Guest Post by Willis Eschenbach
Due to good fortune and the WUWT readership, we got the chance to not only see the Falkirk Wheel, but to take a ride on it … what a marvelous piece of Scottish engineering. No wonder the engineer on the Starship Enterprise was “Scotty” … here’s the wheel, on a lovely day of rain and sun, but mostly rain. Or what is known as “un-made whisky”, as I’m told rain is called locally:
The wheel rotates to move boats up and down, in lieu of a system of locks, to overcome the difference in height between two canals above and below. When you’ve been moved up from the bottom to the top, you are looking out along an elevated waterway that you can see below:
We didn’t go far on the canal, just through the tunnel and back. The gorgeous ex-fiancée and I take care of her father, who is 85 and legally blind. We’re always looking for things that he can do, and so we were graciously given a very short ride on a boat that is used to carry disabled people along the canals, so that they can be safely out and moving in the fresh air. It would be perfect for the old man, he loves the water but has trouble on the ocean, so we’ll see if we can find something equivalent back in the States.
The boat is one of ten that is operated by a charity called the “Seagull Trust Cruises”. I have been amazed by the amount and extent of work that is done by various charities in the UK. Many things that are done (poorly) by the government in the US are done, and done well, by the charities in the UK. For example, the Seagull Trust Cruises operates totally on public donations, and is staffed entirely by volunteers … and they’ve given free rides to over a million disabled people to date. What a wonderful gift for someone cooped up in a nursing home, or homebound for some chronic medical problem, to be able to take a canal cruise.
So I put £20 into the charity right there on the spot, and if anyone else is so inclined, their website is here, it’s a good cause. They’re set up to take people on wheelchairs, and every penny of the money goes to the actual operating expenses—no one, from the highest to the lowest, takes any money at all for their time.
The engineering on the Falkirk Wheel is so well-balanced that it only takes about the amount of energy needed to toast three slices of toast to rotate the wheel by a half turn, boats, water and all … it’s all computer controlled, and if the water levels in the two chambers are different by more than 75 mm (3″), the whole thing stops. Here’s a view from the top of the wheel, just prior to starting back down:
And here are the gears that make it all go round …
From there, an old sea-dog who reads WUWT took us on a tour of the “kirk”, or church, for which Falkirk is named. First, though, we stopped at the Antonine wall. It served the same purpose as the better-known Hadrians wall, regulating commerce. Unlike Hadrian’s Wall, however, it was built of turf, and has since disappeared. All that is left are the trench that was excavated to provide the turf for the wall and increase its height, and the heap of earth on the left that is where the wall once stood:
I was irresistibly reminded of Matsuo Basho’s haiku, written on a battlefield that was already ancient in the 1600’s …
Summer grass
Of stalwart warriors’ spendid dreams
The aftermath …
We were then taken on a guided tour of the Falkirk church. “Falkirk” means “spotted church”, because the original church (built in 36,000BC or some such date) was built with stones of different colors. The church feed lunch every day to the homeless, and the cost of that is recovered by selling the same meals to anyone who comes in … so we started out with lunch at the church. Like the Seagull Trust, the restaurant is completely staffed by volunteers.
Inside, the church is very unusual, because it’s rounded. Unlike most churches, it felt well-worn and well-loved. The best part of the tour, though, was we went up into the belfry.

I’ve never been up in an actual belfry before, in the US churches generally have loudspeakers … the old sea-dog said bells were a gift from the Dollar family of San Francisco … “The owners of the Dollar Steamship Lines?” I asked, because that name is very familiar on the West Coast. Yes, I was told, the family came from Falkirk, and they had the bells made in the US and shipped back to the old country after they’d made their fortune.
And wonder of wonders, I was invited to play the bells! Rather than subject the entire city to a novice, I just played a few notes … I’ve never, ever played an acoustic instrument of that power, it was astonishing. The only thing I can compare it to, which some may understand, is driving a D10 Caterpillar dozer … raw unbridled strength at my fingertips.
