A question for Zeke Hausfather

Zeke is upset that I made this statement in a story at Fox news:

Is history malleable? Can temperature data of the past be molded to fit a purpose? It certainly seems to be the case here, where the temperature for July 1936 reported … changes with the moment. In the business and trading world, people go to jail for such manipulations of data.

he says:

In the spirit of civility, I would ask Anthony to retract his remarks. He may well disagree with NCDC’s approach and results, but accusing them of fraud is one step too far.

I’d point out that Zeke has his interpretation but nowhere did I say “fraud”. He’s mad, and people don’t often think clearly when they are mad. That’s OK.

Without getting into semantics, I’d like to ask Zeke these simple questions:

  1. What is the CONUS average temperature for July 1936 today?
  2. What was it a year ago?
  3. What was it ten years ago? Twenty years ago?
  4. What was it in late 1936, when all the data had been first compiled?

We already know the answers to questions 1 and 2 from my posting here, and they are 76.43°F and  77.4°F respectively, so Zeke really only needs to answer questions 3 and 4.

The answers to these questions will be telling, and I welcome them. We don’t need broad analyses or justifications for processes, just the simple numbers in Fahrenheit will do.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
197 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted