In case you don’t know the line above, lookup “Treasure of the Sierra Madre”. Here’s a YouTube clip of one of the most famous lines ever borrowed for parody use in movies.
I’ve always said that if you can’t laugh at yourself and situations, then what is the point of life? After the PNAS blacklist fiasco, I compared the episode to the East German Stasi and the lists of citizens they made to track personal associations. I also quipped: “Will we have to wear yellow badges to climate science conferences?”. That’s a reference to the Yellow badges imposed on the Jewish population of WWII, to separate them from the rest of the populace. It is a sad footnote of history but not unlike the PNAS paper’s attempt to separate skeptics from the rest of the scientific community.
Lucia decided I had invoked Godwins Law, and being the optimist, I suggested this yellow badge for skeptics, since our friends on the other side of the argument always seem to be such sourpusses:

That seems to be a hit, so much in fact that lot’s of people have designed variations. Lots of examples below. So, I’m going to have a contest. We’ll look, we’ll vote. Then I’ll get some made up. Just leave links to your badge images (Tinypic, Picassa, Imageshack, etc) in comments, then I’ll gather them up for a voting page. Keep it clean, be upbeat and funny. Words combined with images are OK too. Just keep some connection to the Yellow smiley badge obvious.
Here’s some examples by cartoonist Josh:
From Cartoons by Josh


Following a request by Anthony at WUWT and discusion at The Blackboard
about there being some climate skeptic yellow badges I thought an Anthony badge and a Lucia badge would be fun – see above.
And so no one feels left out below is a Warmista badge, and, because I couldn’t resist, a Monckton badge.
The third one started off as the Pielke clan badge as they collectively cover a lot of opinions but actually it could be all of us! And, yes, other groups use rainbow badges – so really useful for all kinds of marches you find yourself on 😉



And a thank you badge for Atomic Hairdryer.

Also one for another articulate poster, Raven
(and hoping he/she will get in touch so I can do an ‘inhabitants’ cartoon)

And Bishop Hill of course.

Not sure if I’ve done this right but here’s a WUWT button for you
I uploaded it to tinypic
http://i45.tinypic.com/1491cue.jpg
Ray says:
June 28, 2010 at 8:54 am
Here is mine…
http://i48.tinypic.com/aucu3q.jpg
__________________________________________________
ROTFLMAO… I think we need to have several of these available, there are too many good ones to choose just one. (I like John’s polar bear and the CO2 resisters breaking a hockey stick too)
Walter Schneider says:
June 28, 2010 at 9:05 am
Buttons are great. They are declarations of the button wearer’s views or attitude. To get that across, effectively, a button must be simple and easy easy to understand.
Effective buttons are great communication tools, but, ideally, they will initiate a transaction in the communication process that leads to a more extensive information transfer…..
___________________________________________________________
You are correct. The button must be different enough to cause curiosity and also not be an “in joke.” Others especially the neutrals must understand it enough to ask questions.
Whats this amigo got against badgers? St-e-e-nking badgers.
Nearly ran over one of them the other week.
norby says:
June 28, 2010 at 1:32 pm
OK – this is fun…. might as well put Mann himself in the reflection of the broken sunglasses….
http://www.packerpalace.com/blog/images/smile-skeptic-3.jpg
______________________________________________________-
ROTFLMAO…. How are we supposed to choose?
Josh says:
June 28, 2010 at 2:56 pm
In the UK you can buy a Monckton badge here Not sure about elsewhere, let me know and I see what I can set up.
I love all the ideas on this thread. One Pielke Jr badge coming up.
______________________________________________________
Josh, I hope you make several of this badges (or bumper stickers or t shirts ) available, with the artists permission of course.
My slight variant badge is here.
CO2 is cool, man.
http://i49.tinypic.com/16m3kop.gif
I vote for SemiChemE
I still like the original plain smiley face in the article the best.
http://rigeradvertising.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/smiley_face_button1.jpg?w=175&h=174
It’ll drive them crazy. How can they argue with a smiley face.
Anthony wrote,
“I also quipped: ‘Will we have to wear yellow badges to climate science conferences?’. That’s a reference to the Yellow badges imposed on the Jewish population of WWII, to separate them from the rest of the populace. It is a sad footnote of history but not unlike the PNAS paper’s attempt to separate skeptics from the rest of the scientific community.”
Yes, murdering six million men, women and children is very similar to writing a research paper with opinions you don’t like.
Darell C. Phillips says:
June 28, 2010 at 12:29 pm
Norby beat me to this but I’ll still offer my version.
http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c385/SSTforumpics/MISC/HOCKEY_SMILEY.jpg
—…—…
And for Josh to consider as well … Should not the sceptical’s “Hockey Stick” smiley be upside down? Ending up with Mann-made global warming cooling down … towards the upcoming ice age?
ChocoNutDancer says:
June 28, 2010 at 6:13 pm
I still like the original plain smiley face in the article the best.
http://rigeradvertising.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/smiley_face_button1.jpg?w=175&h=174
It’ll drive them crazy. How can they argue with a smiley face.
____________________________________________________________________
It needs a caption such as Plants love CO2 perhaps in place of the mouth.
IMO, Deborah on the original “Inquisition Thread” already had the best idea so far. There’s even a place for a message, if you don’t mind a rectangular button.
/dr.bill
Darell C. Phillips says:
June 28, 2010 at 12:29 pm
Norby beat me to this but I’ll still offer my version.
http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c385/SSTforumpics/MISC/HOCKEY_SMILEY.jpg
—…—…
And for Josh to consider as well … Should not the sceptical’s “Hockey Stick” smiley be upside down? Ending up with Mann-made global warming cooling down … towards the upcoming ice age?
—…—…
CalMike says:
June 28, 2010 at 7:08 am
I’m not an artist, and don’t have the technical abilities to “draw” a sample. (And my son is still sleeping)
I thought the most obvious would be to use a broken (bent upwards) hockey stick as the smile on the “badge”.
—…—…
Or, breaking the hockey stick in the middle: That gives the up-and-down rise and fall from the RWP to the DA to the MWP to the LIA to the MWP …. As a crooked smile!
Amazingly, the line quoted isn’t in the movie. The line is actually “We don’t got to show you any steenkeen badges!” Just goes to show that wrong stuff can become popular.
Apologies if still href is formatted incorrectly, but one LAST try here.
http://i45.tinypic.com/33li4pl.jpg
I’ll offer a late suggestion.
Can we capture the belief, of ants on a log floating down the river, that they are in control of the log and the river?
Maybe a yellow button with some wavy lines, a smile shaped log with an end out of the water, with a steering wheel on it connected to nothing? and a couple officer ants? Maybe we could label the log MSMAGW? or IPPCAGW or the Goreraft or the Global AGW or something??
Have fun.
F. Ross, you get the award for persistence!
Love all of the badges, it would be hard to choose. I really laughed at the one that looked like Mann.
Ok here’s my badge proposal, though I dunno if Anthony thinks I’m eligible to win…