Parts of the church are made of sandstone … and it is so old that the very stones themselves have been worn away, not by people or by traffic, but by the rain … where I grew up, that only happens to mountains. The folks of Falkirk appear to be harder than their sandstone, however, if this plaque near the church is accurate …
The old sea-dog had graciously invited us to spend the night at his home, and on the way there we stopped at the Carron Iron Works … or more accurately, a monument to the former Carron works, cheaper ironwork from the Japanese drove them out of business. There I learned that a “carronade”, which is a small cannon which I’d read about in many histories of the period, was named after the Carron works. It’s a lethal affair designed to shoot “grape-shot” at infantry, basically a shotgun on steroids.
All that’s left of the works now are a couple of cannons and carronades … the cannon in the background is one of two surviving cannons from the battle of Waterloo, the other is to the left of it just out of the picture.
The Carron Iron Works was also the company that made the first steam boiler for James Watt, a part of which is mounted in the wall of the monument:
“Stalwart warriors’ splendid dreams” indeed …
We had a lovely evening with the old sea-dog and his good lady, listening to stories of life at sea as recounted by he and his wife, who had accompanied him around the world, and tales of battles in Falkirk won and lost. I can’t thank them enough for their hospitality and the insights into Scotland and life in the north.
The next day we rolled on to Edinburgh, where we are now … but that’s a story for another day, we’re off to see Mary King’s Close.
My best to all, more to come,
w.
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



Very ingenious. A little video of the Falkirk Wheel. http://www.youtube.comwatch?v=KWXcC8nv6U4
The Trent Lock System in Ontario is pretty cool tool. They use boring old hydraulic pistons though.
so glad you found the time to visit the falkirk wheel willis,indeed that you have come to scotland ,an oft forgotten small nation that has punched well above its weight in scientific discovery and engineering endeavour .
i suspect the wheel will remain working long after the last wind farm has collapsed in to the north sea.
have a great time on the remainder of your trip ,but please pick an indoor activity for sunday. it appears we have an extreme climate event happening,more commonly referred to in scotland as a driech day,or a bit wet and windy.
Fascinating, and entertaining.
Thank you Willis
For science-y stuff, you might want to visit the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh and say hello to Dolly the Sheep, amongst other wonders of course 🙂
Lovely read Willis, prepare for the first storm of Autumn tomorrow!
Great stuff Willis – Five stars awarded!
A classic efficient engineering solution.
Scottish explorers, inventors, engineers, soldiers and administrators conquered and ran the British Empire for a couple of centuries: I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that without the Scots England would have found it impossible to build and run its global fiefdom. I’m not Scottish by the way.
What a wonderfully diverse collection of images and experiences Willis! I’m so enjoying this vicarious trip up North, where I’ve not ventured in decades
Yeh. If I ever go near there, it’s something I will make the effort to watch in action.
Willis:
Thankyou for another wonderful report of your travels in our isles.
You say
Perhaps the clearest example of how we use charities is the Royal National Lifeboat Institute (RNLI). You and some of your American readers may want to compare the RNLI to some of the duties conducted by the US Coastguard.
This link goes to the RNLI homepage
http://rnli.org/Pages/Default.aspx
Richard
We have a pair of Falkirk 6 pounders in our garage, made around 1800 for the Reed Shipping Line to sail the South China seas out of Cardiff. A little of the original green paint survives on one of the carriages. We load two pounds of porridge oats over half a pound of black powder once a year and it rolls like thunder.
Uses SKF bearings with seals expected to last 120 years. – http://www.skf.com/files/058365.pdf
Mike H says:
September 14, 2013 at 8:13 am
> Very ingenious. A little video of the Falkirk Wheel.
Your URL was missing a slash, this should work:
The photos now make a lot more sense!
Animated GIF –

[Thanks, Mike, I’ve embedded it. -w.]
If you like canal boat lifts, here is the original of all lifts, built in 1875.
