The shonky world of Guardian reporting – they Fakegate themselves

UPDATE: 7:30PM PST I’ve been offline much of today in travel and then immediately attending the Heartland dinner, so I’m hours late with this update. Apparently, the story has now been restored, and there’s a a second critical story. – Anthony

Yesterday while traveling I got some urgent emails on my phone alerting me to a story by Suzanne Goldenberg (at left) of the Guardian, I read it from a  Starbucks in Susanville, CA while on my way to photograph the eclipse. I sighed and went on, because there was nothing I could do about it at the time except shake my head at the lack of journalism on display.

Readers may recall Goldenberg is the same reporter who broke the Fakegate story there originally, without bothering to check the authenticity of the Heartland documents first, or even to await confirmation from me on questions before publishing a smear. It seems she wrote a story “clearing” Peter Gleick of the document forgery, but the story had no references, no quotes, no sources, nothing.

That story has now “disappeared” from the Guardian website. Here’s the original screencap from Google cache: 

and now if you visit this URL:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/may/20/peter-gleick-cleared-heartland

You get a 404:

A search for the key words on the Guardian website also reveals nothing. There’s nothing at Gleicks Pacific Institute either:

http://www.pacinst.org/press_center/

It seems editors at the Guardian have taken the story down, perhaps because it was baseless and/or premature?

James Sexton finds some interesting things connected to Goldenberg’s “journalism”:

Thanks to reader Kim, I did a little research on the corespondent who reported this ………  story?   It seems our friend, Suzanne Goldenberg,  has a past with departing from the truth already.

Apparently she was the lead reporter in the bombed ambulance hoax.

In 2006 she reported:

On the night of July 23, 2006, an Israeli aircraft intentionally fired missiles at and struck two Lebanese Red Cross ambulances performing rescue operations, causing huge explosions that injured everyone inside the vehicles. Or so says the global media, including Time magazine, the BBC, the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times and thousands of other outlets around the world. If true, the incident would have been an egregious and indefensible violation of the Geneva Convention, and would constitute a war crime committed by the state of Israel.

But there’s one problem: It never happened.

http://www.zombietime.com/fraud/ambulance/

http://littlegreenfootballs.com/article/22533_Al-Guardian_Shills_for_Ambulance_Story

http://cifwatch.com/2012/04/16/suzanne-goldenberg-avoids-mentioning-her-jenin-lies-at-the-guardian-open-weekend/

Or just Google Suzanne Goldenberg ambulance hoax.

Maybe this will be enough for the Guardian to boot her? Fool me once…fool me twice…

When your reporter becomes the news, maybe you should rethink having that reporter. Just my opinion.

I’m off to catch a plane…stories and moderation light today.