Thanks for that.
Typing seems to be all bassackwards today.
I’m not sure a complex issue can be reduced to a simple badge, particularly NOT a smiley face clone. The image rapidly becomes a mere in joke, understood only by a few skeptics. IMHO, a smiley face both trivializes the issue on the one hand, and fails to communicate on the other.
If there is any iconic figure who fully exemplifies the greater issue, the evil inherent in politicization of Science, it is Nikolai Vavilov:
“Vavilov’s is one the saddest stories in twentieth century science. By all accounts a man of truly extraordinary energy, intellectual powers, and charismatic personality, were it not for the backward Lamarckian theories of T. D. Lysenko and their support by the Soviet authorities he might have lived a full life and been destined to become the greatest crop geneticist and plant geographer of the twentieth century….
http://people.wku.edu/charles.smith/chronob/VAVI1887.htm
Here’s mine.
http://tiggerstestblog.blogspot.com/2010/06/very-cold-smiley.html
Bet someone could do this one better:) Its the Giss pink missing coverage globe:)
http://yfrog.com/esd0gj
I for one am GLAD to see somebody rightfully comparing the publication of this paper in PNAS to the treatment of the Jewish people in Nazi Germany (and occupied territories).
For instance, this paper was published in PNAS, so has very high impact and anything it had to say about climate skeptics/”denialists” was read by a large audience. Similarly, thousands of Jewish infants were taken from their mothers’ arms and thrown alive into the crematoria.
This paper called attention to recorded public statements of scientists that had taken a public position about human influence, or lack-thereof, in contributing to climate change. Likewise, Dr. Mengle would administer toxic substances to Jewish prisoners at Auschwitz, to determine how quickly and painfully those substances caused death. He also couldn’t help but sewing people together, due to his fascination with Siamese twins (these artificial pairings always died, of course, but not after an extended period of suffering).
This paper leaves the names out, though they’re easy enough to find given public records. In almost exactly the same way, the Nazis forced tens of thousands of Jews to dig mass graves, then lined them up and shot them, filling the graves. They gassed millions of Jews and burned their bodies entirely (a holocaust) in the constantly stoked, constantly working crematoria. They exterminated whole Jewish families, communities, and nearly entire countries’ worth (only 3% of Poland’s 3.5 million Jews survived) leaving no one–no one!–to bury them, to say kadish for them, or even to remember that they existed.
The Nazis and their collaborators enacted the most heinous campaign against human beings that has ever occurred. No torment, no torture, no unnatural death was spared for the Jewish people at the hands of the Nazis. The only thing that could possibly be spoken of in the same breath, if one has not only a sense of decency, but simply perceptive observation, is another actual genocide. The genocide in Rwanda could be compared with the Holocaust, or that in the former Yugoslavia, or that in Cambodia, or perhaps the Chmielnicki pogrom in the Ukraine (also waged against the Jewish people).
So wear the yellow badges, and wear them proudly, but don’t, for heavens sakes, pretend that they have anything to do with a yellow Star of David, or yellow handkerchief, or yellow belt such as those used to single out Jews historically for harassment, assault, torture, murder, and extermination. When your babies are being tossed alive into furnaces, when your parents, wives, and children are tortured and killed before your eyes, when your brethren are placed on cattle cars and sent to the mass graves, the gas chambers, and the crematoria, then you may properly equate your badge to one of the ones forced on the Jews. Until that day, pray that it will never come, it is utterly foolish to compare the treatment of climate skeptics, denialists, whatever-shamacalits anywhere today to the treatment of the Jews in Nazi occupied Europe. If the two seem in any way similar to you, reexamine how you think.
Best,
Chris
Someone named “Prince of Powerpoint” designed a raised eyebrow smiley that looks quite good . Permission would be needed of course.