The Anderton Boat Lift, in Cheshire.
http://canalrivertrust.org.uk/media/huge/75.jpg
.
… the old sea-dog said bells were a gift from the Dollar family of San Francisco … “The owners of the Dollar Steamship Lines?” I asked, because that name is very familiar on the West Coast.
The name is also very familiar on the East Coast, well known around Pennsylvania, except here someone from the family invested in retail sales. Likely there was some inter-family competition as it shows up on several chains. We have Dollar General stores, Dollar Bargain, even some plain Dollar Stores. Quite impressive.
Perhaps I should add that the original Anderton lift was water-hydraulic – as one caisson falls, its weight pushes the other up, so very little energy was required to make the system work.
And if you like peculiar early engineering, take a look at the swing bridges in Northwich (just below the Anderton Boat Lift). These were built in 1899. Notince anything odd?
http://www.jim-shead.com/waterways/P10522.jpg
The strange thing is that these swing bridges were made as boats – they float. The problem they had in Northwich was terrible subsidence, caused by salt mining. So it was deemed impossible to sink a great pillar-foundation into the ground, as it would be leaning over within 10 years. So the answer, was to make the bridge sit on a big ‘boat’ – a large empty cylinder. This has the added advantage of making the bridge very easy to swing, as there is (was) zero resistance. One horse could swing it around.
.
Hi Willis,
Good to know you’re enjoying the local features. The distant Ochil Hills at upper-right in third pic brood over the home of a big fan of yours where he’s just about to go and get scrubbed-up before meeting with a bunch of friends for a bite and later, a dram or six. It’s a certainty that some of them will be raised in your direction ;-).
Have a great holiday.
Slàinte mhòr!
Sam the First – the Scots took advantage of English domination!
I have been on the Falkirk Wheel – its great. You might almost imagine a space ship shooting out through those rings. In fact you get a canal boat!
richardscourtney says:
September 14, 2013 at 9:01 am
Thanks, Richard. As a seaman, I am indeed aware (and continually amazed) by the bravery and dedication of the RNLI volunteers. The number of lives that they have saved, and their actions in the face of incredible danger and hardship, have brought them world-wide renown among sailors the world over.
w.
The carronade was used extensively for naval ordnance as although it”s short barrel gave it limited accuracy at range, it’s wide bore (firing solid shot) at short range was extremely destructive. I believe the USS Constitution has a battery of carronade on her upper deck.
Willis, I’m glad you mentioned it, it’s one of my favourite pieces of engineering. There’s and excellent timelapse video of it on youtube.
Willis
The RNLI have a string of life boat stations down the east coast. Many will allow people to come in and look at the lifeboats and most will have little gift shops ideal for your Christmas presents. I just bought my diary at the RNLI in teignmouth but held off on Christmas cards as its three months too early.
By the way are you aware of the ‘Mobility’ scheme present in towns of any size? They allow disability aids to be hired by the hour or day. They usually have a fine range of wheelchairs and electric scooters. My mother had severe arthritis and very poor sight but enjoyed it when we hired an electric scooter for her. Best used in pedestrianised areas or on sea side promenades. I don’t know of they have anything similar in the states, if nt it would be a fine amenity for people.
Tonyb
Thanks , Willis, for the image of the carronade. I’ve vaguely wondered what these devices looked like since reading the incomparable Patrick O’Brian seafaring novels.
Funny how one seldom remembers to look up less pressing issues online. I guess it’s because the thought occurs when a computer is not handy, and then one forgets. Last time I paused to think about what a carronade might look like was when visiting the Tower of London about a month ago, on a (way too brief) five-day stopover in England. Lots of cannons and mortars in the Tower….
I am really enjoying travelling vicariously with you on your enviably protracted journey across England and Scotland. I’m looking forward to the next installment.
kadaka (KD Knoebel) says:
September 14, 2013 at 9:29 am
______________
Oh, you are a smartypants.