated with Slides – Lord Christopher Monckton Speaking in St. Paul – Oct’09

LiamIAm
December 7, 2009 9:01 pm

Alternate link for Monckton video on 7Dec’09 from Berlin.
http://www.cfact.tv/category/video/
Then select video from list.

Tero
December 8, 2009 1:23 am

Hi!
Finnish broadcasting company YLE showed last night documentary Ilmastogate (Climategate). You can watch that film via following link (film is publically available 7 days).
http://areena.yle.fi/video/602461
Documentary is very good and reveals lot of stuff. I hope that someboby can generate english subtitle.

Tero
December 8, 2009 1:29 am

Climategate documentary manuscript is publically available via followin link.
http://ohjelmat.yle.fi/mot/taman_viikon_mot/kasikirjoitus
You can translate it on Google translate service.
http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=fi&sl=fi&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fohjelmat.yle.fi%2Fmot%2Ftaman_viikon_mot%2Fkasikirjoitus

GrahamF
December 8, 2009 2:41 am

The UK Met Office has released a subset of data for Land Surface Station Climate Records at http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/climatechange/science/monitoring/subsets.html
The question is how accurate is it. They say: “The data that we are providing is the database used to produce the global temperature series. Some of these data are the original underlying observations and some are observations adjusted to account for non climatic influences, for example changes in observations methods”.
So is some raw data, and some the “value-added” data? If it has been “adjusted” like the Darwin data (see http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/12/08/the-smoking-gun-at-darwin-zero/) then the raw data needs to be seen also to see what “corrections” have been made!

Kambing
December 8, 2009 3:52 am

I can only conclude, somewhat reluctantly, that Google is deliberately and manually (!) tinkering with its search engine. The tinkering is a shape-shifter, changing guises almost hourly. As of now, only ‘climate-gate’ (with the hyphen) will autosuggest.
Worse, the first page of Google’s search results looks like Al Gore’s resume. The Huffington Post? It compares ClimateGate to WaterGate in the sense that they both began with evil right-wing ‘burglaries’! Thus the evil-doers will be brought to justice.
Sure. And so the Nixon Plumbers immediately went public with the dirt they pilfered from the DNC?
These people all need to get the word; they are BUSTED!
For a good list of things that are much harder to suppress, search on ‘AR4 suppressed papers jones mann briffa’. But even here, Google puts the ‘defense’ on page one. (Hey, Google! There IS no defense!)
The Vostok Ice Core data, which show that atmospheric CO2 LAGS temperature over a 400,000 year timespan, are also getting harder to find.
And now, (gotta be a coincidence, right?) the EPA decides that ‘greenhouse gasses’ are ‘dangerous’ to public health? Like water vapor? Do these idiots know that CO2 is the ORIGIN of Green?
I think I should take a stress pill.

Noelene
December 8, 2009 8:02 am

Yay
http://www.news.com.au/world/copenhagen-conference-in-disarray/story-e6frfkyi-1225808437312
TALKS at the United Nations climate change conference in Copenhagen have broken down over leaked documents indicating that wealthier nations would be given more power in future climate change negotiation

AnonyMoose
December 8, 2009 10:16 am

Met Office has released some weather data. http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/corporate/pressoffice/2009/pr20091208a.html
CRU still hasn’t released data, station lists, nor code for past research. Past research still not confirmed.

ross dickson
December 8, 2009 4:16 pm

This is all talk, whikst over in Copenhagen our future is being discussed without any thought to democracy. Everybody I know, work with or socialise with believe that this is just a scam to get more taxes out of us. most people have not heard of climategate and are in the dark of how serious Copenhagen is to their wellbeing . The politicains have done a great job in keeping this quiet but as I said most people are in blissful ignorance. Therefore something must be done to bring this out in the open before it is too late. The envirnmentalists got a few thousand to march on London. I believe, with the feeling of the country, that sceptics could gather thousands more . Look what the poll tax marchers done in 1990. This is the biggest and most unfair tax ever and if this knowledge can be made more known it could stop it.
If anyone knows how to arrange a march of this magnitude please speak up and lets show how the majority feel.

Kambing
December 8, 2009 6:42 pm

Pretty naive, Ross.
Even if you could organize such a ‘march’, it would only be seen as an effort by a few right-wing loons to fight ‘progress’ and discredit the ‘settled science’.
For every ‘marcher’ you could find, the Left could recruit ten. Most being unemployed, they’re professional demonstrators.
As you point out, most people could not care less about any of this, and that won’t change. De Tocqueville has been proven correct: democracies fail when the majority begin to believe in ‘free’ money.
This debate is not about about the environment any more; it’s about the redistribution of wealth. Which, sadly, is about the only ‘consensus’ left

BS is also Organic
December 8, 2009 7:17 pm

The ‘Danish Text’ Disrupts Copenhagen: What You Need to Know
Daniel Stone
http://blog.newsweek.com/blogs/thegaggle/archive/2009/12/08/the-danish-text-disrupts-copenhagen-what-you-need-to-know.aspx
(sorry, I may of posted on another thread)

LiamIAm
December 8, 2009 8:59 pm

Climategate: Barack Obama’s rule by EPA decree is a coup d’etat against Congress, made in Britain
By Gerald Warner | December 8th, 2009
“Who needs tanks on the lawn when you have the Environmental Protection Agency? Barack Obama’s use of the EPA to pressurise the Senate to pass his climate change Nuremberg Decrees shows his dictatorial mentality. He wants to override Congress, which is hostile to his climate gobbledegook because it is representative of the American electorate, and sideline the nation’s elected Senators by ruling by decree, courtesy of the EPA. This is a coup d’état.”
“And what is the justification for this undemocratic action? The allegedly imminent threat from “Anthropogenic Global Warming”. There is always a supposed threat, when tyrants take the stage. The President of the United States has just reduced his moral authority to the level of any Third World dictator heading a “Government of National Emergency”.”
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/geraldwarner/100019206/climategate-barack-obamas-rule-by-epa-decree-is-a-coup-detat-against-congress-made-in-britain/

photon without a Higgs
December 8, 2009 10:56 pm

New Zealand TV programme, ‘Close Up’, climate change debate, with author of “Air Con”, Ian Wishart,
ClimateGate is mentioned
had interactive phone text poll, result:
Ian Wishart 77%
warmer 23%

photon without a Higgs
December 8, 2009 11:17 pm

I ♥ ClimateGate…
APS climate change statement story makes FOX News, 🙂

1 9 10 11 12 13 17