Scots, Scottish, and Scotch

Guest Post by Willis Eschenbach

Edinburgh is not only enough to confuse your average humanoid. It drives the GPS crazy. Why?

Because the city exists on two levels, one of which is about fifty feet (fifteen metres) above the other. It’s bizarre. We’d be driving along the street, following the directions from Google Earth on my iPhone, and it would tell us to turn right on some street. We’d look around … no such street visible. Then we come to a bridge, look over the edge, and there’s the street we’re supposed to turn left on, but it’s way, way down below us. How can that be, we’re on the ground level up here, and there’s a whole ‘nother world of shops and people far down underneath. Bizarre.

We started off our trip by visiting the Botanical Gardens, which were wonderful. Of course, the first sight that greeted us was a windmill, a Darrieus rotor. In this case, it could more accurately have been called a Darrieus stator, because despite rather high winds, it didn’t move during our whole time there. Shocking, I know.

edinburgh windmillThe Botanical Gardens are quite lovely, a serene corner of a bustling city. In one section, I was surprised to see that there was a full-on meteorological station, which was not all that badly situated:

edinburgh met station

The placard in front said that it had been in operation since 1794 … note to self, check the records, should be interesting. Unfortunately, the plaque also said:

Previously located in the Demonstration Garden, in spring 2011 the weather station was removed to this more prominent location as the Met Office automated many of their recording devices to provide real-time readouts.

Since I doubt greatly whether they continued the old station to give an overlap so the two records could be combined, that means that the record effectively ends in 2011.

The Botanical Gardens has an exquisite old greenhouse, a lovely work of art…

edinburgh old greenhouse

And a butt-ugly new greenhouse.

edinburgh new greenhouse

Sigh …

Refreshed by the greenery, we parked downtown and started to walk. First we went on a most bizarre but quite lovely walkway over a street:

edinburgh walkway Note the rain on the roof … liquid sunshine. Then up past the St. Giles Cathedral and on to the National Museum of Scotland. Why? Well, it’s a museum of science … and it’s free. However, it’s also very, very strange. The selection and the location of the objects inside is quite bizarre. They will have say a space suit next to a suit of armor, and that’s just for starters. My daughter’s final conclusion as to the reason behind the strange exhibits and combinations was “Because Scotland” … which as it turned out seems to apply to lots of things in Edinburgh.

They did have a fantastic early steam engine, and the main exhibit hall was a light, airy work of joy:

edinburgh museum main hallTo my eye, one of the loveliest works of Scottish engineering in the Museum, curiously, wasn’t an exhibit at all. It was the radiators that you can see at the lower left above which heated the building. Here’s a closeup:

edinburgh museum radiator

Now that’s a pretty awesome way to heat a building.

In the evening, we had the great pleasure of meeting up with Lord Christopher Moncton, living proof that the species Homo eccentricus britannis is not threatened with extinction. We met in a pub that looks like this:

edinburgh pub

Gotta say … not many pubs look like that where I live … from there we went out to a restaurant. And there I learned that when the flow of the River Christopher is in full spate, all one can do is stand on the bank and marvel at the unending rush of ideas, humor, obscure references, side-splitting stories, explanations of history, and most interesting science, all delivered in his most impish manner which is totally irresistible. My great thanks to him for a most enjoyable evening.

We stayed quite near the St. Giles Cathedral, and the next day I was awakened to a very strange chorus. It went “BONG … ribbit … BONG … ribbit … BONG …” During the night the rain had come on in full force, and a most determined frog, who sounded like he was about six inches from my ear, had obviously set his mind that he was not going to be outcroaked by some giant bell.

We had lunch with another most interesting gentleman, Andrew Montford, the “Bishop” of the climate blog “Bishop Hill“. Like the other well-known climate bloggers that it’s been my pleasure to meet, he is self-employed, and a great conversationalist. We covered the gamut of topics over a fine meal, and sadly bid him goodbye. He also has my appreciation and thanks.

On the walk back to our flat, we passed the memorial to Sir Walter Scott. It is an arabesque fantasy in stone, looking like the fairy-tale castles in my childhood books where princesses awaited their knight in shining armor.

edinburgh scott memorial

It has all the required accessories and accoutrements, flying buttresses, towers, statues hundreds of feet up in the air, even a gargoyle on each of the four corners. What’s not to like?

edinburgh scott memorial gargoyle

We saw the Edinburgh Castle, and Mary Queens close (which was not sealed up on account of the plague as I’d heard, but was built over to provide government offices). And then, sadly and far too soon, it was time to leave. Every place I’ve gone on this trip I end up saying, “But, but, do we have to leave already?” However, we did have to leave, so we rolled out down the A1, enjoying the lovely scenery and dodging windmills … but that’s a story for another day.

Regards to all,

w.

The climate data they don't want you to find — free, to your inbox.
Join readers who get 5–8 new articles daily — no algorithms, no shadow bans.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
86 Comments
j ferguson
September 17, 2013 5:56 pm

The pub in the photo is Weathersoon’s. They are a chain in the UK belonging to a brewer. The pub in Willis’s picture is established in what used to be a bank and is exquisite. In addition to Weatherspoon’s proprietary brews, they offer a few “guest ales” from craft breweries, which to my American taste can be quite good, but then I like bitter and wish we had something like it here in the states.

j ferguson
September 17, 2013 6:02 pm

Willis, on the chance that you are visiting Glasgow ( you should) you may want to visit their Piping Museum.
I was slow on the uptake. Having spent the early part of my career designing waste-water treatment plants, I assumed, when I saw it on our map, that it was a museum of pipes, valves, couplings, and so forth of the sort that one uses to convey liquids. SWMBO heard my ruminations along these lines and said nothing, having been dragged to the sites of many notable civil works over the years so I could marvel at something some engineer had done.
So we went, and soon discovered that piping in Scotland means Bagpipes.
I enjoyed seeing them too, but was a bit disappointed wondering what might have comprised the museum I had imagined.

September 17, 2013 7:40 pm

Willis, why do so many writers, especially mystery authors, write about Edinburgh? Ian Rankin and Alexander McCall Smith are only a couple that immediately come to mind. Have you read the Smith mystery that discusses an old rail line – I assume it’s fictional – hidden underneath the streets of Edinburgh?

September 17, 2013 7:44 pm

I like Edinburgh, and had the fortune of good weather on both visits. I had the best time just walking around and poking my head into whatever places looked interesting. If the weather is decent you can cover the entire extent of the old city on foot. I think the place which made the greatest impression on me was the War Memorial on the grounds of Edinburgh Castle. Inside there are individual bays dedicated to each of the Scottish regiments which served in the two World Wars. In each bay are bound volumes containing the names of servicemen killed in each war.
The name “Watt” is really not that common in Scotland, though much more common there than in the US. We went to one bay at random and opened the book and found over two pages of Watts killed in WWI. We went to the next bay over and found a page and a half of Watts in their book. I looked up and down the hall at the dozens of regimental bays and the full cost of that war hit me for the first time. Unlike the US, the British military system of the time recruited regiments from a specific local. A town or region and a regiment were bound together, so when a regiment took heavy casualties, the families likely all knew each other and people with the same surnames were likely related.
And WWI chewed through regiments like no other war before or since. In some cases towns lost a large percentage of their service age men. I think the traditional regimental system was reformed after the war for this reason.
You’re close to St. Giles Cathedral, which I was told the locals prefer to call “St. Giles Kirk”. It’s worth a visit especially if the private chapel for The Most Noble Order of the Thistle is open.
Another place we literally stumbled across while walking around is the Cannongate Kirkyard, on the Royal Mile. Among the worthies interred there are Adam Smith (“The Wealth of Nations”) and someone reputed to be Handel’s favourite bassoonist.
If you make it up to Inverness there is (or was) a surprising collection of Japanese swords (several from the 1500s) at Cawdor Castle, ancestral home of the Thane of Cawdor, which title was held by MacBeth. And of course outside of Inverness is the site of the Battle of Culloden (1745) which ended the Jacobite uprising and the last hopes for Scottish independence. The Highland Clearances which started shortly afterwards pushed longtime tenant farmers off their traditional lands and out of Scotland. Many ended up in Canada and the US.

davidq
September 17, 2013 8:05 pm

Liquid sunshine, followed by, when liquid diminishes, dry rain, and when it stops, greyshine.

September 17, 2013 8:10 pm

More suggestions if you have the time and opportunity and inclination. Several hundred yards off the western side of Mull is the Isle of Iona, reputed to be the landing place of St. Columba, who brought Christianity to Scotland. There is a ruined abbey abandoned I think around 1000 as a result of Viking raids. The Book of Kells was produced there sometime around 800, one of the masterworks of Western Calligraphy.
Although the channel between Mull and Iona is only a few hundred yards wide, the ferry across can be surprisingly rough at times.
One place I wanted to visit but did not is the Isle of Staffa, about 10km north and a little east of Iona. The cave there inspired the opening bars of Mendelssohn’s Hebrides Overture, often called Fingal’s Cave.

j ferguson
September 17, 2013 8:30 pm

Alan Watt,
I much enjoyed what you wrote above. If you get a chance, have a look at Samuel Johnson’s Tour of the Hebrides. He and Boswell toured the Inner Hebrides in 1755 and his observations are fascinating.

rtj1211
September 17, 2013 10:55 pm

So you blame Edinburgh rather than concede that Google Earth may be a faulty product.
Typical American……

SandyInLimousin
September 18, 2013 12:09 am

Allan MacRae of the Clan MacRae
When I saw your name I thought of two things, Seaforth’s Shirt of Mail and the most well known unknown castle in the world, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eilean_Donan, famous for appearing on shortbread tins and boxes all over the world.
Willis Edinburgh has changed quite a lot since I was a student and working there in the late 60s early 70s I hope you managed to pop up to the castle and see The Honours of Scotland the oldest crown jewels in the UK. As a child the Scott Monument appeared to me to be like a rocket about to be launched into space Flash Gordon style.
Re underground cables when I was a lad, pre-Edinburgh days, we lived in rural Perthshire with a party telephone line, The Post Office as it then was buried the cable along the road site, Two houses requiring a total of 4 miles (7km) of poles wasn’t economic. However the cable was buried only about a foot or so below the surface. Moles would sometimes bite the cable and pierce the insulation. Next time it rained, normally not that many days later, the phone would stop working. I a typical British adaptive engineering (bodging) solution to the problem the Post Office engineers fixed the most vulnerable sections to the roadside fence.
Sandy Clann-na-Cearda

Leewok
September 18, 2013 12:27 am

Nial – I am almost certain you are looking at a picture of the Standing Order on George St looking back towards the Rose Street end of it.

September 18, 2013 1:44 am

Re the Royal Edinburgh Botanic Gardens, Some years ago I organised for them some rare seed from tropical rhododendrons (vireys spp,) collected in islands of New Guinea and Indonesia. Sadly, I’ve not been able to get beck to see how they look. Wonderful breeding potential, and the Garden is big on rhodos. They entertained my wife and me most generously.

thomam
September 18, 2013 2:16 am

tchannon says:
September 17, 2013 at 3:11 pm
The Met Office active station is
http://tallbloke.wordpress.com/2012/09/02/wmo03166-edinburgh-gogarbank-scotland/
==========================================
This is an interesting site (I know, as I run past it a couple of times a week). Well to the West of the city in (occasionally very exposed!) open countryside, albeit next to a rail line and a quiet country road. Not at all representative of the weather (let alone climate) in the city centre.
Botanics are lovely, as it the Standing Order – although the Dome down the street is even lovelier but twice as expensive!

Matt
September 18, 2013 2:25 am

Err, a GPS enabled device that happens to be able to display maps for an unrelated purpose does equate to a reliable “navigation system”. Is this a surprise to you? 🙂
While I do have one of them phones myself, I wouldn’t even use it for that purpose when cycling in the city – I have a proper GPS for that – and the invaluable advantage is that it won’t send me off a cliff like your phone 😉

Cold Englishman
September 18, 2013 2:42 am

I did warn you about those Scottish windmills. The way they fit so neatly into our wonderful landscape – so beautiful, and energy rich at the same time./sarc

johnmarshall
September 18, 2013 3:39 am

You like glass houses then Kew Gardens in London but bigger still are those of the Eden Project in Cornwall.

Paul Mackey
September 18, 2013 4:24 am

What no Gàidhlig? Here’s some
Alba Gu Brath!
(Scotland Forwver)
Tha mi toilichte gun chòrd Dùn Eideann riut.
(I am glad you enjoyed Edinburgh)

climatereason
Editor
September 18, 2013 6:38 am

Willis
Nice travelogue.
You enjoy science and discoveries so if you get the chance watch BBC2 at 9.00pm tonight (wed) when Brian Cox will present what sounds an interesting programme ‘Science Britannica’
tonyb.

beng
September 18, 2013 6:57 am

Palms in Scotland!?!
IIRC, Chinese windmill palms are the most cold tolerant & assume that’s what those are.

Gene Selkov
Reply to  beng
September 18, 2013 7:33 am

@beng: palm trees could be found in people’s front yards as far north as Inverness and Ullapool, but recently (during the last 3-4 years) most of them froze to death.
http://caledonianmercury.com/2010/05/14/palm-trees-fall-victim-to-harsh-winter-and-spring/007604
Those I saw most often were between 15 and 20 years old (about the age of the global warming scam?)
They are still doing fine in the south of England

beng
September 18, 2013 7:12 am

OK, I bet the arboretum staff protects those palms in the winter similar to this:
http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/farnorth/msg0611464930715.html

September 18, 2013 8:17 am

About Scottish jokes, I have read one, which may be true or not:
A new bridge was built between the mainland and the isle of Skye at the Kyle of Lochalsh, replacing the ferry to that island (which I still remember from my previous visit in 1975… If I remember well that one had a turntable to turn the car in the right direction to enter and leave the ferry, or that was between Mallaig and Skye?). There was a toll to be paid to pass the bridge, with one exception: if you have to drive sheep from one side to the other side,
No problem for the smart Scots: someone rented a few sheep for a symbolic amount if you wanted to cross the bridge without paying the heavy toll…
Anyway there was a lot of protest against the toll bridge, and in 2004 the toll was abolished.
See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skye_Bridge

George Tetley
September 18, 2013 11:13 am

Next trip ?
Perhaps a voyage on something like this would stir the sea salt in you Willis ?
http://www.treasure-island-shipping.com