One day later: Mauna Loa CO2 graph changes

UPDATE: 08/07 2:PM PST MLO responds with improvements to the CO2 data reporting

Approximately 24 hours after I published my story on the January to July trend reversal of CO2 at Mauna Loa, the monthly mean graph that is displayed on the NOAA web page for Mauna Loa Observatory has changed. I’ve setup a blink comparator to show what has occurred:

For those who don’t know, a blink comparator is an animated GIF image with a 1 second delay consisting only of the two original images from NOAA MLO. Individual image URLS for: August 3rd ML CO2 graph | August 4th CO2 Graph

Now the there is no longer the dip I saw yesterday. Oddly the MLO CO2 dataset available by FTP still shows the timestamp from yesterday: File Creation:  Sun Aug  3 02:55:42 2008, and the July monthly mean value is unchanged in it to reflect the change on the graph.

[UPDATE: a few minutes after I posted this entry, the data changed at the FTP site] here is the new data for 2008:

#               decimal          mean    interpolated    trend

#               date                                                 (season corr)

2008   1    2008.042      385.37      385.37      385.18

2008   2    2008.125      385.69      385.69      384.77

2008   3    2008.208      385.94      385.94      384.50

2008   4    2008.292      387.21      387.21      384.46

2008   5    2008.375      388.47      388.47      385.46

2008   6    2008.458      387.87      387.87      385.51

2008   7    2008.542      385.60      385.60      385.25

and here is the 2008 data from Sunday, August 3rd:

2008   1    2008.042      385.35      385.35      385.11

2008   2    2008.125      385.70      385.70      384.85

2008   3    2008.208      385.92      385.92      384.38

2008   4    2008.292      387.21      387.21      384.59

2008   5    2008.375      388.48      388.48      385.33

2008   6    2008.458      387.99      387.99      385.76

2008   7    2008.542      384.93      384.93      384.54

Here is the MLO data file I saved yesterday (text converted to PDF) from their FTP site.

Here is the URL for the current data FTP:

ftp://ftp.cmdl.noaa.gov/ccg/co2/trends/co2_mm_mlo.txt

I have put in a query to Pieter Tans, the contact listed in the data file, asking for an explanation and  change log if one exists.

UPDATE 08/05 8:55AM PST I have received a response from MLO:

Anthony,

We appreciate your interest in the CO2 data.  The reason was simply that

we had a problem with the equipment for the first half of July, with the

result that the earlier monthly average consisted of only the last 10

days.  Since CO2 always goes down fast during July the monthly average

came out low.  I have now changed the program to take this effect into

account, and adjusting back to the middle of the month using the

multi-year average seasonal cycle.  This change also affected the entire

record because there are missing days here and there.  The other

adjustments were minor, typically less than 0.1 ppm.

Best regards,

Pieter Tans

UPDATE 08/05 4:03PM PST

I have been in dialog with Dr. Tans at MLO through the day and I’m now satisfied as to what has occurred and why.  Look for a follow-up post on the subject. – Anthony

UPDATE 08/06 3:00PM PST

A post-mortem of the Mauna Loa issue has been posted here:

http://wattsupwiththat.wordpress.com/2008/08/06/post-mortem-on-the-mauna-loa-co2-data-eruption/

– Anthony

0 0 votes
Article Rating
247 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted